Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

A less than 1% question......

Posts

A less than 1% question......

#1

A less than 1% question......

roger lance

I'm over 99% sure of the answer; but, there is that hint of doubt.....and this is important enough that it begs resolution.

So called Danish Oil (a Watco product) dries by exothermic reaction.....leaves a film finish. Rags soaked in this type oil need to be carefully disposed to allow the heat being generated in the drying process to escape without causing a fire.

What about other oils that we use in the shop like Jojoba Oil ( a Lie-Nielsen product) that is used to wipe down our hand tools? Since this type of oil is vegetable oil based and may not cure, is it completely safe to dispose of rags soaked in this oil by throwing them into our trash containers (mine is half filled with saw dust, wood shavings, paper, etc)?

Re: A less than 1% question......

#2

I don't take any chances

Dick Coers

All oil rags are hung up to dry in my shop. I have no idea what chemical driers are added, or if any small percentage of boiled linseed oil is added to the mix of oils that you can buy off the shelf. I never want to assume they won't ignite because the labels never include all ingredients.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#3

Plus 1 on what Dick said.

Barry Irby

I once dropped a rag on the concrete floor in my shop that was only slightly crumpled up. Next day it had gotten hot enough to have some scorching. I don't think It actually caught on fire but it was close. I now take them outside and spread them out on the gravel drive. My chemistry is not good enough to even guess which ones are bad.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#4

Re: A less than 1% question......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"So called Danish Oil (a Watco product) dries by exothermic reaction"

If it doesn't "dry" (AKAS crosslink), it doesn't generate heat. If the oil doesn't have highly unsaturated oil constituents and a catalyst to hasten crosslinking these species("dry"), heat will not be generated at all or generated at an insignificant rate.

But you might need to hire a chemist to study the MSDS sheet for the oil to advise where the rags are safe to dispose.

A safe bet is mineral oil. It is inert.

I would like to see some actual fires described in detail. To get to ignition temperature will take a lot of oil reacting faster than heat dissipates. It seems to me that a mass of rags, soaked in oil, with poor air circulation would, be required. I've never seen smoke curling from a freshly varnished table top. To the contrary, I'm usually fretting over the finish curing in the course of tens of minutes. Has anyone ever seen an oily rage smoke? Not suggesting we be careless-just curious.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#5

Re: A less than 1% question......

John in NM

Non-"drying" oils shouldn't be a problem, as you suspected.

Some like jojoba oil are very inert as vegetable oils go. Mineral oil would be a better choice for rubbing on tools because it is fully inert compared to vegetable oils - it never turns into a gummy yellow coating.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#6

Re: A less than 1% question......

John in NM

Regarding rag fibers, I would bet that rag composition has a lot to do with it. We just saw a demonstration last week burning first polyester, then a 50-50 blend with cotton, then pure cotton, then Nomex. The blend actually burned the best.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#7

rag fire *LINK*

Dick Coers

One local guy lost his shop to a rag fire. He lost the entire shop because the plastic garbage can he used to clean up the dust and rags. It melted, right next to a plastic gas can, right next to his riding mower. So the fire just stair stepped from one combustible source to another.


http://www.nfpa.org/news-and-research/fire-statistics-and-reports/fire-statistics/fire-causes/chemical-and-gases/spontaneous-combustion-or-chemical-reaction

Re: A less than 1% question......

#8

Has anyone ever seen an oily rage smoke?

Keith Newton

I have a young contractor friend that I've done quite a bit of work for. Sometimes he will come over to my shop whil I'm away to work on something, which is fine, but sometimes he doesn't seem to possess a lot of common sense. For instance, to stain or oil something as small as a little table, rather than cutting the sleeve off a T-shirt, he would just use the whole shirt. Of course the cotton shirt is way more absorbent than the wood, so in order to keep it wet enough to give any up to the project would require a pint, where maybe 4 ounces were needed.

One Monday I came back to find a couple of large rags in a large plastic garbage can full of wood scraps, smoking. OH boy, I was hacked off, and he got a little talking to.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#9

Re: A less than 1% question......

Stuart Johnson

All of my finish rags regardless of the finish go in a small galvanized trash can with a lid outside the shop. Just takes a minute and they are gone and safe.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#10

Re: I don't take any chances

AZ in Colorado Springs

Plus 2 on Dick's suggestion. I hang all finishing rags over the edge of the trash can til they harden-- usually two or three days.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#11

Rag was smoking

Doug Wolf

Bill, back in the 1980's I was finishing a roll top desk with Watco Dark Walnut Danish Oil. (It was a different formula back then). I had quit for the day and went to eat dinner. When I came back after about an hour, the coffee can that I had used to throw the rags in all day had smoke curling up out of the can. There were rags in the bottom of the can that had been there most of the day and the 3 pound can was almost full. Luckily, I came back after dinner to admire my job and wipe down any bleed out of the oak desk or it could have turned out worse.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#12

Re: A less than 1% question......

Dave Nichols

I never leave oily rags in my shop, I take them outside and burn them in my burn barrel.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#13

Re: A less than 1% question......

Barry W. Larson

Hi:

As a fan of Jack London in my formative years I have always been interested in the fire that destroyed his grand "Wolf House" while under construction. Linseed oil was used to finish the woodwork and built-in cabinetry and the fire was thought to be the result of combustion of the oily rags which were improperly disposed of - likely just thrown in a corner of the dining room. Of course arson was also suspected at the time but never proven. The link is to an post-mortem investigation carried out in the 1990's which seems to support the spontaneous combustion theory.

http://www.parks.sonoma.net/firecause.html

The moral of the story is be careful with the rags if you are not sure!

Cheers,

Barry W. Larson

Calgary, Alberta, Canada eh!

Re: A less than 1% question......

#14

Re: A less than 1% question......

Mark Hennebury

Probably twenty-five years ago, i was invited into a newly constructed house to quote on some furniture to be made ( a nice house up on the cliffs overlooking the ocean,with a helicopter pad out back) While walking around the house with the owner I noticed a few people oiling the exotic wood flooring, when we heard a squeal from one of them, who then jump up and ran across the room and grabbed a bunch of smoking oily rags off the floor and ran and threw them outside into the snow.

So i never got to see them catch fire, but they were smoking.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#15

Re: A less than 1% question......

james runchey

Back in the sixties I worked, at that time, the worlds largest mink ranch. During pelting season they would send truckloads of oily rags to a laundry, and for some reason the truck sat out overnight, caught fire, and burned up.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#17

A more simple explanation of these oils

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is some right about the responses in the referenced post, but not everything is correct even from Dresdner. For the record:

All vegie and animal oils and fats are made from glycerin combined with "fatty acids" . There are many kinds of "fatty acids". The properties of all these fats and oils-whether they are liquids, solids, where they melt, when they smoke in cooking, whether they will cure to a finish, how quick they get rancid, etc- depend on the amounts of the different fatty acids that go into making the fat or oil. A typical fat or oil will have several of these fatty acids as major components and many more as minor components. You can easily find their composition on the Internet.

More or less they all react with oxygen, more or less quickly. What sets the oils used for finish apart is one particular fatty acid. It has three places on the molecule where it can react and set off a polymerization reaction that will crosslink the oil into a tough film. The other oils only have 1, 2 or no places to react. In this chemistry 3 reactive places on the molecule is not three times better but orders of magnitude better at crosslinking. Oils useful for finishing have a large amount of this fatty acid, 30% as I recall.

Most of the fats and oils have some of this particular fatty acid, but linseed oil has enough of this acid to cross link enough to make a tough film. Other oils like corn oil cross link less to make a thick goo that sticks in cutting boards nicely.

The reaction with oxygen starts the crosslinking but it is the crosslinking reaction itself that generates the heat. Without a catalyst it proceeds slowly as you well know from using these oils as finish. It takes days for uncatalyzed linseed oil to "dry" (crosslink) into a hard film.

When it is hot the crosslinking reaction gets quicker. In a confined pile of rags the more that crosslinking occurs the hotter it gets, the quicker it gets even hotter.

Chemists can put crosslinking places in oils that didn't originally have them. For example soy oil can be made into a oil finish.

So to get a fire, I expect one needs a large amount of catalyzed oil and rags in a confined space that doesn't dissipate heat. I need to try this experiment for myself....not in the shop of course.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#18

Close, but not quite so simple

Michael Dresdner

Bill is correct in that some oils we don't think of as drying oils can be modified into drying oils, so if you are not sure, treat oily rags by laying them out one layer thick to dry.

Bill's description of the drying portion of oil is actually a description of one particular fatty acid, eleostearic acid, which contains triple conjugated double bonds (three double bonds in a row.)

In fact, 80% of tung oil is eleostearic acid, which is why it dries so well without added driers.

However, linseed oil has very little eleostearic acid.

The major components of linseed oil are linoleic and linolinic acids. Yet these (which have at best only double conjugated double bonds, or two double bonds in a row) are more than enough to make it a drying oil, and with driers added, a fast drying oil.

However, the original question was about Jojoba oil.

Jojoba is not a drying oil, and you have very little to worry about in terms of spontaneous combustion, since it lacks any of the conjugated double bond sites needed for this.

Here's a good way to deal with the whole issue:

Lay oily rags out one layer thick. If they have not turned hard and crusty in two days, odds are you have a non-drying oil and don't need to worry about spontaneous combustion.

However, you do need to worry about landfill rules for your area, since some liquids are deemed a leachate hazard.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#19

Re: A more simple explanation of these oils

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Apparently Soy bean oil does have cross linking capability without "adding" anything. My son works at an ADM soybean facility. They process many thousands of bushels a day and produce "meal" and edible soy oil (in train car quantities). Much of the equipment in certain areas becomes coated with the extracted oil. My son obtained several explosion proof light fixtures when the plant upgraded their lighting. The glass lenses are coated with a VERY hard, clear, somewhat amber coating. In some areas a 1/16" or better thick. I have tried removing this with common solvents, lacquer thinner, acetone, DNA, with no effect on the coating. I didn't need to use the fixtures immediately so dropped the project. I plan on trying some paint stripper the next go around. The coating is quite hard and required a sharp tool to even scratch the surface.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#20

Re: A more simple explanation of these oils

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Like I said, all the oils have more or less ability to react, more or less fast. So given enough time, apparently, soybean oil reacts enough to make a hard film. It may be the heat of the lamp helped it along.

Re: A less than 1% question......

#21

Re: A less than 1% question......

roger lance

John.....my Lee Valley spring catalog just arrived and I notice that LV is getting into the game of tool wipes with a product that has mineral oil as its basic ingredient. Mineral oil itself can be purchased extremely inexpensively at your local pharmacy in the constipation/laxative aisle (damhik).

If someone says I'm full of it......they don't know how right they are. :(