Installed a Byrd Shelix head in my planer
Grant Smith
Let me start with the WHY I chose to install a Byrd Shelix cutterhead. My Delta DC 380 15" planer has served me well, but I got to thinking about how it uses HSS knives, while I prefer carbide on every other piece of tooling in the shop except the jointer. Come to think of it, I couldn't imagine using the HSS router bits, sawblades, and such my father used. The knives on my planer (two sets in rotation), are near end of life, or so the Sharpening shop had told me. And, I got to thinking about how much material I run through the machine, given my exclusive use of rough sawn lumber. The impending costs and birthday had me looking in to a carbide solution.
I began to research a bit, and soon discovered a few benefits I hadn't thought about. Here are some:
- cost of sharpening a set of 3 each 15" knives: ~$35 with tax. Needs done periodically, and whenever I hit a surprise. Then there is the trip to town, which I usually combine with other errands.
- Lifespan of carbide inserts versus HSS, difficult to say, but most put it in the carbide lasts five times longer range. Multiply that times 4 sides to each carbide insert, and it starts making sense, even when the inserts cost $3 each or so.
-time spent changing cutters (I am actually quite good at this, so maybe 30-40 mins)
-sound levels: My straight HSS cutters howled like an air raid siren when the DC was on. Measurements (by others) place segmented cutters at around 20DB quieter. Almost don't need hearing protection.
-On the segmented cutter head, one can rotate one carbide insert or as needed to remove any damaged insert from use. No alignment necessary, just remove a screw, rotate cutter. Byrd generously provides ten spares, too.
-A shearing cut is better. Just ask any hand tool guru.
So I ordered a Byrd Shelix h7768, and took my machine apart. I found not surprises other than a failed oil seal where the cutter enters the gearbox. I replaced that seal and the two cutter head bearings (actually installed new bearings on the Byrd head, since that is the entire point). I did visit my mechanic buddy to use the bearing press.
Reassembly went well except I foolishly decided to remove the height adjustment locking knob "to get it out of the way", only to spend 40 minutes getting it back in place (note: YOU DON'T NEED TO REMOVE IT, NOR DO YOU WANT TO EVER REMOVE IT).
Startup: heard some noise on startup, removed the dust collector shroud again to reinspect. Looks like the cutter at the end of the gearbox is pretty close. Discovered I needed to carefully pry the cutterhead towards the input pulley just a bit, then re-tighten the input pulley. No issues after that.
Observations: this thing is QUIET! the guy online who had measured 20 DB quieter is right on the money. It is Cadillac quiet, even when planing with the DC on. I couldn't decide if I should wear hearing protection. The wife was duly impressed, as she is often on the out feed end of the planer for hours at a time when we are bringing in a stack of lumber.
I observed about four tiny "lines" running lengthwise. Upon inspection, a few cutters/inserts needed slightly adjusted, which means loosen and re-torque them. No more issues. Planed surface is quite nice. Nicer than the old cutter head on a sharp day.
I intentionally fed a board with some knots through "the wrong way" to see what the tear out would look like. NONE. Right there is nearly worth the cost of entry. We all know what it is like to have tear out around a knot or an "almost knot", and the frustration of reversing grain. None with this new cutter head on the walnut and oak I ran through.
Some said the chips are smaller. I am not seeing this, at least in relation to the old HSS straight cutters. So you will still have to empty the dust bin about as often.
4 post planer lessons:
- the gear box is fairly complex, but easy to disassemble. If yours leaks, remove the chain cover and tighten the five allen screws holding the cover on.
- Check the idler pulley, mine wasn't turning as it should, had to re-peen the attachment between the pulley and the arm, which solved the issue.
- If you take it apart, look for play where the gearshift shaft meets the "shift fork" re-peen here with a chisel or old screwdriver and hammer. Resist the urge to spot weld it. I was thinking of doing so, but it would have meant I could no longer remove the shaft if needed. I peened it a bit and it is now fine.
-If you need to shim the planer left to right, you can add shims between the main casting and the gearbox. Mine had some brass shims here, presumably from the factory.
So, how much was this thing? Well, around $720 delivered. I ordered mine from Grizzly, once I was assured it is the same product as the one that comes directly from Byrd. Is it worth it? I think so, but then I am a sucker for a new tool. Time will tell if the love affair lasts.
Regards,
Grant in Iowa
