Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Close call

Posts

Close call

#1

Ellis Walentine

Close call

Ellis Walentine

Here's an urgent note to any of you who may own a Delta 50-850 1 1/2HP dust collector. I was planing some wood today and noticed that the air in the shop looked a little smoky, and I knew it wasn't sawdust. I put 2 + 2 together and ran down to my dust collector in the basement of the barn, and sure enough, there was smoke and fire coming off the dust collector motor. I disconnected the power, blew out the flame and dragged the unit out behind the barn, to find that the capacitor had failed and burst into flame. I have narrowly avoided another catastrophic shop fire.


I'm tracking down a rumor that this isn't the first known incidence of this type of failure with this unit. The module number of the entire unit is 50-850. The capacitor is a 30 µF, part # 1346563. The motor and the capacitor have both been obsoleted by the manufacturer, not that I won't be able to get a new capacitor of the same rating from a local motor repair shop. (I hope.) Maybe I should get a different motor instead.

Anyhow, here's a heads-up to any of you who may own this unit or who may have any 1 1/2HP Delta motors that happen to use the same capacitor. My shop projects are now on hold until I can get a working dust collector, but at least my shop is intact. If that had been the last board of the night and I left the shop with a fire started in the basement, it could have been a disaster.

Ellis

Re: Close call

#2

Re: Close call

Barry Irby

OMG! Remind me not to stand near you. I am afraid of lightning.

I have a 1 1/2 HP Delta unit. I will be checking on the capacitor as soon as the rain and hail stop. (It really is hailing here.) Thanks for posting. I have had this unit about ten years.

I thought the picture was of a soft drink can somebody had turned into a bomb. Maybe it was.

Congratulations on ducking the bullet. Good work.

Re: Close call

#3

Re: Close call

Stuart Johnson

Wow, I've had capacitors pop but had no idea they could actually catch on fire. I can't imagine what you must have felt when you first saw it. You must be living right or it would have been the last board for the day or possibly not been noticed until it was fully engulfed.

Re: Close call

#4

Re: Close call

Joseph Piotrowski

glad you caught it.

stay safe and dust free!

Re: Close call

#5

WOW!!

Jim Dillon

Ellis, you were REALLY lucky. I hope your heart rate has settled back to normal! You have a lot of contacts so I hope you can spread the word and get to the bottom of this. Is the capacitor failure/fire an isolated incident, or more wide-spread and not reported? As I recall, this model was quite popular. Keep us posted. Jim

Re: Close call

#6

Re: Oh man

Steve jenkins

Glad you caught it.

Re: Close call

#7

Re: Close call

Mark Nowicki

For about the price of a Kapex, it is possible to buy all the components for a central fire alarm system; control panel, bells and strobes, heat and smoke detectors and automatic extinguishing systems.

http://www.havenfiresafety.com/

Re: Close call

#8

Lee Grindinger

What is it about you and fire?

Lee Grindinger

There is some weird energy here, I'd be scared, very scared. :D

Re: Close call

#9

BTDT

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Was ripping some reclaimed cherry that had a few nails that I hadn't seen. Noticed that the blade was smoking the cut faces more than expected. My DC is out in the garage and I just had this little tickle behind an ear that something wasn't right. Checked the saw cabinet and found nothing.

So I go out to the garage.

The smell of wood smoke greeted me and, sure enough, I had a smoldering fire in the dust bag. Grabbed the extinguisher. Slashed the bag open and let fly.

Fortunately the hot spot was in the collection bag. That got dragged out pronto and spilled onto the driveway where the contents were hosed down.

Next came the filter bag which was turned inside-out, blown off and seriously checked.

I'm not one for the alternative consciousness bit, but something brushed my ear that day and it saved my home. With gas cans and other solvents in the garage, plus two cars' tanks and several propane grill tanks, if that had gotten going, the fire guys (miles away) would have been hosing down my masonry chimney stack and little else.

Glad you're OK and the shop is clear. :) :)

Re: Close call

#10

Ellis Walentine

Alarm systems

Ellis Walentine

Hi Mark,

We have a burglar alarm system, with fire-department notifications, here, but if there's a fire going in the shop, at least in our remote location, there's no way they can respond quickly enough to save us. I need to have my shop set up as safely as possible, and this is the message I'd want to send to you all.

Ellis

Re: Close call

#11

Ellis - I had no idea these things could ignite

Howard in Toronto

Thank heavens you caught it in time with no danger to your loved ones.

Howard

Re: Close call

#12

Re: Alarm systems

John K Jordan

Oh my!!!

How about a smoke alarm down there, mounted above whatever motor and capacitor you replace it with, and wired to a remote outside horn? I bought such a horn once for an alarm system and it was LOUD.

Perhaps the cap rating was on the edge. A motor shop could tell you the details but I understand you can use a capacitor rated higher than what is speced for a given motor although it might be bigger and not fit in the cover provided. I've seen photos where people made their own housing for oversized start capacitors.

(I almost did that when a cap on one of my motors gave up the smoke and I couldn't get a replacement quick enough but I borrowed one from an identical motor instead.)

In fact, after that experience I might be tempted to build a tight (fireproof) steel box and mount a healthy industrial capacitor inside and run a cable to the motor.

JKJ

Re: Close call

#13

Re: Close call

Don Orr

Wow, glad you caught this before it got ahead of you. I hate to see you go through that trauma again.

Re: Close call

#14

Re: Close call

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Start caps (round, black, and plastic shell) are filled with a salt solution. When bad they make steam and usually blow out the terminal connections.

Run caps (oval and grey painted metal shell) are filled with oil. They can swell and catch fire. Twenty five years or so ago they had PCBs mixed with the oil as a fire retardant. The EPA, cancer fears, etc cured that! So they now are little incendiary devices looking for a pile of shavings! If they are starting to swell or to change shape, REPLACE them. If you can't find the same mfd, it can be increased by 10%. Never reduce the voltage rating...370 vac frequently seen on 120 volt motors. For long running equipment, only make cap value changes ONE time! Without going into paragraphs of electrical engineering, I can't explain the voltage value. The more often the motor starts, the sooner the caps fail. Five starts a minute overheats the caps. They need time between starts to cool off thru their skin.

Re: Close call

#15

Ellis Walentine

Re: Close call

Ellis Walentine

Okay, I think there might be good evergreen info here. Bill, can you give a bit more explanation that might be useful to all of us with capacitor concerns?

Ellis

Re: Close call

#16

Re: Close call

John K Jordan

Bill, can you suggest a reference where one could read up on both start and run caps?

JKJ

Re: Close call

#17

Re: Close call

Mark Hennebury

Glad that you caught that in time.

We live in the country and have a well and pump.Two weeks ago we had no water pressure and when i went down to the basement to check the pump and it was hot and humming, but not running. so it hadn't run dry and didn't need priming, turned out that it was the capacitor had crapped out, so the tank was empty which tripped the switch sending power to the pump, but with a dead capacitor it wouldn't start. not sure what the end result would have been had i not been around.

Re: Close call

#18

Re: Close call

Bill Howatt

I don't know why these switches aren't standard equipment on household water pump systems - ours has a low pressure drop-out feature built into the pressure switch. If the pressure gets down to about 0 PSI the switch opens and it will not apply voltage to the pump. Primary intent likely is to keep pump from running if well is dry.

If the pressure goes to zero and it trips out, I have to hold the switch manual lever to force the pump to run to get a few PSI in the system so it will then run automatically.

This feature would have saved my neighbor a few hundred dollars after her young kid left the garden hose running outside and drained her well!

billh

Re: Close call

#19

Auto-start question

Larry Rupprecht

Does it follow logically then that such capacitor-start dust collectors should not be synchronized to start up and shut off with the various individual tools needing dust collection? Unless designed for a specific shop's tools and by a qualified electrical professional, that is.

My experience in various projects has me starting and stopping several stationary tools quite often as a project progresses. RAS to cut boards to length, TS to rip, jointer to square up edges, planer to machine thickness, etc., all at the flick of a tool switch. And the on/off sequences can number several dozen in an hour. Because of the chance of overheating and ruining my Delta 1-1/2 hp collector, I have not done the auto-start connection.

Ellis' close call appears to confirm that electrical knowledge and skill above the layman's level is important in building such systems.

Re: Close call

#20

Re: Auto-start question

Bill Howatt

I have an auto-start and it has been running for years without any motor/capacitor failures although you sound like you might work faster than I do. :)

I do have a switch on the system where I can let the 2HP DC (not a Delta, similar to a Grizzly) and air-cleaner fans run continuously. However, I rarely use it but this would avoid the start/stop issue.

You could let your DC run for say, 30 minutes and then see how warm the motor is. Then go through your typical multi-dozen start/stop routine for a period of time and see how warm the motor is. If it is a lot hotter then you know it is better to let it run for the way you work.

Motor start capacitors in simple terms are spec'd at cycles with 20 starts per hour and the typical number of cycles is around 40-50,000 for the life.

If you apply some of the guidelines to just a TS then they are often outside the start/stop recommendations at times. The reality is that I don't think we see a lot of failed capacitor/motors in our typical shop usage at all.

IMO, Ellis' brush with disaster shows why the shop and related areas such as his barn basement should have a walk-through at the end of the day and be well covered with smoke alarms as a minimum. There is no way you will ever prevent the risk of something going wrong and perhaps resulting in fire.

Bill

Re: Close call

#21

Re: Close call

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

A google search of "motor capacitor failure" will provide more info than you want. I had this written and it suddenly disappeared. LRA, locked rotor amps" is six times RLA, running load amps. This momentary heat happens with every start from a non-turning armature. Every start heats up the motor and supply wires. Every start too often leads to failures. The heat is disappated thru its skin. Sawdust slows down the cooling.

A 42 yr career in industrial maintenance, including 8 yrs selling caps and HVAC equipment taught me the info in the first post. Cap service was a daily occurrence. Any info about HVAC caps applies to all motors: WW, wells, etc. Caps cause a phase shift to help motors start. They heat with every start also. International motors, changing specs, cheap Chinese motors, PCBs, EPA, etc have muddied the waters. Capacitor voltage is really an insulation rating. The caps induce voltages and waveforms that are much higher than the supply voltages. All could be 440vac except the won't fit in the same space. The plastic between the aluminum foil layers has to be thicker.

If you are really concerned about your caps go ahead and replace them

Re: Close call

#22

Re: Alarm systems

Mark Nowicki

Hello Ellis,

Sorry, I should have written: "local fire alarm system"

Re: Close call

#24

Re: Close call

Brian Holcombe

Glad to hear that you were able to save the shop!

I used to race cars, as many of you know. After seeing a few cars go up in flames while the trackside fire truck raced its way to the scene, I became so paranoid that I installed a halon (the current legal version of halon) system into the car, with plumbed lines to the engine bay, electrical wire harness and fuel supply area. The rip cord was placed in the driver seat, so if I were conscious I would be able to operate it with ease.

Re: Close call

#25

Re: Close call

William Duffield

That's really scary, Ellis. :( It makes me think I should build a separate outbuilding to house my dust collector and air compressor. Maybe I could convince the wrens to relocate at the same time.