Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Posts

oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#1

oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Eric Kuehne

I'm getting to playing around with band saw boxes and am thinking an oscillating spindle sander sander would be pretty handy as opposed to my current drill press solution. I don't really know much about these but I'm looking at a use Delta Boss and the Shop Fox/Wen/Wood River/etc. as they are in the same price range. It looks like the Boss has a larger table and a longer stroke but I'm not sure how significant these features are. I will also use this for furniture parts which is why I think the larger table on the Boss my help.

I think the Boss is a good unit but the smaller Shop Fox type units get good reviews. Do any of you have experience with and/or an opinion on these?

Thanks in advance.

Cheers,

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#2

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Dick Coers

I've had very good luck with my Delta Boss. You need to realize if something breaks on it now, you either have to get the parts on eBay, or scrap it. We had a couple of Jet floor models at work. They are nice, and the drums are much taller, but for God's sake, never tighten the shaft with a wrench! For some reason the taper almost welds itself together when over tightened.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#3

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have a Delta BOSS and it seems to work pretty well. First, it's not a top-flight machine like a Clayton, so don't expect that. It has an annoying tendency that I don't like, but it's possible to work around it. The spindle doesn't go perfectly straight up and down. From the front, the spindle moves a bit to the right, maybe a 1/16", as it moves up and then retracts. It doesn't do that front to back.

Second, if you're working in a really cold shop, the rubber sleeves shrink to the point where they don't grip the sanding sleeves very well. I've had to bring mine inside and nuke them in the microwave to make them usable.

Other than those nits, it does what I need it to and works really well on tight inside curves.

Remember, too, that the locking bolt is a left-hand thread.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#4

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Chuck Bjorgen

I sold a Delta BOSS a couple years ago on my local Craigslist. Judging from the interest my listing generated I probably could have sold six of these units. I believe my price was right around $100 so that might have increased the interest.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#5

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

William Duffield

I had that problem with my Jet JBOS-5 earlier this week. It took me almost a half hour to change drums, >( and no I didn't forget that it is left hand threaded. ;)

Another advantage of the Jet is the tilting cast iron table.

Like others, it has a tendency to get the drum surface out of alignment with the shaft or the oscillating motor, and then sands on only one side of the drum. With some fussing, it can be brought back into alignment, until it wanders off again.

But the larger floor mount Jet is even nicer, as it has even longer drums and stroke and more robust transmission, but it is also very expensive.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#6

Re: oscillating

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Back when I was shopping I looked at the Delta, JET and (of course) the Clayton, but I happened to walk into Home Depot and there sat the Ridgid oscillating combo of a spindle and/or 4x24 belt for under $200. Best 200 I've spent on any power tool for the Shoe Box Woodshop. The belt does a good job as an edge sander as well as an abrasive shaping tool for outside curves. The spindle works well on inside curves and the variety of spindle sizes is helpful as well.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#7

Re: oscillating

John K Jordan

I've had the Ridgid for many years. I also mostly use the belt. That's a bit of a shame in one respect since not long after I got it HD had a bunch of spindles on a clearance table for 90% off and I bought all of them.

I prefer the belt on this over my other belt sanders for many things because of the oscillation and the design that puts the belt perpendicular to the table. The dust is a problem. I've decided that for certain tools shops need a Dust Room that you don't enter without a respirator!

The times I used the spindles they worked without a hitch.

JKJ

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#8

JL

+1 for Ridgid

JL

I bought mine a while back. I use the belt and the spindles (depending on the curve). Both work great.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#9

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Jim Dillon

Eric, my Delta Boss has given me good service for 15+ years although I did have to replace a plastic transmission cog. I also have my portable 4 x 24-inch belt sander mounted horizontally in a fixture so I can sand convex curves easily. I use them both a lot. Consequently, if I were shopping today, I would look at the Ridgid combination unit, although recent reviews on Amazon have been mixed with units arriving DOA. IIRC, the more expensive Jet sander comes with a 1/4-inch diameter sanding sleeve which would come in handy for small radius curves. The larger table on the Boss is nice. If you can snag a used Boss for a reasonable price, I would go for it - unless you wanted to spend more money. Jim

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#10

Ridgid

jessecloud

I have the Ridgid, too. I agree that its worth the money.

Pro: low cost, belt sander is almost a freebie, reliable so far (5 years), dust control pretty good*

Con: goes out of square easily - have to futz with it to get consistent results, table is small and in two parts

*have never used the belt, but dc works ok on the spindles - no respirator needed

The bottom line is that the next step up in quality is way more expensive, so this is a reasonable compromise.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#11

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Eric Kuehne

Thanks for the input guys. What I probably should have said at the beginning is that I already own a 6x48 belt/9 in disc sander. If I had it to do over again I would have gone for the Rigid but didn't know about them at the time of purchase. One option might be to simply sell the larger machine as I don't use it that much and just replace it with the Rigid. Any thoughts?

Still hoping for some feedback on the less expensive units. They have good reviews on Amazon but I know the community here well provide better input.

Cheers,

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#12

Re: +1 for Ridgid

john lucas

Me too. I took a workshop and we had access to 3 different higher end spindle sanders. I bought the Rigid because I found a used one. It works absolutely fabulous and i love the belt sander option. It think it's close functionally to those higher end units and far less expensive.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#13

Re: Square (and plumb)

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I made a sled for mine that runs in the miter track. Little bit of iron veneer and the sled is dead nuts square with the belt's vertical platan. You can go 1 step more and add a adjustable fence to the sled to make angle sanding easy. Nice for mitered pieces.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#14

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Ron in Sterling, CT

I have a Ryobi which I bought used several years ago. It has been very reliable, and does as good a job as the Boss, which we have in the workshop where I spend my winters. Ryobi no longer carry it in their line. However the one marketed by Wen looks exactly like it. Also the one carried by Menards (forgot the brand) looks like the Wen. It all depends on how much you are going to use it and what you are willing to spend. The Boss and the cheaper ones perform the same in my experience.

My 2 cents.

Ron

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#15

reccomendation for the Jet bench top

Robin Corell in Atascadero

Before I bought my Max Industrial quality OSS I owned a Powermatic bench top OSS, which is now sold as the Jet bench top machine. the Jet is a great tool but I wore mine out. I purchased it new and it made me a lot of money but just like all the other bench top machines it is not designed for anything more than occasional use on small bits of wood.

For most guys the small bench top machines will be just fine, but if you are like me and every piece of furniture has curves then look for a used industrial quality machine. For industrial OSS machines I'm partial to State or MAX, there is a reason that is what you will see in most Pattern shops

One more thing about spindle sanders, to get the best results you always want to use the largest spindle that will fit. This is another area where the Jet has an advantage because they have an optional 3" diameter drum. This makes a huge difference on large radius furniture parts.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#16

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Jim Dillon

Thanks Eric for filling use in on your shop. Gosh, if you don't use that rather large belt sander/disc sander that much, then "downsizing" to something like the Ridgid makes sense to me. Set it up in spindle sanding mode for what you anticipate to be your biggest use, and use the the belt mode when needed. If, on the other hand, you really have no use for the belt/disc sander and can sell it, use the money to buy a little better spindle sander. Regarding the other brands of spindle sanders, I have no experience with them or can"t recall any reviews of them but my memory is failing like the rest of me :( . Keep in mind that the Boss is not intended for heavy-duty sanding. I would say its 1/4 hp motor is pushing the envelope as far as hogging off wood. Go easy with it and it works fine. The Jet, with a 1/2 hp motor, may be better in that regard. If I were shopping today, and wanted a dedicated spindle sander, I would look at the Jet benchtop because it accommodates 1/4-inch spindles which I would find handy for what I do. Just some thoughts. Jim

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#17

Re: +2 for Ridgid

del schisler

i had mine for a long time the only thing to do is loosen the bolt that holds the spendle on and the belt unit , or it will get so tight you will not be able to get it loose that is all that i can say it works fine

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#18

Kneale Brownson

Another option

Kneale Brownson

I got the PC hand-held oscillating sander that I sometimes mount into a piece of plywood that I clamp to a tablesaw wing. At the time, I thought the hand-held would be useful on larger projects that wouldn't be easy to hold on a table. I've ended up rarely using it on big items, but frequently set it up with the piece of plywood.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#19

+ 3 or is it 4 for Ridgid ?

Mark

Large titling table, variety or drums and belt make it very versatile

High value for cost

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#20

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Mark

I have an Old Walker Turner Driver Series disc / belt combo I also never use.

I bought the Ridgid because it gives me the Belt and Drum combo, which for my needs is more useful and effective.

The other advantage is the ability for a Ridgid Sander to stack with my Dewalt planer on a rotating top rolling tool stand I made

Two machines are now easily and quickly accessible in a space saving foot print, which for me is important.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#21

Re: + 3 or is it 4 for Ridgid ?

Marc in Mass

I have the Rigid and seek no other. Belt and drum, it does it all, and has for 4 years now with lots of use. And you can find them on Craigslist for half price if you look around. I vote Rigid!

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#22

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

Joe Mohnike

I looked at the Ridgid (spindle only) at Home Depot, and was told they did not stock the drums nor would they order them, so I passed on that one. A few days later I happened to be in Harbor Freight, saw their spindle sander and they had replacement drums in stock. I took it home. that was about 4-5 years ago and I have no complaints. It does not have a tilting table or spindle but I have not found this to be a major issue. Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#23

Re: Parts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You can get replacement parts from Emerson (they make the Ridgid tools) and you can get abrasive sleeves for the spindle from Klingspor in grits from 80 up to 150 and 4x24 belts in finer grits.

Emerson gives great service. The oscillating gear on my sander broke. They had me take it to a tool repair guy about 30 mins away, and wound up giving me a whole new motor and gear box - no charge.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#24

Re: Parts

Joe Mohnike

Don't know about parts, never have had to replace any. However, if Harbor does the same as they have in the past they replace the entire unit no questions.

Re: oscillating spindle sander recommendation

#25

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Noting Robin's post about larger drums, I actually use the larger end of the Ridgid's belt that way. It's 3" diameter works well for smoothing out larger radius inside curves as long as you've got an accurate line to work against