Re: Sorry Bill.......
William Duffield
Well, I'm not sorry.
Sometimes, I just like to stir things up a bit, to get people thinking "outside the box."
In this case, I had my tongue planted firmly in my cheek, because if the block had been made from Corian®, all the issues that are making this discussion interesting immediately go away. OTOH, considering Corian® can help with the process of breaking complicated problems down to basics and attacking them one at a time. It can be worked with the woodworking tools we have in our shops. You can’t find it in very thick stock, so like Terry’s board, you have to glue it up. It is only available in 1/4”, 1/2” and 3/4” thick sheets. You can clamp and glue it with some of the adhesives we use in woodworking.
To answer several people's questions about grain orientation in the example shown, I enlarged Terry's pictures and studied them carefully. The grain orientation in both is left to right. The end grain is exposed on the two edges, on the sides of the photos, and that you cannot see. The top and bottom surfaces are face grain. The edge that you can see is also face grain.
TomD’s advise to coat all the exposed surfaces with epoxy, as is his observation that it won’t necessarily prevent all failures. A friend once brought me a butcher block* cutting board to repair. It was immediately obvious that someone had left it partially submerged in a sink filled with water. It had spit in two places. The blocks of wood were arranged in a bricked pattern. Some of the splits were between blocks and some were through the blocks. If it had been sealed with epoxy, it would have survived several more hours of immersion. I explained the reasons for the failure and the expected repair difficulties, and she said if I found it was not repairable, i could keep the pieces. When I got it back to the shop, I realized it was made of teak, which is almost as stable as Corian®. With the same change in moisture content, teak moves about half as much as the next best choice, and a lot less than anything you probably have in your shop, unless you are building wooden schooners, but it had failed anyway. I cut it apart and epoxied it back together for her, reflattened the surfaces, and explained to her what not to do in the future.
* IMHO, Butcher Block means the cutting surfaces are end grain. Anything less is a distortion, whose intent is to deceive uninformed consumers.



