Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

Posts

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#26

Re: Sorry Bill.......

William Duffield

Well, I'm not sorry. :D Sometimes, I just like to stir things up a bit, to get people thinking "outside the box."

In this case, I had my tongue planted firmly in my cheek, because if the block had been made from Corian®, all the issues that are making this discussion interesting immediately go away. OTOH, considering Corian® can help with the process of breaking complicated problems down to basics and attacking them one at a time. It can be worked with the woodworking tools we have in our shops. You can’t find it in very thick stock, so like Terry’s board, you have to glue it up. It is only available in 1/4”, 1/2” and 3/4” thick sheets. You can clamp and glue it with some of the adhesives we use in woodworking.

To answer several people's questions about grain orientation in the example shown, I enlarged Terry's pictures and studied them carefully. The grain orientation in both is left to right. The end grain is exposed on the two edges, on the sides of the photos, and that you cannot see. The top and bottom surfaces are face grain. The edge that you can see is also face grain.

TomD’s advise to coat all the exposed surfaces with epoxy, as is his observation that it won’t necessarily prevent all failures. A friend once brought me a butcher block* cutting board to repair. It was immediately obvious that someone had left it partially submerged in a sink filled with water. It had spit in two places. The blocks of wood were arranged in a bricked pattern. Some of the splits were between blocks and some were through the blocks. If it had been sealed with epoxy, it would have survived several more hours of immersion. I explained the reasons for the failure and the expected repair difficulties, and she said if I found it was not repairable, i could keep the pieces. When I got it back to the shop, I realized it was made of teak, which is almost as stable as Corian®. With the same change in moisture content, teak moves about half as much as the next best choice, and a lot less than anything you probably have in your shop, unless you are building wooden schooners, but it had failed anyway. I cut it apart and epoxied it back together for her, reflattened the surfaces, and explained to her what not to do in the future.

* IMHO, Butcher Block means the cutting surfaces are end grain. Anything less is a distortion, whose intent is to deceive uninformed consumers.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#27

Re: Sorry Bill.......

TomD

I actually thought the original piece was a chess board type of thing since it so obviously was side grain. I was remembering Krenov's game board where he had all the pieces floating with about a 1/4" between. Good design and no problems, but not so good for cutting.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#28

Re: Betting on Bill, and a good idea.

TomD

I am not sure if this is what you were saying Ellis, but if you inlaid those strips, on all four sides, or maybe even biscuits, then you frame it so that there is a little slop. The panel is basically just a panel style door. Except we can't do a frame and panel door without cutting back the proportions of the blocks, which would ruin the look. Epoxy on the endgrain to protect it from stain.

The Bill bit is just how tight you go in accordance with estimates.

Another option is to epoxy the engrain, finish the sides, and use little brass dowels, or some such, to center the board in a frame. Leave a 1/8" to 1/4" gap all around as a design element. Make it tight enough that you can't see the side joints, but not so tight it will blow, or junk will get jammed in there. I think that would work great.

The best way to epoxy the ends in my experience, and I have done this on tables 36 inches wide. Is finish the table, I used Maloof finish; saw the ends off. Run masking tape all around; upend, and paint with epoxy and do same on other end; strip off tape; carefully place a fence and with a sharp straight flute router bit, trim back to square without removing all the epoxy. Even after 30 years it just looks like a regularly finished piece of endgrain on my dining room table.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#29

How you could have made it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For Terry and anyone else interested......

Definition: end grain- the surface you would get if you cut a disk from a tree trunk. Long grain- the surface you would get if you split this disk (looking at the split face. In a board, the end surface of the board is "end grain" and the other 4 surfaces are "long grain".

A "checker board" cutting board is usually prepared in such a way that the top and bottom of the board is end grain. This orientation provides an end grain cutting surface which is better for durability, and the glue joints are long grain to long grain which provides stronger glue joints. So, how to get this arrangement for a board .....

The dimensions of the in the following discussion depend on the final size of the board you want. I will use "XX" for the variable dimensions.

In your case you had 3/4" lumber and you wanted 1 1/2" thick lumber. You can get what you wanted from what you had, as follows. Cut strips of walnut and maple 1 1/2' wide by some amount, XX, long. The XX length will be the width of your final board. How many strips you need depends on the length of the final cutting board. Each of these strips will give you 3/4" of final cutting board length (less the saw kerf).

Glue these strips face to face like making a stripped butcher block- walnut walnut, maple maple, walnut walnut, maple maple, etc. How many you glue will depend on how long you want the board but in any case is you start with walnut end with maple. The result is a block with 1 1/2" strips of alternating walnut and maple.

Smooth the top and bottom surface of the resulting block. Running it through a planer is ideal.

Next slice off 1 1/2" pieces from the end of the board you prepared. Caution! You will be slicing from a chunk of wood ideally suited for a nasty kickback. Use a riving bade on the table saw or better use a band saw. The result will be a bunch of sticks of alternating walnut-maple 1 1/2" cubes.

These alternating strips are then oriented end grain up and glued together to make the checker board pattern.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#30

Anew suggestion, I think....

Barry Irby

Apply two of your birch strips to the long grain sides. Then route a dovetail slot across the other two ends similar to what Ellis drew. Make a strip that will slide into the slot. Apply some glue near the center and let the sliding dovetail float. Then the two sliding dovetails will cover the join between the two layers and act as a handle.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#31

Re: Agree globaly....

Sgian Dubh

"The data is derived from measuring the total shrinkage in drying from about 25 to 0 % moisture and calculating an average rate per change in moisture content. What makes this calculation no better than a rough estimate? Individual pieces can vary 30%. KD lumber is more resistant to change in size in response to moisture than green lumber used to get the data. Any finish retards transfer, more of less. I doubt the shrinkage is linear from 25 to 0. I predict it slows at the low end but I can't find the data to confirm, so that statement is speculation.

Bill, I too have reached a similar conclusion through observations, research and studies I've undertaken.

It’s my observation from working and handling wood over the years that shrinkage factors as wood dries from Fibre Saturation Point (FSP), i.e., typically 30% MC to 0% MC are non-linear. Where 100 per cent of all the shrinkage occurs over the full range of what I call the Shrinkage Zone (in an exactly linear progression) it would be fair to assume a third of the shrinkage occurs between 30% and 20% MC, another third happens between 20% MC and 10% MC, and the final third occupies the range between 10% MC and 0% MC, or oven dry. What I’ve observed is approximately 75 per cent of all the shrinkage occurs between 20% MC and 0% MC. The remaining 25 per cent of wood expansion and contraction takes place between 20% and 30%MC.

This ties in rather neatly with the fact the majority of any distortion occurring in wood happens between approximately 20% MC and 5% MC. Distortion in this instance refers to the amount of warping, e.g., cupping and twisting a piece of wood exhibits as it dries, and not to the amount of shrinkage. Slainte.