Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

Posts

Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#1

Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

Terry Alexander

I am already working on 2017 Christmas presents. I am giving some cutting boards this year. This particular one is 11x16 and 1 1/2" thick. I got it to 1 1/2" thick by laminating 2 pieces of walnut and 2 pieces of birch. Here is a pic of the side view:



Obviously I need to cover the seam. I originally thought of using my biscuit router bit and kind of inlay a 1/8" of walnut or birch. However, SWMBO didn't like that idea. Having used up all of my walnut, she wants me to band the board with 1/4" birch all around. Here it is with the birch ready to cut to size and glue:



Having said/typed all of that, do y'all think I will have trouble with expansion/contraction of the 1/ 1/2" by 16" piece of birch on the trim? As y'all know....getting a perfect 45/90 degree on all 4 corners (IMO) is one of the hardest things to do in woodworking. Will this open up over time?

As always, I appreciate your expertise and value your advice.

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#2

not obvious to me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Obviously I need to cover the seam. " I don't see any seam that needs covering. Whether you will have any chance of success depends on the grain orientation of the blocks. What way is up is not apparent from the picture.

I attended a club meeting in Louisville some years ago and someone there did just what you are proposing on and end grain board. The border locked the interior in place and the miters split. They wondered why. Easy: the radial and tangential grain came and went with humidity while locked in place by the long grain border.

BTW, I find cutting boards that thick inconvenient to handle. (but they look nicer than thin boards. )

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#3

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for troub

Tom c

Can you rout finger grooves on the side?

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#4

Darnit Bill

Terry Alexander

I was afraid that was the answer. Sigh.....guess I'll have to put a little lipstick on my pig :)

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#5

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for troub

don stephan

Bruce Hoadley's Understanding Wood has a table which will suggest if walnut and birch expand and contract with humidity change at similar rates. If they do not, this movement will create stress that might cause tiny cracks or glue joint failure. Also, end grain does not make as strong a glue joint as side grain - think of gluing straws end to end or side to side.

If the grain in your walnut and birch squares all run in the same direction, one pair of opposite sides of the cutting board will be long grain and the other pair of opposite sides will be end grain. As Bill mentioned, in this situation one pair of opposite birch cover strips will be long grain against end grain.

Almost every finish allows moisture in the air to move through it, and when washed a cutting board will be exposed to more than just evaporated water in the atmosphere. With changes in moisture content wood changes slightly in width and thickness, but not in length.

You might consider subjecting your first cutting board to regular use, before making more.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#6

fine- without banding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have made many boards comprised of blocks oriented end grain up. They have held together fine.....but I don't soak them to clean. I now use Titebond 2, but in the past used just plain Titebond. Slather on some vegie oil and they are good for the ages.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#7

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for troub

paul in AZ

It may be heresy but you can cover up seams and other small imperfections with epoxy. Mix it up, tint it with a dye if you want color match or swirl in some matching sanding dust or fine sawdust. Squeeze it into the crack with an old credit card. Once cured it can be sanded clean.

If its a small crack tinting may not be necessary.

Quick, dirty and effective. Just don't tell anyone and they won't notice.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#8

Re: fine- without banding

Michael Bush

I agree. The band or frame isn't going to survive. It isn't just that the joints are going to open up, but that the bands themselves are going to pop off. But the cutting board without the band should be fine for a long time.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#9

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for troub

Barry Irby

It looks to me like you stacked two layers of 3/4" walnut and used one layer of 1 1/2" birch and glued them together in blocks end to end, but so that side grain not end grain shows. This means the joints are end grain to end grain or at best end grain to side grain. The joints would be stronger if the end grain showed top and bottom and the joints were all side grain to side grain.

If the board is as I suspect, it will not be as strong as it might be and should be handled gently.

And the strips will not work as others have said. The finger grooves around the sides might be the best idea for hiding the stacked blocks in the edges.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#10

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for troub

Brian Holcombe

I agree with Barry.

Might be wise to move to a complete re-do here. Wives are not often quick to let these sort of things go easily :D It'll save you from buying a board from Williams Sonoma in the near future.

End grain up, no edge banding. Make the board thick enough so that chopping with your heaviest knife won't split it (2.5").

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re:What they said and.......

Jesper, Denmark

End grain up and no banding. Mixed grain orientation in the board will be asking for trouble and banding is a no-no.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#12

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for troub

William Duffield

I have another, radically different approach to your problem. You have a design that has lots of glaring contrast, so why not celebrate the contrast at the seams instead of trying to hide it? You have two layers. Each dark block in the lower layer should have a light block over it in the upper layer, and each light lower layer block should be overlain with a dark colored block.

If that's not radical enough for you, how about gluing it up from black and white Corian, obviating all your wood movement issues?

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Sorry Bill.......

Jesper, Denmark

but Yuck, Corian cutting board in a woodworking forum. Pleeeeezze. :)

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#14

Moving Forward

David Yoho

Since you glued two pieces of 3/4" stock to get your 1 1/2" thickness, you either have to live with that seam or do them differently. You would be better off making squares from 1 1/2" stock, if that is how thick you want the boards to be.

If that isn't an option due to availability of thicker stock, then perhaps you need to just go with finished boards that are 3/4" thick. This avoids the seam and possible delamination down the road.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#15

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for troub

TomD

1) Band it as you propose, use west epoxy to glue the end grain band on, then coat whole thing with epoxy. Even then the cutting will get through the epoxy and you might end up with trouble.

2) Band the sides as you were planing to do, use epoxy. Band the end but carefully use full width strips of end grain wood (which would require a fairly large board to cut them off. Apply with epoxy and seal end grain of these endgrain bandings with epoxy. Of course if you do that you will not get the white look as much as if you used side grain. Use a water clear epoxy. Most boat brands have one.

3) Apply the banding with epoxy being sure to let it sink well into the ends of the boards. Finish with whatever you want. Might blow, there is some possibility it won't

4) don't band but simply apply veneers over the pieces of wood that have the cracks. The veneers could be really thin like plane shavings or actual veneers. Then don't band.

5) Band as you intend to, but make a slip joint. There are a lot of options here. One would be dovetails with the throughs on the side with the endgrain. Make them protrude neatly a bit like Craftsman joints, when they expand, they will reveal a crack, but they will return. Now is a bad time to do this since the wood will presumably be as dry as it gets, therefor seasonal variation will max out. Coat endgrain in epoxy. Or use craftsman corners, still get a crack. Go for through tenons that protrude, and cut a shadow line in at the joint (single saw cut) so there is a sort of a design feature there that may grow or not. But if it does, it looks a little more intended.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#16

Ellis Walentine

Two other possibilities

Ellis Walentine

Everybody is right: don't glue long grain strips to something that's going to expand/contract in one or more dimensions...

That said, there are two things that come to mind to make the best of this situation...

1. Glue long grain strips to the sides and end grain strips to the ends. This has the advantage of reinforcing the end grain to end grain joints and allows the width to fluctuate. Don't miter the corners though. Let the end grain strips overhang the side strips. This isn't ideal, but it ought to work.

2. I'd prefer to rout a groove around the perimeter of the board spanning the seam. Make a frame the thickness of the groove that is big enough on the inside to allow expansion/contraction. This will have the added benefits of strengthening the weak end grain joints and giving you a handhold to pick up the board. In fact, you could flare the frame of have it arc gracefully on two sides of the board. Lotsa room for creativity.


Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#17

Now I understand the problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I did not realize the thickness was achieved by gluing 3/4" material together. I presume the grain orientation is vertical so that the end grain is showing on the board surface? And, the seam that I didn't understand before is the joint between these layers?

I would cut a shallow 1/8" groove at the seam with the table saw and insert a walnut or maple 1/8" band in the groove. Use Titebond II for water resistance, or epoxy. You must keep moisture out of this seam or the board will fail.

See comment above on thickness.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#18

Board thickness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Brain recommends 2 1/2". I recommend no thicker than 1". My daily use boards are as thin as 1/2". A board that is going to see daily use needs to be easy to pick up, wash, drain and store.

I would find handling a 2 1/2" block somewhere between inconvenient and impossible. The alternative would be for it to sit permanent on the counter. I butcher critters on a 1 3/4" thick block. It is too heavy, but it's what I built 50 years ago for butchering, thinking thick was good. I don't whack trough bones with a heavy cleaver any more so I don't need the thickness that would resist this kind of use.

We have a great variety of boards. Some are for show , carving and serving at the table. The other extreme are utility boards for light to medium duty tasks. These are no thicker than 7/8" and various sizes. I regard utility boards as expendable as they suffer from use.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#19

Couple things...

Grant Smith

Terry,

Looks nice so far. Your proposed birch wrap will work fine on the sides where the wrap runs parallel with the grain in the board. Not so much on the side with the end grain or vertical grain. If the board is an end grain facing up board, then wrapping it won't work on any side. As Bill said, it is hard to tell grain orientation from the image.

I cranked up the woodweb shrinkage calculator and put in black walnut, 7% moisture content start and 15% moisture end point over 16" and I get .3566" of movement between those points. nearly 3/8" of movement compared to nearly none for your proposed wrap since wood doesn't move appreciably over its length. Suffice it to say its gonna come apart.

Take a look at Boos block online and pay attention to their grain orientation and flatsawn/ rift sawn/ quarter sawn layouts to see what works. I see mostly rift sawn wood in their end grain boards.

If you go to woodweb.com and search for wood shrinkage calculator, you will find a useful tool.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#20

Thank you all!

Terry Alexander

I learn so much from this forum. Rarely do I get to contribute to help someone, but you guys (and gals?) really help me. Retired 8/17/2016 so am getting to spend more time in the shop (weather/temperature permitting). Shop is 30x40 so not really feasible to heat that big of a space. Also, 10'- 12' high ceiling.

Again, thanks for all your wisdom.

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#21

overestimation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find the calculations from these sites greatly overestimate what I experience following the movement of lumber samples in my shop.

I never pay any attention to side grain orientation in an end-grain board and I have never had one come apart or even crack.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#22

Ellis Walentine

Heat

Ellis Walentine

I heat my 30 x 40 ft. shop with a woodstove. Gets it real toasty.

Ellis

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#23

Perhaps

Grant Smith

Hi Bill,

I appreciate your experience on the subject of wood movement. I always like your insight and candor. My experience has been somewhat different.

Having lived in many places across the globe, ranging from tropical to savanna to the humidity yoyo here in Iowa, I find it best to build for worst case and not have to worry about it if the recipient of my creations decides to move somewhere exotic like Florida, desert Southwest, or the Philippines. In many families these days, moving is a way to stay employed reliably.

As a beginning woodworker, I built some attractive (if you like 80's styling), yet poorly designed coffee tables for my living room using red oak. I built them in the fall of the year in Sacramento, Ca. I now live in Iowa, and the 18" solid oak lower shelf moves a great deal. Its movement is made obvious by the pressure it places on the lower legs. Perhaps a half inch from dry to humid. Much depends on grain, how fast the tree grew, and other factors difficult to quantify. Sure, I built poorly, and would do it much differently today. That is really the point. Wood moves. Plan on it. Most of us get a lesson at some point as we build our projects.

I agree that the projected movement may be worst case for a given humidity, And I won't argue your point that it may be an overestimate. That said, it isn't difficult to build to avoid problems. An ounce of prevention as they say.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#24

Agree globaly....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....but here we are dealing with a specific case. A cutting board is not going to move far from home unless gifted. Further, it will be slathered in some protective stuff. A slathering of oil or wax will greatly retard moisture transfer. A weekly used then washed cutting board is never going to dry to equilibrium. I have never had an end grain board come apart and it certainly would have if one were to believe the data provided on the topic.....which is inherently flawed.

The data is derived from measuring the total shrinkage in drying from about 25 to 0 % moisture and calculating an average rate per change in moisture content. What makes this calculation no better than a rough estimate? Individual pieces can vary 30%. KD lumber is more resistant to change in size in response to moisture than green lumber used to get the data. Any finish retards transfer, more of less. I doubt the shrinkage is linear from 25 to 0. I predict it slows at the low end but I can't find the data to confirm, so that statement is speculation. In modern air conditioned homes the humidity doesn't have huge swings summer to winter. For example my shop runs from a low of 30% in winter to 60% in summer.

Re: Expansion/contraction - Am I looking for trouble

#25

Re:

Grant Smith

Terry stated that it will be gifted. I also have new information to offer. I zoomed the heck out of the images and it appears that the end grain is on the end nearest the viewer in the second image. This is not an end grain cutting board. Therefore my comments about Boos blocks end grain boards don't apply to Terry. However, he, I and each of us might still learn something about how a successful cutting board company orients things in their products.

I took three facts in to account in my original statements:

1. It will be gifted. To me this means it might go anywhere on the planet, and also that it may not be cared for like your typical woodworker would. I have seen many of my gifted cutting boards at the recipients homes sitting around without much in the way of oil on them. This in spite of the fact that I send each one to its recipient with a card describing how to oil them periodically. I even had one recipient own up to putting one through her dishwasher and getting strips of wood out. Titebond III notwithstanding. I have built and given nearly a hundred odd cutting boards over the years. You and I both know that while finishes help limit moisture transpiration, no finish is known to eliminate it.

2. The regions even within this great country of ours vary greatly. Terry is from West Texas. Even if it stays there, we don't know the starting point of his lumber. Did it just get unloaded from a truck from Minnesota? Was it in his attic? Heck I haven't spent much time in West Texas, but it might be as dry as Arizona in one season, and have monsoon rains in another. I don't know, and more importantly it may be irrelevant since he said he is giving it as a gift. It might just go back to Minnesota, or down to Key West, or across the road from your house. Maybe you or I would end up fixing it five years down the road.

3. All I am doing here is erring on the side of caution with my contributions. For decades people will be googling and getting our answers to questions without the context of the details and lengthy (constuctive) discussion/ debate. I plan to continue this trend in each of my contributions here.

Bill I think we are both on the same side here, but simply with two different perspectives. Thanks for the discussion, and enlightening input, as always.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa