Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

Posts

OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#1

OK I'm going to throw away my chisels  *LINK*


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hk4cwtQJmwU

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#2

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels

John McGaw

I think I'll just wait until Leigh produces a router jig for it...

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#3

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Some friends recently gave me a book called "The Art of Japanese Joinery". I darn near cried when I read it. T.

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#4

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels

Larry

All I can say is: Dam!

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#5

Ok, Brian, Get Crackin'

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Here's your Asahi joint. We'll expect a full pictorial, of course.

:D

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#6

Hah!

Brian Holcombe

:D Next week....I promise :b

I've cut the rising dovetail a few times and it is a rock solid joint, and assembles very similarly (from the back of the joint forward at an angle).

These angled finger joints give me pause because they're mostly short grain.

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#7

Re: Sour Grapes

William Duffield

He could have 3D printed it and painted on faux wood graining.

What did he do that couldn't be done with a tube of CA and a drywall screw or two?

Facetiousness aside, the only things I've seen that come close are a Ming Dynasty chair reproduction by Yueng Chan and of course Chris Hall's "The Carpentry Way".

And Brian is catching up fast.

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#8

Drywall Screws?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Nah, all it needs is "a couple brads 'til the glue dries."

:D

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#9

Kneale Brownson

Glue?

Kneale Brownson

How would you add any to such a tight fit?

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#10

Re: Glue?

Brian Holcombe

Hah, there may be some truth to that. I've had work tight enough that it squeezes glue from both sides pretty often, and I expect a thin film is left.

I always wonder when I'm wedging tenons (I glue them) and the glue squeezes right off the wedge like a squeegee. Good thing that the tenon itself is nice and tight.

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#11

Personally

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I use epoxy bulked up with wood flour to "fill the gaps"

:D :D :D

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#12

Re: Personally

Brian Holcombe

:D Hey....sometimes a little glue mixed with dust is needed.....I pass no judgements :D

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#13

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

I love all the ads for Japanese chisels--as if having those chisels would make it any more likely that I could cut such perfect, difficult dovetails. I'm happy to cut "regular" dovetails and have them come out decent.

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#14

Re: piece of cake

TomD

I don't think there is any real difference, it is just a dovetail. Well a twisted dovetail. Been covered in FWW and other mags decades ago. Layout would be a pain the first few times around, though all it seems to be is you start with whatever gain, say 5 degrees and just add it to each line.

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#15

Re: Glue?

TomD

The fit is just hand tight, he couldn't easily drive that joint together with a hammer, so it isn't all that tight. And as Mark pointed out, there is a lot of end grain so you should be able to get a soak going. It is possible to assemble dovetails and then just wick in CA glue for the bond. But the downside is that it doesn't tend to pull the wood together. So for that approach or epoxy which doesn't swell a joint and acts like grease when assembling, it might be best to use woods of two different colours.

To pull the wood together and get some help from your glue you need some white or yellow glue. If you can still find a low tack white carpenter's glue, that would be the ticket. If not, titebond 1.

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#16

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels

TomD

Speaking of Japanese chisels been using those for 35+ years. You are right, they don't make a carpenter out of you, but I bought them with the assumption I would work up to them eventually, no second guessing. In the case of this joint it would seem to be a case for a fretsaw to liberate most of the wood, and then just chop the shoulders. Unless I was doing a lot of them, I am doubtful chisels would be the best way to root around in those angles.

Re: OK I'm going to throw away my chisels *LINK*

#17

Kneale Brownson

No Gaps is the video joint.