Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

A Survey of Sorts

Posts

A Survey of Sorts

#1

A Survey of Sorts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

We work with razor-sharp metals, usually moving at high speeds. The archives of Wood Central contain any number of posts, some with gruesome pix, of wood shop injuries.

I've got my share of scars, but I've "still got all 10" outside my shoes thanks to several good ER needle-n-thread docs. Having dealt with the after-incident pain you'd think I'd have learned how to keep soft body parts out of harm's way. It seems however, that I may have a subconscious desire to visit punishment upon my left thumb.

It started about 10 years ago with the table saw. Lost some bone on that one but it healed up so's you can hardly tell. Since then, whenever a tool (knife, chisel, hand saw) proceeds to slide or skip out of its programmed path, my left thumb most always appears to be positioned to halt the steel's wayward ways.

Thankfully, band-aids have been sufficient to staunch the leaks, but the current slip got me to wondering if my situation is unique.

So, query:

For those of you willing to admit shop injuries, is there any particular body part (hand, finger, left ear lobe) that you seem to whack more than others?

Have a Happy New Year!

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#2

My left hand takes the brunt of it

Dick Coers

20 stitches, 17 on the surface and 3 on the vessel inside, just below the thumb on the back. Had a bench chisel break out of the cut while paring. The doctor complimented me on the sharpness of the chisel. Childhood injury on the web between the thumb and forefinger. I remember getting it pinched, then looking at the injury and seeing ligaments in there! But the worst is when I sawed through the top knuckle on the middle finger with an Elu biscuit joiner. Two surgeries and fused joint latter, it works pretty well. About 3/8" shorter than it started out.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#3

Same here...

John in NM

Always the left hand - once tangled in a biscuit jointer, several times whacked by the drill press grabbing something and spinning it, once a knuckle on a non-spinning planer blade (recently honed too, nice and sharp).

Only once needed stitches - shrapnel from a rebar splitting wedge hit a vein... but that was the right inside elbow.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#4

Re: Same here...

Joseph Mulherin

About 15yrs ago I cut a piece of my left thumb on the table saw blade.....dummy me....got it stitched up and though a little numb at times it does operate fine

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#5

Re: My left hand takes the brunt of it

Michael Bush

My left index finger has had so many injuries parts of it look like mostly scars, and I haven't been able to straighten the end of it completely in 25 years. But it's still attached and whole.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#6

Re: Same here...

Eric Kuehne

And here. Tried pretty hard to cut my thumb off about 7 years ago. (Saved by the I'd rather be lucky than smart pheonomenon.) Same result too.

To answer the posed question thought I'm don't really discriminate on which of my body parts are damage.

Eric in Los Gatos

P.S. I'm curious and do not want to hijack a thread but I'm curious.

After my table saw mishap I thought long and hard about why it happened. I know why. I was working on a bathroom remodel and just popped into the shop rip a piece of bead board. Unfortunately my head was back upstairs in the bathroom. So what I did was to spend a bunch money on fancy push blocks. Now I like them and appreciate the design and function but the REAL value in them is that, in fiddling with them or making sure they are adjusted properly I have to concentrate on what I'm doing. In my mind that makes the push blocks cheap. Another more extreme(?) reaction might be to buy a Saw Stop.

So now I'm wondering if anyone else has made a change to their method of work as the result of things not going quite the way they had planned. Anybody want to share?

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#7

Ellis Walentine

Re: A Survey of Sorts

Ellis Walentine

I think you said you just had another mishap, Mark. Sorry to hear.

Me, I haven't had enough injuries to single out a usual target. Years ago, I had a few tablesaw kickbacks that caught me in the gut. Luckily I wasn't in the way of one that put a hole in the shop wall. That experience definitely changed my methods of work.

My one serious injury could have been much worse, in fact, I was really lucky. That was the time I managed to run my right middle fingertip into a jointer. By some stroke of luck, the tip of the bone connected with the edge head on and got bounced right back out. All I suffered was a nasty cut and a couple weeks of pain followed by months of regaining sensation in that fingertip. The scar is now barely visible and most of the nerves have returned to normal. That episode for sure changed the way I feed stuff into a jointer.

Woodworking is definitely a no-nonsense activity. It's up to us to always be mentally present and to learn all relevant safety habits and techniques.

Ellis

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#8

T'wern't No Thang

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

this time.

Flush-cut saw kept going after slicing off the peg. Leak stopped with a bit of pressure and a small band-aid.

I was trying to keep the thumb out of the l.o.f.

;)

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#9

Re: A Survey of Sorts

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Similar issue with joiner. I had acquired a full large air dried cherry tree at an auction stacked on two skids (a pile about 4' x 8' x 5'). My son and a friend were moving this lumber to my shop loft when I decided to see what kind of figure the lumber had. I picked up a fairly small cutoff and fed it through the joiner without a push block, about half way through the planer caught the piece and ejected it. My left thumb was above the blades and when the piece left, my thumb went into the blades.

I lost about 1/8 to 3/16 from the entire pad of my thumb. I didn't say a word, just shut off the planer and went in the house, cleaned the thumb, applied antibiotic and wrapping.

However my son and wife saw the wound and talked me into going to the Doctor a day or so later. He said a surgeon would probably graft tissue but he thought it would heal without that. It did although it took several weeks. Still have ripples on that part of my thumb, but no other issues.

That was the last wood that ever went through the joiner without a push block!

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#10

No preference

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have only suffered three minor woodworking wounds early in career with no preference to location. The skew chisel that dropped into hand found a random target. Most of my wounds are from working around the farm with no particular pattern.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#11

jointer question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have considered this machine benign, and hence may not be giving it proper respect. I have not had any close calls to act as warnings. Larry reported an injury that apparently involved jointing a short piece, something I would not do under any circumstances. How did your finger get in trouble?

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#12

Re: A Survey of Sorts

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I was cutting a stack of 1/8" wall paneling for leveling shims for theatre sets. About ten 8" x 15" on a table saw.Entire stack got caught and was slung into my belly at 100 mph. Belly was black and blue and painful for over two weeks.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#13

my mantra

John K Jordan

>>> It seems however, that I may have a subconscious desire to visit punishment upon my left thumb.


Ah, I see new line of shop safety gear to go with the safety glasses, respirator, and hearing protection: Mark's Left Hand Thumb Guard. Available in designer colors: blood red, black and blue, scar white, bandaid beige... Prototype lifted from suit of armor at the museum. Or choose the comfortable, flexible model woven from kevlar.

I could have used one in 1968, working in the Berea College wood industries - I scratched the tip of my left thumb on a monster bandsaw slicing little butterfly covers for the marble game storage holes. It could have been far, far worse.

My serious wood-related injuries have so far been not been from working IN the shop but from working to get the wood TO the shop. I broke my right "social" finger three times in a row, the last time dropping a 4x6 on when the finger was almost but not quite healed, leaving it with an interesting permanent bend at the end. Hasn't affected my piano playing, I mean, it hasn't improved it.

Then a couple of months ago I broke the tip of the same finger on my left hand, again with heavy wood, this time pinching it between the log and the tractor bucket. The nail is just now starting to grow back. I have a plan to prevent future injuries like these - pay someone else to man-handle the heavy stuff.

As for shop injuries, an event in the fourth grade made an lasting impression on me. One day I sat next to a boy who had just two fingers on one hand and two and 1/2 on the other. When he was "little" he went to the basement and played with the dad's table saw. This shaped my philosophy with shop and power tools when I had my own small kids. To this day I think of that every time I turn on a power tool with a sharp blade.

More recently I read something which has turned into a mantra I repeat EVERY time I push wood through any machine, especially the "safe" bandsaw: "Imagine where my hand will go if the wood suddenly disappeared." This makes me think twice about where my hands are, the pressure, my stance, and balance.

Knock on wood. No, that might hurt.

JKJ

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#14

Re: A Survey of Sorts

William Duffield

I've had a few small nicks on finger tips of my left hand from chisels, bandsaw and table saw. The table saw was stopped at the time. I'm left handed.

The only stitches were to the top of my head. I knocked a few K-body clamps off an overhead "rack".

The most serious injuries have been to my inner ears. Tinnitus is permanent and progressive.

Some advise: Design and use competent push sticks, with handles that are tall/long enough to keep your hands away from the sharp bits when the blade throws the wood away from the push stick. For the table saw, a stick that simply pushes is dangerous; It needs to be able to both push and hold the board down all the way to the back of the blade to minimize the chance of kickback. Arrange the power tools so the personal safety protection (push sticks, safety glasses, hearing protection) hang directly over the power switch.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#15

Re: jointer question

Barry Irby

My high school Principal had been the shop teacher. In an effort to show how to not use the jointer he tried to joint a short piece of wood. It flew away and he cut the entire last joint off a pinky. None of the students ever made that mistake.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#16

Re: A Survey of Sorts

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Mark, they make some nice kevlar gloves that would protect your thumb.

I don't play favorites when it comes to minor injuries on my hands. Both seem to spring minor leaks from time to time. I still have all 10 and they are fully functional.

Lee

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: A Survey of Sorts

Jack Guzman from Maine

I mostly work with hand tools. Spokeshave,drawknife,chisels,hand planes. I am right at this moment suffering from a small nick to the flesh of my left thumb. I accidentally caught the edge of an inshave blade while putting it away. It just seems to be a common target. I have nicked it a few times with miplaced paring cuts with a sharp chisel.

I try to avoid using my router or tablesaw. Either one is far less forgiving of clumsiness.---Jack

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#18

Gee, Looks

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

like my thumb is in excellent company!

Thanks for your support . . .

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#19

Re: Gee, Looks

John Stegall

Longest finger on left hand smashed with a hammer. X-ray show 3 pieces at least. Nothing to do but encase it in one of those plastic finger guards and wait. Cut left hand with hand saw, with limb saw, with pocket knife, with...you get the picture. All hand tools. Most serious power tool injury was kick back on the table saw into palm. Stained some nice plywood so paint had to be used. So the left hand gets the brunt of it.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#20

A buddy of mine once said :

Yonak

It's never the hand holding the tool that gets injured.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#21

Re: A Survey of Sorts

Paul Blackwell

i've been woodworking on and off for about 50 years, and I've only cut my left hand slightly with a wood chisel that slipped, and the worst was a kickback on the table saw. I was ripping cherry to about 1 1/2 inches square and two feet long. I always make it a point to push the piece thats against the fence well past the saw blade. To this day I don't know how it happened, but there was a violent kickback that struck me in the belly and almost knocked me down. Fortunately I had my leather apron on or I believe the piece would have penetrated my abdomen. I pulled my shirt up and I had a bruise the size of a softball. I was sore for a long time. My rule on making cuts is that if it doesn't feel right or I have any doubts, I find a different way to make the cut.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#22

Re: jointer question

Mark Hennebury

The jointer is a sleeping tiger;

I have always had a lot of respect for jointer's.

I have owned jointer's with up to 24" cutterheads, my current one is 20" I have never had a safety fence on it or any other jointer. I don't like safety fences or any obstruction in my way. I do operate it with safety in mind though and I am very aware of were my hands are and what can happen if i slip.

For motivation i keep in mind a conversation i had with a hand surgeon where he told me about a patient that he operated on, the patient had been pushing boards over the jointer when one got snagged and his hand slid palm down over the cutterhead filliting most of the bones out of his hand.

He told me that wood workers keep him very busy.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#23

Re: A Survey of Sorts

Mark Hennebury

Most of my injuries have been chisel slips into the left thumb or forefinger, I have lots of scars on those.

I have also had lots of crap in my eyes, one piece that left a hole. A bunch of random small injuries, fingertips, knuckles, thumbs, stuck into belt sanders, or grinders etc.

One mortise chisel in the knee that required stitches ( i don't juggle chisels any more)

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#24

Re: jointer question

TomD

"How did your finger get in trouble?"

The most common is to be pressing down on the piece while running it over the head, and then have it kick back. Whatever one does on tools, particularly ones that have a risk of kickback, one should imagine what one would do if all of a sudden the workpiece was not there. Routers on tables; shapers; TSs; jointers; bandsaws;etc...

- On jointers the two easiest ways to stay out of trouble are to use significant push tools. Ashley Isles who knew the Sheffield scene from a lifetime, said he never saw a pattern maker missing a finger, while such mutilations where pretty common. He said they reason was they always used push sticks.

- Large pieces, are like they have built in push sticks.

- Stand in a posture where you are never leaning on the workpiece, your legs should fully support you from beginning to end. This can require some somewhat more dynamic postures than the fully erect leaning forward ones commonly seen.

- Do not press down on the workpiece over or near the mouth of the tool.

- Consider your guards. US style swing guards are not functional for face jointing boards, consider Euro guards, or double up on other precautions. The reason a jointer is called than and not a planer as in the UK, is probably in part due to the fact that it was not really designed with wide board jointing in mind.

- I don't see the threads these days, but when I used to see the threads it seemed as though almost nobody actually knew how to run a jointer, or how to set it up. So learning that stuff will help.

- Keep it sharp.

If you are playing around with advanced tools or techniques, I plunge cut almost every board as an example, some have old tools with square heads, then you need to know your game.

The jointer is one of the most dangerous tools in the shop as regards it's unlimited cutting geometry. Cutting a finger off on a table saw is nasty, but you can run your whole arm into a jointer, it will keep cutting until it hits the shoulder. I don't see that happening in the real world, but the safe tools like the jointer and bandsaw are both unlimited in cutting geometry. So be knowing about what that means.

Re: A Survey of Sorts

#25

Re: jointer question

Sgian Dubh

"but you can run your whole arm into a jointer, it will keep cutting until it hits the shoulder. I don't see that happening in the real world, but the safe tools like the jointer and bandsaw are both unlimited in cutting geometry.

Tom, since moving away from the US over ten years ago, and back to my native UK, I'm no longer sure of the regulations and tooling configurations typical on US machinery. However, historically, the machine given most respect by British woodworkers (in terms of the ability to maim or worse) is, or was, the spindle moulder, aka shaper. The primary reason for this was the common use of square head cutter blocks along with their relatively high exposure in use caused by the fitting of limited or non-existent guarding, e.g., shaping a curved handrail on a cutter block raised 5"-6" above the table with the handrail passing over a dumpling sat between the bottom of the cutter block and the spindle moulder's table.

Yes, these machines and their tooling set-up had a reputation for sucking fingers into the cutting action when things went wrong because of the cog like square corners of the block, and the necessarily and inherently large gap between the block, its protruding cutters and any guarding in place. Again, historically, surface planers (jointers) and thicknessers (planers in north America [US only perhaps?]) quite often came fitted with square head cutter blocks, and a relatively large gap at the end of the infeed table and outfeed table to accommodate the square block and its protruding knives.

I don't think this type of cutter block has been in common use in woodworking machinery for perhaps sixty, seventy, or even more years. I've never seen one fired up in anger in any of the workshops I've worked in since I started my training in the 1970s. Today, of course, things are a lot safer with a range of safety features, e.g., circular blocks, limiters on spindle tooling, positive locking, etc, and the upshot is it's very unlikely a hand could be sucked into either a surface planer (jointer) or spindle moulder (shaper) block. I can't deny though that you can feed your whole arm into a bandsaw ... if you so wish, ha ha. Slainte.