Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

Posts

Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#1

Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

Barry Irby

I have a lightly used small Grizzly hollow chisel mortiser I bought at auction. Using it today to punch some 1/2" mortises the handle came loose. Its screwed into a steel hub, but only about a half inch. The threads and hole are wallowed enough to prevent the shaft from screwing in tightly. Should I coat it with JB Weld and screw it in or take it to somebody who can weld it? Hmm? Does trying the JB Weld preclude welding it later?

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#2

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I did exactly that to my el cheapo bench top drill press, maybe 20 years ago. I can't get the handle out anymore, but it hasn't budged a smidgeon, either.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#3

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

John in Nm

Probably the JB Weld will do the job. This kind of thing is the sort of job it's actually pretty good for.

It will preclude later welding, but that's not a huge deal - welding probably wouldn't work well anyway, it would take a guy experienced with cast iron to pull it off since the part is so small and it would be welding iron to steel.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#4

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

Dick Coers

If the weld is just a bead around the bar, the epoxy will not be an issue. If you wanted to braze in the bar to fill in around the threads and add the brazing fillet, he epoxy will prevent that course of action.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#5

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

don stephan

Would removing and replacing the hub be an option? Would gluing the handle in prevent future removal of the hub if the epoxy fails?

What did customer support say? Without trying to be negative, is the desire to explore all options or simply find support for using the epoxy?

"Punching" 1/2" holes makes one wonder if too much force was being applied to the handle. If that was the case, perhaps a repair would be short lived.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#6

Except....

John in Nm

The heat from the weld would burn the epoxy - burning epoxy is one of the only things I strenuously avoid whenever possible.... just smells like it has to be really really bad for you.

Not really a rational reaction I admit, but kind of like a purple mosquito I saw once in Mexico. Figured if any mosquito was going to give me malaria or dengue, it would be a purple one! :D

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#7

Did not mean to start a kerfuffle.  Wow

Barry Irby

Sorry if my question offended anyone. This one was at least related to woodworking. I enjoy Wood Central and come here for advice from people I have come to know and trust. I also bring some knowledge and try to share what I know I know. You Tube and Google are dangerous places, People will share what they think they know, if they think at all. You must filter anything you see carefully.

When I got this mortiser I needed a bushing to make it compatible with the bits I already owned. I called Grizzly with all appropriate numbers. Apparently this machine is discontinued and they were not able to recommend a particular bushing, so I bought several based on my best guess. One of them worked. Did not give me a lot of confidence they would have a replacement handle of even know if they did. I will try that Monday.

When did it get to be stylish to throw away stuff and buy new?

It may be that I was "dogging it" trying to punch half inch holes, but if it won't do that, it is somewhat less useful to me. I will discuss that with Grizzly.

Thanks for the answer that JB Weld actually worked in a similar case. I will talk to a welder to see if the epoxy will put him off if it does not work.

CharlieL, if my posts offend you, my name is right beside them, skip them, I read almost every post, but you don't have to. Just let me know and if you prefer, I will skip yours as well.

To the rest of you THANKS for the help.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#8

Poor engineering is more likely

Dick Coers

It takes a fair amount of effort on a 1/2" mortise chisel. I'd say a LOT of these bench top mortisers are poorly engineered to do the job for very long. I'm sure I've read about other failures on the same size machines. Hence the wide acceptance of the Festool Domino!

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#9

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

Joe Bradshaw

Barry, could you try something like a Heli-coil?

Joe

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#10

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

jessecloud

Hey Barry,

I hope you will continue to ask any question you have. I always enjoy them.

Sometimes I know the answer and post what has worked for me, only to learn that someone else had a

better idea - and I think thats great.

And a lot of times, I don't know the answer and learn something from those who do.

When I have a question, I usually google it first, but to tell the truth I get so many different answers that

I often wind up asking it on WC and viewing an informed discussion of competing answers. I think thats what this site does best!

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#11

Joe, I don't know anything about Heli-coils

Barry Irby

I vaguely understand them, but in this case, I think Dick is correct, This is poor Engineering. The hub this lever arm screws into is less than or about 2" in diameter. There is a bolt that passes through the center of it, so the lever shaft can not pass all the way through. The threaded part is less than a half inch in diameter and about a half inch long. The lever is approaching two feet long. That's a lot of of torque to put on a stubby little connection. I suspect a heli coil would get crushed, but maybe not. I will look into them and see whats available.

Wonder if it would not work to drill the threads out of the hub and cut the threads off the shaft and insert the shaft into a snug hole and either weld it or use JB Weld?

Thanks for the suggestion. I will check out Heli Coils.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#12

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

Barry Irby

Jesse, thanks. I come here almost every day. The knowledge base here is astounding. The experience is vast. There are woodworkers of every stripe and many of those people have a "real Job" and bring that knowledge with them. I truly have asked some off the wall stuff (Mark me King of OT) but I also have spent a lot of time answering others OT stuff. I try to contribute both in time spent and financially. And I learn a lot, too.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#13

Don't Worry About It, Barry.  Ask Away

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You give as much or more than you ask for here. Your questions are always welcome.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#14

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

William Duffield

I really enjoy your questions, and even the problems you have that instigate them. The types of problems you have, and the approaches we take to helping you solve them are just the kinds of motivations that get me into my shop and building and fixing things.

Dick is right on. With the invention of the Domino, the HCM and the biscuit jointer are dinosaurs.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#15

Keep on keepin' on Barry!

Stuart Hough

You, your questions, answers and topics exemplify what WC is all about!

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#16

Joe, just went and looked at HeliCoils

Barry Irby

Might work, But I am skeptical.

I found a date on the machine, 1995. I really don't think it has had a lot of use. I looked up a similar machine on Grizzly's site. A GO645 I think. Sells for $269 now, no Idea what it sold for in 1995, but a cheap machine.

The handle on my machine is 5/8" in diameter and 15" long, but they reduced the end to a half inch and threaded it and screwed it into the 2" diameter collar. There is a 5/8 counterbore around the hole to give the handle a flat surface. The threads are deformed and the handle wobbles.

I was nearly convinced the JB Weld would work if I could pull the handle tightly against the steel as for the down stroke. Then it dawned on me that there is enormous force needed to withdraw the chisel on the up stroke. Pretty sure the JB Weld would liquefy or flow.

And there is not a lot for the Helicoil to work with/against. The little nub is half inch in diameter and less than a half inch long.

I think welding is the best idea along with adding some sort of haunch to reinforce the joint.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#17

So....it went ...

Brian Roberts

from working fine to "the threads and hole are wallowed enough to prevent the shaft from screwing in tightly"

without any prior warning?

Seems that some upkeep may have been in order....and I assume it was not "well" when you bought it?

At any rate....clean both the shaft and the hole threads up with the correct tap and die.

If needed cut the shaft off to get to full sized stock to cut good, complete threads on it.

If there is still some wobble....use the epoxy filler....or Loctite makes products specifically for this situation.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#18

Re: So....it went ...

Barry Irby

I don't think I have done significant damage to this since I got it. I have had it for a year or so, but it was 20 years old when I bought it. I got it and bought the bushing for it so I could use my existing chisels and may have Done a few test holes, but basically it has been sitting there unused. I suspect the handle connection was poor and worn and I finished it off cutting four mortises in the bed I am working on. Somehow I did not realize what was happening. You could tighten the handle, but if you really tightened it, it would slip past the last thread and be loose again. I paid very little for it and it will do until a Domino comes along.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#19

Re: So....it went ...

Dave Nichols

I had the same problem with my Grizzly mortise, I brazed it together, been working like that for almost 20 years.

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#20

That is a good thought....

John in NM

Brazing is an effective way of joining cast iron to steel when the joint need not be as strong as a weld. As Dick pointed out earlier, epoxy first would upset the brazing though.

If you have a brazing torch it is a good method to consider (air-propane will do for small parts, but anything large usually requires air-acetylene or oxygen-fuel torches).

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#21

Re: No call for criticism

Hank Knight

Barry,

Apparently the person who criticized your question has deleted his post. I commend him for that. More importantly, I agree with everyone else who has taken issue with the criticism and encouraged you to continue posting as you have done for a very long time here. I always enjoy your posts and find your questions interesting and stimulating, whether or not they are directly related to woodworking. As others have pointed out, diversity is the beauty of this forum (thank you Ellis) and I have never found your contributions offensive in the least.

Hank

Re: Fixing morticer? Job for JB Weld?

#22

We all support diversity......

roger lance

so long as its not too different.