Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Bandsaw blade preference

Posts

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#26

Puzzled by your answer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The carbide teeth are precision ground like a quality saw blade. Additionally they typically are in a stagger tooth pattern that reduces harmonic vibrations.

Bill, my understanding is that carbide is simply a material, in the same way that bimetal HSS blades and carbon steel blades are simply a material. Blade makers then offer a range of blade designs, with different degrees of rake and differing tpi.

Carbide is a prime choice because it outlasts HSS, which outlasts carbon steel. You pay for the privilege. I use HSS bimetal, and these are a good compromise for me.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#27

Re: Puzzled by your answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Carbide is simply a material but carbide blades imply more than a material just as "carbide" bench saw blades are more than just the material. Nobody talked about "glue line rip blades" when they were made of just steel, sharpened and set. The insert teeth on a carbide band saw blade are precision ground on 4 faces just like a bench saw carbide blade is precision ground. Furthermore, the typical "carbide" band saw blade doesn't have all the same sized teeth to reduce vibration. As a result they are capable of making cuts substantially smoother than any steel blade I have used. No smoothing is required before gluing the sawed face. Professional shops that have them buy them for the smooth cut, according to what I have heard.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#28

Re: I wish your buddy lived closer.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

100% coverage. It needs to be held flat.

There are commercial machines that saw veneer. I see them displayed at machinery shows. Cormark (spelling?) has one. They once sawed the thin wood for Woodcraft and may still do.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#29

Re: Puzzled by your answer

John in NM

One difference is that the tooth geometry is very different with carbide since it is a brazed on block rather than a set (bent) tooth of the same material as the blade body. I believe this gives the tooth a more precise planing action, like a router bit. Steel router bits cut more like carbide ones than do steel saw blades, because the cutter geometry is essentially the same - the steel bits just have a vastly shorter life.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#30

Re: Puzzled by your answer

Alexander Grigoriev

Since the carbide teeth can be wider than the substrate, the blade doesn't really need any set, each tooth can cut the whole width. Also, the teeth can have flat sides which will smooth the cut and stabilize the blade in the cut.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#31

Re: Puzzled by your answer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks all for the responses. What I recognise is that carbide is added to the tooth. It is not shaped with the tooth, as are carbon and bimetal blades. The different formats function according to their construction.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#32

nice example

Joseph Piotrowski

that is some nice looking resawing.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#33

And a good example of the utility of carbide

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I fastened the crotch board to some 2" oak, Leveled the crotch face and sawed away till I hit the oak. This procedure and the fact that I didn't need to joint a rough band saw cut enabled me to double the yield of this limited supply crotch wood.

A carbide band saw blade provides exactly the same benefit as a carbide rip blade on a table saw- smooth cuts and long lasting sharpness but with a 1/32 kerf.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#34

Re: And a good example of the utility of carbide

Joseph Piotrowski

sold me! as soon as i set up my bandsaw i'll order one. any recommendation on brand ? blade sizes(tooth) to rip and/or size to resaw?

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#36

blade size

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Lenox makes a quality blade. The 3/2 tooth pattern is versatile but you need to size the tooth pattern for what you will be sawing. Lenox tech service or web site may offer advice.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#37

recommendation please

Howard Pollack

I presume that there are great variations in carbide blades (tooth configuration etc.) Do you have a recommendation? Your crotch wood demonstration is indeed convincing. Thanks. -Howard

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#38

Re: recommendation please

Phil Smith

The saw Bill described is mine. It is a Yates American 30" bandsaw with a Lenox variable pitch carbide. Blade is 1 1/2" with variable pitch 3 to 4 teeth per inch. This blade works very well up to about 8 to 10 inches of wood. Past that the blade begins to load and can wander in the cut. For wider wood you need fewer teeth per inch. Next resaw blade will be 1 1/2 to 2 teeth per inch. I have seen these blades cut and they still give very good cut and they are cheaper because you buy carbide bandsaw blades based on total number of carbide teeth. It is had to appreciate how good the cut is until you see it.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#39

Re: recommendation please

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Is this blade different from the Lenox Trimaster? I have that one in a 1/2" width on my 14" Delta BS, and while it cuts well and lasts a long time, the quality of the cut is not what Bill has described.