Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Bandsaw blade preference

Posts

Bandsaw blade preference

#1

Bandsaw blade preference

Robert Fuller

Given the choice between spending $250+ for a carbide bandsaw blade for re-sawing, or spending the same amount for 8 carbon steel blades, which way would you go?

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#2

Easy decision

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you intend to wear out 8 steel blades get the carbide. The carbide cut is so smooth that you can glue the cut surface and no need to flatten between cuts.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#3

Ellis Walentine

What are you resawing?

Ellis Walentine

I've mainly used carbide blades for resawing really dense or abrasive materials, think cocobolo or ebony, not that it doesn't do a fine job on domestics. But, unless you're going to be resawing a lot, I'd go with regular steel blades.

Ellis

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#4

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

jcousins

agree with bill - if you're going to be cutting quantity on a regular basis go with carbide. over the years my preference is the resaw king - but that opens a whole nuther discussion.

jerry

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#5

Not so certain

Gary Smyth

Assuming that all things being equal --quality blades, same number of teeth, band saws the same and tuned AND time. My thinking is that the opportunity for seven additional fresh blades might well exceed the performance of one carbide blade. I generally believe that you get what you pay for, but in this case to save substantially by careful selection of the carbon steel option seems like a risk worth taking.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#6

I've never owned a carbide tipped blade

Dick Coers

Never had a carbide tipped and have been woodworking for 42 years. I guess that qualifies as an answer. There are also bi-metal blades that are something in the middle of the two you asked about.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#7

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

Jim Dillon

Robert, your question is a very fair one. As one of several who recently posted their positive feelings regarding the carbide-tipped blades, a valid argument can also be made for steel blades. My Timberwolf (Suffolk Machinery) blades have met most of my normal needs and I use them often. However, for resawing, especially exotics, I reach for the carbide blade. Yes, I have to go very slow on my "old" underpowered 14-inch Delta, but the carbide blade gets the job done extremely well with zero drift (important to me). However, I never had to shell out $250 dollars either. I would not hesitate to give a steel blade a try to see if it meets your needs. If your needs lean more towards resawing, then the carbide blade makes more sense to me. But first, try a steel blade from your favorite vendor. Good luck. Jim

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#8

Re: What are you resawing?

Robert Fuller

Lot of resawing, all domestic hardwood (maple, walnut, birch, cherry).

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#9

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

Robert Fuller

Thanx all for the replies. I have an 18" 3HP bandsaw and have in the past purchased steel Lenox blades. But, these do get dull after a relatively short time.

Are the bimetal blades better than carbon steel? What is the advantage?

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#10

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

Jim Dillon

Robert, wow, I LUST after a bandsaw like yours but floor space prohibits it. I hadn't noticed dulling of the carbide blades in an unreasonable period of time but that is just my experience, not yours. I have no experience with the bimetal blades and hope others will post their experience with these more moderately priced blades. Thanks for getting back to us with more information. Jim

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#11

Bimetal, for sure..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The abrasive woods I work accelerate blade wear. I've tried carbon steel blades in the past, including some well-known brands. None of them last long. Now I stick with bimetal blades for all my cutting - general ripping and shaping as well as resawing.

The blades I use are large-ish .. I have a 17 1/2" Hammer 4400. However I resharpen the blades myself, and get at least 3 - 4 sharpenings for each blade. With each sharpening lasting easily 10x as long as a high carbon blade, it is really a no-brainer. And sharpening is a simpe process (I use a Dremel with a diamond disk, and leave the blade on the machine while working on it). It takes me about 15-20 minutes.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#12

Re: Bimetal, for sure..

Barry Irby

I am envious of your saw.....I have a 14" Delta with a riser Block.

I have used both high carbon steel and Bimetal. Have not used a bimetal in a long time because the DoAll dealer that I used to buy from moved away. As I recall their blades were thicker and lasted a lot longer than the steel blades. The thickness bothered me.

I resharpened blades. I tried using a disk on the outside of the tooth and a round bit on the gullet side of the tooth. I got them sharper, but the never cut as perfectly as a new blade. Excellent for hacking up rough work, but not so good for fine detail or resawing. Most probably operator error on my part.

My other approach was to buy a dozen cheap blades at a time and treat them as disposables. That worked well except again for resawing.

Have never tried a carbide tipped blade.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#13

Re: Bimetal, for sure..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Barry

My previous saw was a generic 14" with a riser. Several years ago the taxman gave me an unexpected rebate. My dear wife said get the bandsaw of your dreams. :)

Sharpening carbide with a diamond disk on the Dremel is really a an easy process. Once you have done it once or twice you will never send out blades again, and you will make the blades last several times as long. Sharpening leaves the blades sharper than the original. For a bandsaw the size of the Hammer, it takes about 20 minutes.

I only sharpen the back of the tooth. I don't touch the gullet. This is somewhat like a backbevel, except that it is much the same angle at the back of the tooth - I have exaggerated it here for effect.


I leave the blade on the saw, mark a spot with blue tape, and then rotate the blade by hand, sharpening each tooth as it goes by. All that is required is a gentle swipe along the back of the tooth.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#14

ebd

Re: Bimetal, for sure..

ebd

Thanks for the explaination. I've got to try this.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#15

Re: Bimetal, for sure..

William Duffield

For a bandsaw the size of the Hammer

The size of the saw is secondary. It's the total number of teeth that determines how long the sharpening takes. Some of the blades for my 12" bandsaw have a lot more teeth than the resaw blades for my 18" saw. Do the math :D

I've even effectively resharpened bandsaw blades with diamond paddles, like these, and it doesn't take appreciably more time than the Dremel tool. http://www.woodcraft.com/product/147298/dmt-diasharp-25-diamond-offset-minihone-kit.aspx

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#16

Re: Bimetal, for sure..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

You are correct, as usual :)

I do not recall the length of the blades (about twice the size of the average 14" machine). I use 3 tpi 1/2" blade for everything.

Those DMT paddles are new to me. I have the Easy-lap versions. When I first began sharpening blades, it was on a corner of a grinder wheel. The Dremel makes it easier, plus one can do it freehand and still retain the grinding angle. I can see how you could do the same with a paddle.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#17

Re: Bimetal, for sure..

William Duffield

Tape the paddle to a wedge to set your pitch (and fleam, if you are so inclined), do half the teeth, turn the paddle and wedge around, and do the other half. My 12" bandsaw's blades are 82" long, and the 18"s are 137" long. So, that's 820 teeth for a 10 tpi blade on the little one, or only 411 teeth for a 3 tpi blade on the resaw, a lot more than a dovetail saw, in either case, but doable. I sharpen the front of the tooth, instead of the back, because I can easily control the downward pressure of the tooth on each stroke of the diamond paddle with finger pressure on the upper wheel.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#18

Re: Bimetal, for sure..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

That's a different approach to the one I use. I'd be concerned that the tooth angle is being altered. Sharpening the back of the tooth, as I do, does not alter this. Nor does it require fleam or setting the teeth.

The method I follow is simply a slight variation taken from the video, below ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UygEQ-079Ws

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#19

The main argument for carbide

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Saving wood

With a well set up saw one can saw veneer ready to glue with no jointing or smoothing between cuts. One winds up with a flitch of veneer similar to if it had been sliced in a veneer mill. The veneer book matches well because the consecutive sheets were close to one another in the original piece.

If this advantage is not important then the case for carbide greatly lessens. I think the only other reason for carbide would be if one was sawing highly abrasive woods.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#20

Maybe it's the wood I use

Dick Coers

Especially wide stock, it's a regular occurrence to get a little cupping after resawing the stock. Can't say at what regularity, but it does occur. So the super surface finish from the carbide is a characteristic I can live without.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#21

About carbide

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Carbide, per se, does not create a smoother surface. It is the number of teeth and the set of the teeth that determine the finish.

Carbide offers longevity (especially wish abrasive woods), and an edge that remains sharper for longer will provide a better finish. Dull blades tend to wander and not cut straight. As the blade dulls, so there is a tendency to push harder. Forcing a cut is a recipe for a wandering cut.

Carbide blades do need more tension. However, more tension also creates a stiffer blade and a straighter cut.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#22

not a correct analysis

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The carbide teeth are precision ground like a quality saw blade. Additionally they typically are in a stagger tooth pattern that reduces harmonic vibrations. The result is a cut the same smoothness as a carbide rip saw. There may be other minor advantages but these are the most significant.

If I am simply resawing to get thinner drawer sides I use a steel blade. If it is a figured wood in limited supply I go to friends house and have him resaw on his carbide equipped blade. I wind up with a flitch similar as if I had it sliced.

See my other post for keeping the billet flat.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#23

A cure for this problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Figured wood usually springs as it is sliced for veneer. For example, when I am slicing a crotch I back the piece with 8/4 oak. (the oak is glued to the billet face)

The backing keeps the piece being sliced flat. It works...Have used it routinely for making figured veneer.

For example....


Shown is sequential crotch wood as it was sawed from the billet. No jointing in between cuts.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#24

additional benefit

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One can slice right down to the backing leaving no waste of the "rare" wood being veneered.

Re: Bandsaw blade preference

#25

I wish your buddy lived closer.....

Barry Irby

And would resaw stuff for the rest of us. Perhaps for a small fee. I have resawed some beautiful stuff on my 14" bandsaw and had good success, but it was slow and tedious. I think there is a business opportunity for some sort of machine that would take interesting stuff and turn it into veneer. Either by slicing it or sawing it. I have "wasted" a lot of beautiful stuff clumsily resawing it.

I like your idea of gluing it to a backer board. Do you use 100% glue coverage or just a few spots?