Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

Posts

Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#1

Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I use a router for free-hand removal of waste, for example in making half blind dovetails and hinge mortises. Ideally, I like to route to just shy of the scribe line as illustrated in Picture 1 for a hinge mortise example.



If I can get close to the scribe line one paring cut of the chisel establishes the boundary of the excavation. However, to route close to the scribe line requires excellent lighting as shown in Picture 2.


I purchased the Lee Valley “goose-neck” LED light shown in Picture 3 (Lee Valley 15J7701) to see if it would provide the lighting I desired.



I might add that years of previous experimentation did not provide the lighting I sought. The LV light did, as shown in Picture 2, but some annoying problems were in the path to success.

The light comes with a side mount magnet and an end mount magnet and a separate post to stick in a dog hole (Lee Valley 15J7704). The side mount worked to affix the light to the frame of a band saw or drill press to provide intense task lighting to a work area.

The post for dog hole mounting is stainless steel that is not magnetic, for reasons I can not imagine. Hence, the post can not be simply attracted to the light’s magnetic base and stuck in the dog hole. Rather, the magnet in the end of the light must be pushed out and the post screwed to the light, an arrangement that lacks convenience. Then one discovers that the post is too short to be useful in a worn dog hole.

Next I tried to attach the light to a steel post positioned in the dog hole. The force of attraction of the light’s strong magnet as it engaged the steel post shattered the thin (3/32”) magnet insert in the lamp base as shown in Picture 3.



Reassembling the shattered magnet pieces proved impossible. Each acquired a N&S pole that resisted all attempts at reassembly.

Success with dog hole installation came with magnetically sticking the light to the end of a bench dog as shown in Picture 4.


Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#2

PS- the battery problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I primarily use Tenergy rechargeable batteries for my battery needs. They will not fit in the case of this light. I had to purchase standard disposable batteries for this light, which are 0.010" smaller diameter than the Tenergy battery. For whatever reason the manufacturer of this light provided no clearance between the battery case and the battery pack that would enable the slightly larger battery to be used.

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#3

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task ligh

William Duffield

I've been using one of these for almost 3 years, and have been pleased with it.

You're missing an essential part, the mounting plate, "B" 15J77.02.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=71189&cat=1,70596,43349,71189

In addition to screwing it to a wall, you can screw the plate to either size (3/4" or 22 mm) stainless dog-hole post. That should spread out the attachment force so you don't shatter any more magnets. Have you enquired with Lee Valley customer service to see if you can get a replacement magnet? Have you tried gluing in the shattered magnet one piece at a time? The magnet in the side clip should also hold to the dog and plate combination, but I can't find my clip right now to verify the operation.

I mostly use mine without attachments, since the magnet holds it securely to my drill press, lathe and drill press. I rarely use the magnetic side clip because the gooseneck is so flexible at positioning the light that I can always find a position that works using the magnet on the end.

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#4

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task ligh *LINK*

Keith Newton

Bill, I think a flexible bore light attached to your router would be a good economical option. You could either tape or use wire-ties to a handle, then the light would travel with the router as you rotate it left and right. And at this price, how bad can you go wrong. ;>)


https://firearmpros.com/win-flex-bore-light.html?utm_source=google_shopping&gclid=CjwKEAjw34i_BRDH9fbylbDJw1gSJAAvIFqUGSfg2Mo9_r6p8szc-xiu1xotkkqS2UVEWbTJfSjvrBoCtlDw_wcB

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#5

Re: Cool

TomD

That looks like a cool light, sliding it sideways might solve your problem with the magnet.

As far as flashlights are concerned over the years I have had pretty much a 100% failure rate with LED flashlights over time. The exceptions from the field of early lights are a maglite conversion which is quirky, and a micro Gerber which is a great light if weak. My lesson is that only the tactical level (not just style) lights are worth the trouble. I use them on my bike clenched in my fingers, etc... I do the same with tools or fabricate holders for them, scope ring bases are good starting points. As are the bike light bases, they might work for tools. Fenix is the budget level of tac light I am using. Only time will tell

I also use gooseneck USBs as cheaper version of fixed lights, they cost only about 2 bucks and work with one of the 2 buck chargers. Ebay is a great source of LED bulbs for conventional lights or sewing machine lights for which there are many gooseneck lamps one can repurpose.

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#6

Followup

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Lee Valley customer service is sending a replacement magnet. The problem of the batteries not fitting is being investigated.

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#7

Suggestion......

Barry Irby

You could use a dowel with a fender washer screwed to the end of it for a holder to fit in the bench dog holes. Or, if you happen to have one, a bolt that would fit the hole. I wonder why they made the holder out of stainless?

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#8

Re: Suggestion......

William Duffield

So it wouldn't rust? So it wouldn't shatter the very strong but brittle magnet? :)

The accessory plate that I identified is designed to be flat enough and large enough that it doesn't strike the magnet intensely enough to shatter it.

After Bill's experience (and probably a few others' similar failures), it would be a good idea for Lee Valley to enhance their product description to warn against trying to attach the magnet to objects that have a shape with a tendency to shatter the magnet.

I found my magnetic side clip. It was attached to a bandsaw. I verified that it does work to hold the light to the dog post and accessory plate. The plate, since it has a countersunk hole in the middle, can easily be attached with a FHWS to the end of a wooden dowel of any desired length and diameter, or even to a square dog if that's what your bench is equipped with.

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#9

LRSmith

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task ligh

LRSmith

My solution was to countersink the LV mounting plate (15J77.02) in to a 9 inch scrap 2X4 with a formica overlay.


img

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#10

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task ligh

roger lance

LR.....if I had this light, I'd make a wood variant of the base you made (after all, we're woodworkers).....the light could then be placed anywhere on the bench regardless of dog hole locations.

I became interested in the light following a favorable review by Chris Swartz a couple of years ago.....but I didn't like the battery business.....I find the battery thing to be an annoyance and so I've held out for this light to be made with a regular power cord.....something that LV said the light manufacturer was working on.....I guess they're still working on it.....must be some significant technological challenges to get this thing to work with a power cord.

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#11

More follow up- I like batteries

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

what I most like about this light is its lack of power cord. Because it is so easy to move and position without needing to be tethered to the grid I find myself using it all around the shop. In fact, I would not have lighted my shop to sun-like intensity if I had this light some years ago. It is so handy to illuminate what ever is needed in spot light intensity or a broader flood beam. I just sawed some tenon cheeks on the band saw. The bright illumination of the beam focused on the bade tip enabled me to split the line defining the end of the tenon.

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#12

Re: More follow up- I like cords....

roger lance

Looking around my shop, I've got individual task lights on most tools.....drill press, miter box, radial arm, lathe, band saw, and grinder....all goose necked and all with a power cord.

Only time I ever envied battery powered tools was in construction when you are up in the rafters or some other inconvenient place trying to string an extension cord around to power a drill or similar tool.....and having to reset everything each time you moved.....but, not in a shop where you have outlets well placed to accommodate your work.

Beyond this personal preference, that light has consistently received very favorable reviews.

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#13

Re: More follow up- I like cords....

John K Jordan

I agree, no battery-powered lights for me in the shop. I have many task lights in the shop and all have cords. When I wired my shop I planned ahead for the overall lighting and task lighting and at some places, such as the main lathe and bandsaw, I wired outlets on switches to turn on all task lights with one motion.

There is a small shelf near the top of this picture that has a board on the front. This board has several of the switched outlets behind it and serves to support and hide the wiring and plugs. (It also makes a perfect place to mount magnets to hold pencils, measuring tape, and other tools. I wrap some soft iron wire around pencils to hold them with magnets.)


The only battery powered lights I have, besides the ones I carry in my pocket, are in my hay storage building and other spots around the farm where there is no power. I like the LED lights with D or C cells. Some have had the same batteries for over 6 years now.

I do like battery powered tools around the farm, drills, impact drivers, circular saw, recip saws, side angle grinders, etc. When working on a fence or outbuilding or equipment far from power they are perfect. I used them a lot when building my shop, too.

Now if I could just find a battery-powered welder...

JKJ

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#15

Re: Welder...

John K Jordan

>>>You CAN use a automotive battery to weld...

I vaguely remember something about that now.

Stick welding with the battery, I assume. I wonder how you regulate the current.

I considered getting a generator capable of powering mig and tig (and plasma cutter) but it was too expensive.

JKJ

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#16

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Welder...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I don't know that there would be any simple way to regulate current--it would be more of a MacGyver-like approach in a pinch.

Jason

Re: Product Review-Lee Valley Goose-Neck Task light

#17

Re: Welder...

John K Jordan

Probably cleaner than thermite welding! Did you ever play with that? Exciting.

Fortunately I have a small wire welder I can plug into 110v for things that I can't move next to the shop, flux core wire so I don't have to drag a gas tank. The other machines work best on 50 amp circuits which is harder to come by away from the shop! The oxy-acetylene is fairly portable but I'm not as comfortable with it except for sheet metal.

JKJ