Yes, gauge is important to prevent nuisance trips. It won't affect the perceived power of the saw however - you won't be able to rip a thick piece of maple more easily with a heavier cord or an oversized, dedicated circuit.
Actually, no. With the lighter cord I couldn't rip heavy stuff at all. With the heavier wire I never had a problem,. There's watts, and then there's line losses.
Ok, I can see that if the cord is really light - 16/3 as you said? Its increasing the voltage drop across the cord+motor and drawing more current, which in turn means more heat to be radiated by the motor and less efficiency. I'm surprised it was noticeable, but ripping thick stuff does stress a motor.
At the time I had only one blade, a wonderful Systimatic combo. This was a 9" saw. I'm pretty sure that was a contributor to the problem, but it did go away when I upgraded to the 12-3 wire.
I use an old Unisaw regularly. It has one of the old 'bullet' motors, repulsion/induction style design. I think it is 1HP, judging from the label. There is no HP rating, just voltage and amp draw. I have a 3hp bullet motor on the shelf and have had for years. Bought it as I was sure the original wouldn't be satisfactory. Never installed it because in my use, mostly 4/4 stock with occasional use on 6/4, it works fine. Most stock is pine/fir, cherry or walnut
What is your power availability? 3 H.P. are normally 230 volt only, no 115 volt option. I'd think 1.75 H.P. could run on an adequate 115 volt supply. If your lights dim when you turn the saw on or rip, the circuit is not adequate for one example.
I have done a ton of woodworking with a Beaver saw that had a 3/4 hp motor, and it is absolutely fine for most stuff, they are 9 inch saws which would help to some extent. No question it may not cut all woods with alacrity, but for the home shop, I think most people have too much. I had a General 3hp, and it could easily kill you with kick back. The 3/4 hp is the original Sawstop, because I can win every fight with it when it wants to kick back a piece. The 3hp kicked me over some cherry, and very nearly finnished me. Sawstop does not stop kickback and while 3hp may be the norm in production shops that was not the case in an earlier time. I would probably buy the 1.75 as a hobbyist, or cabinetmaker, unless I just fed the autofeed all day.
Bingo, it is the blade most of the time. Though I am finding it harder and harder to find people who will sharpen square and know blades, at a price in the US should not be a problem. But what is also for sure is that when the 5hp decides to pick a fight, you will wish you were somewhere else.
Tom, I have a Made in the USA 1 hp Rockwell 9" Contractor's table saw with cast iron wings in my other smaller shop in the basement, and I luv the saw when it comes to space saving. It's about the size of todays job site saws, but built a lot better in my opinion.
I ended up with a 5 hp cabinet saw - because the difference in price between a 5 hp saw and the 3 hp saw was about $50 at that time.
My first saw was a 1 1/2 hp Sears Craftsman with cast iron wings - reasonable saw at that time (not the greatest fence). Took me 20 years to burn out the motor - but it eventually died.
As others have said - if you have a reasonable thin kerf blade, you can rip most anything.
In my opinion, here is where the 5 hp (or 3 hp) makes the difference.
If you are using a 40 tooth (or 50 tooth) combination blade that has a thicker kerf - the greater horsepower helps you rip hardwoods more easily. If you have a stacked dado blade and are cutting wide rabbets or dadoes, the greater horsepower helps you to cut the rabbets or dadoes more easily. More horsepower usually means quicker cutting.
If I am ripping a bunch of lumber in quick secession, I will use a rip blade - most of the time I leave the combination blade on the saw.