I was going to get a SawStop saw with a 1.75 HP motor for hobby woodworking, but then I saw that they come in sizes up to 7.5HP. I know I don't need 7.5HP, but the mere existence of a 7.5HP model makes me think that 1.75 is not enough and I should get the 3HP.
Am I nuts? Or will 1.75HP get bogged down?
What could anyone need 7.5 HP for? At first I thought it would let you use bigger blades, but all are limited to the same 10" blades and 8" dado blades.
I don't have a Sawstop and have never tried one of any size so I can't directly comment. I have Delta Contractors saw I bought in 1971. It came with a 1 1/2 horse power motor and I managed to kill it in about a year and a half. Soon after the warranty ran out. (I suspect the motor was less that the best quality.) I replaced it with a 2 hp Dayton and have been completely satisfied.
Part of the answer is what you intend to rip. If the majority of your work will be with stock less than two inches, the smaller motor should do nicely. I occasionally rip stuff that is as thick as my saw will reach, about 3 1/2". It does that well with some care. Reduced feed rate, sharp blade, Etc. If your plan is to rip 10/4 and 12/4 stock in long runs, the bigger saw would be better. Come to think of it, I often rip really deep cuts in two passes. Not a problem for the occasional piece, but a really PITA for a long run.
A thinner blade requires less horse power. I should have a thin high quality rip blade, but I don't. I bought a 1/8" rip blade to cut flat bottom slots as much as to rip. A sharp blade is always better. A thinner blade may be more prone to warping and wandering.
As Barry wrote, it all depends on what you are going to saw and how often. An underpowered saw can still, on occasion, be used for thick tough stock but it will mean very slow feed even with a sharp thin-kerf blade and it may mean more burning. I find that 3hp is good for my needs which occasionally includes some stock over 3" thick -- good thing too since that is the only size saw motor the Robland comes with.
I agree with Barry, I have a 1-1/2 Hp craftsman table saw that I've had since the mid 70's and it is still cutting just fine. I've made lots of furniture from hardwoods, but rarely rip anything over 3/4" thick. I used to use a thin kerf rip blade but when I replaced it last year I went with a full kerf Freud glue line rip blade and saw no difference in rip feed speed.
I have worked thousands of bd ft hardwood on a 1.5 HP Delta Unisaw and never longed for something larger. I would want a bigger motor if I ripped a lot of 8/4 stock but even for this operation the 1.5 is fine with the right rip blade ,...... few teeth, I think 8 but I am not home to count them.
I have had the 3 hp Sawstop for about a year now and I love it. With the 1/8" blade it cuts anything I throw at it like butter including, but not limited to, 8/4 purpleheart 6/4 hard maple 12/4 mahogany. Never considered the 7.5 hp thinking it would be overkill for my needs.
I upgraded from a 1980 Craftsman ? 1 hp ? and with a 3/32 blade could cut alot of wood but slowly and with lots of burn, especially cherry.
I had a 1.75 hp Powermatic Artisan contractor's saw for years and sometimes wished it had a more powerful motor. I trade it for a 3hp Unisaw and was totally satisfied with the 3hp saw. I bought a Sawstop several years ago and considered the 5hp option but decided 5hp was overkill and went with the 3hp model. I'm completely satisfied with it. Be aware that a 1.75hp motor on an older Unisaw is a different beast than the motors on modern saws. The old motors were capacitor-start induction motors which produced much more power and torque than modern electric motors.
As has been stated ~ it all depends on your application, type of blade / dado etc. and material you are intending to use. However, at the time of purchase I would consider the cost of the upgraded, more powerful motor. If the cost is not a significant issue, I certainly would go with a 3HP motor.
I do not believe there are any real downsides to a more powerful motor, and there are some advantages. The advantages include faster feed rates when ripping thick or dense material and the added power will allow you to use a "duller" blade longer before sharpening. I personally don't use the thin kerf blades as I have had some issues with the blades overheating and wandering in the cut (probably due to me feeding too fast).
A commercial user may opt for the 7 1/2 as the faster feed rate is fairly significant when ripping all day long, and the downtime between blade changes is also quite a bit less. This does increase profits for them but isn't really a consideration in a hobby shop.
I have owned and used everything from a 1/2 hp homemade table saw to my current 3 HP Unisaw. I have never seen any task I can't complete quickly with the 3 Hp, but do remember struggling with some of my older under powered saws.
I have been using a made in the USA Delta 1-1/2 hp Contractor's table saw with a Unifence for about 20 years, and don't see myself needing anything else. I think that a lot of people just plug these types of saws into just any 115V circuit that has other outlet or lights on it, and then complain about the power. They really need to be plugged into a appropriate sized dedicated outlet to get the full potential of the motor, plus I believe that you get more life out of the motor by doing so.
Plenty of advice given, so I will answer why the 7.5 horsepower question. If you make a living with a machine, or have an employee on it, you don't want to ever slow the feed rate. Also if you put a power feeder on it to rip 8/4 hard maple for an hour, you really need the horsepower.
If I were looking for a new table saw I would not consider anything under 3 HP,the reason is ,on a few occasions my 1.5HP contractor saw bogged down when I tried to cut 2" hard Maple /Ash, I finally managed to cut the wood after changing the blade to a new full kerf 24 T. ripping blade and cut ever so slowly to avoid tripping the breaker. a sharp thin kerf would have done a little better but the fact remains that that motor is too weak to cut any thick/hard wood no matter what blade is used.
How often do I cut 2" hardwood ? not often but I'd rather have the power and not need it than need it but not have it.
Matt, I sure can't add anything to the excellent advice you've already gotten. I would opt for either the 1.75 or 3 HP Sawstop but lean toward the 3 HP version with the full understanding that the 1.75 would do anything I need with the caveats that others have thrown in. Anything more, for the hobbyist, is way overkill. Full disclosure, I have a 3 HP TS but not the Sawstop as it was not available 16 years ago. If I was buying today, I would give the 3 HP Sawstop serious consideration. Jim
I am a hobby woodworker, mostly, and have had the Sawstop contractor saw with the 1.75 hp motor for 2-1/2 years. I have no idea what you'd use 7.5 hp for, other than a truly industrial, non-stop ripping application. I easily cut 2" maple, oak, walnut and ash. A recently acquired rip blade made it possible to absolutely breeze through wet PT dimension lumber. I don't have a dado blade, though that is next on the list.
This nine foot tall columbarium was built from solid 6/4 and 8/4 QSWO with a 1-3/4 hp contractor saw. For most purposes in a small furniture shop, 1-3/4 hp is sufficient, if you follow the advise the others have provided.
OTOH, if you are planning to cut wide, deep dados, the 1-3/4 hp SawStop Contractor's Saw requires an 8" dado stack, because SawStop doesn't make a brake for a 6" dado stack. I don't think 1-3/4 hp is enough for a wide 8" dado stack, and most saw and dado blade manufacturers agree with me. Therefore, you should go up to a 3 hp Pro SawStop to have enough power to cut wide dados, because the Contractor saw does not have a 3 hp option.
Matt, I don't have a Sawstop but I upgraded the motor on my tablesaw from 2hp, which was borderline, to 3 hp, which meets my needs. I work with very hard timbers in Western Australia.
What has not been mentioned is the power needs as the horse power increases. I am not sure what your situation is where you live. We use 240v for everything (where you use 110v). The tablesaw in 2 hp mode ran on a 10 amp plug. The 3 hp needs 15 amps. I have a Hammer 4400 bandsaw with a 4 hp motor, and it uses a 20 amp plug. I imagine that a 7.5 hp motor would use 3-phase power here. All the others are single phase.
1.75 was workable, but not fun. 3 hp - my current configuration - is a breeze. 5 hp, at a school, was a little smoother, but not a big deal.
So 3 is my personal sweet spot. I have 220, but not 3 phase.
I agree with what was said above about needing more for commercial work and the importance of a sharp, clean blade. I love Forrester blades, but they get dirty quickly and need cleaning often.
You're correct, the 7.5 hp SawStop is only available in 3 phase. Most power companies in the U.S. will not bring 3 phase power in to a residence, or if they do they will charge you a hefty installation fee.
I am not an expert in electric motors. But I have read a bit about them over the years. "Horsepower" is somewhat of a gimmick number and not a good indicator of a motor's true power. So not all 3hp motors have the same torque. So to judge the power of any saw, it takes a little more homework about the motor design to best understand the strength it has at the arbor.
Perhaps someone with more knowledge than I might better explain.
With universal motors (with brushes), yes, hp can be an inflated marketing gimmick. The ratings on induction motors, as used in table saws and other heavy machines, is much less so. Still, it is better to also look at the amperage the motor draws. Another performance number to be aware of is duty cycle. Some induction motors are designed to run all day and all night at maximum power output, while other, less robust motors would overheat and trip a breaker at that load, and are expected to be operated only intermittently.
I'm not a fan of SawStop, sorry. And as far as table saw classifications, Cabinet saws are Industrial grade, and Contractor's saws are Commercial grade. Both should be more then adequate for a home shop. It just depends on what you want to spend.
Electrically, the saw doesn't care what it's plugged into. If there is too much load on the circuit the breaker will trip, but up until that point, the saw will run the same as if its on a dedicated circuit.
I agree though, with what you've seen - people getting a 1.5 HP saw and thinking its underpowered. I suspect it has a lot to do with not choosing the right blade - using a 50 tooth combo blade to cut 8/4 maple for example. You can get away with it with a 5 HP 3 phase saw, but not a 1.5 HP single phase. Using a 24 tooth ripping blade instead would make all the difference in the world however
Well, HP is only a gimmick number because of deceptive marketing and the consumers' poor understanding of physics. It did used to mean something.
What William notes is still true to some degree, not because there is a great difference between motor types, but because most of the induction motor market has historically been industrial and commercial rather than consumer. Businesses often have an engineer or two either in house or on a contract to help with buying decisions when it comes to stuff like motors for a plant. There's little point to playing fast and loose with the physics in this case, whereas there is a great incentive to do so when the buyer is a guy in the isle at Home Depot.
One thing that really can make a difference is the gauge and length of the power cord to the saw. On my old saw with a 1.5 hp Baldor, I used to trip the breaker half the time until someone asked me what extension cord I was using. Turns out it was a 16-3, 25 ft long. I made a new one from 12-3 stranded copper, 12 ft and never had another problem.