Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

High contractor quotes?

Posts

Re: High contractor quotes?

#26

Yeah well,...

John in NM

I still estimate lower by 20% at $150/hour.... If it costs $100/sq ft to build a small, very slightly elevated platform, why doesn't it cost $300/sq ft to build a simple house? I'm not talking about a custom, one off house, I'm talking about the equivalent of a slightly elevated platform, no rails, one step, no covering.

All I can say is that if that market bears such a rate (and perhaps it does), it's ripe for some innovation. Absolutely ridiculous.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#27

Actually, I have been one too...

John in NM

As I said, I never suffered from offering people a square deal, it was what made my business grow. If you can't offer a fair price, as in a price that encourages people to contract with you, then you are in the wrong business - period. No one owes you a living, you go out and make it.

Its very easy to disparage those who say that the bid price is not worth the product delivered. It is much more difficult to MAKE that product worth the price bid. I'll give you one guess which gets my respect!

EDIT:

And the point of all this was not to tear down those contractors offering what I consider a high bid - it was to check if I was out to lunch on my estimate. Your recent reply makes me think I was right. It was enlightening, thank you.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#28

Re: Yeah well,...

TomD

One reason would be if the small house isn't custom. There are guys who have models, have it worked out so there is 2 feet of 2x6 left over when the job is done. Any custom job is custom.

I am building a deck overlooking our lake, took me forever to get the footings in, turned out the berm was a pile of rocks. Required hours of hand excavation. I had to tie into the building in various places. Turned out the original guy put the shingles up with about 6 tacks each (hardened, rusty, don't bend). Then thought better of that plan and face nailed them with common nails, that shortened my life a few months. You just never know. The rest of it is the market and the cost of living in Reno I would imagine.

But yeah, those prices are heart stopping.


Re: High contractor quotes?

#29

Re: Who?

Barry Irby

The show is Flipping Vegas. Scott and Amy are married. He is the contractor and she the designer. Perhaps they just don't appeal to my Southern Sensibilities but they are an obnoxious couple. I drives around in a very expensive car, it may be a quarter of a million for all I know, and screams and yells at the Hispanic crews to work cheaper and faster but produce superlative work. He always wants to go low budget and Amy comes along and goes upscale on the finishes. they generally do low to middle market houses but recently did a high end house that sold for several million. Had a real struggle getting a Level 5 drywall job.

I don't see it often, but it may also be something of a history lesson on Vegas. The market crashed and they have survived doing flips on low/middle houses but Vegas is recovering so they may be able to move upscale.

The personal interactions on the show make it like watching a train wreck.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#30

Sounds awful

John in NM

Guess it sells the ad time though :D

My wife watches one with a couple doing remodels in TX, but it doesn't really sound like that one, much less obnoxious.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#31

Thanks to all

John in NM

Even though areas of this thread ventured into disagreements (and apologies to Mark and Dick, I was kinda grouchy last night), it has all been useful.

Clearly there is some factor I don't understand, as clearly that market will bear that price that I find fairly steep. On the other hand, steep prices for simple jobs are opportunities for others who think they can do the work more cheaply. I think I'll tell my SIL that if the price is a real problem, to look for someone eager to get the job - there is bound to be such a contractor in that kind of market. Whether they can also do said job is another question.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#32

No problem John, I'm grouchy most of the time

Dick Coers

If you give your SIL some shopping advice, I suggest you tell her to make sure and get customer references when shopping by price.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#33

Re: How fast do you drive?

Jason in OC

It's an hour and twenty by airplane. It's 450-500 miles by stagecoach, depending on the route.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#34

Re: No problem John, I'm grouchy most of the time

John in NM

Always wise advice :D