Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

High contractor quotes?

Posts

High contractor quotes?

#1

High contractor quotes?

John in NM

My sister in law wants to build a small deck (10x11) about a foot off the ground, no covering, no railings, just the deck and a step with the decking material being trex.

She got two quotes, both of which seem crazy high to me - $10k and $11k. To my way of thinking this should run about half that.

Is my guesstimating just that far out of date?

Re: High contractor quotes?

#2

Re: High contractor quotes?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

We are just finishing a deck rehab/extension (tomorrow). We added about 7' to a 6' section and it ends up being about 11' wide. So the final dimension is maybe 11'x13'. Okay. There's a railing around the whole thing, a 4x6 landing and two sets of stairs. We used TimberTech. Posts, concrete piers, decking, joists, railing all come to somewhat more than $5k. I haven't kept track very closely, but my wife knows the exact amount. Anyway, with the exception of concrete work($900) we did all the work.

Given how simple you describe your sister's deck to be, I'd say the bids are too high. Bear in mind that Trex is expensive stuff, maybe three times the cost of cedar.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#3

Re: High contractor quotes?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Three contractors were visiting a tourist attraction on the same day. One was

from New York, another from Texas, and the third from Florida.

At the end of the tour, the guide asked them what they did for a living. When

they all replied that they were contractors the guard said, "Hey, we need one

of the rear fences redone. Why don't you guys take a look at it and give me a

bid?" So to the back fence they all went.

First to step up was the Florida contractor. He took out his tape measure and pencil, did some measuring and said, "Well I figure the job will run about

$900. $400 for materials, $400 for my crew, and $100 profit for me."

Next was the Texas contractor. He also took out his tape measure and pencil, did some quick figuring and said, "Looks like I can do this job for $700. $300 for materials, $300 for my crew, and $100 profit for me."

Without so much as moving, the New York contractor said, "$2,700."

The guide, incredulous, looked at him and said, "You didn't even measure like the other guys! How did you come up with such a high figure?"

"Easy," the New Yorker said. "$1,000 for me, $1,000 for you, and we hire the guy from Texas.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#4

Re: High contractor quotes?

Keith Newton

John, in my state, just the deck material is around $3.50 per sq ft, so less than $400 for that much area of material. However it comes in 16' lengths so if they didn't use any end-butts, it might take twice that.

So their bid is $100 per sq ft, and sounds like a lot to me.

Where does she live?

Re: High contractor quotes?

#5

Reno


Re: High contractor quotes?

#6

Re: High contractor quotes?

don stephan

Here, good contractors can't keep up with requests this year so prices high.

There might be peculiarities of your sister's job that increase costs. Perhaps they perceived this to be a "problem" job . . .

Or perhaps they each saw an opportunity to make a killing . . .

Re: High contractor quotes?

#7

Re: High contractor quotes?

Nat Robison

I think that moderate houses around me get built for about $100 sq/ft so that price for a deck seems high.

I just resurfaced my 12' x "15' deck with an Azek composite this summer. I bought about half of the material for about. Other half came free from my brother.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#8

Re: High contractor quotes?

Nat Robison

Meant to say half of the Azek cost about $650. It was a discontinued item so was a bit cheaper.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#9

Re: High contractor quotes?

Dick Coers

No idea about local codes, contractor license requirements, and access to the building site. No idea how busy contractors are in that area. Two quotes within 10% of each other is close enough to say that is the cost. Quotes are free, get another. If it's in the same price range, that's the cost no matter how we feel about it.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#10

Re: High contractor quotes?

jessecloud

Does the contractor have to pull a permit with city or county? Is there a home owner's association that has to approve. Our HOA has a bad rep (probably well deserved) for being anal about stuff, requiring lots of documentation, and slowing things down. Some contractors refuse to work here and I suspect others add a lot to their bid to cover their time dealing with the HOA.

Your sister might ask one of the bidders if there was anything that concerned him about the job or the specs and see if it could be made easier and cheaper for him.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#11

Re: High contractor quotes?

Mark Nowicki

Tell us how you arrived at the $5000.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#12

Re: High contractor quotes?

Chuck Bjorgen

We had a 10 x 16 cedar deck built last year. No footings or other concrete work done. It was built slightly above ground to match the level of the entryways. Supported on blocks. $2,400.00. The crew of four guys came in and had it completed in three hours. The hardest part of this project was demolishing the old deck that had lasted about 30 plus years. My son did all that work. Twin Cities area of Minnesota.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#13

$2,600.00....

Mark Nowicki

$2000 for me, $600 for you, provided that:

- Bruce does all the work

- Nat Robinson hunts for a a bargain on half of the required materials, his brother supplies the other half free

- Chuck Bjorgen's son works for free (footings, we don't need no stinking footings...)

Everybody and everything shows up a Reno at the same time.

Your $600 is for three hours of supervision (taking a picture every 15 minutes, and sending them to my cell phone)

I will be "supervising" the job, if any problems arise I can be at the job site in about 90 minutes (travel time from poolside at the Bellagio to Reno)

Write up the contract, Mark.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#14

How far is Reno from Vagas?

Barry Irby

Maybe you could get Amy and Scott to flip that deck for you. Scott drives up in some $80,000 car and yells at the Hispanic crew, beats them down and demands it be done by morning and Amy provides the design and changes everything Scott started.

I'd be thrilled locally to build it for S10K, but I am in central Virginia.

I noticed something interesting during the recent recession. When the bottom fell out about half the contractors went out of business. Many became little more than handyman services. You would think that with things being desperately slow they would have charged less. It seemed they charged a lot more. The logic seemed to be that they used have several small jobs a day or a few medium sized ones a week. Now its more like one a day or week, so thy have to charge twice as much.

I would investigate shy this one is so much and get another bid.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#15

Re: How far is Reno from Vagas?

Mark Nowicki

One hour and twenty minutes.

Heck, Barry, if Amy is there, I will work for free...... :D

The ones that stayed in business were charging $10K a deck to begin with.

You haven't priced anything new in this century, have you? :)

To give Scott credit, all his work is to code and legal.

BTW, the car is not $80K, it is the price of the tires.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#16

Re: High contractor quotes?

Chuck Bjorgen

I forgot I had taken an in-progress photo. Here's what I got for my money.


Re: High contractor quotes?

#17

Re: How far is Reno from Vagas?

Keith Newton

How far? Yea, I was thinking I could drive out there and back and still make pretty good for 75% of those bids.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#18

Re: How far is Reno from Vagas?

Barry Irby

I have built several deck in this century. Two about 10 by 12 and one 12 by 24'. They included railings and steps and did not cost $10K. Maybe they would have if I were married to an Amy and drove that car. My truck is probably not worth what his tires cost.

When the Code was first passed the only enforcement was they could arrest you for violating the law (Code was Law). I know a builder who was arrested. Locally, meeting the Code means doing just enough to avoid being arrested. Like most hyperbole, there's just enough truth in that to make it funny.

Still be pretty happy to build that deck for $10K. Is there active gun fire in the hood?

Re: High contractor quotes?

#19

Re: High contractor quotes?

John in NM

Materials plus ~32 manhours plus 25% for slop. Quick and dirty, its just a ballpark to see if I think they are a ripoff (they are IMHO).

Any pair of guys who can't bang out a stupid simple, small deck in two days should jump in a lake rather than try to contract.

My guess is that the market in that town is hot and they see this lady as a cash cow. No respect for those guys. I never yet lost giving people a fair deal.

For what its worth, I built a house for less than $100/sq foot. Ten years ago, granted, but seriously, that much for something with no roof, no utilities, no bath or kitchen? I'm appalled - with two p's :D

Re: High contractor quotes?

#20

Who?

John in NM

Guess I'm not watching enough TV :D

Re: High contractor quotes?

#21

Re: High contractor quotes?

Mark Nowicki

In my area (Island of Montreal) a company sells 8 x 12 garden sheds, installed,for about $1300 (15.5% sales taxes included).

My brother just got an estimate to paint three fire escapes (4 story, 30" wide, times 3) All together about 160 steps, center post, railing; $22,000.

He feels the same way you do.

I guess the contractors in Reno have adopted the hotel pricing model; double or triple your prices if you can.

As a semi-retired contractor (I do fire alarms now) can't really same I blame them.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#22

Re: How far is Reno from Vagas?

Mark Nowicki

I did our deck two years ago, 12 x 24, cedar with a 12 x 12 trellis, hidden fasteners, five steps, custom sized aluminium railings.

The materials cost me about $3K. I would not contract a similar deck for less than $15K.

Occasionally, I manage to take my eyes of Amy, and I notice the budget.

I can't believe how low the prices are.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#23

The sheds seem reasonable....

John in NM

I don't know enough about painting to make a guess as to the fire escapes.

How come those sheds seem reasonable to me but I'm coming in at 0.5x for reasonable on a deck?

I figured labor at $50/manhour, which was the going rate when I did this kind of work for a shop. Even tripling that I could come in 20% less than the low bid, and figure $3k for materials.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#24

Re: The sheds seem reasonable....

Mark Nowicki

When I was a window and door sub I would make about $110/hr, about $140 when working with a helper.

I am sure the General Contractor marked that up, plus everything else by about 50%.

I think you are coming up short because you are not marking up the material and the $50 labour rate is actually about a third what it should be.

If you triple the labor rate and mark up the material by 40% you will get pretty close to the asking prices.

The irony is that companies that do quality work and use higher quality materials actually mark up less that companies slapping in cheap stuff.

Windows is the industry I am familiar with and the markup on the cheap plastic stuff is about 80% vs 45% for a quality made to measure aluminium product.

Re: High contractor quotes?

#25

I'm sure there is a forum somewhere

Dick Coers

I bet there is a forum somewhere, where people complain about the incredibly high cost of custom woodworking. They probably start the discussion with, "My sister got this kitchen from IKEA............" " Or my cousin got the bedroom set from Furniture Row..........." It's easy to criticize a small businessman, until you are one!