Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

dog hole layout

Posts

dog hole layout

#1

dog hole layout

lee

Just purchased a gramercy hold fast, and I am now pondering my dog hole layout(3/4" holes) for my bench.

Never used this method of clamping, so before I riddle my bench with holes I am looking for a little bit of feedback on layout.

many thanks

Lee

Re: dog hole layout

#2

Re: dog hole layout

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Lee

The best place for dog holes (I assume that you will be drilling these) is where you need them. Really :)

Work on your bench a little longer before you decide where to drill, and become aware of what needs to be clamped. That will help you decide what is important for you.

For example, I have dog holes along the far edge of the bench ...


The purpose here is to plane across the bench ...


The Moxon dovetail vise is positioned against a square dog (constructed at the time of building the bench), and clamped down by two holdfasts at the rear (round dog holes)..


Driilling for round dog holes is vastly easier with a brace than a drill. The brace has more torque! (My bench top is 3 1/2" of European Oak) ...


12" Millers Falls and 3/4" bit ..


A few more ideas here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/IDeclareThisBenchFinished.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: dog hole layout

#3

Re: dog hole layout

William Duffield

Chris Schwarz has a lot of experience building and writing about benches and offers well thought out advise in several places. Ask Google for help finding them with the search terms:

schwarz dog hole location

I have found through many experiments that a lot more dog holes than most experts recommend are all used, and for many purposes other than hold fasts and dogs. For example, I drop tools and work lights into them.

They are easy to install, and unless you go way overboard shouldn't significantly compromise the strength or mass of your workbench. In general, I wouldn't put them on a closer than 3" square grid. Also look under the bench before you drill any of them, and make sure they don't interfere with vise hardware, cabinets and bench legs. It is not amusing to set a holdfast and then have to move it when you discover a vise won't open or close.

Re: dog hole layout

#4

Re: dog hole layout

AZ in Colorado Springs

My bench is 26" wide by 7' long. I have two rows of dog holes. One row is 4" from the back edge, and the other row is 7-1/2" from the front edge. I also have a planing stop 13" from the right end. When figuring the spacing between the holes, consider the reach of your holdfasts. This roubo style bench, which I built two years ago, is the best tool in my kit.

Re: dog hole layout

#5

Re: dog hole layout

Hank Knight

When I built my bench 10 years ago, I put a single row of dog holes 10" apart and far enough back that my holdfasts, the Veritas ones with the threaded knob to adjust the pressure, reached to about 1 1/2" from the front edge of my bench. I subsequently bought two Grammercy holdfasts and this spacing works well for them too. I thought I would probably want more, but I didn't want to make swiss cheese out of my bench top by drilling holes willy nilly anywhere I thought one might be handy. Recently, after 10 years of use, I decided to add another row of holes toward the back oqf my bench top. I repeated the pattern 10" apart and far enough from the back edge that my hold fasts reach close to the back edge. I staggered them so they alternate with the front dog holes. It was a good addition and I've used the new holes a good bit. I'm glad I waited to drill them. Chris Schwartz may be right that you find uses for whatever dog holes you have, but I'm opposed to just drilling a bunch of holes thinking you'll use them someday. I have relatively few dog holes in my bench and use the ones I have. I'm perfectly happy with he layout and don't think I'll need more.

Re: dog hole layout

#6

Re: dog hole layout

Matt Robinette

I built the Benchcrafted Roubo split top a few years ago and followed their recommended schedule. If I were to drill the holes again I would pay closer attention to being plumb with the bit when drilling. I would have gotten a longer bit that I could align with one of the jigs or fixtures recommended for use when drilling the holes. I used a 6 in bit but most think that a longer bit is easier to line up plumb.

Re: dog hole layout

#7

Re: Drilling Plumb Holes

Hank Knight

I worried about drilling my dog holes plumb. I solved the problem by starting the holes with a 3/4" up-cut router bit in a plunge router fixed to a simple jig and clamped to th bench top, and finished with a 3/4" brad point bit in a hand held drill. The router drilled a clean, plumb hole that served as a guide to keep the brad point bit plumb. The jig was nothing more than a piece of masonite with an edge guide at one end to insure that the holes were a consistent distance from the edge of bench top. I attached the router to the other end of the jig with machine screws through the base plate and clamped the jig to the bench top when I got it lined up with the hole location. I clamped a sacrificial board to the bottom of the bench top where the brad point bit would exit to prevent blowout. I had read warnings about the up-cut spiral bit "self-feeding" violently when it bit into the wood. That was the initial reason for the jig clamped to the bench top to keep the router steady and in place, but the bit never self-fed or misbehaved. The whole procedure went smoothly and produced perfectly plumb dog holes. Finally, I chamfered the dog holes with this large countersink from Lee Valley to prevent the holdfasts from splintering the edges:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/44j2101s1.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: dog hole layout

#8

Re: Drilling Plumb Holes

Barry Irby

You can also chamfer the holes with a bearing guided round over or chamfer bit in the router if you have one and you won't have to buy the giant counter sink. (Sorry Lee Valley)

Wonder if a 3/4" reduced shank drill bit would work if it would fit in your router? Would it feed too fast?

Re: dog hole layout

#9

Re: Drilling Plumb Holes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As I mentioned earlier. use a brace and bit, if you have one. Preferably 12" throw. I would be able to bore the complete dog hole with this combination before you can do so with a router or power drill! I found a router just burns the wood, and a power dill lacks the torque of a brace.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: dog hole layout

#10

Trivial to get good holes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Bore a hole in something 2" thick with the drill press. clamp this guide to the bench and use it to guide the portable drill.

It is so easy to drill a hole with this alignment block that I would recommend to not drill very many holes to begin. Then drill them where you need them as you need them.