How about another way using no dado blades -- just one table saw blade?
Use runners again. But this time set up the cut like a very shallow cove cut. Need to clamp a fence on the far side of blade and run the work piece with runners multiple times across the blade at an angle. Do it so that the cuts just barely bite into the runners.
The resulting face of the board will have a kind of scalloped or wash board look, but it will register flat against the planner. And the planner can do the rest.
I believe it is a safer cut, especially in that the blade doesn't repeatedly "come out", as someone said in the last thread. I didn't like that either.
I know some will say, "Look, I already told you: just use the planner with the runners."
O.K. but suppose the board is wider than your planner. You could do it this way, attach a plunge router to a wide base, and smooth out the washboard that way.
I wish I had thought of this method forty years ago when I made my workbench. I had the hard maple top glued up with the boards all on edge , and I had to go through a big deal making a large router sled to get it flat.
Your stated method, of putting the fence on the far side of the blade for cove cutting is absolutely wrong. The blade is coming toward you, so the fence must be positioned on the near side of the blade.
As you surmise, a dado blade would be totally unnecessary, as all the cutting is done with the outside tips of the blade only. But, whatever you use, the lateral forces aren't good for the tips of the blade, and those tips leave deep v-grooves all along the cove, as you are aware if you've done this type of cutting before. I used to use a round nose molding cutter to avoid those grooves when cove cutting.
I guess I can understand your affection for this possible method of flattening a board, but if I need to flatten something wider than my jointer or planer (note that "planer" has only one "n" -- sorry, there goes my editor instinct again), I take it over to my buddy's shop and run it through his machines, all the better if he happens to have a wide-belt sander. I have a nice short visit and come home with a perfectly flattened and surfaced board that doesn't then require a lot of hand planing or other work to finish the job --- and there are no jigs, fixtures, trial runs, learning curves or safety concerns to worry about either. But, certainly, if you just want to prove the concept, have at it, and let us know the verdict.
Or, you could buy a tool meant to do the job you are trying to do.
I've had more friends mangle their hands on the TS using dado blades than any other tool in the shop. All of those passes needed to do the job you are needing to do, while holding the wood down hard to the table while you feed is just setting yourself up for a bad accident. When talking to those victims later, they said I have been doing this all their life without ever having an accident, before they had their accident.
Now, earlier I recommended that you get a Makita 1806b like the one I've owned since the late seventies, which prorated out would be ~$10 per year. It is about the only tool I've ever seen that gets 5 stars on every review. But if that is too spendy for you, here is a link to another that looks pretty good for a lot less, with double sided carbide 7" blades.
If you started out using hand planes like I suspect most of us did, you can use a power-plane the same way, but much faster.
Forgive me if this was already mentioned but I didn't see it in a quick read-through.
For about $25, I can have anything up to 24" wide jointed, planed, and/or wide-belt sanded at the local millworks where I buy wood. Maybe that's not an option for you but if it is, it avoids a whole lot of aggravation, test runs, etc.
I try to remind myself that their tools and machines are bigger, better, and well-equipped to do anything I need.
If you have a planer why not use that to flatten your boards? You can make a sled out of a piece of MDF or particle board. Place it on a flat surface and position your warped board on it using shims and wedges glued in place with CA glue, be sure to add a cleat at the end of the board to keep it from being pushed off the sled. Now run it through your planer like a normal board. Once flat on one side remove it from your sled and flip it over to flatten the other side.
think that you're going to a lot of mental effort trying to figure out the most dangerous way to get a board flat with the possibility of getting yourself hurt in the process.
I know several people who don't have a planer or jointer. They buy their material s4s or have it done by someone who has the tools. I, for example, have run many yards of wood through my P-Max for friends.
You may want to re-read what I posted. This "third attempt" uses only a single blade -- no dado blades. It's no more dangerous than cutting a cove with a table saw. ( Except I mistakenly said to put the fence on the wrong side. sorry.)
Thanks for the corrections -- including spelling. I must confess that I haven't tried ANY of these methods. but I really do believe I would have done this "third attempt" approach, as I said, way back when I mad my first bench.
Well, Nat, my reply to your reply is that, like my grandchildren, I want to do it myself. Isn't that the whole idea for us woodworkers and woodturners? Otherwise, one approach is to just outright purchase the stuff you are making!
I was really insulted once because I purchased about $1000 worth of rough beautiful instrument- grade mahogany lumber form a wood supply guy to make my son and daughter-in-law a dinning room table. It was new-house present.
I made the mistake of flatting and planning the boards to thickness mostly from ONE side of the boards. So they warped because of inherent moisture problems. When I called the guy for help he said, in a very condescending tone, " Do you want me to make the table for you?" It really pissed off!
I worked a bit harder and made a really fine dinning room table that anyone would be proud of. Screw him!
no. BTDT [but not impressed with the cut quality that took way more work than it was worth]
Making a "washboard" out of something with 10-20 passes? Yeah, I have absolutely no interest in going that route. Especially when a sled through the planer or the drum sander is sooooo much easier, faster, and waaaay safer.
Eliot....I admire your thinking. At least I admire the fact that you are thinking. Part of the enjoyment of wood working is the thinking it takes to get the project done. I spend a lot of time figuring out how to get from an idea to the finished project. I get caught up in "my own thinking" Trying to solve the problems with the tools I have and the skills I have. Thinking in circles. Sometimes I have to break out and buy a tool (grin) or take a class, Or borrow the use of somebodies tools or pay for a service.
I am currently learning to sharpen much better. My chisels are amazingly better, but I suspect not as good as some here. Next is to make friends with my hand planes. Sigh.
Keep thinking. There is very little that has not been thought of. Keep checking here. The vast body of knowledge and experience available to you here is worth a fortune. (If you decide to taper table legs with a RAS, tell me and I will send you a picture of my right thumb.) You have to right every time to stay safe.
eliot feldmqn -- 6/21/2016, 1:45 pm: "You may want to re-read what I posted. The idea is to flatten a board that's wider than you planer."
eliot feldman -- 6/21/2016, 4:45 am (original post): "The resulting face of the board will have a kind of scalloped or wash board look, but it will register flat against the planner. And the planner can do the rest."
Please take a look at my post that I put in right after the one you have quoted. After posting this so-called "third attempt", I realized that I was going to get hammered again by people saying, essentially, what you said -- why not just use runners an put it through the planer?
So the answer was that the board may be wider than the planer. OK you say, but now, since it's too wide for the planer, how are you going to get rid of the washboard stuff. The answer is to use a plunge router with a planning bit and attach the router to a fairly wide base. The base of the router will register flat against the washboard as it plans off the ridges.
Fair enough. But , as I have said elsewhere, I remember years ago making my first workbench , which had a wide glue-up of hard maple boards for the top. I went through the trouble of making a large router sled to flatten it. And that didn't work all that well. I wish I had thought of this washboard idea then. I really would have used it. I would gladly, at that time, taken the time to do it this way.
As for taking it to someone else -- another hobbyist or a pro-- I gave an answer to someone else here: why do any of this stuff? Just purchase the cabinet, table, or whatever outright!
By the way, I think I mentioned it you once, my son-in-law is named Mark Mandel. He lives in CT. Whenever I see one of your posts, I think of him.
Thank you for a thoughtful reply. Your views and mine are identical.
Talking about buying new tools and sharpening chisels, I did spring for one of those expensive horizontal flat disk deals with several disks of increasingly fine abrasive. It's hard to beat. Still the best way is with stones, diamond films, etc. The hand tool site doesn't stop talking about it.
You plunge router will be less and less stable as you take more cuts, the wider the plunge base the more difficult it will be to hold the cut plane perfectly registered with the prior cut's surface. Even with a wide bit, say 1-1/2" diameter you'll be trading one set of scratches and ridges of another.
Having planed slab wood with a router, I can state that there's a lot of work left to do to get an acceptable flat and clear surface. I used a belt sander fixed in a sanding frame that will index the platen to the surrounding surface followed by a card scraper. Now, of course, I can run it through the P-Max and get it dead flat up to about 40" wide.
You just need to go ahead and do a video showing how you can turn a wide twisted / warped board into a nice smooth flat piece of finished lumber, with nothing but your table saw, and creative imagination.
I for one would like to see what you can do. There has been more than enough talk / speculation about it. Just do it, then show us what you learned, and how great it worked.
My kids accuse me of "McGivering" stuff all the time and are sometimes amazed at how I do things and what I do it with. OTOH, One of them said he feared that one day he would break a leg and I would show and have only a banana and a grape and try to figure out a way to fix the leg anyway.
Do be careful. Shop accidents can be life changing. A friend of a friend was dentist and hobbyist wood worker. He somehow managed to cut off all four fingers on one hand with a chop saw. His wife rushed him to the trauma center. In their has and panic, they forgot to take the fingers. He is now a car salesman and divorced.
I have made the mistake of working when tired twice. One time ended up with a block of wood off the lathe to the forehead. (27 stitches) Another time I saw my hand as if disembodied, reaching out to stop the TS blade. That time I just left the shop.
I read your last post at my email site, but I can't seem to find it on Woodcentral.
You seem a bit fed up with me. But your last post was somewhat unfair; I never said it could be done with "nothing but a table saw". My best shot. I think, is to make repeated very shallow cove cuts at the TS and then use a plunge router with a planning bit and a wide base to smooth off the washboard. I really do wish I had thought of that many years ago when I made my first bench.
As for making a video, which I understand is just your way of needling me, I've never even been able to get pictures onto this site. I was always stymied by getting the number of bits down to some acceptable level.
If I ever figured out how to do videos, it would be to show some of my methods for turning thin hollow vessels through a small hole.
Frankly, there have been sufficient responses about how unsafe these methods are, that I will drop the whole thing. Why post these in the first place? I like to keep thinking. How about you?
Following the table saw thing with the router looks like you're merely complicating the router/planer jig thing with an unnecessary procedure (that being the table saw cuts). The router/planer will get your piece flat in a single operation, and if you can't use a planer as follow up, flipping the board and doing the opposite side with the router jig will give you two flat parallel surfaces, provided, of course, that your reference surface is flat.
The whole table saw thing becomes surplus work in this.