Vacuum Veneering with Polyurethane
don stephan
Anyone know of instructional text or video on using polyurethane glue for vacuum veneering?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Vacuum Veneering with Polyurethane
don stephan
Anyone know of instructional text or video on using polyurethane glue for vacuum veneering?
Re: Vacuum Veneering with Polyurethane
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
No, but why would it be any different?
What is the attraction for this adhesive? Other than its service in wet environment I can't see any advantage for it. Additionally, it has not been proven over long time for furniture construction.
Re: Vacuum Veneering with Polyurethane
Alan Young
My preference is Unibond-No Bleed through

I also like Titebond Liquid Hide glue but I have trouble controlling the correct amount with out having bleed through- Still the bleed through can be scraped or sanded off and it is easily repairable

Nope, but....
Grant in Iowa
I have used Dap Weldwood plastic resin glue for some time in building waterskis and other bentwood laminations with great success. If you are looking for waterproof, this is your product. And you can mix up just what you need for a given project and store the rest for years in a cool place.
Using PE glue would have me fearing that it might damage the bag, grow like a blob, or something weird. If I were thinking of using it, I'd simply do some tests, and be sure to protect your vacuum bag from that nasty foaming action.
What is leading you to want to use PE glue?
Regards,
Grant in Iowa
Maybe more accurately, a video on how to clean
Dick Coers
the inside of the bag! Man that would make a mess!
We used West System epoxy in a bag now and then...
John in NM
With a layer of plastic wrap between the piece and the bag!
Here are some quick instructions
Craig Thibodeau
Hi Don,
I have an article coming out in Fine Woodworking in about 6 months detailing how to use Poly glues for a variety of things. That doesn't help you now so I'll give you the short version for veneering since I use it for nearly all of my veneer work.
It's not overly complex to use and using too much is less of a problem that using too little. Too much will just cause more bleed through onto the face of the veneer but it's easily sanded off. I tend to use Home Depot adhesive rollers to get an even layer of glue over the entire surface, there shouldn't be puddles and it shouldn't look dry. Mist your veneer with a bit of water and lay it onto the glue, less water than you might think.
Make sure you have a layer of plastic between the veneer and the caul or platen as poly glues will stick to just about anything. I'd recommend using at least 1/4" thick mdf cauls over the veneer faces to even out pressure from the vacuum. Give it at least 2 hours in the bag to cure and leave any seams taped overnight. You can continue working on the panels and do any edging or trimming after the 2 hours though. I've found that if you get excessive bleed though scraping most of it off is faster than sanding.
Hope this helps,
Craig
Re: Here are some quick instructions
don stephan
Thanks for the information Craig. I'm guessing that the water mist goes on the glue side of the veneer, that will be placed against the rolled out layer of polyurethane on the substrate, and that the entire veneer surface needs a light misting, not just a bit of water in one place to start a chain reaction. Might be worth a year subscription to make sure I get the article. You are the 2nd person this week to say polyurethane has become their most common adhesive for vacuum veneering.
Re: Here are some quick instructions
Craig Thibodeau
Don, yes the water goes on the glue side of the veneer and a very light mist over the whole face would be ideal.
Poly glues have a strong learning curve and that makes them a hard sell to most woodworkers used to using yellow glue. With some practice it can become another resource for gluing though.
Craig
Can you share a picture
Dick Coers
A picture of a piece using polyurethane adhesive in a vacuum bag? I'd like to see what the squeeze out and foaming looks like. Also, with all the issues I've read about just using water based adhesive with veneer and panel movement, spritzing water sure seems counter productive.
Re: Can you share a picture
Craig Thibodeau
Hi Dick,
I don't have a picture handy but next time I glue something up I can shoot one. The water spritz is very minimal and only happens after the glue is spread and right before the veneer goes in the bag so there isn't much time for movement of the veneer.
Craig
I would like to hear .....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
....about where it has any advantage of convention adhesives.
Re: I would like to hear .....
Craig Thibodeau
Hi Bill,
It has a few that I consider make it a good choice for many things. It is a slippery glue with no initial tack so joints that would tend to seize while being assembled go together easier. It is essentially heat and moisture proof when cured. It also doesn't introduce a noticeable amount of moisture to veneer glueups.
Disadvantages are cost, it's quite expensive. And cleanup can be a pain if you don't work clean. Also has a distinct learning curve to get good quality glue ups.
Like many things in the shop once you get used to working with certain things in certain ways it can be hard to introduce change. I use a whole variety of glues for different things and intermix them for some tasks as needed, poly just adds one more option for me.
Craig
how to clean it up, etc.
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It is waterproof. I have used it for a joint subjected to periodic submersion and it has held well (reinforced with screws). I think it has a use in outdoor application. I need more convincing that it has any place in indoor application.
If you haven't, how to clean it up deserves mention. As received, it is a polymer and readily soluble in solvents like acetone. Curing involves crosslinking. Like all polymers, once crosslinked it is insoluble in everything know to man. So if it is desirable to clean it from hands, etc. it needs to be done promptly and acetone is a good choice.
This class of chemicals can cause sensitization in some individuals. It is less a risk when the chemical has already been polymerized like in this adhesive. Never-the-less I am wary about getting it on me.
Direction frequently involve adding water. I have never added water when using it. There is plenty of water in wood, likely around 10% by weight. Maybe if used in Arizona.....
Re: how to clean it up, etc.
Craig Thibodeau
My method of cleanup is to wipe my hands with baby wipes from Costco if I happen to get any on my hands, that removes most of the glue if done quickly. I prefer not to wipe my hands with shop solvents if it can be avoided. Cleanup on the workpiece is best done once the glue has cured, chisels and sandpaper work well at removing the foam residue.
I'm not trying to convince anyone to use poly glues, just answering someones question as I have some experience using it. Glues like many things are sometimes chosen for personal preference rather than hard facts. Personally I'll never use Unibond again and I don't like using epoxy for commercial veneer but it works great with resawn veneer.
Craig
It doesn't introduce moisture?
Dick Coers
"It also doesn't introduce a noticeable amount of moisture to veneer glues."
How does that work since it was mentioned that you have to spritz the veneer with water?
Re: It doesn't introduce moisture?
TomD
I probably wouldn't use it, but the sprtz would be less than the moisture of many wood glues the only app I am familiar with is bansawn veneers bagged together for boats. Fills saw marks, sets from wood moisture.
Re: how to clean it up, etc.
TomD
Skin was the thinking at one time. Sttrongly so. Don't know current thinking.
Re: how to clean it up, etc.
TomD
Diphenylmethan-4,4'-diiosocyanate sounds bad. 
and indeed it is
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"Diphenylmethan-4,4'-diiosocyanate sounds bad." I have little reluctance to "bathe and breathe" most of the chemicals encountered in woodworking but this one deserves some caution. Isocyanates are highly reactive with about everything, which therefore includes body parts. Sometimes the reaction of chemicals with body parts leads to unhealthy results. Hence, be cautions using chemicals that are highly reactive.
You don't have to spritz it...
John in NM
In my experience urethane glues will set without the additional moisture, it just takes a lot longer. My experience is entirely in clamped setups however, not vacuum bagging.
I agree on lack of need for added water
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Relative to the chemistry going on there is a ton of water available in the wood to accomplish crosslinking.
In general desirable crosslinking will occur more completely at slower rates, that is without added water. At fast rates the molecules can not move to favorable positions for reaction before the polymer viscosity increases too much to allow this diffusion. Hence, while a water spritz will make the cure faster, (speculation to follow) it may make it less complete with the result that the cured adhesive will be less tough.
I would like to have the opportunity to discuss this point with a Gorilla chemist and if I do I will report the result.
Hmmmm... that is a good point...
John in NM
I have gotten away from using urethane glue in any case, but I'll definitely file that one away in case I start using it again.
If one were trying to keep the hours down on a vacuum pump, I could see it being worth adding some water, but probably not otherwise. What's a few more hours clamping time vs tougher glue?
Re: Quite dangerous
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Can't say how dangerous in the limited exposure a woodworker would get in a normal once in a blue moon project, but I worked with a compound which incorporated Isocyanates in the formulation, it was a coating used to "paint" printed circuit boards used in a high moisture location.
I built a special booth with negative air pressure and the operator coating the boards with an airless gun was protected with air breathing apparatus.
We had people several yards away that complained of sensitivity to the material even with the special booth and all the other precautions we took. We spent many tens of thousands of dollars to find an acceptable substitute coating that would pass the moisture testing for the product.
Like Bill, I normally do not have any problem working with chemicals, solvents etc., however I do tend to stay away from Isocyanates. To me there is not enough "special" properties to warrant the use.
The best varnish no longer available....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Years ago one could buy "moisture cured" polyurethane varnish for floors. It cured so hard that dog toe nails would not dent it. Even on stairs it held up for years. I have it on a dining table that looks good as new decades later. But the isocyanate crosslinking chemicals we judged too harmful to allow in a varnish and it disappeared from the market as a wood floor finish.