Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

I want to float an idea.....

Posts

I want to float an idea.....

#1

I want to float an idea.....

roger lance

I live in Michigan.....virtually surrounded by lakes, rivers, ponds, etc etc.....and every year dozens of kids and adults drown.

The drowning hasn't started yet as the water is still cold.....but soon things will warm and people will be lost......and this is happening in a state where just about every community has a modern school with pools.

Why aren't kids being taught how to float ??.....I learned to swim and float at a very young age (there was no pool in my schools).....and I'd practice relaxing and floating every time we'd go swimming.....which was often as that's what kids having fun in Michigan do.

It disturbs me that so many drown each year.....when knowing how to float prevents that.....give a child a gift.....teach them to float.....its knowledge that lasts a lifetime.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#2

Re: I want to float an idea.....

John C Lucas

There is a technique i learned in life saving called survival floating. Basically you float face down like a limp jelly fish. The you cross your arms slowly then push down and out while exhaling and lift your head. Take a breath and put your head back down and relax. Then start the whole process over. Just to see if it works several of us did that for 24 hours in the pool. It was amazing how easy it is. Like you i think it should be taught to every one. The other thing that drives me crazy. If you cant swim and know it, why are you in or near the water without a life jacket. Its that simple.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#3

Its not the water, it's the ethanol

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Chemical substances are involved in many drowning cases.

BTW, I never could float.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#4

Re: Its not the water, it's the ethanol

Jerry Gibbs

Like Bill, I could never float. I live near Roger and had a lot of swimming classes. I am amazed by survival stories of long floating times.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#5

Re: Its not the water, it's the ethanol

John K Jordan

I could float fine, even very young. My brother, however, could not - he could sink and walk on the bottom if he wanted to, even with a full breath. Staying afloat required movements of arms and perhaps legs.

Now if you could devise a tiny wearable, inflatable flotation device that wasn't bulky like a life vest maybe more people would wear them. Some might have to be disguised as an emergency cold beer.

JKJ

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#6

Re: Can't float either

Larry Rupprecht

Amazing! It's been 50 years since my beginning swimming class in college. We were first taught the floating technique as described here. It didn't work for me and I have never heard of one other person who also sank quickly as I did. The instructor suggested I had no body fat...6'2" and 175 lbs....or I was some freak. Now I know there are at least three of us freaks!

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#7

Make that Four


Re: I want to float an idea.....

#8

Re: Gain a little (or lot) of weight!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

When I was in my late teens /early twenties, I would take a deep breath and sink to the bottom of the deep end of the pool (12 foot) and set cross legged for up to three minutes or so.

I was 6' 3" then and weighed slightly less than 150#.

Flash forward 35 ~ 40 years and about 100 LBS. and I could lay on my back in still water and take a nap. Haven't swam for several years due to arthritis, replacement hips and laziness

but probably still can float as the weight is still with me!

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#9

Alan Young

Re: I want to float an idea.....

Alan Young

Never been a "Good" swimmer- dog paddling or back stroke are my methods. As far as floating-I was taught the front float as a kid and that worked- for a while but in latter life find floating on my back to be more practical- ie I can float longer if I have to---I never go out in a boat with out wearing a life jacket- even an expert swimmer can get his/her head twapped in an accident and no swimming skills can save you if you're unconscious...

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#10

There are , at least, two elements.....

roger lance

in learning to float: physical aspects and mental state.

Just like any ball with a hollow air filled core (tennis, football, basketball) or battleship.....any human being will float.....humans are filled with hollow spaces that keep a person overall less dense than water. Some may float higher than others.....some lower to the water surface.....but they will float.

Its that mental side that keeps some from floating.....as I said I'd practice relaxing in the water......float on my back where it was easy to breath.....and if there was relatively calm water, you could almost nap......certainly rest and recoup so you could swim on.

I filled my lungs also and swam under water for distance and length of time underwater.....but when I wanted to float, I didn't have to fill my lungs and hold my breath.....i was breathing normally but would be totally relaxed..... a little foot and hand movement sometimes.....but that was about it.

The mental side of this is probably the most difficult to develop.....but once a kid (or adult) is convinced that they can float, there will be fewer people lost.

Alcohol and drugs were mentioned as causes......I'd say cold water is more of a cause up here.....that and panic. I was a very good swimmer but no match for cold water.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#11

Re: There are , at least, two elements.....

Henry W

Roger

You wrote: "Just like any ball with a hollow air filled core (tennis, football, basketball) or battleship.....any human being will float.....humans are filled with hollow spaces that keep a person overall less dense than water. Some may float higher than others.....some lower in the water surface.....but they will float"

Maybe on average, statistically speaking, humans float (are overall less dense than water). That is not universal. Yes I can "float" - meaning with a little effort I can keep myself at the surface of the water. Without that effort however, I do not float (if you disregard the last 20 lbs that is).

(20 lbs ago) I could fill my lungs with air, and then without any movement promptly sink to the bottom of a 12-14 foot deep pool. Even now I can fill my lungs and just be buoyant, and then release air from my lungs and begin to sink.

A quick google search regarding human density provided these values (i.e. the first numbers I saw) :

- Muscle density is 1.06 g/ml,

- Fat density is (about) 0.9 g/ml, and

- Adult bone density 1.2 g/mL.

And of course I recall from my science classes that the density of water is 1.0 g/mL.

Examining these values it would seem to me that a muscular person with low fat content could clearly overall be more dense than water and not float. That 'calculation' does NOT account for the hollow spaces you described.

Do you really think athletes with extremely muscular physiques (say LeBron James?) actually float?

Lots of my assumptions there - and I can't say I know anything about basic anatomy or physiology (i.e. your statement that there are lots of hollow spaces that keep a person less dense than water).

I just can't understand or explain why I sink so readily and consistently (or used to) when I am 'supposed to be able to float."

Henry

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#12

Re: There are , at least, two elements.....

William Duffield

I'm somewhere near neutral buoyancy. With lungs full of air, I float; with lungs empty, I sink. It takes less air now than it used to.

When I was in elementary school, all the kids in town got free swimming lessons sponsored by the Y, and a lot of the more athletic and older kids took a course in life guarding. Even if you know how to swim, and try to rescue someone who is drowning, you can drown too because in their panic, they will grab hold of you and pull you under. You need to learn how to break the hold, turn them around and pull them face up to shallow water. There are many other life saving skills you learn in these classes.

We lived in a poor town–no pool; we learned to swim in the lake, with alligators, and thunderstorms most every afternoon.

We made sure my son learned to swim, and get himself out of a pool by himself, before he could walk.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#13

Re: There are , at least, two elements.....

roger lance

Henry.....I'm not an expert in this area.....but, I do know that i was able to float with complete ease......and was also able to sink underwater and stay there with very little effort.

I was at peace in the water.....relaxed.....it felt natural to be in the water. I think the real key to being able to float is mostly mental. You may have a greater body density than other people.....and therefore, you might have to move your arms and feet more than others to maintain yourself in a float.....maybe, you might have to float on your face instead of your back or even in the "deadman" position to successfully float.....I'm sure there is variation here.

But, I'd be very doubtful that there are large numbers of people who have a body density greater than water.....I think that would be a very rare person.....certainly, extremely rare in a young child.....and even that person with high body density could be taught techniques that would keep them breathing on the surface of the water with low exertion to allow them to rest and recover so they might swim.

Sadly, we had a drowning last month on an inland lake when a man, who was out boating with his family, went into the water to rescue his son who fell overboard....he rescued the child and then went under. He did not swim well and did not know how to float.

I'd hate to take the position that some people just can't float.....and not have this basic skill learned.....when it can make such a difference.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#14

Re: I want to float an idea.....

philip f Duffy

Good thoughts re floating. We Navy guys have to learn or die trying, in all our training for time at sea. But recently, a neighbor of mine lost his 18yr old son, a full ride scholarship waiting, because he and his pals tried to swim a mere 50 yards out to a sand bar in our nearby river. This lad could not pass thru the river current and died. Many people still mourn his passing- - If only he knew how to float!! Philip

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#15

Different forms of "floating"......

roger lance

This discussion is causing me to remember some things we would practice while in the water as a means of floating or drown proofing.

One technique was to be in the water in a vertical position.....and hold my breath while I sank about a foot below the surface.....wait until I needed to breath again.....then a few small hand movements would bring my head above water.....take a breath.....and then sink below the surface.....and repeat the sequence over and over. You had to remain calm and quiet in your motions knowing that you would just be below the surface and could get a breath when needed.

We also saw some TV show on drown proofing where a person in 20-30 feet of water could sink vertically to the bottom and then use his feet/legs to push off the bottom and propel themselves to the surface and in a forward direction as well to get air and get closer to shallower water.....kind of looks like the teeth of a saw.....we practiced that also just like we'd practice how to make a double play after watching a pro game.

Again, techniques that require calm.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#16

Re: Different forms of "floating"......

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Your first technique I learned in swim class in college. That helped me pass the swim test in boot camp at MCRD.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#17

Re: Can't float either

Keith Newton

I've never been able to float without effort. I not only sank to the bottom, I could lay flat with a full breath. You'd think I'd at least be upright, but I must have had a heavy thick bone higher up, like my head-bone.

Even in salt water I wouldn't float. I recall a trip bareboating in BVI, some of my boat mates wanted to scuba dive, but hadn't brought enough lead to get down without a big struggle. They couldn't believe how easily I could go down and just cruise along the bottom, or side of the cliffs for about 1 ~ 2 minutes between breaths. Finally a commercial dive boat came along, then they bought or borrowed ballast belts.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#18

Re: I want to float an idea.....

John McGaw

I was taught the same method when I was maybe six years old at the YMCA but they called it the "turtle float" back in 1954. We were taught a similar technique in my minimal USAF survival courses in the 60s or 70s. It indeed works wonders, uses little energy, and except in very cold water can keep you going for a very long time.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#19

Re: There are , at least, two elements.....

roger lance

Henry.....you've made me do a little digging to get some king of figure on overall human density compared to water and I'm not coming up with much except a Wikipedia reference under the subject "Human Swimming" which states on average that overall human density is 0.98 that of water.....and then goes on talking about variable factors like fat content and water salinity that affect this ratio.

It would be interesting to read a real scientific study on floatation in regards to physical fitness. I'm thinking that really fit individuals do have very low fat percentages and more muscle.....but, they also generally have better developed breathing, lung capacity, circulation, etc.....and possibly the ratio of these factors to muscle mass might be offsetting to their overall density.

Interesting....but I don't know.....I just hope someone reading this takes a grandkid to the shallow end of the family pool and makes a fun game out of learning to float.

Re: I want to float an idea.....

#20

yes to floating, and simming lessons for ALL

Henry W

Roger

My parents are Dutch immigrants - yep the low countries. Every 100 meters or so there is another canal or a river, or so it seems. And NO, neither of them can swim! They made certain that their kids could - swimming lessons every summer, sometimes 2 sessions back to back. Most of the times I enjoyed it, sometimes not (never could do the kick of breast stroke).

I will never forget the first aid (CPR type) training, the 'drown proofing' (you described it in an earlier post - float, or sink to bottom, get to surface for more air, repeat cycle - all with minimal effort to conserve energy). And 'floating' (never my strong suit, even as a kid) - for 10-15 minutes at a time...

Everyone should have the opportunity to learn to swim (and float!).

Now I count swimming as my primary form of exercise - but there is no deep end on this pool so I can't really sink, or float, much.

Henry