Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

I'm working on a column base,

Posts

I'm working on a column base,

#1

I'm working on a column base,

Keith Newton

For one of the older homes a few blocks up my street. The columns are 12" diameter at the bottom, and my turned base will be about 5.25" Tall, and about 17.5" D at the bottom layer.

I'm gluing up 3 layers, with 6 sides mitered in each level, that will be glued together like a layered cake.

Everybody knows that a frame with mitered corners will self destruct if there are swings in the MC of the wood, and the wider the boards, the more extreme it will be. If the wood gains moisture, the swelling across the grain will open the toe, or outside corners of the miter, then if it goes below the starting point, the heel of the miter will open. I plan to really soak them inside and out with CEPS after turning, to help stabilize them, i hope.

When I glue the 3 layers together, I will be brick-laying, or staggering the joints, so the joints don't all line up in each layer. I was just pondering this, and wondering if it is better to only shift the joints about and inch from each other, or brake the joints about midway in the length of the next layer.

I'm inclined to think less it will be better for the glue joints between layers, if the joints are only slightly offset. This will keep the grain alignment closer between the layers, which will cut down on the shearing effect on the glueline, if or when the wood moves, than shifting the miters half the length of it's neighbor.

I don't recall ever reading anything where this was discussed before, and would be interested what others do, if I have missed catching it as I was learning my craft. What say ye?

Re: I'm working on a column base,

#2

Re: Column Base

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I anticipate that you want all long grain on the outside surfaces. The footers I've dealt with in my area are not pie-constructs if they are used on the exterior for the very reason you speak about. Here the layers are either single pieces or glue-ups of 2 or 3 boards which are then set anywhere from 0° to 90° in rotation in the stack and are then screwed/nailed in the center area which allows the natural expansion to occur in each layer independently.

Will you be staining/varnishing rather than painting? Paint will hide the end grain.

Your description is essentially that of a segmented turning. The difference being that you want the thing to be solid rather than hollow. I suspect that if you can use ring construction rather than stacked "pies" you can reduce the expansion factor to insignificant amounts. Depends of course on the column load. Most large columns here use a solid beam (4x4 or 6x6) in the center with the "show" as a stave-constructed shell.

Re: I'm working on a column base,

#3

Ellis Walentine

I wouldn't worry

Ellis Walentine

It's not clear to me how you are constructing these bases. I would be mitering up, say, 6" wide boards for the three six-sided rings. By the time you bandsaw and turn the rings, the miters will only be a few inches long, so I'm not thinking they're going to want to open appreciably, especially if you seal the daylights out of them with epoxy.

Ellis

Re: I'm working on a column base,

#4

Re: I'm working on a column base,

Paul in NJ

Keith,

Why brick lay at all. Say you turned a block with the wood grain all aligned in the same direction. Would anyone notice it going slightly oval with the moisture swing. Look at white oak for instance with an eight percent moisture swing. Quarter sawn will move 3/16" and flat sawn twice that. In reality with paint and maybe a epoxy seal coat, the moisture swing inside the wood would be much less. Also you can probably pick another wood that has a better t/r ratio.

Another thought. Have you thought of acrylic vacuum infusion?

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: I'm working on a column base,

#5

Thanks Mark, Ellis and Paul,

Keith Newton

I've glued up the miters halves together yesterday. The one I'm replacing Mark and Paul was solid layers which were solid layers at 90º from pressure treated pine. It was the newest one on the house, so not worth wasting my time repeating that method.

I've used Spanish Cedar for my buildup, and will be turning out the middle as much as I can, yet leave plenty to support the porch roof, since this is load bearing, with no interior support. And yes, Ellis, you are probably right, at least Im hoping by super sealing it up, I shouldn't have any worry, with this great wood.

Re: I'm working on a column base,

#6

Ellis Walentine

Re: Thanks Mark, Ellis and Paul,

Ellis Walentine

Your biggest concern is that the cedar will expand and open up the miters on the outside where they will be seen. This is going to be hard to counteract if you're starting with KD wood, because nothing, not even epoxy, will protect the wood totally from moisture transfer. The good news is that if your miters net out at a minimal length, the expansion isn't going to open the joints enough to matter. I would try to come up with some kind of ventilation scheme, though, to try and keep these plinths out of constant contact with moisture. And, I'd seriously consider letting the wood come to a reasonably moist equilibrium MC before your final join. Shrinkage isn't a problem, expansion is.

Ellis

Re: I'm working on a column base,

#7

Re: I'm working on a column base,

Matt Robinette

Have you looked at a composite base. Unless it is a must to be historically correct there are plenty of bases out there that are resistant to rot and a lot less labor intensive. It can sometimes be cheaper to change all the blocks with new composite rather then spending many hours making just one if they need to match.