Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

QSWO better left to power tools

Posts

QSWO better left to power tools

#1

QSWO better left to power tools

Matt Robinette

I hate to admit it but QSWO kicks my butt when trying to use hand tools to tame the devil wood I have to admit the quality is #1 maybe #2 but all of the common fixes failed soak in alcohol, high angle frog 55*,toothing plane, it got to the point where it became unworkable with hand tools. It may have been the kiln drying process that hardened the wood but if I were to drink brown ale before trying to get this wood conform to my needs I may have had to pull a #4 plane with toothing blade along with a #80 scraper from where it became in bedded into the wall because of the tear out. Any one else feel my pain?

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#2

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

Bill White

ME TOO!

Had a piece of ribbon white oak that just not surface with anything I tried.

Finally took it to a shop with a wide belt sander to get it to the dimension I needed.

Beautiful wood, but a bear to work.

Bill

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#3

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Back in the day when wood had to be worked with hand tools you didn't see much furniture made from quartered white oak.....or oak of any kind for that matter. When tools, techniques and materials from some age are employed one can be sure that success is only limited by one's ability. Problems can arise when mixing these elements from various times. Then woodworking becomes a research project to see if a tool from some age works with materials and techniques from other ages.

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#4

Im not sure I would soak with alcohol

Keith Newton

All you need is one spark to get a fire going, and in a well lit room, the flame can be harder to see.

The loss of water in wood, going from green or saturated, down to 6-8% doubles its hardness, so if you are going to use anything, why not just use water?

You may already know this, but the grain in those ray cells is perpendicular to the normal cells, and as you are probably finding, not too well bonded to neighboring cells. Since most QS lumber will not be 100% from edge to edge, there will likely be some rift toward the edges, so inspect the rings on the end grain, and skew your plane, so it is favorable to the Rays, and not against it, causing that grain to lift.

In the absence of a high-angle plane, you can grind/hone a face bevel on your blade to achieve the desired angle, or even flipping the knifes in a cutter head can take care of the problem. This does require a lot more power, so you probably won't want to leave your planer set up this way. This will cause crushing on soft woods.

And of course, sharpness is crucial regardless of cutting angles.

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#5

Worse than the fire hazard

Dick Coers

Is now the high percentage of methanol in denatured alcohol. The government killed a lot of alcoholics during prohibition from poisoning DNA, and I guess they still don't want to take a chance that you would drink a cheap source of alcohol! Not saying you will drink it, but you are absorbing that poison through your skin.

From one MSDS;

Poison. This product contains methanol. Methanol is metabolized to formaldehyde and formic acid. These metabolites may cause metabolic acidosis, visual disturbances and blindness. Since metabolism is required for these toxic symptoms, their onset may be delayed from 6 to 30 hours following ingestion. Ethanol competes for the same metabolic pathway and has been used as an antidote. Methanol is effectively removed by hemodialysis. Call your local poison control center for further instructions.

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#6

Re: Im not sure I would soak with alcohol

Matt Robinette

Thanks for the advice but the only thing sparking in the shop was my temper because I just paid stupid tax again,see I just finished a kitchen table made from QSWO and it also just like this top for a entertainment console I am making had tear out right in the middle. I guess to chase the grain pattern would like doing doughnuts in your car. But this time I thought I had it wooped a super sharp blade with hair thin mouth and high angle frog. ERRRRR wrong answer. I even tried my #80 scraper with a freshly sharpened blade,it bounced across he top. I could take it to someone with a wide belt sander and be done with it but no it seems the simplest tool will have to do. A hand scraper,slow and plodding and the top will look maybe a little more hand made than I had hoped for and extend the time in the shop. I will surely be working up a sweat then a serious thirst will set in that will need quenching. I see a silver lining I guess it is not all a bad thing with more shop time needed win! and certainly more beer double win!. :)

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#7

Getting Besotted

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Alcohol, polluted or otherwise, ain't the answer.

A good drum sander, or a wide-belt, Now THAT's an answer to figgered (or gnarly criss-grained) wood.

Did a QSWO dining table for my son. P-Max was an essential stage. Scraps were not saved.

It's well after 5 here on the East Coast . . . . . . .

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#8

Re: Im not sure I would soak with alcohol

William Duffield

Did you try a very closely set chip breaker?

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#9

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

TomD

During the hand tool period they made a lot of very big boats, out of white oak. The British Brown oak is similar, and it is popular in furniture.

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#10

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

Hank Knight

Several years ago my daughter and I built a couple of Chinese three-legged stools together. I post d several photos of our father-daughter project here. I gave her the choice of any wood in my stash. She chose white oak. I groaned but didn't try to talk her out of it. The project called for a lot of hand work and I expected it to totally kick our collective butts, but it didn't. Not to say the hand work was easy, but we got it done with surprisingly few problems. I didn't tell her how hard oak was to work until after we finished, so she never batted an eye. She hollowed the seats with a carving gouge, pared the seat mortises

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Katherine/image_zpsc626384c.jpg.html][/URL]

and hand planed the leg tapers.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Katherine/image_zpsd5efa463.jpg.html][/URL]

I was proud of her, and she was pretty proud of herself.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Katherine/image_zps5f193718.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: QSWO better left to power tools

#11

Re: Im not sure I would soak with alcohol

Bob Lang

That would be my suggestion as well.

Bob Lang