Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

decks

Posts

decks

#1

decks

Bruce, a MN Galoot

we're considering adding a deck onto our house, a split-entry type. The back door is about 5 ft off the ground and used to lead to a deck, but we built a sunroom on top of it.

Anyway, there are too many choices now. The decks we've built before have all been cedar. And refinishing them has been a major PITA. So are the composites worth the extra expense? Is there a clear winner among the composites? Should we stick with redwood/cedar?

Any information would be helpful. Thanks.

Re: decks

#2

Re: decks

Ruler2112

I've no experience with decks, but built steps for my back porch out of the grey solid composite decking from HD. It is completely awesome and well worth the expense IMO. 10 years later, the steps look the same as when I built them. Didn't like the idea of the hollow-core stuff from other places and have never used it, so cannot comment on it.

Re: decks

#3

Re: decks

Barry Irby

I covered my front deck with Cedar colored decking from Home Depot. I put down a Welcome mat. Turned out it was slick on the back. About tore a leg off in the wishbone pose on the way out. One foot shot out from under me and the other one went somewhere else. Be careful with slick on slick.

Also, the decking has span limits. For example, it is suppose to be supported on 16" centers. If you turn the boards to a 45 degree angle the joists need to be on 12" centers.

Re: decks

#4

Re: decks

ChuckInND

I built a deck for a friend of mine quite a few years ago ( ten or more ) using Trex decking, Trex railing posts, Trex hand rail, and powder coated spindles. He hasn't had to do anything to it since, and it still looks great.

Re: decks

#5

Re: decks

Bill Howatt

This house has had 2 wooden decks, one spruce and one cedar. The life-span was not really that different between the two. Problem with the cedar one (I didn't live here when the spruce one was present) was nails driven through the top of the boards into the joists which trapped water and caused rot. Redoing the staining was a job.

I put on an addition which modified the deck shape and I used Trex. It is probably close to 10 years old now and apart from the dark brown color fading a bit it is still like new - no cracks and splits.

I spray it with bleach once or twice a year typically and rinse it off. In the winter I shovel the snow off with a plastic snow shovel.

I could have gone with 16" joist centers but for very little extra cost went with 12". One deck is very low to the ground so I used stainless, trim-head screws which I screwed in without a pilot hole and then hammered the raised composite back over the head which effectively hides it although you can see subtle bumps when it is wet.

When I bought the Trex there were few other options in composite around here but that has changed now but I would still go with a solid product. Yes, it is not cheap to purchase but I think the life will more than compensate for the initial cost.

If you don't like the thought of composite, have a look at Ipe which is a popular wood for longevity (apparently).

Bill

Re: decks

#6

Re: decks

roger lance

Just had my deck pressure washed.....this is a wood deck made with pressure treated stock.....and then stained the deck with Sherwin Williams Cedar Tone stain.

Its been two years between washings and staining.....so, this is a fairly frequent maintenance procedure.

As I get older, the less maintenance that must be done, the better. Were I to build another house, I'd want to use maintenance free materials wherever possible and affordable.

Re: decks

#7

Re: decks

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I resurfaced our two decks with Veranda composite decking from Home Depot. It looks as good as the day it was done 10 years ago. There are no visible fasteners. Once a year I wash it with a dawn, vinegar, baking soda and water mixture and then pressure wash it to rinse and clean. Yes you have to have 16" centers in your framing. The composite doesn't splinter and isn't any more slippery than wood decking in our cold winters (NW PA).

Lee

Re: decks

#8

Re: decks

walta

If this project requires a permit and inspections, be aware most of the codes have changed.

Often the best plan is to make the deck self supporting with footing near the house. As putting any load on the home in a compliant way will be attached to the floor joists 18 inches deep into the home.

As for deck maintenance my plan is pressure treated wood no paint, no stain, no sealer let the wood turn gray and replace the wood when it rots in 20 years.

Re: decks

#9

Question

Don Goodwin

Are the composite materials hot on the feet? Several years ago, we stayed at a cabin in the backwaters of Norris Lake in TN and the dock was a composite material that about burned our feet off. I am going to be re-building my deck on the south side of our house in central Indiana and had crossed Trex and its competitors off of my list because of that bad experience. Should I re-think that and consider composite? The idea of no maintenance is appealing.

Re: decks

#10

brick

DizD

Sounds like a project similar to what I'm working on now - had a deck off screen porch (about 4' above grade) and it needs replacing and I'm going to tear it out and go to a patio at ground level and use brick pavers. After looking at the use the deck had (or didn't have) a patio makes sense for me and the brick is ultimate in low maintenance. My brick guy says it's also easy to make an elevated masonry floor if you wanted to consider that.

Re: decks

#11

Re: Question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Heat is a consideration, according to everything I've read. Composites can get uncomfortably hot.

Re: decks

#12

Re: brick

Bruce, a MN Galoot

We were thinking about a tile surface deck, but there is no adhesive that will stand up to the heat/cold cycles in MN, from -30F to +100F. The deck will be about five feet off the ground. I'd prefer a patio, but with increasingly bad knees we are reluctant to add steps to our leisure time.

Re: decks

#13

Yes

Ray Thompson

I have both Trex and Timbertech(front and rear) and they both get hot to walk on in Central Indiana. In addition the squirrels love Timbertech and have made the railing unsafe in a couple of places.

Ray

Re: decks

#14

Re: Yes

Don Goodwin

Thanks for the info. I'll keep composites off of my list for my deck replacement.

Re: decks

#15

Bart Goldberg

Re: decks

Bart Goldberg

I had my Trex Transcends deck installed in September of 2011. It still looks amazing. I have not had any issues with it and would recommend it.

Bart

Re: decks

#16

Re: decks in MN

richard Long

I have three decks at my house in MN. All have composite decking and all look great. One has been there for at least 7 years. The other two are just under 2 years old. I have not noticed a the decking getting hot in the summer sun or at least not any hotter than the original wood decking on the older deck. I replaced the original wood decking after it became a splinter hazard for my grand kids.

I used the hidden fasteners and they have worked great. No nails to pound in every year and no screws to tighten.

I got a building permit for the two newer desks as they are attached to the house, but the building inspector told me if I have not attached them to the house I did not need a permit or inspections.

Just make sure your footings go deep enough, at least 42".

Re: decks

#17

Re: Temperature, Centers

Ruler2112

I think it depends on the color of the composite. I just went outside with bare feet & the concrete and light grey composite decking felt about the same temperature.

Sorry - should have added to my first reply that I used 12" centers. With how it flexes when picking it up, I didn't want to risk it deforming.

Re: decks

#18

Re: decks

Jay Lombardo

I have 2 composite decks, one using the grey stuff from HD around the pool. It has held up for the past 9 years beautifully, no maintenance at all. 3 years ago I tore up a 16 x 20 cedar deck that was horrible, rot, splinters, stainless screws popping, just a disaster. I extended the deck to 16 x 40 using Fiberon composite. It is fantastic, no splinters, no screws showing, no staining, still looks like the very day I installed it. Well worth the extra expense. One way to save money on the install is to use a fastening system from Camo. the hidden fasteners from Fiberon would have been roughly $700 for a deck that big. I really liked the Camo system and it only ran about $200. 16" on center required and you have to allow for the boards to expand LENGTHWISE not across the width like we are used to. Blows my mind to see the gap between 2 20' boards expand and contract by 1/4" from the cool of the morning to the heat of the afternoon.