Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Dark Patches in Cherry

Posts

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#26

methylene chloride=danger

Dick Coers

No recommendation of using methylene chloride should go without health warnings. Please follow all warnings and protect yourself! Also note, it will not lift deeply penetrated dye/stain.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#27

Re: methylene chloride=danger

Brian Roberts

Indeed!

Methylene chloride can actually induce a heart attack in those with heart issues!

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#28

I remain puzzzled

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

John,

there is some fundamental problem you need to fix that isn't anything that has been suggested yet. If you have the patience to provide the data to understand this problem someone can fix it.

The pictures didn't look like the wood had been stained, which was why I was fooled into thinking the sapwood had staining from mold. Where's the color?

If this was ordinary cherry, ordinarily sanded and stained, with ordinary pigment stain, the wood would be more colored than it is, and vastly more uniformly colored. There is some fundamental problem in some step of the finishing that prevented most of the wood from taking up stain. What is being called "blotching" is not what I would be concerned with until I figured out why the wood was not staining.

As far as blotching is concerned, I stain most everything I make, especially cherry. I don't use a conditioner. I believe what often is referred to as blotching is the result of inadequate sanding.

Properly sanded, stained cherry will show subdued differences in stain take up as the grain changes direction. For walnut and maple we try to enhance these differences, applaud them, and give them the attractive name of "figure". The same can be said for cherry. Reserve blotching for cases resulting from poor sanding.



Shown is a cherry chest of drawers meticulously sanded and stained with pigment stain to bring out the figure. For a uniform color spray NGR stain and the figure will largely disappear.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#29

Stained then sanded

John in NM

If you've not seen it before, that is exactly what wood that blotches looks like after having been stained (fairly darkly in this case) and then sanded down for refinishing.

Seen it often when trying to color match a finish to another existing piece - something customers always want and something that is fairly tricky to get right on the first go at it.

The solution, if John hasn't completely abandoned this thread yet, is to use a moderate stain or dye to minimize the visual impact of that darker stuff in the pores. Personally, I don't think its worth it, live and learn and make a new panel.

This sort of problem is why I typically use dyes rather than stains (as in pigment stains), though I'll admit I don't use them on cherry. I do use them on maple sometimes, usually as a thinned BLO carrier with some acetone to get the dye to mix with the oil. Seems to work well and is more predictable than the other way's I've stained maple.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#30

Bill...

Brian Roberts

You are absolutely correct.

"Blotching" can occur with most any species of wood....depending on how it's cut and then how it is prepped for finish.

The "'blotching" which occurs in figured woods happens for the exact same reason that it happens in plain old pine.

Stain is more readily absorbed by end grain then face grain.

The undulation of the grain that gives maple that desired "curly" or "fiddleback" figure is simply a repeating pattern of end grain and face grain.

We go to some lengths to make that figured grain "pop" in some woods and disappear in others.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#31

I misunderstood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Somewhere along the line I thought this pieces had been re-stained as part of refinishing. If it is going to be stained, and its sanded well, a challenge after 60 grit, I would expect the stain that shows in the picture will get blended away.

More likely there are still the remains of 60 grit scratches lurking ready to sop up lots of stain.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#32

Lurking scratches...

John in NM

Those are a problem - but wiping it down with mineral spirits or alcohol usually reveals them with close inspection. Water also works of course.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#33

Possible correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"We go to some lengths to make that figured grain "pop" in some woods and disappear in others. " Leave me out of the "we" when it comes to cherry.

My point is that I don't try to make differential grain staining disappear in cherry. I go to great lengths to ensure I don't get blotching from imperfect sanding. I embrace the enhancement of the inherent figure when it is there to enhance......no different than what many do in walnut, etc. I never understood treating cherry any different than the other woods we stain to enhance the grain.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#34

Re: Possible correction

Brian Roberts

Yeah....I was referring to pine when I spoke of trying to eliminate "blotching".

And...no amount of sanding will prevent it in most pine.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#35

Re: Question

Hank Knight

How does a hand planed surface differ from a well sanded surface with respect to absorption of stain and resulting "blotching"?

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#36

A world of difference

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The surface preparation and the staining, or not, must be considered together. I stain most everything I make so I have a lot of experience with staining. I used a pigment stain, homemade as of the past few years- mineral pigment in oil with a bit of drier.

I can not control the stain take-up on a hand planed surface. Additionally, the planing defects that are invisible before staining become a defect after staining.

My sanding procedure must burnish the wood surface for it becomes easier to control the take-up of stain. By comparison staining a hand planed surface is like applying stain to a sponge.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#37

Re: A world of difference

Hank Knight

Bill,

I'm not surprised by your response. A sharp plane severs the wood fibers cleanly and leaves them open to absorb stain/finish without obstruction through capillary action. Sanding abrades the surface and leaves the fibers ragged and filled with debris (on a microscopic level), so absorption is not as free as with a planed surface.

I'm puzzled, however, by your comment about burnishing the surface. I've read a fair amount recently about final sanding before the stain or finish is applied. The consensus seems to be that finish sanding beyoud 220 is not necessary and is, in fact, counterproductive because the finer grits "burnush the surface." Your post indicates that your objective is to burnish the surface before applying stain. What is your final sandpaper grit? Is there a way to control the absorption of stain by varying the degree of burnishing. This a new concept for me, so I am probably out in left field with my understanding of your post. If I am, set me straight.

FWIW, I seldom stain. When I do, I use analine dye added to either a filler, or to a preliminary coat of shellac, rather than a true stain. I have zero experience with the pigment stains you use. I admire your results, however, so I'd like to understand how you achieve them.

Hank

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#38

Re: A world of difference

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You asked a lot of questions....

1. I sand to 180, and occasionally lightly to 220 on a fine grained wood like cherry. The "burnishing" is speculative. Whatever, meticulously sanding at each grit until the surface is completely uniform in luster at each grit leaves me with a surface that is easily stained "uniformly". I put uniformly in quotes to allow for the fact that grain variation results in differential stain uptake. I don't get "blotches" from torn grain.

2. I apply stain with a rubber like padding shellac. The panel in the background is already stained. By applying pressure to the rubber more or less stain is squooze out and into pores. I can stain a whole chest of drawers with a few teaspoons of stain.


3. I make stain by mixing 15-20% Japan colors 10 % linseed oil and 70 % by weight General Finishes Prestain conditioner. I was told by their chemist that the conditioner is what they use as their pigment stain solvent. I used to use Sherwin Williams pigment stain (1970's) until my 30 year old can ran out. General pigment stain is just fine if you can find the color of your dreams. I was told it is all mineral so it will not fade.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#39

Re: A world of difference

Hank Knight

Thanks, Bill. Sorry for all the questions. I'm going to save your regimen and try it on the next thing I build of cherry or walnut. I misunderstood when you talked about burnishing the surface to be stained. Your explanation makes perfect sense.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#40

Question

John in NM

The Japan colors - is that the fancy Ronan paint or something else? I've seen that stuff at the local real paint store but never occurred to me to make stains with it. Neat idea.

Minwax gave pigment stains a bad rap, with their heavy colors and brush on, wipe off instructions. Bet more people would use them if they did it the way you do.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#41

Re: Question

Jesse Cloud

I took a brief foray into custom pigment mixes. The really cool thing is that a mind boggling variety is available online. Not primarily for woodworkers, but for the much larger market of people making their own makeup.

Just buy a small amount of pigment and mix with oil or shellac. You can dial in pretty much any color you wish.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry

#42

sanding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can not overemphasize the sanding steps. At the end of each grit the surface must look perfectly the same luster. Any dullness reveals torn grain that the sanding dust is trapped in. Brightness reveals machine tool burnish. Any place dust is trapped will trap stain too. Any shiny place won't take the stain. I avoid starting coarser than 120 unless driven to 100 by some problem I haven't been able to solve with a hand plane or scraper. I don't think I could successfully stain if I started at 80 grit. 80 grit scratches are very difficult to remove.

Most stains now days are not mineral pigment stains, and worse, to get colors not found in nature dye is added to some stain formulations. I have never been successful using these stain products except on oak where the Minwax "oak" flavors of stain do well when applied in moderation (see picture of my Grandmother's refinished china cabinet).