Dark Patches in Cherry
John Pierce
Are the dark patches in noted in the photo due to inadequate sanding? All boards in the photo were sanded at the same time to 220 grit.

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Dark Patches in Cherry
John Pierce
Are the dark patches in noted in the photo due to inadequate sanding? All boards in the photo were sanded at the same time to 220 grit.

Re: Dark Patches in Cherry
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It looks like moldy patches in cherry sapwood. - stain it.
Did you use silicon carbide sandpaper?
Dick Coers
Did you use black sandpaper? Is that the edge or the face, it's hard to tell what we are looking at.
Re: Did you use silicon carbide sandpaper?
John Pierce
You are looking at a flat 4" surface section. I stained it after sanding 200 grit with Al oxide. I wondered if not applying stain with a cloth but with a brush may have flooded the surface with too much stain.
John
That info helps, most often called blotching
Dick Coers
The most common term for the uneven penetration of stain is called blotching. Plenty of info on the internet for using stain controller, gel stain, NGR stain, wash coat of shellac before staining, etc....
What brand of stain did you use, Minwax? No matter what you used to apply it, that is what you get. If you use a gel stain, you can use a rag and leave a little more stain on the surface to make a more even color.
What goes on here is the undulation of the "grain" in the wood. As the wave comes to the surface, it is more like end grain and the stain soaks in deeper. Stain controller seals those open pores and will not let the stain penetrate as deeply.
Something amiss with the staining
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The attached picture is what stained cherry should look like, though your color could differ some. I don't understand how you got the result you got. Provide all the details and maybe a solution can be found.

Re: Something amiss with the staining
John Pierce
My concern is the sap wood (light color). This panel was originally covered with Minwax 235 cherry stain and covered with a Polyurethane finish. I could have created a picture before refinishing. The original did not seem to have much bloching. I had this top from 4 years ago and decided to reuse it for my current cabinet top.
I sanded through the Polyurethane finish with 60 grit until I got down to bare wood. then I worked my way up thru 100, 150, 180 up to 220 grit. I made sure that i spent plenty of time at each grit grade. Then I applied Minwax 235 cherry stain with a brush. Where there was excess stain, after about 10 seconds, I wiped it off. After the stain dried, I sprayed it with three coats of General Finishes High Performance Semi-Gloss Water Based Topcoat. I allowed each coat to dry and sanded with 220 grit before applying the next coat. The heart wood looked fine and the sap wood had the blotching in the photo.
John Pierce
Re: Something amiss with the staining
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It doesn't look to me like the stain stained much. I don't see much color added. I don't know why the stain didn't stain much.
For coloring sapwood a dye stain works better, but it takes more experience to get it on uniformly unless you can spray it.
It would have helped...
Brian Roberts
to state in your original post that the panel was previously stained and finished.
Difficult to help without the complete story!
It did look like the remnants of a previous staining....which is VERY difficult to remove.....without sanding deep enough to remove all traces.
Re: It would have helped...
John Pierce
Is there a way to tell of you have sanded far enough to escape the problem of Blotching?
John
Re: It would have helped...
Brian Roberts
I see the problem as remnant stain in the grain lines....which will look like "blotching" when stained again.
When all the dark stain is gone from the grain lines you have sanded far enough.....and that may take a LOT of sanding.....
Sanding will not eliminate blotching
Dick Coers
I explained in my previous post, it is due to the grain structure of the wood. Wait, I guess if you sand the entire board to dust, it will eliminate your blotching problem. LOL
Re: It would have helped...
Jesse Cloud
When you think you have sanded enough, rub some paint thinner onto the piece with a clean rag and inspect it carefully. Sander marks, glue, and residue of previous stains will show up clearly. "Blochyness" may or may not show up, and as said below, sanding won't fix blotchyness either.
Re: It would have helped...
John Pierce
I guess I just have chalk the blotchy appearance up to experience. Next time I will not use a previously stained and finished top.
Thanks for the many responses I have received.
John
Re: It would have helped...
don stephan
The nature of cherry is to stain unevenly. I've been told that a well known finisher/author publicly wrote once, if you don't like blotching, don't use cherry. I haven't seen that claimed writing.
There are likely hundreds if not thousands of posts and articles on the Internet addressing ways to avoid blotching and still put color on top of cherry. They would include in no particular order spraying color, sealing, glazing, toning, gel, and perhaps more.
charles neil blotch control woeks for me
del schisler
i use chares neil blotch control on all my cherry and other woods for blotching and it works for me the link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfCYMdrP8rM&list=UUUgl-M-8eVLCs5OwGx9CLsg
Very Frustrating....
Brian Roberts
when it becomes clear that neither the OP (John) or the subsequent posters (who I believe are trying to help) has carefully read all the writings in the thread!
John....You should have told us in your VERY FIRST post that you were asking about a piece that had been previously stained and finished and that you had attempted to sand said finish off in order to re-use the wood.
The issue shown in your picture is NOT blotching caused by staining a fresh piece of wood.
It is residual stain left from your attempt to sand the old finish and stain off.
It MAY be possible to sand deep enough to remove THAT RESIDUAL STAIN.
If successful in that endeavor....THEN you may experience BLOTCHING when you stain it for the SECOND time.
There are a number of commercially made pre-stain conditioners available...or you can make your own....many "recipes" for that also.
Re: Very Frustrating....
John Pierce
I am sorry that I mislead everyone. But I am rather new to this sort of thing and did not realize that I was misleading everyone.
Always willing to help...
Brian Roberts
....just treat the forum like a doctor's appt.. :o)
Can't really help without the whole back story!
Re: Very Frustrating....
John in NM
No need I say.... sure it could have been more clear, but I caught your drift right away (although I didn't really have any advice to offer).
I treat forums more like a social gathering than a doctor's office - I sure don't go to the doctor for fun! 
Re: Negativity
Jerry Gibbs
If I was a newbie I would be reluctant to pose a question.
Re: Negativity
Jesse Cloud
Hope you don't feel the responses were meant negatively, We sometimes fall
into jargon too quickly. I hope Brian's clarification helps you make sense out of
the responses.
And do take the responses with a grain of salt. Most woodworkers are wonderful, helpful people but as the saying goes "Ask three woodworkers and get 12 different answers."
Hope you will let us know how your project comes out!
John, you knew at the first post
Dick Coers
that it was used lumber? That's amazing!. Nothing wrong with a post suggesting the a person give as much information, on what they are doing, as possible. Some people are more analytical than others and know that to get information, you need to give information to the team. If they assume we know what is going on in the shop, a nudge to tell them to use a longer explanation is merely helpful to everyone.
Re: John, you knew at the first post
John in NM
No, not that it was repurposed, but it was obvious from the picture that a stain had been applied and then sanded off. Whether that stain was a first run at finishing or whether it was done years ago is irrelevant to the problem.
Re: Very Frustrating....
Howard Acheson
>>>> It MAY be possible to sand deep enough to remove THAT RESIDUAL STAIN.
Yes, you are correct. Sanding off an existing finish is problematic. The prior finish is deeply absorbed into the wood surface and sanding will not remove all of it. Any residual remaining on the wood will prevent a new stain from properly and evenly being absorbed. This leads to one form of blotching.
I suggest you remove all the existing finish using a chemical paint stripper containing methylene chloride. Follow the directions on the label. Then sand the surface to smooth it out.