Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Bed Rail to post connection?

Posts

Bed Rail to post connection?

#1

Bed Rail to post connection?

Barry Irby

I getting geared up to build a couple of Queen Sized beds for my granddaughters.

I made one years ago and made a bolted connection that was concealed and I liked it, but it was a lot of work.

Clearly I want something strong and durable. What method do you prefer for making the connection of the rails to the posts.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#2

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Stub tenon and mortise, held in place by bolt and either captive nut or barrel nut.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#3

Never made bed frame

Gary Smyth

But I have moved many times and broken down and re constructed many. These will last a lifetime. Use the mortised and not the surface kind. Provided the bed is not used as a trampoline, once done no worries.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#4

suck it up

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

bed bolt is the only way to go for rigidity and durability. Will last generations, what ever you do in bed.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#5

Yup...bed bolts

Jesse Cloud

Mine have survived many moves and my increasingly heavy body for decades.

I think I used a couple of jigs to ensure that the catch hole for the nut and the bolt mated up.

The further back the catch hole is, the harder to drill straight into the middle. so make it a reasonably sized bolt and be generous with the size of the catch hole, no one will see it anyhow. ;)

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#6

Re: Never made bed frame

roger lance

If you use this type of hardware, I'd also suggest that you place some sort of a wood plug in the rails to accept the screws which are going into end grain and would otherwise work loose over time.


Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#7

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

Rum

I've been eyeballing these:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Hardware/page.aspx?p=71050&cat=3,40842,43730&ap=1

Actually I have a handful sitting in the shop waiting for me to test them but the bed project is stacked up behind a few others at the moment so haven't done much beside fondle them.

I was looking for something with the strength of the traditional stub tennon and bed bolt combo but without the external visibility (yeah I know.. bolt covers..) and ran into these rigs. They LOOK like just the ticket and appear to apply a fair bit of pressure but haven't really done a full stress test.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#8

Bed bolts and floating tenons

Dick Coers

And I turn button plugs from contrasting wood instead of brass caps to cover the bolt heads.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#9

Re: Bed bolts and floating tenons

William Duffield

How do you get the plugs out without damaging them when it's time to move the bed?

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#10

Re: Bed Rail to post connection? *LINK*

John McGaw

I used fasteners similar to this when I built my first/only bed and they have held up very well. The ones I used were pretty expensive compared to these which I suspect are foreign-made knockoffs but I just received a shipment of these and they are pretty stout and I suspect that for any normal usage that they'd hold up fine. I prefer the round-ended ones since it is easy to make a router jig to cut the recesses -- essentially a 3/4" slot with rounded ends which works with my regular brass inlay collar and a 1/4" spiral bit -- it serves my laziness well.


http://www.cshardware.com/15-74-5.html

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#11

Thanks, Everyone

Barry Irby

John, I looked at those. What I like about them is they stay attached to the bed. Nothing to lose and no tools required for the set up and take down of the bed. I have to admit I am skeptical of them at $4 a set. If they deform or fail.....?

I am thinking I will use bed bolts. I made my son a bed that used home made barrel nuts embedded in the posts and the bolts embedded in the rails in a Tee slot. This way everything stayed with the bed. I even installed a permanent magnet to hold the bolts in the "retracted" position and routed in a recess for the wrench. the wrench was an ordinary open end wrench, easy to replace if it gets lost. This setup, while concealed and "elegant" was a lot of work.

This time I may go with bolts through the posts into nuts in the rails and turn a cover for the bolts with a magnet to hold it in place. What is holding me back is this would require some sort of socket wrench to assemble and dissemble the bed. I suppose I could buy a set of bed bolts and the wrench that does with them, but that wrench is an odd ball thing and if it gets lost, not sure it would be easy for a "layman" to replace. I suppose I could leave the bolts a bit proud of the surface of the leg and use a little more of and dome to cover them. Then an ordinary open or box end wrench could be used. What say you?

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#12

Re: Thanks, Everyone

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I bought my female children socket sets when they came of age. I regard a set as essential to living. They do to and find many uses for these tools.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#13

Re: Bed bolts and floating tenons

Dick Coers

Just a little pressure on the under side of the plug with a card scraper or putty knife. The plug has a flange on it, like traditional mushroom head plugs. Our son has moved his bed the most, but I've not gotten on my knees to see if the walnut plugs are looking bad. It will soon go from Chicago to Phoenix, so another cross country trip. That makes it's 5th tear down.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#14

Re: Thanks, Everyone

John in NM

I've used both the hook hardware linked in several posts and bed bolts in a M-T setup. The bed bolts are bulletproof, but the hook hardware is durable and vastly less trouble - those are what we used in the shop I worked for, and if they are in a nice snug mortise, they are plenty strong enough - like a hinge, the screws just have to keep them in the mortise and the edge of it takes all the weight.

I did the same thing you're thinking of for covering the bed bolts, only I used one of those rosette cutters (could also be called a chatter-master bit) and some rare earth magnets in the back to stick them to the bolts. I made mine with a bit of hardwood dowel stuck into the back of the wood so they couldn't be knocked off easily, but that may be a bit more than is really necessary. If you're any good at turning (I'm not) that would be an easier way to go.

I'll second Bill on the socket set, a decent 1/4" drive set is a valuable addition to anyone's household tool kit, and not terribly expensive.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#15

Ellis Walentine

Ditto

Ellis Walentine

You can still get old-time bed bolts, with the tapered square heads, but I use 3/8" X 5" Allen socket head cap screws and square nuts mortised into the rails. The stub tenon supports the weight and the bolt holds the shoulder tight to the leg. Once, for a king size four poster rosewood bed, I had the cap screws gold plated and had special barrel nuts made from 1" diameter steel rod with a 3/8" tapped hole perpendicular through the center of the rod section. Installation was simple: drill a hole in the rail and pop the barrel nut in. If the design calls for it, you can use traditional bolt head covers over the bolts.

To counterbore a hole for the cap screws, you can make a dedicated drill bit from a shorter cap screw of the same diameter. Glue a section of Allen wrench into the socket with JB Weld, then file two opposing cutting edges on opposite sides of the bolt head. Pre drill a 3/8" hole in the leg, then chase out the counterbore with this custom bit. Works like a charm, and the bolt cap sits dead flush and tight. Looks like a little black dot on the face of the leg.

This may seem like overkill for some folks, but I've never cared for the amount of slop in the hook-type fasteners nor their tendency to bend and/or pull out. Maybe I was just using cheap hardware. On the other hand, I always overengineer things a bit. Fewer callbacks that way.

Ellis

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#16

Re: Thanks, Everyone

John McGaw

The steel in these particular brackets is a full 1/8" thick. If sufficiently long and strong screws are used and if the mortises are tight the chance of deformation is pretty minimal IMHO. I just bought three sets, 1/2 of one set is going to hold in the stretcher on my new table but others will be going into knock-down work supports (fancy sawhorses, if you will). I still haven't figured out where I bought my original expensive set after all these years.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#17

Re: Bed bolts and floating tenons *LINK*

William Duffield

That'll work. :)

My concern was a hypothetical, in case someday a future owner forgets the trick to getting the buttons off. The way things are going, it's not going to be long before everyone forgets how to use bed bolts and brass bed bolt covers, so even doing it the traditional way probably wouldn't help. :(

I've always used mortise and tenon, old fashioned bed bolts with square captured nuts, brass bed bolt covers, and of course a traditional bed bolt wrench.

The following link is an example, not a recommendation for a particular vendor.

In the future, I might be tempted to use multiple 14 mm Dominos, if the bed was not in a preindustrial style.


Bed Hardware

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#18

Re: Hardware bonding.

TomD

Epoxy, you bond a threaded rod into an oversized hole with epoxy (like WEST). Cheaper, neater, stronger, easier to use. It also requires near zero skill as the alignment of holes, etc... is pretty much eliminated. While one is supposed to use a much larger ratio of hole to stud, I find 1/2" rod in 3/4" hole is more than enough for furniture uses like work benches or beds You can cap it off with an acorn for a nice finished look if that suits the project.

Re: Bed Rail to post connection?

#19

Ellis Walentine

Good tip

Ellis Walentine

Appearance on the outboard end of things is the issue. Acorn nuts may fill the bill. Or a coverplate. I've not tested the pull-out strength of a piece of thread in endgrain. Like any other bolt specification, it would depend on the depth, and probably some species specific criteria.

Good one.

Ellis