He knows that, it was very clear in the post I replied to above.
His reply had a bit of tongue in cheek directed towards those who either did not understand that the OP was inquiring about the equipment wire rather than site wiring or did not know that breakers are not intended to protect equipment.
Unfortunately, its a bit hard to get one's nuances to come through clearly with the written word (and a bit harder even when discussing wiring! )
I'm not an electrician or EE. I thought that the manufacturer's requirements enter into the discussion as well. Grizzly was known for over speccing circuit capacity at one point e.g. 40 amp breaker for a 3 h.p. table saw. I thought that had to followed when installing a dedicated circuit to be strictly up to code.
To add to the fray, I vaguely I remember something about a difference if a motor is hardwired to a dedicated circuit vs a motor on a cord with a plug that fits into a wall outlet.
Maybe that is because someone might unplug the motor and plug in a heater.
Or maybe I'm just confused because I'm elderly and feeble minded. There is no way I can correctly interpret the code without triggering a brain aneurysm.
You are on the right track. For motor loads there are special rules that allow a much larger breaker to be put on the wire to handle startup surges for instance. The wire's ampacity has to be some value above the FLA of the motor and this ampacity rating is at a lower temperature than the rated temperature of say, your 90 degree romex which lowers its ampacity rating. There are NEC tables.
I think there are similar rules for intermittent devices such as welders.
The circuit has to be dedicated without receptacles for the reason you suggest, somebody might plug too many regular loads into the circuit and overheat the wire.
On the topic of "too many amps" lets say you have your 2 amp device plugged into a 20 amp circuit. If it can handle 2 amps safely, it has ten times that much available. The cord on that device might be designed for 10 amps at the most. If the device develops a nice solid short, it could pull 20 amps until something gives. If that weak link is the cord and it bursts into flame in that pile of shavings, you could have a nice little fire. So, my point is I hope someone designed it in such a way that it cannot develop that sort of short.
The poorly matched comment was to say a dangerously matched combination. The OP mentioned having a 40 amp breaker on a No. 12 wire. Plug a welder into that and you might have a problem. Wonder how long you can draw thirty or forty amps through a No. 12 before it melts.
I saw a house where they moved the panel. The panel was on one side of the house and they move it to the other. They threw a No 10 wire over the roof and fed a 200 amp panel with it. Two years later I saw it again. The local power company had rejected the set up and refused to run a new service. They had been running a 200 amp panel for two years on a No 10 wire! Kitchen range, heat pump, water heater, the whole deal. Can anyone explain why it had not failed?
The Code writers have worked very hard to make electricity as safe as they can. The Code is very complex because the requirements are complex. Throw in the fact that many amateurs have never seen a Code book and never took a class, and did not even stay in a Holiday Inn and its no wonder so much of it is screwed up.
I Understand where everyone is coming from BUT from a code "legal" standpoint the ONLY thing a breaker is required to do is to protect the "Permanent building wiring and receptacle"
In the normal home installation most of the breaker size is 20 Amp with #12/2 wg wire installed. The receptacles are also rated at 20 amp. Note a larger size wire and or higher rated receptacle can also be used legally. The breaker then protects the wire and receptacle. ANY SIZE wire may be used in the appliances or tools plugged into the receptacle, including extension cords. IE: A table lamp may have #18 wire to the plug (perfectly adequate for a 100 Watt bulb), while a toaster or Iron may have #16 or even 14 wire.
The electrical code ENDS at the receptacle PERIOD.
It is perfectly legal to leave the shop wiring breaker at 40 AMP as long as the wiring and receptacle were sized properly when installed.
The ONLY FACTORS to be considered are I) that the existing breaker MEETS OR EXCEEDS the motor load of the tool to be plugged in (still legal if not but breaker will trip). and 2) that the wire size and length will not cause the wire to overheat or cause a large voltage drop under load.
I would recommend he makes his extension cord, I believe he said 20 foot ~ 25 foot would also work well with #10 /3 wire.
i know #12 would work (and be legal) but you will get much less voltage drop during motor starting with #10. The cost difference is minimal and that is what I have used for all extensions used in my shop for my 3 horse Unisaw, joiner, dust collector, and 5 hp planer.
NOTE: IN ALL CASES ANY EQUIPMENT THAT IS PLUGGED INTO A RECEPTACLE IS EXPECTED TO BE PROTECTED BY OVERLOADS BUILT INTO THE EQUIPMENT NOT THE BUILDING CIRCUIT BREAKER!!
Note: I am a retired Manufacturing Engineer, and I subcontracted and contracted HVAC and electrical work as a second job for many years. I have wired many residences, and done both commercial and industrial wiring. There is no "License" for Electricians in the State of Indiana, but I was bonded and insured.
A few years ago, I went along with someone to check out his friend's problem. She said her power had gone out during a storm, but everyone else around her had power. We walked out to the back yard and almost stepped on a couple of 10 gauge wires in the grass. Most of the insulation had fallen off years ago. This was the service drop.
The power company, being unencumbered by the NEC, can apparently rate conductors on their side of the meter however they please. Hanging in free air, a 10 gauge wire will safely handle more than 30 amps, of course, but when this drop was installed, probably nobody expected this:
"The OP mentioned having a 40 amp breaker on a No. 12 wire."
That is not what he said at all. He mentioned the outlet is already installed, and the distance to the machine, and then that since it had to be routed over the DC he didn't think the 45 feet of 12/3 he had on hand was enough.
I took that to be "enough length" and that he was using 12 awg for the equipment lead - for which task it is sufficient if it is to be attached to a plug and plugged in to the outlet. If he is considering relocating that outlet to the end of the 12 awg wire, then you definitely have a point. We don't know which it is though.
This has been a confusing thread, no doubt about that!
Note a larger size wire and or higher rated receptacle can also be used legally.
Possibly I'm misreading the Code (or failing to read a more pertinent part of it at all), but Table 210.21(B)(3) seems to allow a "higher rated receptacle" only in the case of a 50A receptacle on a 40A circuit. Happy to be educated if there's more to it than that. Disclaimer: I'm not an electrician and my code book is 2002.
Apparently I wrong according to the Code, IF the 12/3 wire he mentions is installed as an extension cord. Depends on the definition of Permanent and Dedicated And building wiring. And other factors such as whether the load is intermittent or long term. (Please excuse the terminology, I am working from memory and not looking up the terms in the Code.) An intermittent load may be rated to the capacity of the breaker and wire, which ever is less, but a long term or permanent load may only be rated to 80% of the capacity. A table saw is probably considered an intermittent load, but a water heater is considered permanent or long term, whatever the term is.
Perhaps my error is that I was trying to use common sense to prevent a dangerous situation. I thought/assumed the 12/3 wire was copper and going to be a permanent part of the circuit. Even if he is going to install a plug and receptacle rated for the 12/3 wire, making it an extension cord, I think he intends to leave the saw plugged in for a long time, not quite permanently, but nearly meeting any commonsense definition of long term if not permanent. We don't know what size wire is fed by the 40 amp breaker to the receptacle. I assumed originally he intended to hook the 12/3 to the breaker but was concerned he did not have enough. I thought that meant length, but he may have meant he was wishing for some No 8.
This is bothering me. I would rather err on the side of safety. I think it is smarter, easier, safer, and cheaper to change the breaker to a 20 amp size than to argue about the Code or whether it is a permanent installation or an extension cord. He already has No. 12 wire and it is adequate for the saw. I have not looked it up, but I am reasonably sure 45 feet of wire does not have enough current drop to impede the performance of the saw or circuit. Makes no sense to me to buy No. 10 30 amp wire and put it into a 40 amp circuit.
Some questions come up here and get barely a notice or response. Some get fairly concise answers. I believe we have flogged yours nearly to death. I think buried in the many responses are some good answers. I hope you can sort the good ones out.
In fact, if you have any doubt at all you might want to hire a qualified electrician to do this for you or at least tell you how to meet your local standards. A few bucks worth of good advice can be priceless. Be safe
Barry, the term "permanent" covers that wiring and associated receptacle that is physically installed into a building running from the power company's meter base and to a receptacle or to a directly wired object, IE: furnace, Central Air conditioner, water heater etc. ANYTHING beyond that is covered by UL and CSA ratings.
It matters not if an item is "Plugged in" forever. IE: Washing machine, dishwasher, garbage disposal etc. IF THEY ARE WIRED DIRECTLY to the existing circuit breaker they are covered by the electrical code. (I have seen and installed dishwashers and garbage disposers that were directly wired).
If they are "Plugged into a receptacle they are not. By the way I have installed many (probably over a 100) electric water heaters, haven't seen one yet that plugged into a receptacle.
gents: have an electrician waiting in the wings. When dealer delivers the saw, I'll give him a call to do the hook-up work as well as one or two other things that need to be addressed.
Pulled the motor covers on all the 220 machinery and made note of HP, amps, etc., to have on hand.
Thanks for all the help. Was an interesting exchange of ideas.