I'm going to have 1500 bf of ash sawn. I'll be having about 500 bf cut according to my needs. The rest, I'll hold onto for later, general use and, likely, for others. What thickness would you say would be the most popularly desired ? I'm thinking 1-1/8".
I guess it depends totally on what you intend to do with it. Most folks would use more 4/4 than anything else for small furniture but if you ever want to make a big table you will be in forehead-smacking mode when you realize that some 6/4 would have been perfect. Is there any reason that the sawyer can't produce a mixture of thicknesses biased toward the most common?
When I mill logs on my sawmill besides 4/4 and 8/4 I usually cut a few thicker slabs, say 10/4, 12/4 and sometimes even a 16/4 slab which I then mill into 4"x4"s.
These sizes are very useful for woodturning. Even 8/4 is good for platters and medium sized bowls. 2-1/2" thick is even better.
Ash 3"x3"x37" would be good for baseball bats which are $15 to $20+ to buy a dry blank. 4"x4" lengths are great for turned boxes.
Just recently I pulled a couple of 10' air dried 2-1/2"x10" black cherry boards from my storage and cut them into turning squares for a woodturning class we did for kids, some bowl blanks, and for gluing up for turned Beads of Courage boxes. Very useful! (and quite expensive if you can even find that size)
Where do you live? If close enough and you had thicker boards I'd buy some! I've never had ash logs.
From the perspective of someone that sold this stuff - mostly 4/4, as well as a lesser amount of 5/4 and 8/4. 3" if you ever imagine making bats. 3 and 4" if you expect to turn any posts. In a pinch one can always plane or resaw it thinner but you are screwed if you need thicker. We didn't sell 200 feet of 6/4 anything in all the years we sold lumber. Unless you anticipate a specific need don't saw any 6/4.
Currently, there is almost no market for ash. Don't count on selling it.
Right now I am dead in the water on the display cabinet because I don't have a suitable plank of 8/4. I have a rack full of 4/4 and 5/4.
Another use for 16/4: I had a hard time finding this for ash bed posts a few years ago. Hate the thought of having to glue up something like that; just doesn't look right.
Yes, the thing is, I don't know what people will want it for. I was, also, thinking mostly 4/4 but I wonder if 4.5/4 would be more practical. Also, I will be having some 8/4 and some 6/4 cut for my use. I plan to increase quantities of those a bit to mix in, especially 8/4. Is 5/4 popular ?
My question, I guess, is what sort of mix and what thickness for the regular boards ? Thanks for your input.
A few years from now will be a different story. Right now, there is nothing more hot than natural edge slabs, big and thick. Thrown on top of cast iron legs,and it will sell anywhere!
Ash is not in fashion and has not been for many years. When we began selling lumber ash and cherry were the same price. Now it is the cheapest domestic hardwood. Until manufacturing (the places that buy trailer loads, rail car loads or ship loads of lumber in China, Europe and the US) decides to make high volume furniture and architectural products from ash there will remain less demand than there are logs in the areas being harvested.
BTW, there is no species powder post beetles prefer better than ash. If you store it, treat it.
You are not going to make minimum wage manufacturing and marketing 1000 bd ft of log run lumber. If you can't sell the logs it will give you an indication of whether they will yield lumber of marketable grade as judged by someone that knows this business, and what the current demand for ash is.
If the logs are typical your 1000 bd ft of logs may yield 250 bdft of top grade lumber, 250 ' of #1 common and 500 bd ft of lower grade lumber. Or if the logs are not good saw logs they may yield no top grade lumber. You will have a near impossible task of selling the lower grade lumber to individuals even if it was a species more popular. Farmers won't buy the lower grades for their needs because it is not rot resistant.
In my experience log owners vastly overestimate the quality of their logs and what they will yield. A reality check is to see if someone is interested in buying them.
When I'm building anything like a table or dresser, something that has an exposed edge on the top, I like to have a finished edge of nothing less than 7/8". To get that, I need 1-1/8" for rough thickness, at least. If there is the slightest warp, cup or bow, you need to start with something thicker. So part of the answer is how it comes off the saw, but I'd start with 1-1/8", maybe 1-1/4" to give yourself something to work with.
We used to stock hard maple for industrial applications- bumpers, and I don't know what all it was used for. Then the price went to the moon when Japan decided to build a bowling alley everywhere. At one point 8/4 maple was higher than walnut. We moved the customers over to 8/4 ash and it served the needs well.