Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

Posts

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#26

Pratt in 2009

R. Payne

Found the 1909 experiment to be fundamentally flawed and, when repeating the experiment, came to the opposite result. Pratt, 2009 was more rigorous so unless you have something better you haven't proven your point.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#27

Less than impressive...

John in NM

The primary reason being that Pratt clearly missed the reasoning behind pre-filtering the light going to the salt box, and why it matters where that filter is placed. Ideally, the glass box would have been pre-filtered with a pane of salt - not doing so was admittedly a bit sloppy on Wood's part. This is pretty basic, and it makes me wonder how much Pratt knew about spectroscopy at the time. Pratt is also appears incorrect in his understanding of why the floor of his salt box is warmer than the floor of the glass box - if he had been up on spectroscopy he would have gotten that - it's the reason for the filtering Wood did.

The second reason is that in repeating the experiment, he introduces variation and then condemns Wood's work for not considering the variation that Wood took care to avoid. Rather than taking temperatures all over the place (yet ignoring ambient temp far outside, inexplicably), he should have taken care to place a single thermometer, preferably shaded, in the center of the boxes.

And a very minor point - Pratt clearly shows his bias in his writing style. While none of us are impartial, it's fairly unprofessional to show it in such an article. The reason for this should be obvious. I am showing bias here too in how I write, the difference is that I'm not trying to convince anyone.

On the other hand - I do not agree (and never have) with Wood's using this experiment to draw inferences about the broader climate. They are very different systems, and he should not have extrapolated so drastically from one to the other.

The atmospheric greenhouse effect does work as you describe. Boxes with glass on the top do not to a great degree. Glass (or any mineral compound) does absorb some bands of light and radiate that energy as heat (longwave IR). You can see that clearly in Pratt's data. However, Wood's point was that this effect was not of the same order of magnitude as the limiting of convection (that is why the ambient outside temp is important).

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#28

Well said

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a friend that does research in this area and what you say is correct. Greenhouses work by preventing convection of inside warm air with outside cold air. Poly(ethylene) greenhouses work just fine and this material is largely IR transparent.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#29

And now that I've slept on it....

John in NM

I'm even less impressed. I almost feel sorry for Pratt now, that is one embarrassing paper.

The reason is that he did not prove what he thinks he has proven. He did demonstrate that the original experiment had some generalizations that may not have been permissible. They would be impermissible if the generalizations introduced more inaccuracy than they prevented - I do not think that was the case, but I do recognize that it is a point of debate.

He did not, by any stretch, disprove the conclusion of the original experiment. The way to go about doing so would have been to quantify the absorbed energy of each pane material and then quantify the radiated energy of each material and then draw one's conclusion from that comparison.

I suspect doing so would not have provided him the result he desired however, and that is an unfortunate hole that even the best scientists fall into now and then. There is nothing wrong with falling in a hole, the trick is to climb back out rather than trying to dig through to the other side.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#30

Re: Well said

Barry Irby

I added a sunspace to my house to capture some solar heat. I used sheets of glass originally from patio doors, single layers of glass. I did it on a sunny day in the winter. Within minutes of installing the glass the interior was 60 degrees warmer than the outdoors. Whatever the physics is, it cooks. Cools down rapidly at night. I could play with shades and insulation, but I lost interest.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#31

Re: Well said

R. Payne

I've worked in greenhouses, both poly and glass. All else being equal the poly one require more heating to maintain tropical temperatures. Why? Because the glass reflects the heat IR energy back into the building instead of letting it pass through.

Yes, trapping hot air is important, but so is the reflectance of the IR.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#32

I misremembered, R. Payne is correct

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Either I recalled the incorrect explanation or just didn't remember the correct explanation correctly. Friend that does research in this area confirmed that absorption of radiant heat from the "dirt" by the greenhouse covering, be it glass which is best or poly(ethylene) with is poorer, and re-radiation back into the greenhouse is a substantial contribution to greenhouse heating.