Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

Posts

OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#1

OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

Pete in Holland MI

Having just returned to Michigan after spending most of a week with my Air Force son in Tucson, AZ, there were several things about his early 90's house that I am uncertain about, but living in Michigan all my life, have no experience to make judgments with.

Knowns:

1) Stick frame single story house on a slab. 1700 sq ft.

2) Heat Pump on the roof for heat and AC.

3) Plywood siding.

4) Asphalt shingle roofing (light gray color).

5) Insulation appears to be fiberglass in the walls. 2 layers of 6" in the ceiling.

6) Eaves are well vented. Gable end louver vent on both ends of the house.

Questions:

1) In the summer, heat from the ground warms the slab floor on the sunny side of the house. Would it make sense to create a thermal break between the edge of the slab and the surrounding ground (surround the slab with 1" of foam buried about 12-18" into the ground) ?

2) Summer or winter, the house is in a vacuum. Outside air is being drawn into the house from outlets and the fireplace. All fans and vents are off. Water heater is in the garage. Happens with HVAC on or off. I can't figure out what's causing the vacuum.

3) There is an 18 x 24" louver vent on each end of the house to vent the roof. All of the sofits are vented. Is this enough venting? I'm wondering about a ridge vent, power vent, turbine vent, or a series of the aluminum "muffin" vents. Guessing one needs far more ventilation to get the heat out of the attic in this part of the world.

Seeking the wisdom of you south-westerners !

Thanks !

Pete

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#2

1 Suspect

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is the very normal heat convection in the structure. As sun load increases and warmer air in the structure rises, it will induce a draw in the lower part of the structure that will be made up when opening a door or anyplace else that's not covered by a non-gas permeable layer. This is normal and Necessary. As the old saying goes "The house must breath." Were you to halt the air change, you'd soon have toxic mold growing down the walls.

Loose dirt's not a great heat conductor. Some landscaping along the south and west wall of the house to shade those areas will help. Even just shredded bark mulch beds will help.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#3

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

No longer a "southwesterner" but I grew up there in the days of swamp cooling and pit heaters.

PSS: 18x24 gables coupled with the other vents should be fine

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#4

I like ridge vents

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When one calculates their area one can see why they move air and move it in the most favorable direction. When I added them to my daughters house I could see the heat currents pouring out of the ridge on a sunny day.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#5

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

Keith Newton

#2 is a mystery.

If everything is off as you state, I'm wondering if you killed all the power to the house. Before turning things on one by one, you would need to open the doors long enough to equalize the pressure, because even a small vacuum is just air pulled down stretching it out, kinda like the opposite of blowing up a balloon then letting it slowly escape, rather than popping it and loosing it all at once.

I would look for a leak in the ducts going to the registers in the attic, if that is where they were run.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#6

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

John in NM

1. I don't think it would help much, but it wouldn't hurt if he wanted to do the work. I doubt it's the slab warming up so much as the wall itself. More insulation/radiant barrier is about the only thing that would help, and those aren't really practical for retrofit.

2. I agree with Mark that this is probably just a normal convection draft. Quick and dirty builders are notorious for not mudding boxes in, so they tend to be drafty. Under the walls is a problem area too, since slabs aren't all that flat and the lumber for the sill plate may not be all that flat either. When I lived in Tucson we'd get scorpions crawling under the walls and into the house. That can be fixed with caulking if you can get at the base of the wall.

Ceiling boxes, bathroom vents, duct penetrations, etc are all nice draft points too.

3. More venting might help some in the summer. Those whirly turbines are an easy install, a lot of houses have a couple of those. I like ridge venting a lot myself, might be worth the effort if the roof is shingled and you can match the shingle color. A roofing supplier will probably have rolls of corrugated plastic stuff that goes under the shingle cap.

All the roofs I've done since moving I used a radiant barrier OSB called Tech Shield. Another thing that is very tough to retrofit, but on new construction it is the way to go.

My last house in Tucson convinced me to never buy another "builder" house. It only costs a little more to insulate well and seal well, but none of them do it because they appear to think that the buyer prefers to have $250 heating and cooling bills every month over a slightly more expensive buying price. Perhaps they are right about that, I may well be one of the outliers.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#7

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

Barry Irby

Shading the edge of the slab might work or at least help. Adding foam would help but might introduce other problems like providing an easy path for termites (Do you even have termites in that part of the world?) or maybe scorpions or other critters.

The airflow through the house is much more complicated, as others have suggested. Generally, the "stack effect" causes warm air to rise and exit through high openings and suck air in through lower openings. This can be aggravated by poor construction and things like exhaust fans. For example, your dryer sucks air out of the house and dumps it outdoors (hopefully). There MUST be air coming back in somewhere else to make up for it. Same for the bath fans and the hood fan.

If the roof has excellent ventilation its good, but it has to be done well. The combination of ridge and soffit vents is usually the best. You need to ahve lots of low (soffit) vents to allow the ridge vent to work properly. As a friend says, "you gotta have as much goes outs and you do goes inta". If the attic does not have enough inlets, the escaping heat/air will suck air up out of the house and that will add to your AC bill.

Some local power companies will provide you with an energy audit. That should include a blower door test and that will reveal the leaks. Short of that you can do a lot yourself. You can use a cigarette as a smoke pencil. Anything that will provide a little stream of smoke. Hold it near any outlet, light fixture or window. Easier with the blower door, but still possible without. You may be albe to buy smoke pencils on the internet.

I would think heat loading would be your problem. Look into spraying the underside of the roof sheathing with foam.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#8

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

John K Jordan

>Adding foam would help but might introduce other problems like

>providing an easy path for termites

I don't know what type of foam is considered I do know that styrofoam in contact with or even near the ground is an invitation for big black ants to build cozy homes. I have seen this several times, once in styrofoam flotation blocks in a white water canoe.

JKJ

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#9

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona *LINK*

Dick Coers

No direct experience, but researched radiant barrier foil. Should be perfect for your son. They also have solar powered attic vent fans now.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WoEi6KbinBw

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#10

Termites in AZ

John in NM

Yes, they can be a big problem.

Worst case is the subterranean termite that invades new construction through cracks in the slab or from outside the slab. Stick a nice fresh bit of green pine out in the desert and I swear the termites can smell it!

In older homes the wood is dried out and termite damage (both airborne and subterranean) tends to be limited to areas that are frequently wet due to something like a roof leak.

The airborne termites are called "dry wood" locally because they will infest exposed dry wood, but they seem to prefer damp wood. The infestation tends to be smaller but the most typical treatment is tenting because the methods that poison the ground don't work with these ones.

I would guess that the bulk of the termite control industry in AZ is based on problems with new construction, but a termite inspection is still required (presumably by the lender) any time a home is sold.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#11

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

Barry Irby

Foil/reflective insulation has been around a lone time and can be very effective. But there are a number of problems associated with it. Poor installation tend to negate it value. So does damage and dirt or dust.

For it to work as a reflective or radiant barrier it MUST have two things, a shiny surface and an air space to reflect across WITH trapped or still air.

We (Home Inspectors) regularly see it in crawl spaces under joist cavities. This stuff was sold as Al-Foil. I have no way of knowing how well it worked originally, but most of the time, by the time I see it, it is pretty beat up. Dragging the ladder in and out has killed a lot of it. Plumbers, cable guys, and other repairs have trashed a lot of it. the problem is that once you tear it and open up the cavity, it negates the value of the entire bay because there is air movement. (An advantage to fiberglass here is that if you tear it, you only lose the part that is torn out or damaged, not the entire piece.) A side benefit of foil is that it is an excellent vapor barrier. I have never seen rot to the joists above the foil from overwhelming wetness in the crawl space.

The idea of laying foil over the insulation in the attic is a good one, but it degrades over time and fairly quickly. The skin effect is right on. Almost anything covering the fiberglass (even a sheet of paper) will improve its thermal performance by as much as 15% by reducing the air currents they spoke of. What ever you use must be tough and durable enough to resist the wind and other stresses in the attic. And it must breath, allowing the moisture to escape, and the perforations they spoke of will do that. The problem is that the attic has enough dust in it to degrade the reflective performance to nearly nothing in five years. So, they install it and it seems to work almost as well as they claim, At First. They it sort of fades away.

We need something that has a cover on the foil that keeps it clean and has and air space of about 3/4". Something like bubble wrap with giant bubbles. (The air space must be about 3/4" because of the wave length of the radiant energy). Tough enough to keep the bubbles inflated.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#12

Double bubble

John K Jordan

What about the bubble insulation used with metal roofing? Could that work?

http://www.insulation4less.com/Insulation4lessTechnicalArticles-79-Double-Bubble-Insulation.aspx

JKJ

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#13

Re: Double bubble

Barry Irby

The major problem I have is that this industry has been fraught with BS. The kind of crap where you have to hold your watch above your head to protect it. Probably be good to have your cell phone in that same hand.

I don't have the scientific skills to check all this, but I have been told that the air space needs to be about 3/4" because of the infra red wave length. Much smaller than that and the radiation does not "see" the shiny surface.

One problem with getting unbiased information on reflective barriers is that the Government farms out all the testing to Owens Corning and Owens Corning does not produce any reflective barrier.

The other problem with all of this is the building science is very complex. Trying to figure out where the vapor barrier should be or even if there should be one at all is tough. In a cold climate the vapor barrier should be next to the warm surface. Just behind the drywall and under the floor sheeting. In a warm climate it goes on the far side of the insulation. Far to the north its clear it should be right at the inner surface of the wall. In southern Florida It should be on the outside of the wall.

Unfortunately, most of us live in a mixed climate and have to decide whether to go with the mostly cold method or the mostly hot method. In Southern Florida they ahd Nursing Homes that had vinyl wall paper. Several years after they were occupied they discovered the wall paper had been glued with wheat paste. The AC cooled the buildings well enough that moisture migrated in from out doors and condensed behind the vinyl. The wheat was a food source and it was a mold factory. They had to abandon the buildings.

There have been cases where people laid foil over the attic insulation and so much condensation drooled off the under side it wet the insulation to the point it dripped through the ceiling. So the foil would be need to be perforated so the moisture (in the form of humidity) would migrate through it harmlessly we hope.

Study up on the difference between and air barrier and and a vapor barrier.

Something to do today. (Assuming it cold and maybe snowing where you are.) Look up in your attic and see if there are drops of water clinging to the nails sticking through the roof sheathing. And if your house is more than a few years old look at the plywood around the nails and see if there is a rust stain there. If so, that means condensation has been rusting the nails and the rust has been bleeding out into the wood. Particularly, check above the bathrooms and kitchen. The sheathing may be darker there than elsewhere. Water/rust on the nails is a cold weather phenomenon. The darkened sheathing is caused by mold and occurs in cool weather. Not hot enough to cook out and kill the mold and not cold enough to freeze it and arrest it.

I've seen attics with such terrible condensation problems the plywood fell apart by delaminating.

The question becomes do you have too much moisture arriving or not enough ventilation? Yes.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#14

I don't think it's the wavelength...

John in NM

That drives the 3/4" gap, since IR wavelengths are quite short. Some sources include emission all the way to 1mm, but I would have said shorter than the 0.5mm range. The gap is necessary to prevent conduction from the radiant barrier surface into the cooler side of the system.

The 3/4" rule of thumb is more of a distance of convenience in many ways - material that thick is readily available for making standoffs, it's an easy distance to eyeball, and it's large enough that precision is not required of the builder. Air gaps under 1/4" would do as well but are inconveniently small everywhere but double pane windows.

The larger gap does help a lot if it is ventilated, making it a lot easier to remove any air warmed by the radiation.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#15

Hmmm...

John in NM

"I don't have the scientific skills to check all this, but I have been told that the air space needs to be about 3/4" because of the infra red wave length. Much smaller than that and the radiation does not "see" the shiny surface. "

That doesn't really pass the smell test I'm afraid.... If it did, double pane windows would be useless, their gaps are much smaller than 3/4".

The shiny surface works by minimizing the available area for radiant emission, nothing more.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#16

Re: Hmmm...

R. Payne

But glass in windows is reflective to IR (the reason greenhouses get hot is the IR is bounced back into the building). So it is a completely different problem than reflecting IR with a shiny surface and how much room is needed and the 3/4 inch gap doesn't apply to windows. Double (and triple) pane glass works by a different mechanism than reflective foil.

ron

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#17

not how greenhouses work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They work by preventing convection of the air heated by the dirt(and other surfaces) for mixing with the outside atmosphere. (I have a friend that studies this stuff.) So basically, they capture hot air.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#18

Reflection is not how a radiant barrier works....

John in NM

A radiant barrier is a smooth surface that minimizes the emissivity of a warm object such as a house's roof. The shiny surface has to face the side of the system that is desired to stay cooler (so shiny side down for roof sheathing), and have an air gap of some kind. If the air gap is ventilated it works even better because air molecules do come in contact with the barrier material and transfer heat (this is why double pane windows usually have a partial vacuum between the panes). Ventilation tends to remove the heated air.

People see the shiny thing and assume it is all about reflection - because reflection is something they can easily wrap their heads around. While reflection can be a minor component, reducing radiant emissivity is the bulk of what the barrier does.

As to the greenhouse, Bill has it right - the greenhouse just traps the air and moisture warmed by the sun. Glass generally does not block IR unless it is specifically doped to do so, and even then the absorption is typically very narrow band - that only causes problems for very specific applications, like IR spectroscopy through optical fiber.

You may be thinking of low E windows, which do have quite a bit of engineering to prevent heat from getting through. I don't think I'd choose those for a greenhouse though.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#19

Are you sure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When we moved to TN years ago ceiling heat was the most commonly used heating. Resistance coils were installed in the ceiling under a layer of drywall. A layer of aluminum foil was installed under the flooring. I presumed it was there to reflect radiation back into the room.

Indeed, a shiny surface has lower emissivity but I think it will not get as hot to begin with because of reflection.

Solar mirrors reflect IR radiation. So why would radiation not be reflected from a roof or from anywhere else a reflective film was installed?

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#20

Re: Are you sure

John in NM

Reflection is a minor component, but as I understand it, emissivity is the main controllable variable using these materials. I believe the difference lies in the surfaces not being amenable to specular reflection due to their geometry. Instead they tend to be diffuse reflectors, scattering as much heat, or perhaps more, than they reflect back to where you want it.

Now if one found a surplus one of these:


And built a house under it..... :D

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#21

Re: not how greenhouses work

R. Payne

While they trap hot air, the reason they stay hot in cold weather is the glass allows UV and visible light through from the outside and blocking the IR that is radiated from the inside. If it was just a matter of trapping hot air any building would be a greenhouse.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#22

Ask the experts

John K Jordan

The Oak Ridge National Laboratory, where I retired from, has a building science research center. They are heavily into insulation research, funded by the government, not associated with any manufacturer.

I think anyone can contact them through the ORNL web site. I could probably find an email address/phone number if needed.

JKJ

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#23

Wow, Did not expect this much response

Barry Irby

Over the years I have been stunned by how poor the Building Science is in general. At least where it has been reduced to any even vaguely understandable level for a non scientist.

As I said, I am not enough of a scientist to sort this out definitively, but I would love to have some good understandable information.

Thirty plus years I was building what passed for super insulated houses, some with solar components. Low E glass was unheard of at the time.

Heat moves by three different means, Conduction, Convection, and Radiation.

Much of what we think of as insulation is slightly "deceptive". the part you can see is not the insulation. It works by holding a layer of air still. Still air is a pretty good insulator. The glass in fiber glass is a good conductor, But by have the fibers loosely associated they fail to conduct a lot of heat from one to another, but they hold the air trapped inside the bundle still, reducing Convection. Foam does an even better job of holding the air/gas still.

My understanding of double pane windows is that a larger air space is better than a thinner one if nothing else because the thickness of the air acts as additional insulation. Argon is even better because it does not move around and convect the heat as easily. There is a film effect. The air clings to the surface. This happens on walls and ceilings too and has an R value of about .7 in still air. IIRC The effect of the air trapped in windows increases with the thickness up to about 3" where the convection currents take over and diminish the effect. Good storm windows over single pane windows are better than double pane glass in sashes. Think of the air/argon between the panes as if it were invisible foam. Its easy to grasp that thicker foam is better than than thinner foam. (aerogel (sp?) is an attempt at invisible foam, but as far as I know it does not last long enough)

Reflective surfaces are an attempt of control heat movement by Radiation. I may be wrong about the 3/4" space, but there are limits. Perhaps its difficult to maintain a space less than that properly? (Remember the paint they marketed with "micro-spheres". Supposedly it had spheres that were so tiny you could not see them in the paint film and they were hollow and shiny on the interior and would reflect the heat both in and out. Paul Harvey promoted it. The Feds shut it done as a fake)

I need to know more about emmisivity and absorbtivity.

I know people that used foil backed drywall and were very pleased. The foil backed roof sheeting seems to be getting a good rep. I've never seen it locally.

Another think to keep in mind if that once a building is reasonably well insulated Air flow through the building becomes the biggest source of heat loss.

Wonder if there is some good consumer level unbiased info available?

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#24

Consumer info....

John in NM

It's out there on the web, but hard to sift out of all the misinformation. Much of the problem I've seen (in other sciences, not this one specifically) is that the people who do genuinely understand the science tend to lack the communication skills to explain it clearly.

The only thing I would say is missing from your explanation is the time component - insulation slows the transfer of heat, it does not stop it. More insulation, whether foam, fiberglass, or just air gap, works to retard heat flow in or out. So yes, more gap is better - but the mechanisms which it retards are convection and conduction. Air gap or even vacuum has little effect on radiation. The only way to work that time component into radiative transfer is by minimizing the surface's ability to radiate efficiently. This can be done by making it smooth and shiny, or by a low E coating, and I don't know how they work.

Reflection is important, but most of the foil coated stuff is geared towards being radiant barriers rather than reflective ones. White roofs and walls do help keep a house cooler, and that foil backed drywall will probably help a little too. But where that drywall will really shine is in keeping the heat in rather than out - it is a radiant barrier, slowing the radiative transfer out of the house.

Re: OT - - House efficiency tricks in Arizona

#25

Ah... but it is

John in NM

As shown in 1909 by a man named R.W. Wood. His experiment involved constructing two greenhouse models, one with glass and one with rock salt panes. Rock salt is less absorptive of IR radiation.

He found that the two greenhouses performed similarly, clearly demonstrating that the mechanism works by trapping hot air.

The trouble is, saying that "glass blocks IR" is not accurate. Most mineral compounds and glasses do absorb specific bands of light, and the bands do get fairly broad in the IR spectrum. However, they transmit other bands of IR too, and the IR spectrum is huge.

Unfortunately for a debate such as this, most IR transmission graphs I've seen stop around the short to mid-wavelength IR. Most research has ignored the lower mid to long wavelength and far infrared - which is the thermal end of the spectrum, presumably because these bands are less useful for communications through optical fiber.

Even so, for a greenhouse to work as you claim, glass would have to reflect IR or absorb it and radiate that energy back inside preferentially to the outside (and that 1909 experiment demonstrates it does neither). What it does do is absorb some parts of the spectrum, and likely radiates in and out at a different wavelength - likely a longer one, but I'm just guessing. While it would help some with heating, it would be a minor component compared to trapping the air and moisture inside that is warmed by the sunlight. Regular houses do not do this because they block the full spectrum of sunlight coming in (shade) rather than because they fail to block IR going out.