Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

new table saw recomendation

Posts

Re: new table saw recomendation

#26

Re: thanks william and everyone else.

William Duffield

Don't forget to check the brake gap adjustment whenever you have your blades resharpened.

I set mine off once, while cutting the binding off of some government documents so we could run them through a copier or put them in a ring binder. What I didn't know was that they had embedded a layer of metallized mylar inside the binding between the layers of cloth, paper and glue.

If you ever manage to trip the brake and you can't explain why it happened, SawStop would like you to send the brake back to them for analysis. The processor in the brake works kinda like a flight data recorder, and they can learn a lot from it. They might even replace the brake and your blade for free.

One of our customers, a shop teacher, was giving the initial safety lecture to a new class of students. These kids often have problems, and end up in shop class because of them. He had the SawStop turned on while he explained the brake mechanism. One of the kids decided to try it out for himself, stepped up and stuck his finger into the blade. It worked. The shop teacher was not pleased. When we did demos, we used a hot dog, just like in the videos. We promised the owner's dog that he could have any hot dogs we managed to cut in two. He always went home hungry. We passed the hot dog around. Only a few of the observers could even find the nick.

Our sharpening service could often repair a blade that had been involved in an incident. If it haven't been warped, if necessary they brazed on a couple of new carbide teeth.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#27

Re: options

TomD

+1 old machinery is the best there is plenty of usable stuff beig msde today, but it is good in exactly the same way, and to the same extent as Ikea furniture is good. You can see the difference from 20 yards.

I am all for looking ahead, but at this point I need sawstop about as much as I need depends. It is basically impossible to cut something off on a table saw unless you want to. Higher-end trades like pattern makers don, t do it. And as an amateur where you don't have to work when you are sick, it is completely impossible.

I would doubt SS is built tough it is designed for unskiled lobor like the Biesmeyer fence.

Still when paying retail, it makes sense to buy what the market wants. It just doesn't make sense to pay retail.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#28

Re: new table saw recomendation

TomD

Chuck a riving knife, to me, is basic. Particularly with solid wood. SS is completely unessary. It is a bit like seat belts and air bags. SBs are necesarry to control the car, and they save lives. ABs are mainly an issue because people wouldn't use SBs.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#29

Re: new table saw recomendation

Michael Wilkins

Thought I would dip my toes in this murky water. All the saws mentioned before are good machines. I purchased a sliding table saw long after the Saw Stop came onto the market. I read all the reports about the safety features, and agree with them all. Not too pleased that the inventor was trying to force his technology onto all manufacturers; but you can't blame for trying to make a buck.

After acquiring my sliding saw, I have never had any kickback situations, my fingers are a long way from the spinning blade, it has more than adequate power. And it is a heavy-built machine with lots of power.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#30

Re: new table saw recommendation ( Tom )

ChuckinND

Tom, I understand what your saying, it's reasonable, but where does it stop ? As I said before, there are a lot of other machines and tools that will take a good bite out of you. Do we take it to the point that it gets so expensive for people to get into woodworking that less can afford to do it ? For me it's just a hobby, and probably always will be, because especially in this Walmart world, it's very tough to make anywhere close to a respectful wage or profit from it. After about 30 years of it, I've lost a lot of the passion and drive that I use to have for woodworking. In a nut shell, I'm about wore out. I also think that the majority of the general public, including the forums, think that if your a woodworker, you must be retired and don't have anything better to do, and you don't need the money. I'm far from being retired, and don't know if I will ever be able to retire. Currently I'm going through some very difficult times and looking for work. I'll also mention that when SawStop first came out, they really rubbed me the wrong way by trying to make it manditory in this country, but didn't want to support the American worker, instead they decided to support jobs in Taiwan. Much like a lot of other American companies have done, sent jobs elsewhere. I've been a blue collar worker pretty much all of my life, and their decisions don't sit very well with me.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#31

Re: new table saw recommendation ( Tom )

ChuckinND

The other thing that really bothers me is that over the years a lot of folks in the forums will promote SawStops. I've listened to gripes about commercial duty Contractors table saws, one being poor dust collection as part of the cabinet saw sales pitch. So I decided to do something about lessening that gripe, and spent a lot of time figuring out how to collect dust from the contractors saw that I own, and do it the best that I could in a user friendly and efficient manner. I can not justify the cost of a cabinet saw and the extra cost of running more power out to the shop for something that is not profitable. The lack of responses or support about what I've done with dust collection from the communities has been less then rewarding. Most that do like what I have done want my ideas for free, or will try to copy it without giving me any credit for my time and hard work. In this now Walmart world, I'd think there would be some appreciation in keeping woodworking affordable, and not more expensive for people to get into. But what the heck do I know huh ? Apparently not much.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#32

Re: options

papa

I have an old Delta/Rockler about 50 years old run's great does everthing I needed cut my thumb once not serious but a good cut it cost about $2500 bucks well the price of a StopSaw is about $2500. would have save a lot of pain and discomfort Just my 2 cents....

Re: new table saw recomendation

#33

Re: new table saw recomendation

clay foster

It depends on what he will be making. If it will be a lot of panel work, I would recommend a sliding table saw. Laguna makes a nice one.

If it is furniture work, I would get a Jet cabinet saw (left titling blade) with an Incra 1000 miter jig and Biesemeyer fence.

Ideal situation would be both, which I used to have.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#34

Ellis Walentine

Sorry for your troubles, Chuck

Ellis Walentine

I'm sure all your complaints have some validity, but please refrain from putting people down because they recommend something they believe in. Maybe the questioner can afford a SawStop, and why shouldn't he buy one if it has advantages? If he can't afford it, maybe he will buy something a little less expensive that someone has recommended.

Ellis

Re: new table saw recomendation

#35

Re: new table saw recomendation

john lucas

Talked to my friend this morning. I'm going with him tomorrow to look at some saws. I think he's leaning toward the Saw stop. he's not the type to rebuild an older saw. He always complains about how expensive this or that is but when he decided to buy and lathe and get into turning he drove to Canada and picked up a Oneway with everything on it directly from the company.

I don't know if anyone around Nashville has a sliding table saw on the floor. We will see.

Thanks for all the input.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#36

Re: new table saw recomendation

Rum

Most of the euro mfg's have deals with local users where you can pop in an see the sliding saws in their shop. Not quite the same as seeing it in a showroom but might be worth a call to the sales reps to see if they have anyone local.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#37

Re: new table saw recomendation

JohnM in Mid Michigan

I'll second what Clay F said: get cabinet saw with Incra miter, but I'd go one step farther on that recommendation and say: get a _modest_ cabinet saw (I have 3hp and would recommend 1.5 or 1.75hp - its enough and safer if slightly slower) and in addition to an Incra miter get the Incra TS-LS fence, not the Biesemeyer. When I upgraded from a Bies clone to Incra TS-LS it was magic/gigantic. When you get used to the repeatability of 1/32" incremental settings on Incra stuff, you'll want it everywhere. Really need it on my miter saw next but they don't have a preconfigured system, have to build it... wish I didn't have a day job.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#38

Re: new table saw recomendation

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Remember that SawStop has a regular contractor saw (which I have) and a 1-3/4 hp cabinet saw. Both are completely adequate for normal furniture work. I can easily rip 2" oak. The contractor has trunnions much more substantial than my old Delta contractor saw and they hold a setting without budging. BTW, everyone will tell you that the blade that comes with the saw needs to be replaced, so I bought a $100 Freud combination blade. I shouldn't have; I like the SawStop blade better.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#39

Re: new table saw recomendation

Jesse Cloud

The other myth is that once the brake goes off the blade has been destroyed.

Not so. Any decent sharpener can replace any teeth (usually 2 or 3) that were damaged for a modest fee, way less than a new blade.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#40

Old saw recommendations

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been able to buy, and have seen with some frequency for sale, Delta Unisaws and the Powermatic equivalent (66?) for $500 to $1000. Unless you want the features of SawStop there is no better choice of saw than one of these vintage saws if you can find one in that isn't broken in some way. The only thing that wears out are bearings which are easy to replace.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#41

Re: Old saw recommendations AGREE

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have a Delta Unisaw about 9 years old, it was one of the limited editions made in Tennessee, came with the extended cast iron on both sides plus the wooden extension on the right (it is the left tilt edition) and mobile base. At the time I looked at the General (Canadian made) and the PM 66. Any of these would have more than met my requirements.

However since all the saws from the US are now made overseas, (don't know about the General that was made in Canada) I certainly would recommend purchasing a used American or Canadian made saw. Unless the saw has been dropped off a truck or allowed to heavily rust, there is nothing that cannot be fairly easily repaired. These saws in my opinion will last for generations of normal work ~ probably would do the same if used commercially!

I have some Asian made machines, including the $1k Powermatic woodworking drill press. None of these compare favorably with the older American made machinery.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#42

Re: question on Dado blades ( Bruce )

ChuckinND

Bruce, could you be more specific about your old 9" not holding a setting ? Both the Rockwell 9", and Delta 10" Contractors saws that I own I've never had a problem with any of the settings.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#43

Re: question on Dado blades ( Bruce )

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Sure. Neither the blade tilt nor the height adjusters would hold a consistent setting. Both would drift, so either the angle or height would change from the beginning of the cut until the end. It wasn't always that way, though. Bear in mind that my saw was bought new in 1965 and led a fairly rugged life, with many different people using it, and it sat on job sites for years. It didn't get to sit in a shop very much until I got it.

And that fence, crappiest I've ever seen, with the exception of a friend's crapsman. It never, ever held a setting and would twist as well.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#44

Re: question on Dado blades ( Bruce )

ChuckinND

I doubt that the 9" that I have ever seen a jobsite enviroment, and I know that the 10" that I have didn't either because I bought it new. I think that the rods were small on a 9" because the whole saw itself, cabinet and cast top is small, about 25% smaller then the 10" models. If you think the rods were small, the rods in a 10" Powermatic were smaller then the rods in a Delta 10". As far as Craftsman goes, I think thats where Contractors saws got the bad reputation, they just were not built as well as the rest.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#45

Re: question on Dado blades ( Bruce )

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm sure you've had the trunnions apart on your 9" saw. Mine were just plain sloppy. They come apart in 3 major pieces and getting them aligned wasn't easy. It was the looseness in the trunnions that was the culprit. If they'd been like the Unisaw or the PM66 it would have been a different story. The trunnions on my SS are very substantial and very tight.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#46

Re: Old saw recommendations

john lucas

Well we went to Nashville to day to look harder at some saws. He picked the Saw Stop Professional. We Went to General Industrial Supply and they had Jet, Powermatic, Rikon and Saw Stop plus a few well used powermatic and one Delta. They matched the price of woodcraft and offered free delivery and set up. He is also buying a Powermatic 8" Jointer and A Jess Em router table. Didn't buy them today but is pretty sure that's how he's going.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#47

Re: question on Dado blades ( Bruce )

ChuckinND

Nope, I've never had a reason to take the trunions apart. And actually, I've had a few of the 9" saws because occasionally I will buy one if I see one for the right price to clean it up and resell it. I've never needed to mess with the trunions on those saws either. I try to stay away from beatup and abused jobsite machines.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#48

Re: Old saw recommendations

Hank Knight

Your friend will be happy with the SawStop PCS.

Sounds like he pulled out all the stops! Nice shopping trip.