Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

new table saw recomendation

Posts

new table saw recomendation

#1

new table saw recomendation

john lucas

I have a friend who wants to buy a table saw. Money isn't a problem for him and he tends to do things right. He has an older saw and bought a Oneway lathe several years ago but I'm guessing he wants to do more flat work which is why the upgrade.

I haven't really kept up that much. What table saw would you recommend. Woodcraft told him the saw stop of course because that's what they sell. One of our friends told him to buy the Delta because he has an older one and they were excellent back then. Someone else told him Shop fox. I've never met anyone who owns anything by shop fox. I have an older Grizzly cabinet makers saw that I reconditioned and it's a good saw. That's as far as I could go with him so thought I would ask the guys who actually do a lot of flat work what they would recommend.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#2

Re: new table saw recomendation

Ken Krawford

I recently bought a Sawstop to replace a Unisaw and really like the new saw. I had a serious table saw injury and wish I had made the switch years ago.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#3

Re: new table saw recomendation

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I've had a Grizzly 1023SL for about 16 years now. It works. No complaints.

Back when my dad was woodworking, before dementia took over, he had a new Unisaw. I thought that was an awesome machine too. The fence on it was really nice. Way better than mine. Overall his saw was better than my Grizzly. But mine was a fraction of the cost. Kinda like a Ford or Chevy compared to a BMW.

But if I was in the position of "Money isn't a problem for him", I wouldn't hesitate to look seriously at a SawStop.

Or, maybe even some of the European machines that appear (to me) to have more safety features. Maybe one of those machines are worth looking into?

Good luck.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#4

Re: new table saw recomendation

ChuckinND

You don't leave us with much information about the buyers situation, and everyones situation is different. I've had an American made Delta 34-444 Contractor's table saw with a 30" Unfence and a full-size Delta mobile base since I bought it new in 1995 ( about 21 years ). Wired to the correct electrical source, it's been all the saw that I've ever needed, and I expect that it will stay that way.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#5

Re: new table saw recomendation

Bill Howatt

I often wonder if Delta isn't a lot like Sony - they keep running on a reputation earned years ago that, IMO, isn't deserved today. Lots of complaints about Delta service and parts availability abound.

I have a Taiwanese contractor saw with an upgraded fence and it has served me well but if I was starting over and money was not object, I'd be heading to the SawStop store.

Bill

Re: new table saw recomendation

#6

Re: new table saw recomendation

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

John,

I am now several months along with using a Powermatic 2000 saw. I am very satisfied with this machine. It is accurate and well made. It has a riving knife (highly recommend) and an arbor stop that makes blade changes easier. It has built in mobile casters that can be engaged for moving the saw. The version I have has a Jess-Em router lift built into the table. All and all a good machine.

T.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#7

if " money isn't a problem" *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

Rienhard from Switzerland make a nice saw for around $60,000. USD base price with some nice options available.






webpage link

Re: new table saw recomendation

#8

Re: new table saw recomendation

Hank Knight

John,

Most of the machinery companies have either moved their manufacturing operations to the Far East, or have been acquired by Eastern conglomerates. Almost none manufacture here anymore. Delta was bought out be an Eastern group and all of their manufacturing has now moved offshore. From all reports, their quality has suffered badly. I had an older Delta Unisaw that was a fine machine; but after experiencing a serious kickback a couple of years ago, I sold it and bought an Industrial model Saw Stop. It is an excellent saw. The quality is better than anything I've seen, short of one of the very expensive european saws like the one Mark linked above. More importantly for me is the SawStop safety feature. Without getting into the politics of the inventor's efforts to have his technology mandated by the government, it is clearly the state-of-the-art in table saw design. If I were in your friend's shoes, I wouldn't consider any other saw. I have no affiliation with SawStop. In fact I'm on the record as an opponent of the inventor's efforts to have the government require all manufacturers th incorporate his technology in their saws. I'm just a very satisfied SawStop owner.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#9

Dam I could sell my house and buy that.


Re: new table saw recomendation

#10

Re: new table saw recommendation ( Bill Howatt )

ChuckinND

Bill, I think that your correct about Delta, except maybe about the Unisaw. But in my opinion, I wouldn't buy one of those either until the new Delta shows that they have their act together. SawStop ? No thanks, there are plenty of other tools and machines in a shop that will take a bite out of you just as well. As I said before, I'll stick with the old Delta Contractor's saw that I have. What could go wrong with it in a mostly hobbyist situation that I can't replace ? Bearings and a motor I could buy from just about anyone, but I seriously doubt that I'll ever have to do that. I don't need an industrial and stationary saw that is just harder to move around in order to put it away at the end of a day. Plus if I was to buy one, I'd have to get a bigger breaker box in our home, then run a bigger electrical line out the the detached garage/ shop that we still park our vehicles in. All added things for a saw that I really wouldn't be gaining anything from, except for bragging rights.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#11

options

Mark Hennebury

Buy used.

If you set up for three phase electric power in your shop, either by phase converter, VFD or three phase line you have a whole world of cheap ( relatively speaking) industrial grade machinery. There are lots of really nice old table saws, similar to the Reinhard available with nice sliding tables for joinery work, for the same cost as a cheaper made new machine. My Robinson saws are from the 50's and i wouldn't trade them for a new saw ( except maybe a Reinhard)








Re: new table saw recomendation

#12

My exact experience and recomendation


Re: new table saw recomendation

#13

Re: options

Rum

I might commit a small felony for that wadkin...

Back in the realm of new obtanium. Everything I've heard about the sawstop is that its a top notch piece of equipment on par with the older Delta and PM stuff. Generally the reviews have been that they're heavily built saws because the brake puts a fair bit of stress on the frame so its over built to handle that.

I don't think I'd buy new Delta today (burn me once..). Powermatic still looks pretty nice but their prices seem perhaps a bit overly proud of their equipment compared to somewhat comparable items from Grizzly. The Grizzly 1023 and 690/691 machines are generally pretty well liked and are perhaps the better value machines for the low/mid range. Grizzly also has some higher end stuff but no experience with it... I would be hesitant to go with their sliding saws (at least at the lower end of that range) as the tolerances required for those are fairly tight.

For euro format I have the 79" hammer and its been a pretty good machine. I have a few nits but overall I've been happy.

http://www.hammerusa.com/us-us/products/sliding-table-saws.html

I actually have the saw/shaper combo

http://www.hammerusa.com/us-us/products/saw-shapers.html

If I was redoing it today I'd probably grit my teeth and pull out my wallet for the K500 series

http://www.felderusa.com/us-us/products/table-saws.html

Or take another hard look at the minimax machines which are in the same rough class as the K500 (better than hammer, maybe close to on par with the felder line depending on how you slice the apples).

http://www.minimax-usa.com/index.php?option=com_virtuemart&Itemid=35

The merits of the slider vs the sawstop on functionality & safety have been widely debated so I won't go there :D

I will say that moving to a sliding table saw some things have been wonderful; the outrigger makes it the most awesome mitre saw ever, I can hit fraction degrees of accuracy without trying, being able to straight line rip a 78" board is also pretty nice (I'm actually adding a top to extend that somewhat - felder sells rails that ride in the slider that you can bolt 3/4" plywood to and almost double the throw). They do take up a fair bit more space though... I know of a few folks who only work with solid wood who're happy with the 48" machines which are close to on par with a traditional cabinet saw, but if you do much sheet good work the 78" is near the low end of the acceptable size imho, its big enough to crosscut a 4x8" sheet of plywood (if somewhat unwieldy) but not big enough to rip it lengthwise. Trying to use the traditional rip fence to rip is also annoying because of height differences between the table and the slider (some people have dialed that mostly out, I haven't spent the time .. yet).

Re: new table saw recomendation

#14

Nice but....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

...the greatest saw in the world ain't worth a hill of beans if poorly operated. At the end of the day, all I need is a saw that cuts straight. Most saws, if properly tuned and operated can do that.

Not that I would turn that saw down if it were a gift. ;-)

T.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#15

Re: new table saw recommendation ( Bill Howatt )

William Duffield

stationary saw that is just harder to move around in order to put it away at the end of a day

Obviously, you've never used the mobile base that SawStop makes for their Industrial and Pro saws. The actuator is right up front where it is easily accessible; even at about 800 lbs., I can lift it and set it back down with not much more force than the pedals on a piano; since all four casters swivel, I can move it in any direction with two fingers, and when I set it back down, it is solidly flat on the floor at all four corners, and does not rock or move.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#16

Re: new table saw recomendation

William Duffield

My experience and opinions on SawStop totally agree with Hank, with the exception of his opinion on government requirements. I have no opinion on that issue.

Full disclosure: I own an Industrial SawStop. I formerly worked for a Woodcraft franchise, where I recommended, sold and installed SawStops. However, I was paid hourly, and received no commissions. While I worked there, we dealt in several other brands of contractor, cabinet and tilting arbor saws, including Delta, General, Powermatic, Jet and Steel City.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#17

Re: new table saw recomendation

Jesse Cloud

Interesting question, lots of good answers. Here's my two cents...

A lot depends on how much time and effort he wants to put into the saw. You can't beat old iron, but he would probably need to put in considerable effort to get

it back to its youthful state and keep it that way. Thats fine if he has the skill, time, and interest.

I've put significant numbers of hours on Delta Unisaws, Powermatic, Grizzly, and Sawstop. If money is not a factor, I would definitely go with Sawstop for safety and quality. One thing that impressed me was that when I set something on the SS, it stayed that way. On many of the others, I needed to recalibrate fence settings or depth of cut fairly often.

Except for old iron, I definitely would not buy another saw with a splitter. The riving arm is way better.

And Tom's right - you need a good basic saw that cuts straight reliably and safely.

If he's cutting a lot of thick wood, go with five horsepower. And buy good blades!

Re: new table saw recomendation

#18

Re: new table saw recomendation

William Duffield

One disadvantage of the SawStop is that it only uses 8" dado stacks and 10" single saw blades. It does not work with 6" dados, or Diablo blades, etc.

I think I would be even more wary of using an old table saw without a riving knife than one without the SawStop technology, personally never having cut off a finger, but having experienced multiple kickback scares (but no injuries).

Re: new table saw recomendation

#19

Re: new table saw recomendation

ChuckinND

The Riving knife seems to me like another gimmick, much like the SawStop. Just to get people to buy a new saw. Very few people ever used a splitter or a blade guard before all this hype.

.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#20

question on Dado blades

john lucas

I'm guessing the saw stop technology doesn't work when using a Dado blade. Can anyone answer that. They have a saw stop at our local craft school. It has fired twice using dry wood. Ruined the blade of course. I did see that the price of the new brakes has come down considerably.

How is the fence. I can't answer for my friend but a good fence is an absolute necessity. I'm still working on my Grizzly fence. It's pretty decent but could be improved. Then fence on my older Powermatic artisan saw was excellent.

If it has a riving knife is it easy to remove when necessary.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#21

Re: new table saw recomendation

William Duffield

You can call them what you want, but there is nothing gimmicky about them.

I also almost never used my splitters or my blade guards, but the riving knife is so effective and so easy to install that I always use it, except when I take it out to install the SawStop blade guard. I will admit that, even though it is also easy to install and remove, I only use it when I need to improve my dust collection (e.g., if I'm sawing lauan (which I'm allergic to) or cocobolo (which I eventually will become allergic to if something else doesn't kill me first).

Re: new table saw recomendation

#22

Re: question on Dado blades

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Saw stops work with an 8" dado blade. That requires a different braking cartridge.

I have the SS contractor saw with the cheaper fence. That fence doesn't move at all and locks on the front rail. The upgraded fence is better, but I didn't want to spend the money.

The tilt mechanism is the easiest to move I've ever worked with. My previous saw was the 9" Delta contractor, similar to Chuck's but 30 years older, and it wouldn't hold a setting for love or money.

The riving knife is very easy to remove, but I haven't, not even to remove the cartridge and blade.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#23

Re: question on Dado blades

William Duffield

Yes, the SawStop technology does work with dado stacks, but only 8" dados. When you install a dado stack you need to replace the brake with one specifically for 8" dados. Last time I checked, the dado brake was about $20 more than the standard 10" blade brake. It is fairly easy to swap out the brakes, but when you do, you need to adjust the gap between the brake and the saw teeth. Too far apart, and the saw won't start; too close together, and the brake may fire unexpectedly (usually either on start up or on shut down). It is quick and easy to adjust, with a nickel (the gauge) and an allen wrench. Swapping the brake is quicker than swapping the dado stack in or out.

I'm not even going to try to explain how a brake could be triggered by students at a trade school, but I've heard some pretty amazing stories. I assume no fingers were lost by either incident.

The SawStop fence is sturdy and precise. It is basically a Beisemeyer design, and a little sturdier than what you would find on a Delta or Powermatic. The fence itself might be a little larger or smaller, in which case you would need to adjust all your jigs that ride over top of the fence. I haven't measured, because I converted from a Delta Unifence, which required a total remake of my jigs.

Yes, it has a riving knife. They are required by law in the U.S. on all saws manufactured after a certain date, which was probably prior to SawStop's first production. They've been required for much longer in Europe, even on the saws Mark showed us. Installing or removing the SawStop riving knife is trivial, but precise. Note that SawStop offers different riving knives for thin kerf and standard kerf blades. And, the riving knife on any saw is pretty ineffective with any dado set, because it is too tall, it only inhibits wood from getting into the back of the blade from the left side, and the right side of the blade is partially guarded by the fence.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#24

thanks william and everyone else.

john lucas

My friend may go to Nashville on Friday to look at some other saws and maybe again at the saw stop. I've volunteered to go with him.

If I remember correctly the student was ripping dry yellow poplar to make some glue ups for a carving project. Nothing out of the ordinary and was a student of several semesters so had some decent skills on the saw. I never did hear what happened the second time, just heard from the instructor. He's been teaching there for 20 years or so and has only had one injury. That was a jointer accident. He bought the table saws because he was kind of forced to for legal reasons. Still he says they are good saws other than the misfiring.

Re: new table saw recomendation

#25

Re: thanks william and everyone else.

Hank Knight

John,

I've had my SawStop for almost three years. I've never had a missfire. I'm sure they happen because I hear of them. The only one I'm familiar with occurred at a woodworking school and involved a student. The student was adamant that he had not touched he blade. Interestingly, his work was being video recorded. The video replay showed that he had turned thr saw off and reached to remove a cutoff and inadvertantly touched the blade plate causing he cartridge to fire. He didn't even realize he'd touched it. The safety technology works while the blade is winding down after shutoff and the cartridge will fire if the blade is touched before it comes to a complete stop. My point is that missfires probably happen, but they are uncommon and some of them are probably not technically "missfires." However you classify them, missfires aren't something I worry about with my SawStop.

As William mentioned, you ned to change the brake cartridge from a 10" one to an 8" one specifically designed for dado blades. The change can be easily made through the throat plate opening from the top. You don't have to get down on the floor and change it from below the table. I adjused the gap between the blade and the brake the first time I mounted the dado and I've not had to readjust it as long as I'm using the same dado set. The same wih the adjustment for my 10" blade. Once I set it, it's good as long as I'm using he same 10" blade I set it for. I do have to adjust it a little if I change 10" blades, switching to a rip blade, for example. But the adjustment is easy with the allen wrench provided with the saw. I invested in a long T- handled allen wrench which makes adjustment even easier.

The fence is very nice. It's very solid and stays where you lock it down. It doesn't deflect at the back like many fences. I grew fond of the UniFence on my Unisaw, and I wish the SawStop had the high-low option the Unifence has, but that's a personal preference. I'm well satisfied with the SawStop fence.

All in all, I have no complaints about the SawStop. It is a fine, well designed and well built saw.

Hank