Last year I bought a compass from Harbor Freight. Like most stuff from HF it is useless. I've tried the various compasses from the office supply big box stores. Not so good.
I am thinking about ordering the 7-1/2 Pencil compass from LV. It's pretty pricey (to me).
Does anybody have this compass and does the screw that holds the pencil in place actually hold the pencil in place or, like the others I have tried, does the screw just screw into the pencil and let the pencil wobble?
I think Woodsmith magazine had plans to build one I. The last issue. I bought a cheapie a few years ago that uses a standard pencil. Don't remember where I got it though.
A beam compass or pair of trammel points are move versatile. They are often convertible from dividers to compass. One interchangable head is a pencil lead holder, and it holds a few drafting pencil leads inside, obviating the need for a pencil. They will draw an arc in a very wide range of radii, depending on the length of the rule or beam you choose to attach them to. They can be found relatively inexpensively on eBay. often included in drafting sets. These old sets usually include dividers and compasses for both pencil lead and ink. Sometimes the set includes a beam extension for the compass. The drafting leads have the advantage that you can sharpen them to a chisel point with a small piece of sand paper, or a file, so you don't need to carry around a pencil sharpener. Pencil Sharpener
Most new trammel points and beam compasses are in the same price range as good quality compasses, but old ones can often be a bargain. Good quality sets were made by Dietzgen, K&E and Alvin. Search eBay for "drafting set".
I also have two pairs of modern design trammels imported by General Instruments, and available from Harry Epstein that work well with steel rules, yard sticks or scrap wood.
Check yard sales or ebay for old drafting sets. I have some really nice compasses (or compi) that I use. They hold drafting leads instead of pencils and draw very accurate circles and arcs.
Joe, I have one that is very similar in design to the LV. I made a piece out of sheet metal to slide into the pencil holder that holds the pencil much better, and it prevents the screw from munching on the side of the pencil.
Joe.....I've not had an issue with the pencil getting loose in the LV.....its held well.....your thread caused me to look at the current group of compasses at LV and they are different from mine which I bought years ago but the quality of LV tools appears to still be there.
and look up drafting tools or drafting compass (to avoid the north/south kind). Even with shipping I bet you can find comparable. Then decide. Depending on your application (and the radius necessary a trammel or beam may be better. I don't like people picking out tools for me, so the option is yours, but do look around. Full drafting kits can cost less than some Lee Valley compass offerings (and they offer precise screw fine adjustment). No matter what you select just make certain that all the screws are there as they are small with awkward screw pitch and difficult to find if not there.