Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

DC tripping protected outlet

Posts

DC tripping protected outlet

#1

A.J. Hamler

DC tripping protected outlet

A.J. Hamler

As I think I've noted prominently before, I don't know nothing about electricity. Well, that's not true -- my grandfather always told me that you shouldn't touch a bare wire while holding an open can of beer, but I've been told by others that holding the open can of beer is irrelevant, that it's the touching-the-bare-wire part that's key. I'm not willing to test that theory, however.

Bottom line, I don't no electrics.

So -- I recently got a PSI Long Ranger remote switch to use with my Jet DC-1100 dust collector. The switch works wonderfully, and I wish I had gotten one a long time ago. I'm having an issue with it, however.

For some reason, the dust collector is now constantly tripping the protected outlet it's plugged into, the kind with the reset button. I've had the collector for a year and it's been plugged into the same outlet it is now, and not once has it tripped the breaker for the circuit itself (it's a 30-amp line). But now that the DC is plugged into the Long Ranger -- which, in turn, is plugged into the same outlet the DC was plugged into before -- it's tripping the outlet a bit more than half the time. Maybe two out of three times it's used.

The tripping occurs not on powering up the DC with the Long Ranger remote, but rather on power-down. The DC fires up just fine and runs fine as long as I need it, but when turning it off as it winds down the outlet trips and must be reset before it's usable again.

I'm embarrassingly clueless. I've sent an email to PSI but haven't heard back yet, and thought I'd see if anyone here had any idea what's up with this, and how I can correct it.

TIA

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#2

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

John in NM

Well, there are two possibilities here:

1. Something in the way the remote switch works is confusing the GFI outlet's monitoring circuitry.

2. The GFI outlet's monitoring circuitry is faulty.

Options:

1. Replace GFI outlet with normal outlet - obviously that is not always a good idea, but sometimes it is fine depending on local circumstances.

2. Find a normal outlet into which you can plug your DC/switch system.

3. Replace the GFI outlet with a new GFI outlet to test possibility #2 above. I find GFI's a bit expensive for parts bingo, so I wouldn't do this one myself.

4. Find one or two alternate GFI outlets in your house to use for testing possibility #1 if you want to know whether to just replace the GFI with another. I would probably do this if I thought it important to replace the GFI with the same (I've seen GFI's fail in odd ways when subjected to long term use near the upper end of their spec'ed current range).

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#3

Problem Should Be

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

in the switch box relay that is tripping your GFCI.

Sounds like your Long Ranger has come up a bit "short". Best contact Penn State about the problem or to get a replacement.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#4

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

Grant in Iowa

GFI's work by "comparing" the current on the "Hot" lead to that on the neutral, or "return" lead. If the difference exceeds a given reading, the GFI trips.

I won't claim to know entirely, and I welcome corrections by those more in the know, but here's what I *think* is happening:

1. Long Ranger is "on", DC runs as usual, current on each lead is roughly the same, so the GFI doesn't trip. A.J. is happy.

2. A.J. commands the Long Ranger to "Off", long ranger interrupts the "hot" lead, but leaves the neutral/ return lead uninterrupted (my assumption, can someone verify this?). Nobody tells this arrangement to the GFI.

3. DC motor is now a freewheeling inductive motor. It is generating a bit of electricity, some of which passes ONLY through the neutral lead of the long ranger to the GFI.

4. GFI decides "HEY, this is what I am designed to prevent!" and trips out because the in and out current are not the same. Not sure if the current would be enough to trip the GFI without a completed circuit, but maybe so, I think we are talking milliamps to trip one.

4.5 (afterthought) The DC might have a switch that interrupts both the hot and neutral when turned off. This could explain why it worked fine before the Long Ranger.

5. A.J. spends much time trying to figure out why all of this is happening. That other thing he was doing isn't getting done like planned. Now my other thing isn't getting done either. And that guy reading this is now behind too.

My recommendation is to plug the arrangement in to somewhere that has no GFI. Since you don't know a lot about electricity(my assumption based on your stated dislike), DON'T just remove the GFI and install a regular outlet. In most cases, GFI's are only installed where they are required by code. In addition, they often have other regular outlets downstream from them that are protected by the GFI.

SO, you either need a long ranger type device that interrupts both the hot and neutral leads (or verify that yours is, and is instead bad in some other way), or you need a non-GFI outlet. As I said, if you are in the garage, that will not likely pass code.

I welcome other perspectives/ corrections to my thinking above.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#5

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

John K Jordan

I understand there are devices which commonly trip GFCI's, for example some VFD inverters for variable speed lathes, etc. My Jet 1642 always tripped a 110v GFCI.

Fortunately, my reading of the regs say a GFCI is not needed on a dedicated circuit feeding a power tool so I simply replaced the GFCI with a standard outlet.

I have on occasion had a "weak" GFCI that would trip more easily than it should. Replacing fixed that.

I must admit I have never heard of a 30 amp GFCI outlet. I though that 20 amps was the maximum for an outlet and you had to use a GFCI breaker to go higher.

JKJ

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#6

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

John McGaw

In most of the world, such an outlet would be called an RCD (residual current device) and come in different sensitivities. The LS (low-sensitivity) device is made for machine protection, not for personal protection. So far as I can tell this is not the case in North America but it might be worth a call to a proper electrical supply house to explain your problem and ask if they have anything that might help.. Or you might just want to remove it and put in a regular outlet (unless your shop is some sort of swamp, of course).

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#7

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

don stephan

My suggestion is to remove the remote control from the system and try the DC again, to see if once again it works well with GFCI. If not, suspect the GFCI; if they still play well together I would call the maker of the remote control and discuss.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#8

Re: DC

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

the JET is a 115/230 wired motor, and, from my understanding is equipped with a DPST switch. The RC contacter in the Long Ranger should be a DT switch as well but the 115v model A.J. is using may not be. PSI makes a 230v model that must be a DPST unit for a 3-wire system.

You analysis of the trickle current in the neutral on the shut-down may be correct, however I think A.J. is mistaken as to the amperage of his circuit. GFCI outlets max out at 20amps and you need to go to a GFCI breaker in the service panel to get more like those used in home-run circuits for Jacuzzi-type tubs and such.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#9

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

del schisler

i bet it is in the motor of the dc when it winds down , inside the motor their is a slide piece that open's up when the motor slow's down , their may be a spark that is doing this ? my guess

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#10

A.J. Hamler

Re: Problem Should Be

A.J. Hamler

I've emailed them, but haven't heard back yet. Only been a couple days, though, and they're pretty good about communications.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#11

A.J. Hamler

Re: DC

A.J. Hamler

It is indeed a 30-amp circuit, Mark. I had it installed specifically about two years ago to handle a couple high-amp tools, including the DC.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#12

A.J. Hamler

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

A.J. Hamler

Mark said the same thing about GFCI outlets topping out at 20 amps. (I wouldn't know -- see my disclaimer on electrical knowledge and proficiency in the OP.) However, it is indeed a 30-amp circuit, with a 30-amp breaker in the panel. The first outlet on the line has the GFCI reset button, while the second one on the line is a regular outlet. Both outlet boxes have little "GFCI Protected Outlet" stickers on them.

If GFCIs top out at 20 amps, though, what's the point of the electrician putting that GFCI on a 30-amp circuit?

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#13

The Point

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Your sparky may have been trying to meet "Code" for a garage 115v outlet to be GFCI protected while at the same time giving you more amperage to meet demand. Keep in mind that your outlet (a duplex - 2 sockets?) maxs out at 20 amps so if you tried to pull more than that through that outlet you'd have a real problem. You could, however, pull more than 20 on the circuit through multiple outlet boxes so long as the draw on any one of them didn't exceed 20amps and the wire used in the circuit could handle the load. Normally, a 30 amp circuit requires No. 10 copper wire although I have seen people use 12.

Since you had this done by an electrician, was this, by any chance, an "inspected install" that passed?

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#14

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

John K Jordan

>If GFCIs top out at 20 amps, though, what's the point of the electrician putting that GFCI on a 30-amp circuit?

Some things are not clear.

- Is this a 110v circuit or a 220v circuit?

- Is this a 110v Long Ranger or a 220v long ranger?

- Is the 30 amp breaker a single-pole (takes one space) or double-pole?

- Is the GFCI a standard 110v GFCI (that you could plug a lamp into)?

- Is the second outlet you mentioned a standard 110v outlet?

- Can you tell from inside the panel if the 30 amp breaker is connected to a 12 gauge wire? (you might not if you are not used to wiring, with experience you can tell by looking at it)

Maybe you could take pictures of the receptacles and the breaker panel, and if comfortable doing this without dying, remove the steel panel cover and take pictures of the wiring in the panel.

The wiring in a 115v circuit is normally 12 gauge protected by a 20 amp single-pole breaker in the box. Using a breaker that is too large can be a serious problem. The breaker is sized to protect the wiring and keep from burning down the shop.

As others mentioned, a 30 amp breaker normally requires a bigger wire than #12.

HOWEVER, there are special rules for breakers and wires for dedicated circuits that feed large motors since the startup current "spike" can be high and can trip a "normal" breaker. On a large motor the running current is normally much less than the startup current. Perhaps someone installed a 30 amp breaker based on your motor size or even because that motor at one time actually tripped a 20 amp breaker. (This is independent from your current problem of the GFCI tripping.)

I am not a licensed electrician, but I do not think a circuit with a 30 amp breaker feeding a standard 110v GFCI then chained to one or more additional standard 110v non-GFCI outlets would meet the special motor rules.

If this is in fact a 110v circuit what I would personally do is swap the GFCI for a standard receptacle and swap the 30 amp breaker for a 20 amp breaker and see if that worked.

Given your experience with wiring, if you are not completely comfortable with this it would be best to get an electrician to look at it. (If you got electrocuted how could you post a followup message!!)

Your local electrical inspector would be glad to look at this and advise and not even charge for coming out like the electrician might, but some people are afraid to call an inspector. In my experience inspectors are reasonable and knowledgeable and only want things done safely - they aren't out to "get" anyone! The worst he would do if he found a problem is require it be done right.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#15

Your 20A GFCI recept. is a code violation.

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

According to NEC, 30 amp branch circuits require 30 amp receptacles. This is different than 20 amp circuits which allow both 15 and 20 amp receptacles on the same circuit. Reference attached. This is from the 2011 NEC but I don't think they've changed this.


Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#16

Special motor circuits

Bill Howatt

My, non-electrician, understanding is that if you are making use of the special provision that one of the rules is that the motors have to be hard-wired into the circuit. Receptacles are not allowed since that permits other devices to be used with a circuit that has an oversized breaker.

Bill

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#17

Re: DC

John in NM

I would be less surprised by a faulty GFI in that case. I've seen them fail similarly when they regularly get close to or over their rated load.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#18

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

John in NM

If the installer knew you planned to plug a DC and a table saw in to that outlet, that would be a different situation than plugging an electric range into that same outlet. Neither individual tool would draw more than 20 amps but the the wire & breaker may have to deliver more than 20 amps.

While a GFI might eventually start to have monitoring problems in such a case, you'd not have a problem with a regular outlet. The difference in configurations is primarily geometry to keep people from plugging high load devices into regular circuits. For appliances like stoves and driers, one typically uses a plug with larger surface area and stronger springs for better conduction. However there are 30 amp outlets and plugs available that are roughly the same size as normal plugs.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#19

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

Chuck in Mtl.

this would have been my guess..some back EMF on the neutral line causing a current flow. the gfic is doing its job by tripping.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#20

A.J. Hamler

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

A.J. Hamler

John, here are the details you asked.

- Is this a 110v circuit or a 220v circuit?

It's 110V

- Is this a 110v Long Ranger or a 220v long ranger?

It's a 110V Long Ranger

- Is the 30 amp breaker a single-pole (takes one space) or double-pole?

Single.

- Is the GFCI a standard 110v GFCI (that you could plug a lamp into)?

Yes, although the outlet shape is kinda square, plus it has the reset button on it.

- Is the second outlet you mentioned a standard 110v outlet?

Yes.

- Can you tell from inside the panel if the 30 amp breaker is connected to a 12 gauge wire? (you might not if you are not used to wiring, with experience you can tell by looking at it).

I'm pretty sure he used 10 gauge; I even seemed to recall him mentioning it. I was in there when he was working, and he had to use some real muscle horsing it into shape.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#21

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

John K Jordan

Here is one chart of the possible receptacle configurations:

http://www.cordsetsinc.com/configurationandvoltagechart.php

Maybe you could see which one(s) are used in your circuit (the DC plus all others). That should tell the amperage rating on the receptacle (and the voltage, unless installed by a drunken electrician.)

JKJ

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#22

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

John K Jordan

>- Is the GFCI a standard 110v GFCI (that you could plug a lamp into)?

Ah ha, if you can plug a lamp into these then you have a 15 or 20 amp GFCI and receptacle downstream. (I just posted a link to a chart.)

The fact that he had to muscle the wires into place is evidence that the wire size may be correct. 12 ga is hard enough. 10 ga is a real pain in the neck. (but for a real fun time, try wiring with 8 or, gasp, 6 ga)

As someone else mentioned, you have to use a special 30 amp receptacle on that line - code says you can't use your existing GFCI and receptacle. In fact, you don't even want that GFCI.

The electrician should have mounted a 30 amp 110v receptacle for your DC and changed the plug to one that will fit. Assuming the 10 ga wire is run to ALL downstream receptacles, they also need to be a 30 amp receptacles (if you want to follow code) This may require changing the plugs on anything plugged into those additional outlets.

Is this a new line the electrician installed or did he "upgrade" an existing circuit? If this is an upgrade and the electrician ran 10 ga wire to the first receptacle and left existing 12 ga wire for the outlet (or outlets) downstream, that may be a problem and potentially dangerous on a 30 amp circuit.

If this is the case, you could do what was mentioned earlier: replace the GFCI with a standard receptacle, replace the 30 amp breaker with a 20 amp, and see if the DC works ok. The whole circuit would be 20 amp then and everything else could be left alone. (if you don't have experience, an electrician or your brother-in-law should do this.)

Of course, since I am not a licensed electrician my opinions on this are just like those of anyone else who is not a licensed electrician - based on experience and my own research, not something to base your own safety on.

BTW, I did a lot of wiring in the central highlands in Mexico. Anyone here would be aghast at what we found there. The worst I saw was bare copper wires carrying 110v ac, stapled in parallel down concrete block walls in a store - right where even a kid could reach up and touch. I guess the ones that are still around are the ones that learned quickly. Another thing was a 50 amp breaker feeding 14 ga romex strung 100 ft across an attic to a water heater. Disaster waiting to happen. It was several years before I made it back with the right supplies to fix that one.

JKJ

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#23

A.J. Hamler

Thanks, all

A.J. Hamler

Thanks, everyone. Tons of good info here. (Some of it, I can even understand. )

Obviously, something's not right in my setup. However, since every thing worked fine previously before getting the remote switch (and again, after posting all of this in testing it w/o the switch), I'm thinking that the DC is fine and there has to be something amiss with that remote switch that won't let it interact with the GFCI. Still haven't gotten a reply on my email to the mfg. May be time for a phone call.

Meantime, just for a lark I plugged a number of other tools into that same GFCI on that same 30-amp circuit, and none of them had issues with tripping it. Again, I'm thinking the issue is the remote switch.

Meantime, the DC works fine 100% of the time w/o the switch on that circuit and about 50% of the time with it on that circuit, so I'm still in business.

Thanks again.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#24

Re: Thanks, all

William Duffield

For another lark, you might experiment with plugging other machines into the long ranger, at least one with an induction motor and one without.

Re: DC tripping protected outlet

#25

A.J. Hamler

Update

A.J. Hamler

After waiting a week and never receiving a response from Penn State on my email outlining the issue, I called them directly today and talked to one of their technical guys.

Seemed clueless as to why it would do that, and the best advice I got from him was to plug it in somewhere else. Not surprisingly, that wasn't much help.

As a couple folks here have suggested I think I'm just going to take that GFCI outlet off the circuit -- again, it's a dedicated circuit on one wall of the shop only, just for a couple high-amp-draw tools -- and replace it with a regular one. If/when I sell the house, I'll put the GFCI outlet back.