Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

Posts

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#26

Re: Just my 2 cents...

John K Jordan

Same here, a big framing nailer plus five or six smaller nailers and staplers. (Ever use a palm nailer? Beautiful in a tight spot, incredibly dangerous if misused.)

While I don't unload after use, I am careful to aim the business end away from me at all times. Resting it on the knee or hand or head at any time would not be smart. If someone breaks into my shop and shoots their head with my nailer or drills a hole in their leg or sticks their hand in the drum sander I will feel sorry for them and send them a get well card.

My builder friend has used multiple framing nailers every day for many years and has never had one fire unintentionally. Last time I checked also doesn't hold it up to his head. He did have an employee cut his thumb off with a kickback while free ripping. There are hazards everywhere for the careless.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#27

Re: Just my 2 cents...

William Duffield

My new one has the optional bump mode, and I've decided I'll never be in such a hurry that I would accept the additional risk involved in using it. Before I loaded it with nails and before I connected it to air, I tried out the mode controls, just so I know how to operate it, so I won't activate it out of ignorance.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#28

Such Silliness is

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

written to try to protect people who are not in the upper tier of the IQ scale, and people who are dedicated to the principal that they know more than the rest of us.

Nail guns are machines. Machines malfunction despite "safeties" and such; it's in their nature, and their capacity to inflict serious injury have been proven thousands of times over. If a simple instruction to unload the gun before connecting the air hose saves one life, it's not silly, especially to the person who followed the advice and avoided injury when the thing malfunctioned.

Famous last words: "I've done this hundreds of times," "Hey, easy, there's nothing to go wrong."

I seem to have missed someone trying to get you to follow the direction, John. I'm certainly not trying to do so. But you seem to be advocating for others here to ignore it. If that's your real point, to ignore advice because you personally regard it as "silly" or just some lawyer's bs, then don't get annoyed when others have different views and experience.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#29

Its not in a machine's nature...

John in NM

Malfunctions are in worn parts or faulty engineering, or sometimes improper modification. That is the point.

Machines do not capriciously do things on their own, but humans love to anthropomorphize to satisfy either their tendency towards superstition or the desire to pretend that mistakes they make are someone else's fault.

I do not advocate that people do anything other than observe and make up their own minds. I maintain that there is no need to have the nailer empty when connecting air to it, because an in spec nailer will not discharge spontaneously. No one has explained how it will do this, apparently finding "because they said so" to be sufficient.

If you want to cast that as foolish, that is your business, but you won't be able to defend such a position. Physics is on my side, and outside a courtroom the laws of physics trump the closed mind that follows rules for the sake of following rules.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#30

Guilty

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

have to confess, I've never once in 15 years, checked any one of my nail guns for "worn parts" and doubt that I would recognize a part as being worn to the point of being dangerous if I did, especially a part that might actually cause the gun to fire when connected. Granted, my guns have not had the use a framing crew gun would have, and I do keep them clean and stowed, but I learned to use them from friends who are pro framers, roofers, and finish carpenters. Can't tell if they read the "instructions" and legal bs in the pamphlets packed with their guns. Can tell that they seem to have adopted various ways of doing things, and connecting a loaded framing gun doesn't seem to be one of them.

Now you may have the last word as I take my closed mind and blindly conformist attitudes to a different subject.

peace

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#31

Re: Guilty

Barry Irby

I am guilty too. As I mentioned above I had a Senco Framing nailer (SN-IV) that would eject a nail fairly often when we connected it to the hose. Now that I think about it, (because of this thread) it would have been smarter for us to unlaod the gun at the end of the day, or at least retract the nails and and move the slider (?) forward so there was no nail "in the chamber".

I can tell you than it did it often enough that if anyone had connected the air with the snoot pointed at a body part, say your thigh, they woudl have been shot. Certainly not every time, but fairly quickly you woudl have been taught a lesson.

This is sort of like the Turners saying to learn to stay out of the line of fire. If you constantly use a bad habit, the gun only has to misfire once. If you do any thing thousands of times, you will make a mistake. Some how your fat winter coat will retract the nose safety and you left pinky will be on the trigger and you will connect the hose and you get shot, unless you ALWAYS point it somewhere else.

I too don't work on my guns. I am only vaguely aware of their internal workings. In some respects, I don't care how they work. Magic for all I care. I have seen enough accidents with them to stay out of the way. Nails and staples that curled around. I've shot the side of one nail with another nail. Stay out of the line of fire. Keep your fingers back.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#32

You forgot the laws of entropy.


Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#33

Explain please...

John in NM

Depends on how you use the word "entropy"

If you wish to use it scientifically, you will be unable to apply it to this discussion because in that context it does not mean what I suspect you think it means.

If you want to use it in the typical pop culture way, fine, it means unpredictable for the most part, though in this regard it is not a law at all. And my material point is that this is predictable, nail guns that are in spec should not do this under any circumstances. Way back at the beginning of all this I said that I do not take the precaution recommended because my few nailers/staplers are in spec. They are in spec or they are repaired/replaced.

All this fuss over worrying about what someone else does. Astounding!

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#34

No explanation necessary.

BrianMonumentCO

John,

If you want to ignore common sense advise to follow basic safety instructions.

That is YOUR problem.

Good luck.

I will not make any further responses.

I find your posts and your lack of interest in basic safety to be irresponsible.

Good luck.

EOF.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#35

Sure it is...

John in NM

Words have meanings. You either used this one completely incorrectly, or the matter is open to debate (if you intended to use it in the pop culture sense). I asked which it was, and you did not answer.

I disagree that the recommendation under discussion here is common sense advice. I find it reasonable to conclude that it is un-necessarily over cautious, for reasons I have already stated. Whether this conclusion is reasonable or not is open to debate, which is what we have been doing.

Exiting a debate is a reasonable path if you cannot adequately defend your position in the debate.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#36

In Case You Missed The Memo . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

WoodCentral is not rec.crafts.woodworking and nobody here is running for elective office, at least not openly.

If you're actually looking for a debate forum, try Fox News or the RNC.

In the mean time, by all means fell free to just ignore any "alleged" advice you see posted here which you dislike.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#37

Gee, thought you were done

John in NM

If Ellis or Bill wish to cut off debate, that is their prerogative and I will politely agree.

But if there is one thing that will get a fight out of me, it is guys like you playing the bully. You should know that, we've done this before.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#38

re: in spec/out of spec/worn parts/etc...

John Coloccia

Things like pneumatic/hydraulic valves are designed to work under pressure and don't necessarily function properly/seal fully/whatever until the system is properly pressurized.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#39

Oh, But I Am

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

and you have "won"

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#40

True enough....

John in NM

But I suspect that is more true of older models, like the Senco Barry owned. It would not be a difficult task for a clever engineer to design a nail gun that does not discharge spontaneously as it wears, and I would speculate that this has a lot to do with the infrequency of the described event.

Parts do wear however, defeating the intentions of even the most diligent engineer - which is why I pay close attention to the overall function of tools like pneumatic nailers. When they malfunction they are retired or repaired promptly - that seems to be common sense to me.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#41

Rather OT - Re: Oh, But I Am

John in NM

Won? No, I wouldn't say so at all.

Winning is proving one's point or learning something from having one's point disproven, it doesn't matter a whole lot which it ends up being. Demonstrable truth is more important than opinion, and winning is understanding the truth regardless of one's opinion on any subject. Having one's opponent simply give up is not winning.

That is all kind of abstract I realize, but that is what I think the point of debating is - to learn truth through challenging others to prove you wrong.

In that regard, perhaps a successful debate is when someone convinces you to change your opinion, incongruous though that sounds. Its the only way the debate actually closes, if that is what we are to use as a measure of success.