Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

Posts

Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#1

Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

William Duffield

I just acquired a framing nailer, and (believe it or not) I was actually reading the directions. I warns that I should always connect the air before loading the nails, because connecting air pressure may cause the gun to cycle, discharging a nail. I'm OK with following that advise. My concern is that I already have four other assorted pin, nail and staple guns, and hadn't noticed that warning in their instructions. Is this something that is only possible with framing nailers, or could it happen with my other guns as well? I usually leave the other guns loaded when I put them away and sometimes even disconnect the air before reloading them. I'm thinking those practices may not be safe.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#2

Framing nailers scare the hell out of me

Dick Coers

It takes a lot of force to set those long nails, so it's a BIG deal when they fire. When I built my garage, firing that thing by my head to nail the rafter to the ridge beam, was really stressful! Never heard that one could fire when hooking up the hose. How could it fire without pressing down on the safety nose?

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#3

Sure

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

There's not a single part of the human anatomy that reportedly has NOT been nailed by a gun of some sort.

When connecting air, I ALWAYS point the gun in a "safe" direction. I EXPECT it to cycle.

Do I empty the guns after disconnecting them? No

Do I leave nails in them? Always.

Do I always check the nose piece before connecting? Absolutely.

Has one of mine fired when first connected? Nope

To answer Dick's question: In a wood shop, and more-so in a construction situation, it's pretty easy for the nose-piece to get stuck, by a piece of dirt or flotsam or a slightly bent slider, in the "unsafe" position such that an operator in a hurry forgets to check it, connects the gun, and POW!, call the EMTs

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#4

Common nail gun mishap "U" turn *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

I haven't seen what you describe happening, but I do see this happen fairly frequently, especially when fastening denser hardwoods like oak:

18 AWG finish nailer, assembling the myriad of trim pieces when I trimmed out my home. Yes, the 18 AWG was used often due to the casing design. I used the 16 AWG for installing major pieces like base moulding, plinth blocks, etc. Never had this issue with the 16 AWG.

Nail makes a "U" turn. Yep. A "U" turn. Example, nailing a 5/8"x 1" piece of trim to the edge of a 5/8" piece of casing. A 1 1/4" nail goes in, then comes right back out adjacent to the hole it went in, protruding about a half inch. It didn't go flying, but I was glad I didn't have my finger next to the nose of the gun when I nailed that one. It is an odd feeling to see the end of a nail you just fired pointing back at you!

I think what was happening was I had the long axis of the nailer parallel to the workpiece, and the chisel tip on the nail followed some dense grain upon entering the wood. This curved the nail left, and that deflection bent the nail on its thin axis, which curved the nail, which caused its trajectory. It poked back out of the board pointed right at me. Sobered,yet intrigued, I closely examined the nails and realized that the nails are actually slightly rectangular in cross section. This means they are predisposed to bending left or right, but not as much front to rear. I now take advantage of this knowledge to orient my nailer so as to have a smaller chance of side blowout when nailing smaller parts. I guess I learned the hard way.

I searched and have linked to an article that speaks to this below. It is called blowout, and my self discovery is actually known by many, apparently.

I also have a pin nailer which bit me one time as I tried to tack some mini round over to a small project. I similar thing occurred, and I was using the longer pin nails I had on hand at the time. The nail came out in a place I wasn't expecting and just nicked a finger on old poophead (funny name I have given to my underperforming left hand).

Lesson is, keep your digits away from the nailing area. Use a block, clamp, etc. to hold the pieces in place, NOT your digits. Also, don't use longer nails than needed, as longer nails deflect more easily.

Hey, at least ol' poophead can share with the typing pretty good!

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa


Pneumatic nailers and blowout

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#5

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

Barry Irby

I have used many nail guns over many years. Had a Senco framing nailer that used to sort of cough out a nail when the hose was connected. NEVER point it at anything you want to keep.

Have had finish nailers do the U-Turn Dick was talking about many times. He's right. Keep the digits way back.

One time I was trimming out a house and leaned of the edge of a balcony Installing a piece of trim under the lip. The nail came through and touched me on the knee. Just touched my knee cap. Didn't hurt or draw blood. I took the rest of the day off.

In the same house I was way up on top of a ladder and got a jamb. Stupidly decided to fire the gun to clear the jamb. Retracted the safety and pulled the trigger. Somehow it shot a nail right through my index finger on my left hand. Luckily it went beside the bone. I climbed down thinking "somebody is going to have to pull that out." The guy working with me was as green as grass. Pulled it out myself, put a band aid on it and went back to work.

I have or have had about a dozen guns. I never bother to unload them and never disconnect them when loading or changing nails. But I NEVER point them in a dangerous direction.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#6

Re: The four rules

TomD

All guns are always loaded, all the time, no exceptions;

Never point a gun at anything you aren't willing to see destroyed;

Keep your finger off the trigger until your sights are on the target;

Be sure of your target and backstop (no hand on the other side, or bounce back risk)

Relax.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#7

Re: The four rules

BrianMonumentCO

TomD, You are absolutely correct for a firearm.

The rules you cited were the first things taught at my first journeyman position as a gunsmith.

Unfortunately this thread is about pneumatic nailers with people who feel they are immortal.

They appear to believe that the can survive an accident.

And they appear to do things that make accidents possible.

MY RULES for pneumatic nailers

1. wear safety glasses

2. clear all nails from nailer prior removing or connecting air

3. clear all jams on ground level by removing nails and air.

4. sore all pneumatic nailers properly (ie in a case/box)

5. never leave a pneumatic nailer loaded.

I wonder if any actually put a drop of oil into the air nailer occasionally as many require.

(IIRC some do not require oil.)

Just my 2 cents.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#8

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

Bob Entwisle in NJ

I have followed that rule with the brad nailer that i use, (I read instructions) and it makes sense to me on some level that through transport and rattling/vibrating around that the firing mechanism could end up in an unsafe position, and that the act of connecting he air line could result in the gun firing.

I've never had it happen, never heard of it happening etc.

(And I toss a few drops of oil into the gun every time i use it too, also recommended in the instructions.)

Bob in NJ.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#9

Re: The four rules

TomD

I wouldn't ague with that. But if the main concern is shooting oneself I would probably still stay with the four rules. The shooting guys could have added hearing pottection, and safety glasses and maintenance, etc... But they wisely focused on not shooting stuff that is not the intended target. General accidents can bring in everything from the electrical system and compressor maintenance, to hearing protection and the many good points you mention.

Maybe it is just the kind of accident they feel entitled to recall in trade publications, but there seem a remarkable number of framing nailer victims who latter fully recover. Obviously not to be relied on, but a cavalcade of x-ray pictures of heads with fully embedded nails does raise the question of how large the target in these heads was n the first place.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#10

I like to understand why,

Keith Newton

William, If I had just bought a new gun, and read this, my first reaction would be to try to make it happen, so I would know what to expect.

I think a good test would be to leave the nails in, then pull the trigger without the air line connected, then bump the tip. Then I would connect the hose, with it pointed into the ground to see if I could make it happen.

I suspect on a gun this size, with a smaller hose, it will spit the nail out at a fairly slow velocity. If it spits it out harder than you like, you can couple the air slowly, allowing lots of pressure to escape while connecting the hose.

If you know you can make it shoot a nail just by connecting the hose, you'll always know to point it in a safe direction when connecting the hose.

Also, rather than removing all the nails from the magazine, you probably can just hold the lever on the spring feeder back, while moving the nail back a couple of inches, then letting the feeder reel up to the front ahead of the nails, without having to go through the extra motions of taking them out then putting them back.

Personally I think there are lots of greater hazards than this one. Do they offer any safety tips to prevent double firing, to prevent you from shooting your hand, or someone else downrange?

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#11

Lest We Forget

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The Darwin Effect is at full strength and operational in this situation.

I've been around and worked with framers for decades, and witnessed some really stupid practices with nail guns. One very common among framers was taping back the trigger so the gun would fire with only a bump. Guns came with 2 triggers; one for "pros" and the other for "normal" peoples' safety.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#12

Never even heard of that before...

John in NM

But then I'm not real big on either nail guns or reading instructions.

If I had a nail gun that discharged on connecting the hose, I would conclude that it was very poorly engineered and probably get rid of it.

That this is not a notorious fault of nail guns tells me that the warning is from the lawyers rather than the engineers.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#13

Re: Never even heard of that before...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I had an electric staple gun that would fire a staple every time the power cord was connected. I have also been present when a framing gun fired at connection, but it was one of those "tied-back" speed nailers that I mentioned above. The guy using it didn't seem surprised or concerned so I gathered it wasn't the first time. I also kept a safe distance between him and me :\

Given the way nail guns are mistreated in the wild, with or without OTJ modifications, I always use extreme caution when using someone else's guns.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#14

Re: The four rules

William Duffield

It appears I have started a very interesting conversation. Thanks for all the thoughtful replies. I expected there would be a lot of different opinions.

I'm not sure why there should be a separate set of rules for nail guns and regular guns. They have a lot of similarities, and there is a continuum of devises between one class and the other. e.g., There are BB guns, CO2 powered BB Guns, air rifles, and the Remington 476 and its ilk.

There must also be some overlap between hunters and framing carpenters. :D

I have seven pneumatic guns and rotary devices. All but one call for periodic applications of oil. The only one that advertises "oil free" is a Porter-Cable 16 gauge finish nailer. I always add oil as recommended to the others.

I suspect that the reasons for the warning about my initial question has a lot to do with the lawyers' recommendations, but the warning wouldn't be there if it were not at least remotely possible, even if only in the state of California. This kind of discharge might be more likely if the gun gets abused or full of crud, or as it wears.

I think from now on, I will unload all five of my guns whenever I've finished using them. Like a "real" gun, there is always the chance that someone unfamiliar with their operation, or a child, might get access to them.

I know that it is all too easy to become complacent with safety as one gets more familiar with any power tool, and that makes them even more dangerous, even though Homo stultus may believe he is infallible and immortal.


I've seen more than enough evidence of that from people who disparage SawStop.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#15

Soooooo...

John in NM

What does this have to do with my post? I don't recall recommending any kind of imprudent behavior, just observing that as nail gun problems go, this one strikes me as vanishingly unlikely.

That we have a total of one eyewitness account at this point - of a hacked nailer - tends to support that assertion. My narrow crown stapler has a feature wherein you can repeat stapling by tapping the safety against the workpiece and it will fire so long as the trigger is depressed. I would guess that the event you saw was a combination of a similar engineered feature and the stupidity of defeating the safety. I do not think that is evidence for concern on the part of those who leave their pneumatic tool safeties un-altered.

You guys want to unload your nailers every time you're done? Have at it, you're quite welcome to do so. I won't bother, because the likelihood of what you fear is exceedingly small.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#16

Re: Soooooo...because

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

you "never heard of it" . . .

The CDC sure has . . . 37,000 ER visits being just the ones that got reported

http://www.cdc.gov/features/nailgunsafety/

With a bump-fire trigger-set, easy for this to happen at connection of high pressure air.

Would be interesting to see if there are finer detail on occurrences.

Framing crews are always under serious time pressure which can and do lead to careless mistakes and omissions.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#17

While that is a nice link...

John in NM

It is only marginally relevant to your point, since it covers all nailgun accidents (as your statistic does also) and the precautionary steps advocated in that link do not even include the one being discussed here!

Now since you've got me slightly annoyed here, I will point out, with some emphasis, that I did not say that I had never heard of a nailgun accident! I said I have never before heard of a nailgun discharging upon air connection. I acknowledged that I can easily see how defeating the safety could cause this problem.

Since neither of mine have safeties disconnected, I will continue to NOT unload it after every use, because I think to do so is silly.

The state of the safety mechanism is the problem here, not the act of connecting the air. It's a lawyers recommendation, not an engineer's.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#18

Re: I like to understand why,

BrianMonumentCO

But why would you deliberately take the risk of it firing out of spec?

That is asking for trouble.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#19

Re: While that is a nice link...

BrianMonumentCO

John, Good luck. I hope you never have to become a ER statistic.

But gambling is still gambling.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#20

Re: The four rules

BrianMonumentCO

I was only interested in using the basic 4 firearm rules as it applies to general gun use and not just hunting.

I do CAS (Cowboy Action Shooting) and we and other non-hunting shooting sports (IPSC, 3 gun) have a whole set of rules specific to that sport. Hunters also have a hunter safety class that they learn from.

Not sure what education a user of a pneumatic nailer has?

Also a felon can probably buy a pneumatic nailer while he would have no chance of LEGALLY buying a firearm from an FFL (pro gunsmith, gunstore, cabelas, bass pro etc.)

Hunters would have a natural understanding of how deadly/dangerous their "guns" are, while a framer/carpenter/whatever may not realize it.

In hollywood a pneumatic nailer is fatal, remember lethal weapon 2 (IIRC).

It took more than one nail but it drove the point home.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#21

Lawyers' Notices

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Looked at a wood chipper lately? Painted yellow but covered in stickers and labels. It was represented to me that every one of those little signs represents a different law suit following injury or death.

William's directions' caution about the air connection will have been the result of several, if not many, such activations when the air was connected. That's how such things get noticed at the corporate legal department and put in the owner's manual. Lawyer's warnings on stuff are always playing catch-up.

A wise and experienced attorney early on taught me to avoid making lists of possible occurrences in an agreement because "The baby ain't been born who could make a complete list to cover everything that can happen, so one of the many you miss is the one that'll gitcha."

John, you stated that you've never heard of the issue. Now you have. You need not be annoyed; no insult was intended. My point was that these things are dangerous and just because you (or I) haven't heard of a specific problem only means there is a gap in our personal experience.

BTW I leave nails in my finish gun and brad nailer. The big framer (sequential trigger and all), however, I unload when done.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#22

Re: While that is a nice link...

John in NM

If the statistics agreed with you, it would be a completely different story. The fact is that most nailgun accidents are due to misuse, defeating safety mechanisms, and somewhat careless use that is not misuse. I have witnessed all of those as well as the rest of us, and as I said before, neither I or any others have advocated such things.

What I am saying, and will continue to say, is that unloading a nailer after use is carrying coal to Newcastle. If you guys want to, go for it. I won't bother because it is silly.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#23

Re: I like to understand why,

William Duffield

Yes, there are several pages of warnings of bad things that can happen, through carelessness, gun malfunction or failure of the materials being joined.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#24

Re: Lawyers' Notices

John in NM

Wood chippers are not relevant to this discussion. Your point might apply if I were advocating the defeat of a safety mechanism, which I am not.

More likely this butt covering admonition is the result of the success of product liability suits that should have been tossed out. Some lawyer for the manufacturer is concerned they would lose in spite of the injured party having defeated the safety. So they give silly advice.

You have not yet convinced me of the pressing need to follow this advice.

Re: Pneumatic Nail Gun Safety Question

#25

Just my 2 cents...

Stuart Hough

I have 4 different size and make of nailers, from 18 ga. brad to 3.5" framing nailers. I always listen to that one bit of warning my father gave me..."If it CAN bite...it WILL one day." I never give them the chance. (Comment qualification: I am and have never used one for hire, so therefore have never had a time constraint on what I was doing. I tried the bump-fire feature on all and decided it was not something I needed to use, so I haven't in years.)