Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Logging for drawer sides

Posts

Logging for drawer sides

#1

Logging for drawer sides

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Quarter grain drawer stock is ideal for Period Furniture drawer sides because it responds less to humidity changes resulting in a more stable classically made drawer. But, it is hard to find quartered poplar in commercially manufactured lumber. So, make your own....

In just a short time we had billets for resawing over 200 sq ft of quarter grained drawer sides, or had it been beech, dozens of plane bodies.

Step 1 is to locate a large tree and sturdy son in law. A neighbor took down this 33" poplar that had spent most of its 85 year life growing in a dense forest only to wind up too close to their house. I supplied the sage advice to the job.

pic 1

Step 2 is to buck it into appropriate lengths.

pic 2


Step 3 saw a slab off each side. A chisel tooth chain does well here. Slabbing off both sides took 5 min or less.

pic 3



Step 4, split of saw out the center of the tree and discard it for firewood.

pic 4



Step 5 seal ends. I forget the Anchorseal so we used latex paint.

Step 6 put it somewhere to dry where it has good air circulation on all sides but not in direct sun. These billets will be ready to resaw for final drying at the end of summer next year.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#2

Pic 2

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Is that a WoodCentral hat laying on the ground in that picture?

Isn't it illegal to allow a WoodCentral hat to touch the ground?

Well, I guess it isn't on the ground, it on a shirt or jacket. Maybe that's ok then.

:b

Nice write up as usual. Thanks for sharing.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#3

Ellis Walentine

Question for you

Ellis Walentine

Nice tutorial, Bill. No doubt, this is a recommended way to harvest drawer side material. It's interesting to me that you decided to keep your log sections intact instead of reducing them further. I have to wonder how well seasoned the interior wood will be at the end of next summer. At one year per inch, it could take a lot longer than that for the moisture to equalize, even though the billets are short. The amount of moisture loss through the sealed endgrain will probably be very similar to the loss through the side grain, but overall seasoning would be faster if the billet were reduced to smaller sections.

Another issue is how serious you are about having true quartersawn material for the sides, and how you plan to resaw it. Sawing that billet through and through will yield more rift material than quartered. Of course, I'm sure you are willing to accept grain that is +/- 15º - 30º from true quartered, which would still have the benefit of stability and minimal shrinkage, if not a particular ray pattern, which wouldn't be pronounced or prized in poplar anyhow.

Musical instrument billets, which are intended to yield perfect quartersawn material for guitar tops and sides, are typically riven or sawn exactly perpendicular to the growth rings, resulting in tapered sections depending on the diameter of the original log.

I have a couple nice sassafras logs I just took down that would be perfect for drawer sides, and I'm intrigued about this prep process.

Ellis

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#4

What does it take to bury the year per inch myth

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I saw 4/4 lumber in May it is down to 25% in a month if it is poplar and 3 months if it is oak. These times illustrate the uselessness of the year per inch myth. How long it takes lumber to dry depends on species, thickness, grain orientation, air circulation, temperature, humidity, ultimate moisture content target and probably something I forgot. I sawed some 12/4 walnut some years ago and stacked it inside with restricted air circulation so it would dry slowly to mitigate splitting around a crotch. In 2 years it was in the 12% range and ready for resawing and final drying. On the other hand in a cold damp climate it might take a year for 4/4 lumber to get to 25% and infinity to get to 10%.

In the summer air circulating out of freshly stacked poplar will be cold from the evaporative cooling.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#5

Re: Question for you

terry quiram

I would cut the painted ends off and apply anchorseal. Paint isn't the best thing to use. I would also cut these into boards and sticker them for drying. If you don't your drying time will be 2 years instead of 1, unless you plan to kiln dry.

I have an old desk with QS Sycamore. Its pretty cool.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#6

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The amount of moisture loss through the sealed endgrain will probably be very similar to the loss through the side grain....in fact I expect it to be way less and zero had I remembered the Anchorseal. Under unsealed conditions the loss through the end grain is about 10X faster which would result in unacceptable end checking of these short pieces. I don't seal long lumber.

Another issue is how serious you are about having true quartersawn material for the sides........NHLA standards for quartered lumber is grain orientation of 30% or less. Seems a reasonable target for drawers.

, and how you plan to resaw it...... band saw parallel to one of the chain sawed faces.

I will leave it to dry in large billets until the piece is 20% or less. It will stay straight dried in a large chunk. It will get resawed into 5/8" rough stock for drawer sides a month or so before I need drawer sides and then dried to 8% someplace warm. If resawed after the billet is essentially dry the resawed boards will stay relatively flat as they complete drying.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#7

drying strategy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have dried thousands of bd ft of poplar. I am doing what I am doing based on prior experience.

If I sawed 5/8" boards from these billets while they were still wet these small boards could warp into useless potato chips as they dried. I will dry the chunks until they experience most of the shrinkage they will experience, then resaw the rough cut sides, followed by final drying to useable moisture content.

Works for me. Others experience may differ.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#8

Drying sassafras

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have dried similar sassafras billets. This species dries as easily as poplar if not easier. I didn't even bother to end seal and it dried flawlessly. I never thought of it as drawer sides before. But what a pleasant odor when opening a drawer from the appropriate cabinet. Must work that idea into some future project.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#9

I don't get what step 3 contributes

Keith Newton

If you are after QS, you have ruined a good portion of your log by cutting off those slabs.

As easy as the chain saw does a rip cut in this manner, I'm also a bit baffled by driving in wedges. Why didn't you just saw right through the center to quarter it or eight's or 16ths. While poplar isn't a hard wood to saw when dry, almost if not all woods are about half as hard when green, so it would be easier now than later.

Latex primer is a pretty good end sealer.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#10

yes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I worked up a terrific sweat watching Tom work and had to shed my shirt and hat. We had no limb to hang it on. In retrospect it would have looked nice on the Pivey handle.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#11

I think you need to run a test here.

Keith Newton

Your statement about them turning into pringles might be true if flat-sawn in some other of the "white woods" like Sycamore, and Sweetgum which have a lot of grain runout. But a good forest Poplar like this QS should stay flat.

Before this gets archived, I'd like to see you post this in a sawmill forum for feedback.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#12

Re: I don't get what step 3 contributes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This tree had 1000 bdft of logs. I was after a few years supply of drawer sides reduced to billets I could lift and in a shape that was easy to stack and eventually resaw. All the steps were directed to reach this goal in a short time. The rest was firewood, 60+ blocks of it.

You are encouraged to illustrate your sawing strategy to meet your objectives.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#13

Re: I think you need to run a test here.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I cut timber one summer, had part interest in a hardwood mill for a short time, ran a hardwood lumber business for 30+ years , have sawed and dried thousands of bd ft of poplar for the business, and have built many chests of drawers. I have sawed quartered lumber on a circle mill when that was my objective. What I did here met my objectives and I am uninterested in what the sawmill form thinks of them. Their results (and objectives) may differ.

Rather than insinuate I don't know what the hell I am dong I encourage you to post what you would have done to meet your objectives for rescuing some drawer stock from a firewood tree. The bystanders can learn from the different approaches to meet their specific needs.

BTW, to ward off criticism of poplar for firewood, there was a reasoned objective here too, outside the scope of this forum.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#14

Ellis Walentine

Re: drying strategy

Ellis Walentine

Yeah, I saw 2" planks usually, depending on what I intend to use the wood for. Warping isn't much of an issue unless the wood is flatsawn, which of course this isn't. Even at 5/8", I don't see warping as an issue, especially if the boards are properly stickered.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#15

Ellis Walentine

Not a rule

Ellis Walentine

One inch per year is less of a rule than something to think about. I know, for example, that if I cut 36" diameter red oak (which I did after Hurricane Sandy blew down about 20 of my biggest trees) and cut it into firewood length, that it retains a lot of moisture even five years later, and that's without sealing the ends. All I'm arguing here is that it is a matter of degree, not a hard and fast rule.

As for how I would cut those blanks, if I wanted quartersawn wood, I'd cut them into quarters and let them season that way. They're a lot easier to carry, too.

Ellis

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#16

Poplar Firewood?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Warms you 4 times

1. When you cut it

2. When you stack it

3. When you carry it in

4. When you haul the ash out

Burning the stuff, however, is a waste of effort.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#17

there is a time and place

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What one does must be measured against objectives at hand. There is a time and place for easy to split poplar firewood. Personally, for my needs and my fireplace I never harvest it. It wasn't my tree, my fireplace or my needs. My goal was to rescue some drawer siders with little effort.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#18

Clarification of objectives

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The overall objective of the effort was to cut up some massive poplar logs into firewood lengths. The objective of the project illustrated was not to recover as much perfectly quartered lumber as possible from these logs. Had this been the objective the sawing strategy would have been substantially different and the time it took vastly longer.

This massive tree, destined for firewood, yielded 60+ blocks of wood. Parts of a few of these blocks got quickly reduced to something that could be moved and eventually resawed on a band saw into thin drawer sides (typically about 7/16" finished) that are largely quarter grain for stability. Neither figure or yield were relevant to this effort. Time was most important. I doubt we had more than an hour is the drawer side part of it all.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#19

2" planks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I sawed drawer sides on a circle mill I sawed a light 6/4, then resawed after KD. But the sawing yesterday was with a chain saw in the field (literally) to be followed by a band saw prior to final drying at some later date.

Again for drawer sides on a circle mill, I split the log in half on the mill, turn the half moon down with the flat side on the carriage and saw it through. The narrow boards from the edges are rift cut and go into drawers that are not tall. The widest boards come from the middle of the cant and they are near perfect quarter grain for wide drawers. The useless center of the log and bark can be trimmed on the mill edger or on the band saw when resawing.

But I don't have access to a mill now and 33" poplar logs are not easy to come by in any case. It was an opportunity to be seized as best I could in a short time.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#20

Firewood example

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your firewood experience illustrates the uselessness of general drying time guidelines. I have dried firewood for every one of the last 30+ years so I have some experience. Had I stacked those blocks here in May with good air circulation and covered the pile they would be less than 30% MC by September. It is easy to know they are under 30% because at this MC the wood begins to shrink and the blocks radially crack.

For air dried lumber in these parts the rule of thumb is 90 days for oak and 30 days for poplar, on sticks with good air circulation. These times yield lumber that can be cheaply and easily KD with minimal risk of KD downgrade. They do not yield lumber ready to build stuff out off.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#21

Re: time and place

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Agreed.

Aside from QS drawer sides/slides, poplar makes good mulch. Easy to chip/shred and it breaks down fairly quickly to feed the soil and kkep the carbon in the grough where it does some good.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#22

Re: I don't get what step 3 contributes

John McGaw

Actually, I think that was exactly the right thing to do based upon the appearance of the heartwood of that tree. Added to that, it is safer to avoid burying the nose of the chainsaw in the center of a log when you are ripping -- being able to cut all the way through is less likely to cause problems.

I've watched a commercial sawyer (Full Cycle Woodworks here in TN) cutting really big trees for QS stock. Their method entails an experienced man standing up on top of a log that might be 4+ feet in diameter and ripping it lengthwise using a huge saw with a 3-foot bar and rip chain down the whole length, rotating the log 180-degrees and doing it again, and then ripping the two halves yielding four quarters that will fit in their small bandsaw mill. Even though they are experienced with the work and take safety precautions I cringe when I think about it. Imagine the ramifications if you are standing on top of the log you are sawing and there is a kickback. I know that they've done a white oak this way that measured 6-feet at the butt end.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#23

slow going

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It was common to split lengthwise a log too big to be sawed on a circle saw mills of days past. I've done it and it is slow and hard on the saw. It is times faster to cut with the bar parallel to the grain. Long stringy chips pour out and it is about as fast as cross cutting.


The more perpendicular you get to the grain the more the chips become fine dust which indicates slow cutting. It may be that chain saw mills use a different chain. I don't know anything about them.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#24

Re: slow going

John McGaw

What I've used is simply called a "rip chain" at Bailey's and I believe that they are identical to what is used in chainsaw mills. They are sharpened differently than a regular cross-cut chain (don't ask me how) and are often skip-tooth to reduce the load on the engine. Even with a fresh rip chain it took me a very long time to rip the last maple and hickory logs I tried it with. No fun to produce even 6-foot flitches.

Re: Logging for drawer sides

#25

Re: Clarification of objectives

Yonak

Bill, this is a very interesting essay. I have learned a lot from it. I must say you have taken a lot of guff (actually good challenging questions) for your efforts and, it seems to me, all of your answers are to the point and sensible. Thank you for this educational thread.