I am screwing up my courage to start converting my house and shop to LED lights. actually bought a case of replacements for Incandescent bulb and CFL's and installed the first one the other day. They will go in as the other die.
I was using a flashlight with a LED in it in a crawl space examining a furnace during a Home Inspection and noticed the exhaust fan appeared to be strobing. Possible? I know there are some electronics involved in the residential bulbs that reduce the current but I don't know to what effect. Have no idea what's happening in a flashlight.
LED bulbs meant to screw into standard home fixtures are a mixed bag. Their efficiency and potential strobing are tied to the method used to convert mains AC power to the DC which drives the actual LEDs. There are cheap simple ways to do it and there are intermediate ways and then there are optimal ways. If the maker goes all-in and uses the best methods there should be no visible strobing and the bulb will also work well with (most) household dimmers. The cheapest bulbs will have definite 120Hz pulsing in North America (100Hz in Europe) because there is nothing involved other than a full-wave bridge rectifier.
I believe that all high-end LED flashlights use active rather than passive current limiting which means that the DC current is pulsed and this might cause strobing if the frequency and speed were closely related. This wouldn't seem to be a common thing in regular use since the pulse frequency is very high. If the flashlight has dimming mode and/or flash settings then it certainly is using active current limiting. The throw-away LEDs from HF seem to have no other current limiting than the internal resistance of the cells; at least I could find nothing in tearing down those that have failed.
It was a product of old style magnetic ballasts to be found in old style T12 fluorescent fixtures. If the goal is to be rid of flicker, one only has to jump forward one step in technology to the now government required electronic ballasts and not all the way to the trendy LED technology.
Some led lights only use a half wave rectifier so they are off 60 times per second and on 60 times per second. Many people can see the flicker on half wave rectified lights. Most household led's I've encountered thus far seem to be flicker free.
I have various LED bulbs over my lathes, purchased at the big box stores. Some of these have obvious strobing that I can see on spinning wood, but not on stationary objects. It is not objectionable, probably because I use a mix of various LED and CFL lights. (The best CFLs I've found are those made for photography.)
There is still some strobing in modern fluorescent and LEDs, it's just that the effect is at a frequency not readily detected by the human eye. At some speed on my lathe I can see the results of strobing with both electronic ballasted fluorescents and LEDs.
Not sure about screw in type LED's, but some of the street lights I have installed can strobe rapidly if there is a problem with the driver in the fixture. There are a few that I drive by in the morning and the strobing is very noticeable. So I would say "yes" but only in the context that I have installed these fixtures.
LED's are transistor devices powered by DC current. I suppose if the DC power supply is poor the DC will vary some and in fact the light output of an LED is current dependent which in turn could be voltage dependent. So maybe I answered my question but I am still skeptical this small variation would be perceived as flicker. Personally I don't see it in LED's or modern electronic ballast fluorescent. It annoyed me to distraction with the magnet ballast fluorescents of days past.
Depending on how an AC source is used to drive an LED there can be pulsing of the supplied voltage, usually 60 or 120 Hz.
Battery powered stuff like flashlights may use a pulsed DC current in order to achieve variable brightness settings and for reducing power consumption so they run cooler.
In the case of pulsed DC I would expect the frequency to be higher that the eye/brain can discern, but in the case of Barry's fan blade example it seems more likely - the constructive interference of the high frequency pulse with the fan blade frequency could easily lead to a visible strobe effect. A good test would be to go back to the same furnace and try the flashlight on different brightness settings - most have more than one these days. I bet the strobe is only visible on the lower ones. I'm sure the homeowners won't mind a followup visit from Barry
I don't perceive the flicker with my eye. I see it in the strobe effect on some speeds on my lathe where the spinning work appears to slow or stop even when still running.
The old fluorescent bulbs (magnetic ballast) gave me a headache from the flicker, new ones don't, not because the flicker isn't there but because the frequency is beyond what I perceive. But just because it isn't perceptible doesn't mean it is gone. And it may be important or not depending on what you're doing. I have adapted by placing an incandescent bulb over my lathe.
Different people can see a given flicker differently. The eye/brain can integrate (smooth) the flicker down to certain frequencies; I wonder if differences in the detectable frequency can stem from physiological differences in the cells in the retina.
I noticed this interesting wiki page but I'll have to save to read it later:
We learned about "flicker vertigo" in flight school: some people get violently ill from light through the prop and some are not affected. (Never bothered me) In extreme and rare cases it can trigger epilepsy-like seizures.
I find driving down a road with sunlight flickering through the trees to be very annoying. Fortunately the situation usually only lasts a short time. Might be like the light through the prop except its not nearly as consistent or long lived.
A battery is a perfect DC source, perfect for what a LED needs. Brightness is a function of voltage. So why would one add complex circuitry to make a pulsed DC source to power a flashlight when simply adding a resister would suffice to dim it?
An answer could be that some flashlights have a pulsed mode (for why I never understood, cool factor?) so I suppose with this circuitry already there it might be easy to just change the frequency. I hope someone with an oscilloscope provides a definitive answer to this question.
And as such I would not expect the brightness to vary much as a function of voltage the way an incandescent bulb does. Varying the bias voltage to a semiconductor generally does not give you a linear current draw outside a narrow range. But without digging into the web (for which I am too dull tonight) I can't really say more than that.
We have several electrical experts running around here, perhaps one of them can provide the off the cuff answer that I can't.
I will point out though, that when I refer to a pulsed supply for dimming, I'm not talking about that silly strobe effect that some LED flashlights offer. I'm talking about pulsing at a high enough frequency that the eye perceives fewer photons over a given (and very short) time. In this regard, our eyes appear to work as integrating imagers, though much more sensitive ones than your average CCD.
>So why would one add complex circuitry to make a pulsed DC source to
>power a flashlight when simply adding a resister would suffice to dim it?
I have a good oscilloscope and could check for you but I'm busy the next few weeks.
A resistor would waste power, reducing battery life, and would lock the flashlight to a specific voltage. For example, some flashlights can run on several battery types, such as either two CR123A non-rechargable or one rechargeable 18650. These are different voltages and would need two different resistors, but a pulsed switching regulator can handle this for pennies.
One reason LED bulbs are pulsed is a switching regulator is a very efficient way to exactly control (and adjust) the current, voltage, and therefore brightness. The electronics to are so cheap they are almost free these days.
Many LED flashlights are controlled by a regulator using pulse width modulation. This pulse has nothing to do with the stupid flashing modes the manufacturers put on lights. (I refuse to buy one that forces me to SOS or strobe the light at some point.) The pulses from the regulator have to do with controlling the power and therefore brightness. A flashlight that has different brightness settings will be pulsed with a lower duty cycle for dimmer settings. A 100% duty cycle will give full brightness.
The duty cycle is adjusted to give a more constant brightness as the battery voltage decreases. My favorite pocket light has four brightness settings (controllable with a switch separate from the on/off button). As the battery dies, the percentage ON time of the duty cycle of the pulse is modulated, increased to keep the brightness constant. The brightest setting is already at 100% so it can't be adjusted - I can always tell when the batteries are getting low when the brightest setting starts looking just like the next brightest!
Another reason to pulse LEDs (and laser diodes) is to save power. The battery can last a lot longer if the LED is only on part of the time. This reduces heat as well. Some of my very bright lights get VERY hot on high power and really suck the power. Fortunately full power is not needed much here on the farm.
I don't know if LEDs bulbs that run on 110v are pulsed for power or brightness reasons. Some people claim that pulsing a light increases the apparent brightness but I have no knowledge of that. I suppose the combination of visual image persistence and short, very bright pulses might have that effect.
Since you asked (well you didn't but someone might), my hands down favorite pocket light is the Fenix LD22.
I have maybe 6 of these stashed in various places. What I like:
- compact, fits nicely in pocket
- uses standard AA batteries (2)
- has a non-nonsense ON/OFF switch (aren't forced to cycle through modes)
- the switch is done right (momentary with a soft push, click for full ON)
- has four levels of brightness, changed with a separate switch on the side
- quite bright at highest setting, 215 lumens, can see across field
- will last 150 hours on dim setting - fine for walking around
- reasonably priced compared to some of the ego lights
- the moronic SOS and strobe modes are just a touch away if you want one
My second favorite light is a Defiant with NO modes except ON/OFF, D-cells power for incredibly long life, so bright I got rid of all my spot bulky lights. I can find my horses in the pasture about 700 ft from my bedroom window. Quite cheap. Home Depot sells these periodically and I buy several each time as long as they are not offering the models with the idiotic mode cycling.
>...I would not expect the brightness to vary much as a function of voltage
>the way an incandescent bulb does.
I agree. But I was surprised at how much the brightness varied on an LED I was testing last night. Since this was not a component off the shelf but was pulled out of a ruined 4.5v flashlight (Maglight) mounted on a carrier perhaps it had more electronics inside than just the diode, perhaps a resistor. I hooked it up to a variable voltage power supply and cranked the voltage from zero to 4.5v. The LED switched on at some voltage (I didn't note what) but was extremely dim and ramped up smoothly to very bright at 4.5v.
One interesting experiment we did with an LED maybe 20-30 years ago: we put a jumbo red LED into a dewar of liquid nitrogen on my kitchen floor and cranked up the voltage. (Can't remember if there was a current limiting resister.) The LED accepted FAR more power at -320 deg F than it could have at room temperature. It got way brighter than we expected, so bright it made a red spotlight on the ceiling! There was no way we could look down into the dewar. Good clean fun!
The fancy electronica are cheap these days. I think the biggest reason for high prices is there is an undiscriminating person born every day. The snob appeal of the bestest and brightest for flashlights is amazing.
Another reason is the quality. For example, back when there was little competition Streamlight once had a very high reputation and very high prices. Now their prices on some lights are low but the quality has taken a big dive. People concerned about quality are willing to pay more.
For more info (and opinions!) about flashlights than one human can possibly absorb try the Candlepower Forum, full of both technical savy and lumen snobbery:
I never tried mapping the I-V curve of an LED back when I messed with this stuff, but what you describe from the maglite LED is a bit broader than I would have expected.
My experience with diodes is almost all empirical and limited to some very special cases - stuff like LED's I have a general idea of the theory and as long as it lights up I don't worry too much more about it.
The radio telescope I used to work for had mixer "diodes" a lot like what you describe with the LED in the LN2, only the mixers run at 4 Kelvin. At 5 Kelvin they start to lose the superconducting properties that make them more like diodes than resistors, and by 6 Kelvin they are simply resistors. Those had a very tight linear like zone on the I-V curve, on the order of mV. Still I would have guessed the flashlight to have something around a 1 V range (just shows you what guesses can be worth! )
I put the LED back on the power supply with the intent of paying closer attention. It switched on (so dim I couldn't see it without the lights turned off) at about 2.3 volts. I cranked up the voltage but forgot about it not being on the heat sink. The smoke came out around 4.3-4.6 volts! It appeared to ramp up brightness continuously without steps. Maybe I'll dissect the post-smoke module and see if there are tiny components inside.
I also did not think to measure and plot the light output with the lux meter. Duh. I hearby turn in my electronics, engineering, and experimental methods cards and go back to feeding llamas.
The high output lamps are pulsed to keep the heat down. They say heat kills them. You may want to confirm this claim
They are supposed to get brighter with more current....up to a point.
I suspect my $6 flashlight may not be as sophisticated and just run off battery voltage. I have been lusting over one that flashes SOS that I see at flea markets. And it has a red handle.
In tactical situation the flash is supposed to mildly incapacitate people. Flashing lights can cause seizure, so there is more than just dazzling light at work, possibly.
The better grade of lights are designed for uses that include mounting on guns. The power of these lights is critical to target identification and sighting. A low power light might mean you can only shoot to 30 yards, say. Then there are a wide variety of forces that the firing of guns can inflict, so that comes into play also.
I went through a lot of LED lights, virtually buying every one I saw for a while. Mostly they broke. The first one I got as a bike light, and while cheap it was good, I still have it. Many lights failed after relatively short term exposure to use on a bicycle, rattling down the road.
That was quite a comprehensive discussion of flashlights and all their component parts. And I thought the Hand Tool Forum obsessed about planes!
I know the battery stuff and this part is accurate with one exception so I would presume the other stuff is too.
Li-ion cells indeed can catch fire when over charged or charged too rapidly. They are ruined if over discharged. Hence, as far as I know, all Li-ion cells come with battery management electronics to prevent these occurrences. It is this electronics package that shuts the battery off (suddenly) when the battery reaches a specified discharge level.
If you use rechargeable batteries buy the best charger you can. It will pay off in battery life.