Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

sanding straight and flat

Posts

sanding straight and flat

#1

sanding straight and flat

Jerry Gibbs

I am in the middle of a project involving QSWO, but I have had this problem with other woods. I have trouble sanding without creating a bow or dish or other irregularity in a straight piece or flat panel. This is especially a problem when I am using coarse sandpaper, 80 grit or so, to remove initial irregularities. My frustration is that I know of the issue and am aware as I am sanding.

I have the usual assortment of portable tools, including random orbit, belt and vibrator sanders. I also have a stationary combination oscillating drum and belt sander. The platen on that machine is 7" for the belt. I do not have a wide belt or drum sanding stationary machine. Any suggestions are welcome. Jerry

Re: sanding straight and flat

#2

Re: sanding straight and flat

John K Jordan

Jerry, I'm certainly no expert but when I have something that I can't put through my wide drum sander (my first choice) I sand by hand using a piece of plywood with sandpaper attached with spray-on adhesive. I made up a number of these sanding boards (about 2"x10") with different grits.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#3

Re: sanding straight and flat

Jesse Cloud

If the irregularities are sticking out, level them first with a scraper or chisel. Then start sanding.

I was taught to draw cross hatched lines with a pencil. Start by moving the sander on the diagonals. Keep the sander moving all the time. Don't pause on the irregularities. Move the sander slowly and steadily. Don't push down, let the tool do the work.

When the only lines left are the irregularities, draw a new crosshatch and sand again. Repeat until no lines are left, then a last crosshatch and sand with the grain.

Then blow off or vacuum to remove any leftover grit from the coarse grit, move on to the next grit with the same process.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#4

Tell up more

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is the nature of what you are sanding that 80 grit is required for the first grit. It is rare that I need a grit this aggressive for a project. If you are getting the surface irregular is demonstrates that you are over sanding.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#5

Re: Tell up more

Jerry Gibbs

One would be a glued up panel where the joints are not aligned perfectly. The other would be such as a table leg where the table saw leaves marks.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#6

Re: sanding straight and flat

roger lance

Jerry....this is one of those moments in woodworking where you may have to stop avoiding something and go for it.....use a hand plane.....get comfortable with using planes.

I'm making a big assumption here because I've done that.....once I started cutting dovetails by hand, I found it was not as difficult as I'd imagined.....same with using hand planes.

If I'm wrong.....just like Rosana Dana use to say....."never mind".

Re: sanding straight and flat

#7

Some thoughts

David Yoho

For a panel glue-up I always start out leveling the glue joints with my Stanley #80 cabinet scraper. Once smooth and flat on both sides I turn to a random orbit sander, starting out with 100 grit and finish with 150. Keep the sander moving and let the tool do the work.

For something like a table leg where I want to remove saw marks, it's a light pass over the jointer and then sand either by hand or random orbit.

It sounds from your statements like you're trying to do too much with sanding alone. Starting out with 80-grit is, to my mind, too aggressive and might be the culprit causing part of the problem.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#8

Re: sanding straight and flat

Dick Coers

It will take a new technique for you. If you start with a belt sander, then move to a random orbit, move the random orbit 90 degrees to the previous direction. Likely you are only making a single pass on the side of the panel, then overlapping more in the center. Make two passes on the side of the panel, then don't overlap as much in the middle. Don't be afraid to use the belt sander at a 45 degree to the grain. I also learned to double clutch the belt sander on the ends of the panel before continuing into the field. That way you spend the same amount of time near the ends as you do in the middle. It takes skill to sand well. Not like throwing the sander around on the panel like they do on TV.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#9

response- some sage advice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Sanding into submission- been there and done that, but no more. There is a better way.

Removing a lot of material with free hand sanding is one of the hardest jobs there is. I regard a belt sander as the most difficult tool in the shop to use and the disasters it is capable of producing make it something to be avoided. So, how to avoid it.............?

Hand planing and scraping are both faster than sanding. The secret to both is the ability to sharpen these tools. If you aim to stay in woodworking the best advice you are going to get is to learn to sharpen and used these essential tools. Taking the saw marks off a table leg with a # 4 or #5 plane is a trivial 1 minute task. Sanding them off and keeping the leg properly shaped is a task beyond my reach.

There is a secret to panel gluing that for some reason is kept secret.

1 flatten one side of the boards to be glued on the jointer then plane the other face. Make one joint at a time being careful to align the joint as the clamps are tightened. 30 min in the clamps and you can proceed to the next joint. It is a rare panel with more than 2 joints so it is not a long task to get the joints right, one at a time. I expect joint alignment to be better than 1/64" on my panels. Scraping/planing this minor misalignment flat is quick. Then I proceed to 100 or 120 sand paper, hand sanding.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#10

See latest issue FWW

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The latest issue, available to look at for free at your local WW store or Lowes, has an article on flattening panels. My continued advice would be to 1. avoid the need for major material removal in a panel preparation and 2. appreciate that a belt sander is a very difficult tool to learn to use. Practice.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#11

Belt Sander

David Yoho

I benched my belt sander many years ago after I bought my first random orbit sander. While I do still have it, I hardly ever use it and when I do it's never on any furniture projects. I just never got the hang of not causing bad low spots no matter how much I tried.

Funny thing - when I was first starting out working with wood my stepfather gave me my first Stanley cabinet scraper. I thought it was neat looking but had no idea what it did. One day a friend came by my workshop for a visit. Since he was a hand tool guy, I asked if he knew what the thing was. The delight on his face was immeasurable while he explained its use and how to set it up. I started practicing using it and soon became comfortable with it. I've found many uses for it through the years but the task when I most often reach for it is smoothing the joints of panel. My joints are never perfect but usually all I need is two or three swipes with the #80 and it's flat and ready for finish sanding.

Re: sanding straight and flat

#12

cabinet scraper joy

John K Jordan

One thing that might help for someone who hasn't used scrapers much is one of the holders. I have one from Veritas with a screw adjustment that will hold a bend without hand strain - I loaned it to someone restoring a hard maple table top and it worked great even though he had never seen a cabinet scraper.

Veritas holder: http://www.craftsmanstudio.com/Veritas-Scraper-Holder-p/V05K3301.htm

I use small scrapers often for woodturnings (pic), with the lathe on and off. The small scrapers are very thin. (I bought some of these from Highland Hardware and Woodcraft.)

I can take ripples or center nub out of the bottom of a bowl or platter with a gently curved scraper very quickly instead of making clouds of dust with power sanding AND the curved surface is not deformed as it sometimes is with sanding. I also use them on spindle turning, recently on some very long spindles that had too much vibration even with a sharp skew - a small flat scraper did the trick. Like for flat wood, the scraped surface needs little or no sanding so it can be much quicker.


Re: sanding straight and flat

#13

Re: response- some sage advice

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

My procedure is very much like yours however as I only use rough lumber, I often leave my individual panel boards over thickness by a 1/16 to 1/8". After gluing up a couple of boards, I run them through my 20" planer, taking off just enough to level the surface. I then run the remaining boards through the planer and continue the process until I have reached the desired width.

The only issue I have ever had with scraping is that (as you stated) you should either sand the piece after scraping or scrape the entire project without sanding. Scraping alone does leave an excellent surface for final finishing but does have a different appearance after final finish is applied (DAMHIKT). I have finished a couple of minor projects using only scraping, but normally use Bill's process and sand all surfaces after using the scrapers. I do use the LV scraper holder (and the LV "burr" setting tool when possible).

Re: sanding straight and flat

#14

Re: response- some sage advice

TomD

"Hand planing and scraping are both faster than sanding. The secret to both is the ability to sharpen these tools. If you aim to stay in woodworking the best advice you are going to get is to learn to sharpen and used these essential tools. Taking the saw marks off a table leg with a # 4 or #5 plane is a trivial 1 minute task. Sanding them off and keeping the leg properly shaped is a task beyond my reach."

I would far rather hand plane anything than belt sand. And so it has been for 35 years. If I gave up woodworking I would still probably play with my planes now and then. But if someone says that belt sanding is slower they just don't know how to use a belt sander. The main trick with a belt sander is fresh belts and pull back and up to counter the tendency to hollow your work. I have a belt sander that I could push a plane into like gently closing a door, and it would swallow that metal plane as fast as one could feed it. Since it is a power tool there is no practical limit as to what sanders can do. If I was getting paid to do stuff, I would doubtless use hand tools on something delicate like a tapering table leg, but flat stock nearly as wide as the belt would probably go faster on a belt sander. A stroke sander is another option. Tag Frid is an example of an iconic hand tool guy who was perfectly happy pocketing the extra cash a belt sander made him.

Sanders and planes are quite different in principle as sanders have generally unlimited geometry, while planes are quite limited. So you could probably tunnel right through a table with a belt sander, but with a plane, once it hollowed the surface out a few thou it would stop cutting. You can use these different cutting styles to make different things happen more easily with one or the other.

But yeah, planes...

Re: sanding straight and flat

#15

Re: sanding straight and flat - Long board

TomD

There are lots of things that get sanded fair, usually some kind of long board is used. Varying flexibility jointer length sanding blocks. Tedious work, but sometimes the only way. Let's not forget that sharpening is mostly just sanding and we expect to be able to do that with some success freehand. You could probably use a hand plane making the plug for a Corvette, but your couldn't finish it that way.