Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Formby's Tung Oil

Posts

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#26

Yup, 100% tung

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is the real deal, but as a finish it takes "forever" to dry and cure and the resulting film is quite soft and easily damaged. I didn't say that Waterlox was all tung oil. It is, however, a true tung oil-based varnish that is far beyond Formby's which is mostly linseed with a bit of tung mixed in so they can market it as a "tung oil finish". I suspect it is "lighter" to start because the amount of solids (what's left after the dry/cure process) is less. I used it a long time ago, but it took too much to "build" a final film.

The advantage of tung is that it doesn't darken over time whereas linseed and flax will get darker,

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#27

Re: More about "over the hill" - not buying it

TomD

From a practical perspective that might be true, but isn't it the case that the polymerization means that the chains are forming, and while the finish can be thinned, that is just mixing in some wet stuff that may or not help application, it does not reverse the polymerization. The effect of that with adhesives is that some of the components that are able to chemically bond have already shot their bolt and you have a gumbo of stuff not yet formed up, stuff that is just there for show, and stuff that still has go. Exactly how all that get sloshed around and forms up is way way above my pay grade but it sounds and unlikely combination for maximum adhesive effect either for adhesives, or finishes one wishes to sink in, adhere etc....

Further if you had a given level of solvent from zero on up and are forced to add more, when that finish cures there will be pathways where the solvent left. That could even be good if what you wanted was for the material so covered to equalize as fast as possible to ambient, but if you are looking for certain kinds of protection, finish density, adhesion, and so forth, not so good.

Another thing I know to be true is that solvents don't thin certain already large molecules. So one sees this great wetting happening but the solvent is wetting the finish is not. This is why just thinning an epoxy does not convert it into rot doctor, you need an epoxy that is thin in itself in it's uncured state. Again, what effect that has is unclear, one might not want the finish to penetrate, using a clapped out finish with some solvent might be one's dream product...

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#28

Re: The best method...

TomD

I am going to send this one in for FWW tips. Or is the a better deal out there for tips?

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#29

Kneale Brownson

Are Mustard and Ketchup containers the same?


Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#30

Re: Are Mustard and Ketchup containers the same?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know. Never worked on mustard containers but probably not.

The limitation of most plastics is that they are a poor barrier for oxygen. Tiny amounts of oxygen ruin beer and turns tomato products black and off flavor.

We don't buy mustard. If you only see it in glass then it is affected by oxygen. If it is in plastic and the plastic unusually thick then the plastic may be multilayer to provide an oxygen barrier. Some of the layers provide the barrier but have worthless mechanical properties. The rest of the layers give the bottle mechanical properties and isolate stuff in the barrier layer from the food contact.