Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Formby's Tung Oil

Posts

Formby's Tung Oil

#1

Formby's Tung Oil

Dave Bair

I've used this product for about a year and it's starting to thicken enough to affect it's application characteristics. I've tried to determine the solvent used by Formby (Sherwin-Williams) but can't get past it's registry number (64742-88-7) on the CAS site. CAS doesn't list such a product on it's free public listing. Any ideas as to what the solvent is? It really stinks but I'm not familiar with solvents other than alcohol and mineral spirits, so odor isn't going to help me.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#2

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is getting thick not because it is loosing solvent but because it is curing (polymerizing). Any hydrocarbon solvent will thin it- mineral spirits, naptha, paint thinner, turpentine, etc.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#3

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

Dave Bair

Thanks, Bill.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#4

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

Steve Schoene

Instead of going to a CAS site, just google CAS with the numbers. Lots of sources will come up. They point to a variety of similar mineral spirits solvents.

Formby's Tung Oil Finish is not tung oil but is an alkyd varnish. The thickening is curing and indicates that it is on the way to becoming over the hill.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#5

Eliminate the air

John K Jordan

Some other finishes also have this problem, for example my favorite, Tru-Oil. What I do is keep a tank of nitrogen handy and bleed some into the bottle to displace the air each time I replace the lid. This keeps oxygen away from the liquid and prevents it from skimming over or thickening. I got a tank of nitrogen from my local welding supply house.

A commercial alternative is a can of Bloxygen but it is expensive.

http://www.amazon.com/Bloxygen-Grams-Finish-Preserver-Spray/dp/B001OW80PK/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1440728505&sr=8-2&keywords=Bloxygen

The stuff sold to keep wine fresh is exactly the same gas and might be cheaper per use.

From the label Bloxygen is a mixture of nitrogen, argon, and carbon dioxide. I may try mixing some argon/CO2 with the nitrogen since I have tanks of that in my welding room.

Some people store the bottle or can of finish upside down but seems like that would still leave the oxygen in the container. One guy told me recently he displaces the air by dropping marbles into the container. I also read of someone who bleeds propane from an unlit torch into the container - that might be exciting one day.

BTW, nitrogen also works well for keeping things like chips and beef jerky fresh and for modifying the existance of varmints caught in live traps.

JKJ

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#6

Funny thing...

John in NM

The best Watco I ever used had been sitting around for 15 years or more, and was quite thick (for Watco). Stuff worked great as a film builder, kind of like a thinner version of the old McCloskey's varnish before Valspar bought them and started filling the cans with gloss poly.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#7

Ah, McCloskey's

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Did more than one wood floor with their tung oil gym-seal. A lovely and durable finish done in by the VOC regs.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#8

More about "over the hill"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The fact that the varnish has started to cure does not affect its ability to continue curing. The only practical effect of it heading over the hill is viscosity. When it is too thick to brush and level it becomes useless. Thinning will help for a while.

Viscosity is sensitive to amount of cure. The viscosity rapidly increases as cure continues. The result is if it took 6 months to get where you are at, in some lesser time it will get twice as thick as it is now.

Bottom line- You may be near the top of the hill and close to being over the hill as was stated. Quick, build something that needs varnish.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#9

Re: Eliminate the air

William Duffield

A much less expensive (free) way to eliminate the oxygen and stop the polymerization is to put the can in a vise, and squash it until the can is just full again. Put the lid on tight before you release the vise, as there is some spring back. I don't think it is really necessary to point out that this works very well for steel cans, less well for plastic, and not at all for glass. :D Thanks to Frank Klausz for this tip.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#10

It was nice stuff alright...

John in NM

All the more so for being fairly inexpensive and readily available at a decent hardware store.

I'm thinking of trying Sutherland Welles spar varnish as an alternative.

That can of Watco was in the shop of the old telescope, no one used it but me. Should have swiped it when I left :D - but I didn't really think about how differently it behaved until I was thinking I should buy a new can of Watco.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#11

Not plastic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Plastic might seem the ideal container. Just squish it to displace the air. But, many plastic compositions are "screen doors" to oxygen diffusion. In the extreme you can keep a gold fish in a sealed silicone container. On the other hand some vinyls, like Handy Wrap, are good oxygen barriers. And lots of other stuff is in between and unsuitable for storing a finish that cures by reaction with oxygen.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#12

Re: Not plastic

William Duffield

Good points, Bill. I was only considering original containers. (Hopefully the manufacturer would choose an appropriate plastic.) One reason for my lapse is that I have been trained to not transfer flammable or toxic chemicals to unlabeled or mislabeled containers. I have a CIH CSP SWMBO watching over my shoulder.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#13

Beer and Ketchup

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The reason you don't see beer in a plastic container is that after a billion dollars of research no one has discovered a plastic that is a sufficient oxygen barrier for an affordable bottle.

Ketchup is typically bottled in a 5 layer very expensive container. But consumers are willing to pay the price for the squeezablilty, and less weight of a large container.

Now there is a thought. Put you curing finishes in Ketchup bottles. (don't forget to change the label)

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#14

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

Howard Acheson

Formby's Tung Oil finish contains no real tung oil. It's oil/varnish mixture which is formulated with linseed oil. It's a faux tung oil intend to look like tung oil when cured. Look carefully at the label. I says "My tung oil fininsh is a high-quality furniture varnish made from a balanced blend of tung oil and other oils". The "other oils" are linseed which makes up the majority of the solids in the product.

If you want a true tung oil, look for a product that says 100% or "pure" tung oil.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#15

Re: Formby's Tung Oil addendum

Howard Acheson

Meant to mention, the thinner is mineral spirits just like any other oil based varnish. But if the product has begun to gell, it can't be resurrected.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#16

Want Tung Oil . .?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Waterlox is where to go.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#17

Re: Beer and Ketchup

William Duffield

Also, a bottle of ketchup is liable to stay in your refrigerator a lot longer than a bottle of beer. :) At least, it does in my house.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#18

Re: Beer and Ketchup // glue dispensers

AZ in Colorado Springs

Not to hi jack the thread, but these work well for glue. Often the hole is just right for squeezing out a thin line of glue when you need only a little bit. The cap snaps closed and you're done.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#19

Hey, that's a good idea!

John in NM

Now if only I emptied them as fast as the beer bottles!

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#20

Re: Want Tung Oil . .?

Dave Bair

Actually, I chose Formby's because of a FWW review of wiping varnishes. That review included an evaluation of the amount of yellowing for each product reviewed. Formby's yellowed the least, which is what I wanted for a hard-maple sleigh bed I'm building. My go-to oil finish is Minwax, but I just couldn't get acceptable results from their water-based poly. The review also indicated that it's not tung oil. The Formby's is ideal for my finishing methods right out of the can; I have to thin the Minwax more and more with each revision of their formulations. Their stuff is getting more like honey every time I buy a new can.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#21

Re: Forked Tongue Oil, Maybe?


Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#22

They do put Beer in plastic containers

Tim Greif- west of Chicago

Ever been to Las Vegas? You can carry open liquor on the street. I recall walking around with Bud Light in a plastic bottle. They used plastic to eliminate the potential for broken glass on the streets. At least that was the case last time I was there.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#23

Dale Lenz

What I did

Dale Lenz

As many have said it's the air in the container causing the problem. Once I cracked a container of "Tung oil" open I'd poor off into smaller jars. I still have a large collection of baby food jars. Yes, label the jars.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#24

there are monor exceptions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Beer is bottled in wide mouth plastic for sports events and apparently other special cases where short shelf life is tolerable (or the taste of oxygen exposed beer not noticed) . The wide mouth empties the bottle if it is thrown. The short shelf life is not an issue in a sports venue.

Re: Formby's Tung Oil

#25

Re: Want Tung Oil . .?

Howard Acheson

Waterlox varnish in no more "Tung Oil" than Formbys. It's a varnish.

All oil based varnish contain a drying oil. In the case of Waterlox, the varnish component is tung oil which is heated and mixed with other chemicals. Once all the ingredients are combined the resultant material is no longer tung oil. It's a varnish made with tung oil.

If you want or need true tung oil the only way to get it is to look for a product where the label clearly states either "pure' tung oil or true tung oil.