I am building a small table from qswo. I want the rays to show on each face of the legs. My thought is to make 1/8" veneer and mitre the edges. The legs are tapered from 2" to 1". Is this practical and get a nice tight joint? Should I make thinner veneer, say 1/16" and and forget about the joint? Any thoughts appreciated.
From the perspective of having no experience with the proposal I would worry that expansion/contraction of the underlying wood might open the miters if the veneer is too thick.
I did this once with maple legs that were glued up, to make them look solid. As I recall, I ordered some 1/16" veneer for the purpose and didn't worry about the joint - if you get a nice tight glue line, it won't be noticeable in white oak, even less so when quartersawn.
With rift cut veneer the joints will be nearly invisible. But with quartered there is going to be discontinuity of the rays at the corners. I would want to make up a test leg for this design. My gut feeling is that I would not like the result. But then this thought is from the source that recently delivered an unfavorable philosophy on the overuse of figured wood. I would add quartered oak to my list of curly woods that are overused. I don't know what is setting on these legs but my concern would be the legs distracting from what sits on them.
The taper complicates things a bit. In Arts & Crafts period furniture a common technique is to stack two or three solid pieces, then veneer the edges to cover the glue lines. Most often the veneer is around 1/8" thick. In the finished leg you see two solid surfaces and two surfaces with thick veneer. This is the method used by Gus Stickley and this image is from my book "Shop Drawings for Craftsman Furniture".
If only one surface tapers, you can veneer over the tapered cut. If two taper you should be okay on the solid surface as long as the taper stays within the outer solid piece. The degree of flake may change at the taper, but if the piece is truly quartered it should look okay.
I can't think of any good reason to miter the corners, or to veneer more than two opposing sides. In original pieces the corner is beveled back to the glue line as in the photo. That makes the joint disappear almost all of the time.
In some antique pieces you will find cracks in the veneer, generally near the ends of the legs. The quartersawn core will move seasonally in thickness, but unless the piece endures extreme conditions it is negligible and doesn't cause any harm.
In theory a crack can occur due to wood movement, and I used to believe that four solid pieces of wood with some sort of miter at the corner made a better leg. In practice the veneer is a whole lot faster, if you slice the veneer from the same pieces that you use for the core you can match the grain on all four sides of the leg, and it likely won't crack unless someone puts the piece down in a damp basement or up in a hot attic (or both). My theory now is that the original pieces that show cracks suffered such treatment.
The busy-ness of qswo lets you get away with things that would jump out at you with other hardwoods. Pictures of an old chair can be seen at the link.
In my experience, I think it is a wasted effort to try to carry the QS down the leg, even if the rest is. If you have some 2" oak, you can usually get some rift off to the sides, which will give you the same pattern on all sides of your leg tappers without having to deal with veneering.
Visually it just doesn't work out as anything special. Even when I'm doing doors, I like to choose rift for the styles and rails, then use the QS for the wide panels.
While the grain angle in the leg might just qualify by grading standards as QS, neither the leg nor the veneer is near 90 degrees and hence there are no large flakes to deal with matching. And indeed this is the situation I would be looking for in making a leg.....almost quarter sawn. The true QS lumber would be used to make the top.
The largely rift grain will make it easy for the eye to blend in the grain from the various faces. I suspect the discontinuities of 90 degree orientation large flake QS would not look good in a leg, but you will be the person to prove me wrong should wrong be the case.
I'd also recommend using rift sawn for legs and using qswo for the top. If qswo is used everywhere, a piece can get to be visually confusing......let the eye go to the top.
You're right about the first picture, at least at the top of the leg. I was trying to illustrate the stacking with veneer over the glue lines. In the piece, the grain gets flakier as it moves down the leg. On the whole, it is on the edge of rift/quartered and shifts back and forth along the length.
What looks good is a matter of taste and personal opinion. I like the look of rift sawn lumber in a lot of places, but I'm really not sure if that is because of how it looks to my eye, or if I find it satisfying to have a really stable piece of wood in the right place, or a similar grain pattern as it turns a corner. I know with doors it is a combination of both.
When we build it's always a dance of putting the right piece of wood in the right place while juggling what was done at the time, what pleases the eye, and what particular wood is available. Within those constraints we hope to achieve a passing grade. Original Arts & Crafts pieces have a certain look, and part of that look is there is a lot of variation when it comes to figure. That's the nature of the material; it's easy to find pieces with spectacular figure, but not so easy to find enough matching pieces like you can with other hardwoods. These days there are lots of images available online to help, if making an authentic looking piece is the goal. More often then not, "good" original pieces show ray flakes all over, but the flakes are subdued by the finish. While making the flakes "pop" is today's goal, more even color was the goal at the time.
Authenticity may or may not be important to the contemporary builder, but it's a good foundation. Here is an example that is more typical. I would prefer a prettier match to the top, but that isn't always in the cards and ultimately there isn't any right or wrong.
I built a table about 10 years ago that had tapered qswo legs. I built it so that there was qs figure showing on both of the legs facing out by doing a thin veneer. Because of the natural grain of the oak, the veneer is barely noticeable. (the left face in this picture is the veneer)
To make the veneer, I glued a thicker piece of qswo (3/16") to one face, and trimmed it flush with the sides using a flush trim router bit. Then I shaved the veneer to 1/16" by running it through the table saw.
I didn't do qswo on the fourth side of the table leg due to the taper. I placed that side of the leg on the "inside" of the table
If it were not a tapered leg, I had been going to suggest a mitered fold of a 4/4 board.
When I've done those the grain wraps around the corner and looks "right" to all but the woodworkers who understands that the grain should look different on the side and the face. First time I saw it done I knew it looked funny but took me 5 minutes to work out why. I still think it looks good though.
I suppose one could do this out of 6/4 and then taper the resulting blank. That would probably preserve the look fine with qswo since the taper cut is perpendicular to the desired ray figure.
I'm glad you were able to follow what I was saying. It is a lot easier to glue a "thick" veneer to the leg blank then shave it down into a "thin" veneer with either a surface planer or table saw
I made a table/desk on a commission. They wanted QSWO and all I had was sawed 4/4 and a little 5/4. The small amount of 8/4 I had was on the bottom of a very large stack and I was not willing to move a seven foot tall stack to get to it.
I glued two pieces of 5/4 together to make a blanks. I tapered them on two faces. On the straight face and one tapered face I glued a piece of 1/16" shop made veneer from the same stock. The legs tapered from about 1 7/8" to about 1". I just bent the veneer from the straight section at the top to the taper without any trouble. Then I put a tiny chamfer On the corners of the legs and it hid the veneer perfectly. It was very difficult to see the joint. The client was thrilled. Even after I explained why a piece could NOT be quarter sawn on all four sides. The table stayed at his office for about two years and drew a lot of positive comments. No one noticed the trickery on the legs.
To speed up the gluing of the veneer I glued four faces at one time by flipping them back and fourth. I inserted a two inch wide scrap between the legs to insure full contact. On the ones that were folded I used a long caul and a short one.
If u have a lock miter bit or even if you don't *LINK*
Grant in Iowa
Jerry,
The lock miter method I used on a lamp once. I left a hole in the center for the cord. I was able to get the fit just right and clamped it up with stretch wrap by just winding the wrap around and around until the joints were tight. I only did this once because it took some trial and error to get things to assemble tightly. Then a guy showed me the tape trick and I haven't looked back. Anyway, here is the lock miter method if you want to be fancy:
The miter tape joint trick allows the builder to just do simple 45's on each corner. I have linked to the basic idea below. I would improve on his approach by using clear packing tape 2" wide and paying close attention to getting your miters straight so there are no gaps before you do the glue up. The results are as near flawless as I have seen. The stretching packing tape keeps the joints tight.
The resulting part from either method may or may not be perfectly square depending on your skill and attention to detail. You can easily fix any problems at the jointer and planer, however. Suggest you build them maybe 1/8" over size to accomadate squaring after the fact. Results in a strong attractive part.