Does anyone have any knowledge of the pros and cons of real hardwood versus engineered locking wood flooring? Which would you use and why? I have read the engineered flooring hype, but would like to to hear about real world experience.
Flooring is changing with development of new top coat finishes and adhesives. Basically solid wood, some now are top coated at the factory is not for slab floor it is installed to a wood sub floor with nails. 3/4 inch wood will last the life of the house with the ability to be refinished many times and spot repairs while not easy are doable. Engineered flooring has a thin veneer on top the best ones can be refinished several times the inexpensive products are a one time deal. The more expensive floors tend to be thicker and some can be nailed to the sub floor but most are glued to the sub floor, repair of engineered products is not always seamless. Engineered product is very forgiving to the DIY guy,no expensive tools, No need for the industrial sanding and staining,minimal dust,low odor but beware of formaldehyde used in some engineered products, SWMBO can pick out the exact color,texture as in hand scraped ect. she wants. The prep work before the floor is installed can be the hardest but it is the most important part of the job if you cheat here the finished product will show it. Your supplier should have the installation instructions to follow for the manufactures warranty to be effective. YouTube videos are helpful but they don't show the sore back and knees,good luck.
One very real downside is the difficulty of repairs with engineered flooring. I've been helping a friend repair his floor that was damaged during a break-in. The insurance company wouldn't pay for a complete R & R, so we're trying to repair the damaged areas. The original manufacturer still makes the color, but has changed the size. I won't bore you with the details, but we're having to rip larger pieces down, run them thru the planer, shave the tongue down and put the groove back in - all while being careful of the finish. Then remove the original, damaged pieces and replace. Since we have to be carful not to damage the adjacent pieces, it is very time-consuming and stressful. If the floor was real hardwood, it could be sanded and refinished. It might even be possible to spot sand and refinish.
Practically speaking, repair ability is a non-issue. High end engineered flooring offers more options and variety than solid, and is easier to install.
If you take a poor-boy approach, you'll end up with schlock with either solid or engineered.
In a suitable home in which I intend to remain I'd say go for solid wood. It is available in a multitude of species (although not always cheaply) and, as others have stated, it is repairable and refinishable. For a home which is being flipped or which is not a long-term thing I'd go with the cheaper solution, whichever that may be.
I'm in the situation now where I am needing up rip up laminate I put down in 1998 in my family room and kitchen and replace it with red oak to match the wood in the rest of the house and ceramic tile in the kitchen. The great thing is that 3/4" red oak purchased now is the same size and is totally compatible with the 1964-vintage and can be woven in pretty much seamlessly. Of course all of this depends on scraping enough money together but that is true of all home projects.
I thank everyone for their input and suggestions. It seems like the primary advantages of solid hardwood are its repair-ability and potential longevity. The engineered products might win on price and ease of installation. Since my kitchen counter is already in place and I need to get the dishwasher under it, the thickness of the flooring might be the determining factor, but we need to look at some samples before SHMBO makes my decision.
Another factor I have learned is often of importance is the fact real wood is real without a lot of potential off-gassing and so forth. Some people perceive themselves to be very sensitive to solvents and glues, and so forth. I have noticed this is often a SWMBO issue.