Some thoughts on this
Ellis Walentine Also, once I've done the making-multiples exercise, I'll get a much better sense of what kind of time it takes, what the setups are like, what components lend themselves better to production work, etc. If I make, say, four mini's on-order as part of the test and get even only $125 each for them, that's $500 earned to conduct an experiment that I would surely have had to conduct anyway but would otherwise have paid nothing. As to poly, waiting overnight isn't an issue at all. Remember, these are things I plan to make here and there as I have time as an adjunct to my main profession. True, I'll need to keep delivery time in mind for any orders, but waiting two overnights to apply three coats of poly doesn't strike me as a big deal.
In my case for this instance, it's not really "work" at all, Dick. This is an experiment, the main purpose of which is to see what the making-mulitples process is like and make notes. In that sense, it's something I'd have to do anyway, but in this case I'd be getting paid for it.
Thanks for starting this thread, AJ. Clearly there are a lot of variables involved in pricing our work. My decision tree always starts with "What will the market bear?", and there are a million factors that enter into that, such as:
-How well does this product solve the customer's need for functionality and aesthetics? In other words, why would someone want to buy this. If it's useless or unattractive, it doesn't matter what the materials cost or how long it took you to make; it ain't gonna sell.
In the case of your spool cabinets, I have no idea who needs one of these cabinets or why, much less what they're willing to pay. If it's a sewing accessory, what are the odds that your customer perceives the differences between your masterful work and some cheap drawer box that is perfectly adequate for storing their spools and whatever, or cares enough to spend the extra cash? My hunch is that the odds are pretty slim, so you need to be able to make these at a low price and try to make whatever profit you deem necessary. This is the kind of item that would definitely profit from being jigged up and made in multiples.
My other first impression was that the real market for boxes like this is the jewelry box market. There you are selling to men -- a completely different market with different price expectations -- who want to impress their mates with a beautiful, loving, personal gift that will have daily utility and reward its happy owner with the luxury of your sublime handiwork. In other words, if you're going to make small drawer cabinets, the market for jewelry boxes is likely a much bigger and more lucrative bulls-eye than the sewing accessories market. You may not be "working," and that's probably a good thing, but you need to reassess whether you're doing this to make money.
Of course, if you get into the jewelry box arena, you're suddenly up against a huge amount of competition, ranging fromthe cheapo department store jewelry boxes to the overwrought high-end ones. Here, product differentiation is going to be a bigger issue. Where is your niche? Assuming you have the woodworking abilities to make almost anything, do you also have the design chops to compete with some of the really gorgeous jewelry box designs out there? The point here is that the market is big, so there's plenty of room to stake out a segment and target a product to that segment.
Production itself isn't a guarantee of competitiveness. In the case of your boxes, they appear to be very straightforward, so there's not a lot of jigging required. Usually, production fixturing is a big investment in time and precision to create quick ways to do things that take a long time by hand or without fixtures. You get the payback by being able to crank out multiples of things that would be daunting for someone else to make as a onesie. So, I'm not convinced that you'd see enough of a lift from doing multiples of this item. Maybe rough out parts for a bunch of them at a time would be a benefit -- not too much investment prior to finding your orders.
I tend to pontificate ad nauseam on stuff like this, so I'll zip it right here. Maybe this has been useful, or at least interesting.
Ellis




