Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Pricing advice

Posts

Pricing advice

#1

A.J. Hamler

Pricing advice

A.J. Hamler

I'm probably nuts, but after numerous requests for a particular item I make I'm considering making the item for sale on a limited basis. To that end, I have no idea how to price it. The item is a miniature spool cabinet, the little two-drawer one on the right in the first photo below. I've made several over the years -- both full-size and miniature -- but I've always made them as gifts for friends and family. Here's what they look like:


The full-size one measures 18" deep, 23" long and 11" high. The smaller one is a scaled down version, but not exactly a 1-to-1 scaling proportionally since doing it exactly it wouldn't be high enough, nor the drawers really deep enough to hold much. It measures 5-1/2" deep, 9-1/2" long and 6-1/4" high. (That's why the miniature one has a somewhat "taller" appearance than its larger cousin.

It's the smaller one I'm thinking of selling, since I could produce these fairly quickly in multiples, maybe four or six at a time. The market would be anyone who has any interest in sewing, with the use being as a small desktop cabinet that would hold anything at all, not just sewing stuff. I made a full-size and mini for my wife; she uses the full-size one for her sewing stuff, and the small one on her desk for pens, pencils and other office-supply kinds of things. Unlike the drawers on the full-size spool cabinets, which are open, I've installed small dividers in the mini to better organize desk stuff.

Construction: The cabinet is oak with rabbet joinery, although I would also offer these in walnut and cherry. The frame-and-panel appearance of the ends (and back, which you can't see here) is faux. The drawers are also rabbeted construction with poplar drawer boxes and oak fronts, with the fronts cut out for the decals. I've produced the decals myself, so there's no expense there. Reproduction spool cabinet knobs are available for full-size cabinets, but not the little one so I've used something that while not an exact match has the same kind of look. The knobs are generally easy to find, and not particularly expensive. The finish is stain and poly.

So, what would be a good price to ask for the mini?

And, as long as I'm asking, what about the full-size one? Those are much more involved with overall larger size, the frame-and-panel ends/back are true frame-and-panel panel not faux, tiny cove routing on the recessed decal openings, the bead trim (which I mill myself), and the expense of the repro knobs. Doubt that I'll make the full-size one for sale, but thought it might be good to have an idea what to price one just in cast anyone asks, ya know?

TIA!

A.J.

Re: Pricing advice

#2

Re: Pricing advice

Sgian Dubh

Material costs + 100% - covers your time selecting materials (including driving, phone calls, etc), vehicle mileage, that sort of thing.

Work out your hours to make the item. For example, let's say you make a batch of five taking 100 hours = 20 hours per item. Charge this out at whatever rate you need to make it worth your while. Add your material charge to the labour rate and that's it.

'Worth your while' of course can mean different things to different people. Your labour rate should at minimum cover overhead (maintenance, electricity, building and machinery repairs, heating, rent, etc) whether as an amateur or professional. The rest of the labour rate goes towards your wage (for living expenses) and profit for reinvestment, savings, illness, holidays, administration costs, etc. Base your hourly rate on what wage and profit you want to make on each item.

The hourly rate could therefore be anything that barely covers your overhead, and a bit for profit to invest in machinery and equipment, if you're basically working as an amateur doing this for primarily for pleasure, or to commercial rates applicable to running a full-time business - it depends what you're trying to get out of the venture.

You probably won't want to wade through the full blown estimating system I describe at the following link, but you're welcome to chew your way through it if that tickles your fancy! Slainte.

http://www.richardjonesfurniture.com/PDFs/Estimating.pdf

Re: Pricing advice

#3

Re: Pricing advice

Rum

I take a bit of a different tack on some of this than most folks might. You definitely need to cover time and costs (that's a great doc Richard! thanks for sharing) but in this case I'm going to argue that that is your minimum. In a specialty market like this there is usually a premium because of the slower nature of the sales.

What you're selling here is less a "need" product and more a "want" product so you need to set the price high enough that people mentally put it into that category without completely pricing yourself out of the market. You don't want to be compared with the plastic crap from walmart so you need to be priced sufficiently above that that people put you into a different mind bucket.

Fortunately you seem to have a decent number of comps available rom folks who seem to be taking a similar approach. I see a bunch of similar looking ones doing a google image search for "spool cabinet" - most seem to be antiques which will be mainly what you're competing against so its probably worth looking at them some.

This fellow seems to be in roughly the same market and has direct prices:

http://www.hyerswood.com/product.php?product_id=22

They seem close to the prices on the nicer antique ones so that seems like a reasonable place to work from anyway.

Re: Pricing advice

#4

Re: Pricing advice

Dick Coers

I'm surprised you are asking since you've made them before. I make a real effort to make as close to $35 per hour as I can. But, I have no idea what you pay for insurance, utilities, and other general business expenses. So my rate may have no relevance to you. We have no idea how fast you work or what machines you have. Only you can set a price. And lastly, there will be economy with numbers. Making 3 or 4 at a time will really add to the profit.

Re: Pricing advice

#5

Re: Pricing advice

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Gosh, I have been making and selling furniture and other woodworking things professionally for over a decade and I'm still asking that question! Why? Well, for several reasons that include:

- Where and how I market....galleries, commissions etc. Each sales venue can effect the pricing.

- State of economy. These days, consider it lousy.

- Where I sell things. Some things sell better in some locations and some sell better in others. I have work that sells well in NC and not so well in Chicago, and vice versa. Price is sometimes gauged accordingly.

There are other factors such as "wow factor" and other intangible qualities. But I have found over the years that pricing can be a little more complicated than a standard formula.

That said, you at least need a point of reference. The types of formulas suggested by others can get you in the ballpark. It can be a fine line between an attractive price and over-priced. I think an approach to take is to err on the higher side. If they don't sell, you can always mark them down. But if you establish a low price, it gets a bit trickier to raise the price.

How is that for a general and non-specific answer!!

T.

Re: Pricing advice

#6

Re: Pricing advice

Sgian Dubh

You make good points Thomas. The price you can charge might vary considerably depending on market conditions, e.g., sales location such as galleries, exhibitions or word of mouth, etc, perceived clientele, the rarity of your product, and so on. In the pricing system I've developed, modified and used over the years really only gives an indication of costs to the business and the hours needed to make a piece.

After that, it's necessary to assess if the estimated price is appropriate to the market or the client. If the planned charge is judged too high for the market, there may need to be some rationalisation of materials and planned processes, e.g., swap expensive hand dovetailed hardwood drawers for cheaper tongue and housed drawer boxes out of plywood with a planted hardwood front.

There again, the piece might really be too economically priced for the market, so it might just be a good idea to raise the price, and yet do no extra work to add value.

Putting a price on a piece can be difficult, even if you have good systems in place, as I have, to work out costs and time for a planned job. I suppose, in the end, it comes down to the same old thing - you can get what the market is willing to pay, and there are a lot of things that go into determining what a buyer considers a fair price.

There's a whole host of other stuff that could be discussed in relation to pricing work, e.g., promotional work such as exhibitions, online, and so on, that are all expenses that a business might have to somehow accommodate in the pricing of items for sale, and billable hours having to cover non-billable time, etc, but I suspect those sorts of issues aren't really germane to A.J's situation, even though they're interesting (to me anyway, ha, ha). Slainte.

Re: Pricing advice

#7

A.J. Hamler

Pricing advice -- better description

A.J. Hamler

I think I didn't quite express what I'm going for in my OP, and that's entirely my fault. You guys gave some fantastic info on pricing -- in fact, I've copied and pasted it all into a document that already filed for future reference.

However, it's all kind of geared to someone doing this as a mainstay of a woodworking business, which isn't what I'm going for at all. For one thing, there's no way I could possibly measure the amount of time I spend on these, as they're going to be a minor sidebar to what I really do for a living which, of course, is being a world-famous and beloved-by-all woodworking writer. I have neither the temperament nor time to be a pro woodworker in a business sense.

In my case, I want to make these when I either a) have spare time, or b) am already making something else and by chance am working with the same wood in sizes conducive to knocking out a few components for the cabinets and setting them aside for later. I do this all the time for any number of things I make. I have, in fact, squirreled away some components for some mini spool cabinets already. I was working with 1/2" oak a couple months ago that was already 6" wide, and so I went ahead and cut five top/bottom pieces for the cabinets (they're the same). I already had a cove bit in my router table for the other thing I was working on, and went ahead and cut the cove profiles, too. Then just stacked them in what passes for my to-do shelf/box out in the shop. Ditto the drawer fronts when I was working with some 1/4" oak for something else -- as long as I was working with it anyway, I just went ahead and cut as many drawer fronts to size as I had material for and added them to the to-do shelf/box. When I get around to making some mini's, as I call them, I'll have a nice head start.

Of course, if I ever get "orders" for these I'd need to set aside time to complete them, which I'd deal with as it happened. That shouldn't be an issue, though, as the mini's are not nearly as time-intensive as the full-size ones. I figure if I get an order for one, I'll make two (or four or six).

Anyway, what I was looking for was some basic ballpark figures of what you might expect items like this to be priced at. The link that Rum provided gave me a good idea as to what these can bring, although I doubt I could get those prices in this area. (Online, maybe, should I decide to offer them through my website or something. Also, maybe, if I get them in a gallery.)

What I saw on that site added to that the good info you guys have provided, I think I have a starting point for it all. Thanks! And sorry of any confusion as to my goals in the OP.

A.J.

P.S. I really liked the small knobs that guy on that site found for the miniature cabinets. I'll need to find me some of those.

Re: Pricing advice

#8

My gut reaction

mdclor

I would price them at $200 for the mini and $500 for the full sized one. There is no logic involved and I can't rationalize my suggestions, but there it is.

Re: Pricing advice

#9

The question is still tough

Dick Coers

I don't know where you live. If you are going to try and sell them to people in Chicago, Boston, or LA, I know you could get more money than I can here in Peoria. What happens if you get 30 different answers on here, are you going to average them? It's my opinion, that hobbyist woodworkers are not very good judges of market value. Search the internet, find people in your region that are selling them, and then charge what you want. If you want to ignore what it costs you to make them, then just charge what that guy on the link does. Simple. I can't afford myself when it comes to custom furniture, never could. I live too frugally to buy custom made furniture. Same reason I don't go to a tailor when I need a suit. So if I ignore what it costs to make something, I'll sell myself short every single time.

Re: Pricing advice

#10

Re: The question is still tough

Jesse Cloud

I wouldn't limit myself to a local market. Your product looks like it would be pretty easy and economic to ship.

Find a couple of crafts magazines in sewing type areas, call to ask for ad rates. Make a few to have ready when the ad runs. Pick a price that you would really like to get.

Buy a nice ad and see what happens.

By the way, if Merle would spring for $200, you could probably get $300 or $400 from a lot of buyers. ;) :D ;)

Re: Pricing advice

#11

Clint Searl

$250-$300 for the mini (at least)

Clint Searl

And don't do the full size. But I think the real question has more to do with your motivation. If they're easy to crank out and you enjoy the process, the cost of T&M plus a "creativity" premium is justified, and "creativity" calls for a hefty price.

Re: Pricing advice

#12

Re: Pricing advice

don stephan

When we make items using good woodworking practices and quality hardwood, and sell them for less than a living wage + materials, are we telling the public that woodworkers don't deserve a living wage? Already the average consumer can't tell the difference between furniture that will last even a few years and furniture that won't, and keeps buying disposable furniture and complaining about furniture in general when it fails. When people see nice looking hand crafted furniture priced to compete with China factory prices are we disrespecting ourselves? Of course, we will sell less when we price our time at a living wage, unless the customer understands, and cares about, the value of craftsmanship.

Re: Pricing advice

#13

Well said Don.


Re: Pricing advice

#15

All well and good but

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....it is an economic fact that the customer sets the price and the maker determines availability. The market (geography and quantity) will set the price for this cabinet and its maker then decides if he/she is willing to make the quantity the market requires for this price.

Persons in the cub that market their products do so through regional galleries. The gallery staff will know what the pieces can sell for.

For a while I made a similar sized 4-drawer "collectors cabinet" sized for a particular size range of mineral specimens. They sold at a modest rate at $225 direct to collectors that could be found at shows and meetings. I sold one to a coin collector. They didn't sell at all in a gallery. I concluded there was little demand around here for a general purpose cabinet of that size.

Re: Pricing advice

#16

   


Re: Pricing advice

#17

And More From "Danny Downer" . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Now that the Chinese have dropped their currency valuation, those $39.95 versions in the crafts store notions department just got cheaper yet.

Look for a gimmick to set your items apart like personalization or laser engraving, etc. that may appeal to buyers who have only a minimal appreciation for your woodcraft.

Re: Pricing advice

#18

Re: Pricing advice

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

An hourly rate should include making time along with SELLING time. We can get only $20/hour here. Selling time cuts that in half. Is it worth it? When you go to a 19 year old show, spend $275 more than you grossed, and nothing for material cost. YOU HAVE A VERY BAD DAY! Another seller was selling pieces with $1.00 of maple and an hour of work for $7 and turned pens from tropical hardwoods for $12. Have fun, showing is another huge skill to learn besides making sawdust. It is best to see the previous years' show before you try to get in this years. Find out the "surprises" before it costs you money.

Total the show fee, travel cost, lodging cost, food cost on the road, display cost(tables, table covers, signs, folding chairs, lights, tents, tent weights, etc.) Now sell four boxes all day for $200, How much did you make? Do your table cloths colors match? Do they go all the way to the floor? Do you have 50# weights on each tent pole leg? What happens when a five year old eating cotton candy touches and knocks a box into the mud. You are lucky if the parents say "we are sorry". Every show is different, READ THE FINE PRINT on the show contract!

Re: Pricing advice

#19

What are you?

mark Hennebury

Are you a craftsman in business or a businessman in crafts?

Do you care about what you do, or what you get for what you do?

• A craftsman studies his craft;

o produces the best product that he can and hopes someone will appreciate it and pay for it. To him this is very personal; a craftsman is doomed to a life of disappointment and poverty.

• A businessman studies his customers;

o he provides them with whatever they want, at whatever price they will pay, and whatever quality they will accept; nothing personal here. He is destined to be wealthy and contented.

Pick one.

Re: Pricing advice

#20

A.J. Hamler

Re: What are you?

A.J. Hamler

Hopefully, I'm a crafty businessman...

Re: Pricing advice

#21

A.J. Hamler

Thanks, all!

A.J. Hamler

Great info and ideas, so thanks to everyone!

As it happens, I'll be part of a small (very, very small) show locally next month. The main purpose of the show is a showcase of local talent in various media, and not a sales event -- although we are permitted to sell what we bring if we wish. For my three items I've elected to take:

o A table I made for a magazine article. The table came out great but I have no use for it, so I figure this might be a good (read: profitable) way to get rid of it.

o A second item I'm particularly proud of "just for show" that ties into an extremely handsome magazine cover for which it was the cover project.

o And the mini spool cabinet. My thought was to mark the cabinet NFS, but to include info on ordering one.

In all, more of an experiment than anything else. Based on all your recommendations, I'm thinking the absolute most I could sell that mini cabinet for in the context of this extremely tiny show in this low-population area is probably $125-$150. The way I figure it, if I get a few requests it'll give me the incentive to make it in a single very small run of multiples as a test, just to see what the logistics would be in making it in batches. That way I'd get an idea if it's something I can realistically attempt, with a guarantee that I'll sell whatever I make.

We'll see what happens.

A.J.

Re: Pricing advice

#22

Re: Thanks, all!

Dick Coers

Hate to see a craftsman work for those kind of wages. But it's your deal. I'd sure switch to lacquer for the clear so you can spray and get multiple coats done is a couple of hours, instead of waiting over night for each coat of poly to dry.

Re: Pricing advice

#23

A.J. Hamler

But I'm not "working"

A.J. Hamler

In my case for this instance, it's not really "work" at all, Dick. This is an experiment, the main purpose of which is to see what the making-mulitples process is like and make notes. In that sense, it's something I'd have to do anyway, but in this case I'd be getting paid for it.

Also, once I've done the making-multiples exercise, I'll get a much better sense of what kind of time it takes, what the setups are like, what components lend themselves better to production work, etc. If I make, say, four mini's on-order as part of the test and get even only $125 each for them, that's $500 earned to conduct an experiment that I would surely have had to conduct anyway but would otherwise have paid nothing.

As to poly, waiting overnight isn't an issue at all. Remember, these are things I plan to make here and there as I have time as an adjunct to my main profession. True, I'll need to keep delivery time in mind for any orders, but waiting two overnights to apply three coats of poly doesn't strike me as a big deal.

Besides, I suck waymo big-time at spraying ...

A.J.

Re: Pricing advice

#24

Re: But I'm not "working"

Barry Irby

This has been an interesting thread. I marvel at the difference between art and craft and the act that some people can get hundreds of dollars for a turning and I can get fifty. I resent the fact that the gallery wants fifty percent of the sale price and I have to acquire the wood, the tools, the skill and the time to make it and I get only half. And yet I don't want to invest the time and effort to sell it.

Your last comment about not working made me think. Be careful. Producing multiples of anything gets to be too much like work. That's WORK, work. Making one is fun, interesting, entertaining. Making a bunch gets to be a PITA. I have a friend that had a sign in his shop that said something like....One Chair $200, Two chairs $500, four chairs $1,200, and eight chairs $3,200. The few people that did the math would argue that eight chairs aught to be cheaper per chair than one. His answer was that he hated making the same thing over and over.

At some point it ceases being a fun craft hobby and becomes production. Somewhere in there you can't argue that you are doing it for fun and you would be doing it anyway. If you don't NEED the money, don't take the fun out of it.

Re: Pricing advice

#25

Production Work

David Yoho

Barry, I'm totally in agreement with your friend about making multiples. I think multiples lend themselves to a production arrangement where your equipment is setup for specific parts of the fabrication process. Once set, there is no time wasted in setting things up and you can just crank stuff out. That's okay for some but I'd go crazy in the first hour. I'd much rather be making custom pieces. Even when customers request something they've seen of mine, I never ever make an exact copy of whatever it was they saw. I always change something about it to give it its own uniqueness.

As far as AJ's experiment, it could go a little deeper than it seems. Beyond the obvious purpose of making multiples and learning what he needs to from it, did you ever stop to consider he might just come away with fuel for another article? After all, he did say he was a "crafty businessman".