Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT Framing Question

Posts

OT Framing Question

#1

OT Framing Question

TomD

I am building a room onto my summer place that will be framed first as a deck and then walls will be erected above the deck structure, and then a roof will be put on. Size is 8 x 14 feet. The deck is supported by a ledger at the wall, and the other side will be supported by a beam running about 7 feet out from the wall, there will be a cantilever of 1 foot, footings are in, and these factors are fixed.

The "room" will function as a screen porch but is being built to have full wall strength, and the capability to completely enclose the structure and later insulate it or whatever. The real intent though is that the porch needs to be secured many months of the year, and screens need to be as full as possible, yet the structure easily boarded in for security, so while I want a screen I also want secure walls. Probably the easiest way to get there would be to stick frame the structure, and sheet the lower walls while leaving plentiful and large window openings under conventional headers.

So here is the question. Notwithstanding the stick option I would like to frame the long wall pole style with 3 x 6"x6" posts on 7 foot centers, with a large header over the top. The only problem with this approach is that the posts would be resting on the deck edge with no particular structure under them. This is because the deck is joisted on 16 inch centers extending over the 7 foot support beam one foot. It should be easy to ensure that the post all sit above a joist, but the load transfer of a beam to 3/4 ply deck/to rim joist/and joist seems inadequate. My solution is to either pair two of the 2x10 joists at the corners and center point, so that the transfer is at least to that extent. Another option is to place a 2x12 girder notched into the base of the posts, along the base of the wall, this would transfer the load Across the whole surface just as the average pole structure uses beefy poles and beams to carry roof or second story loads. Over on the Hand Tools board someone mentioned a bottom plate, and that is essentially what this would do as a conventional bottom plate is not still without the studs.

I have seen structures where the front rim joist was built up, but I don't really think that will make maters better in this case where the front rim joist is not directly supported by posts.

This Bob Villa piece shows the basic structural layout, though he is attempting a very different structure overall. Start at 1:40. He also has walls on two sides and the posts are set back enough to be almost over the beam. But if as seems likely my explanation is completely bad, you can get a sense of what I am doing from his segment.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKMiCHKIIiY

Re: OT Framing Question

#2

Re: OT Framing Question

Barry Irby

Its best if the load path is as direct as possible.

I think you should set the posts over the tips of joists and double or triple them. It would be good if there is pier of column directly below them under the beam.

In a way, ignore the band board across the ends of the joists. Don't double it. Let the posts rest on both the band and the joists, but mostly on the joists. The band's job is to keep the joists from flipping over sideways like dominoes and to help keep the ends of the joists aligned and transfer some loading to the adjacent joists. If the band starts to support the post, you are relying too strongly on the connection between the band and the joists.

You have a short cantilever. That's good. What you want is if you "look" from the side of the porch the load comes down vertically through the post, to the doubled joists, angles through the joists to the beam, and straight down to the post below. Looking from the end of the post it should be a straight line, post to joists to beam to column.

You are fighting several things. Any wood that is being compress cross grain (joists, flooring, beam) will compress about ten times as much as any wood that is vertical (Posts and column.) Often the post is about ten times the height of the cross grain stuff, so the compression is similar. So if you have a really fat set of joists and beam your floor can take on a sort of sine wave at the end. (Down a 1/4" at the posts and up in the center of the openings.) If the wood is treated and wet or not fully cured this can be exaggerated.

Re: OT Framing Question

#3

Kneale Brownson

Re: OT Framing Question

Kneale Brownson

Are you going to roof and screen the deck in right away?

If not, and if you're eventual plan is to make it a room added onto the house, then I'd plan on ripping out the deck when the eventual comes along and starting over with a real footing and a floor you can insulate.

Re: OT Framing Question

#4

Ellis Walentine

Ditto Barry and Kneale

Ellis Walentine

... and if you intend to make this a heated space, insulate it now and close up the undersides of the cantilevered sections of the joists to keep the mice and other critters out.

I solved a similar problem years ago when I converted a screened porch (screens floor to ceiling) to an enclosed porch by installing large double-hung windows in the openings between the posts and walling off the space above and below them.

Ellis

Re: OT Framing Question

#5

Re: OT Framing Question

George Koch

Tom, What about the future roof bearing? Is it going to be a shed type roof bearing on the outer cantilevered floor or is it going to be a gable roof bearing on the sidewalls? Also what region of the country are you, to determine snow load requirements?

Re: OT Framing Question

#6

Re: OT Framing Question

Matt Robinette

It has been my experience that if you have a question about a building structure ask the local building inspector what he wants to see and most the time they are very accommodating. It is not so much a joke but the truth you ask 100 carpenters how they would build something you will get 100 different answers but the one who approves it is the building inspector. No one want to end up with something that looks like it was built by some jack leg hack.

Re: OT Framing Question

#7

Re: OT Framing Question

Keith Newton

My first bit of advice, is to change that 8' to at least 12' x 14'. That is too small to really function well. You will enjoy being out there so much more after it is finished.

Your goal, sounds like what I did at my cabin. I made my sunroom 14' x21. There are 2 6' wide patio doors on each side in the 14' walls , and 3 in the 21' wall, so the room is mostly glass, with 10"-12" of wood in between.

I also did a cathedral ceiling, with a window in the gable, so being up here in the tree branches looking down on the creek feels like being in Nature, with all the comforts of home. The doors are closed, with the AC running now, while it is 100* outside. When it is nice out, 7 x 20 square feet of screen when all the doors are open. I drop down a Murphy bed and sleep out here listening to Katydids and frogs singing me to sleep, and most nights get to hear some Owl and Coyote music as well.

If you make it 8' then put a table and chairs out there, you won't have room to get around it when people are sitting around it. Plus the big expense is in the perimeter, it won't make it too much more expensive, nor much more work to make it a bit larger.

Re: OT Framing Question

#8

Re: OT Framing Question

TomD

George, shed roof where the rafters are carried by the wall in question. Snow load will probably not be an issue, but it could be, they can get any imaginable amount of snow, but being lakeside the wind rarely lets it settle.

Re: OT Framing Question

#9

Re: OT Framing Question

TomD

Matt, that is generally good advice relative to structure and approvals. However, they don't travel out this far. I don't think the structure is all that off the wall, I have seen similar things around here, including the posts. I am hyper critical on structures, and am just looking for the best ideas, which I know I will get good feedback here as with your comments. There would be zero problem if I just narrowed the structure to be supported by the main beam

Re: OT Framing Question

#10

Re: OT Framing Question

TomD

That is good advice, unfortunately, the land falls away. We also Occasionally get icebergs the size of school buses on the beach when the lake breaks up. They could come up that far on the worst years.