Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Joinery Question

Posts

Joinery Question

#1

Joinery Question

AZ in Colorado Springs


What would you make this shelf from -- solid wood or sheet goods -- and what joinery would you use? I think the vertical pieces all have vertical grain, so I see cross grain movement issues all over the place, if solid wood.

My niece asked for one of these & so now I'n trying to figure it out.

Thanks

Andy

Re: Joinery Question

#2

Re: Joinery Question

markhennebury

Plywood or particle board, biscuit jointed.

Re: Joinery Question

#3

Re: Joinery Question

don stephan

There is no requirement that designers and factories respect or even know the properties of wood. Harsh, but that's based on my observations.

Can't tell from the picture if the edge is solid wood or edge banding.

Re: Joinery Question

#4

An opportunity to........

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...practice you dovetail skills :) No reason not to orient grain to avoid cross grain intersections.

Re: Joinery Question

#5

Re: Joinery Question

TomD

Sheet goods probably, but I would rather do something interesting than all that banding. FOr solid wood:

First blush if you look at the left side of the wall there are 2 C shaped 3 sided boxes, I would make those with fixed and glued biscuit butt joints, such that there is no cross grain, end grain ends to ends, but just butt and biscuit, or some similar joint. I don't think dovetails really work in this situation as it currently stands.

You then mount these boxes in place on the wall (or hold that as a thought). The bottom of this run is a half box, just treat it as a full box if you like and mount it with the others.

Then on the right side you have a half panel on top and two full panels, these present your cross grain situation, You can simply tack them to the wall like cleats, and leave it like that, another option is to use biscuits or splines, and glue one biscuit, or end and either slide them in place, or glue them up.

You can actually get rid of the cross grain issue, by making all the right side pieces so the grain runs from the corner out, and all the left side pieces into end to end boxes (as suggested above), so that where they contact the right hand pieces it is side grain. Then you get a vertical expansion issue, but that probably isn't all that serious, and could be dealt with in the mounting (keyhole them). The only problem in that approach is that when removed from the wall the unit might be a little fragile.

With panel goods you can put it together any old way, but you have all the edges to band, which is not a look I really want.

If I was making this piece for myself, I would start with the idea of it, and a blank sheet of paper, and do something similar that used real joinery. But I gather she is already sold...

Re: Joinery Question

#6

Re: Blank sheet of paper for solid wood

TomD

While it is too busy for my taste, but one blank sheet of paper idea is to make each of the little panels out of a piece of walnut and maple, where they are joined with dovetails, or maybe finger joints, at a 45. This gives you a square with a diagonal colour change. And if done correctly it gives you endgrain on two adjacent sides, that you then dovetail together at 90 degrees for each corner joint, and just follow that pattern down the wall. Sorta thing Leigh or those Incra people do to show off their joinery machines. You could probably use biscuits also if you don't want to spend your whole life on it. Of course when you do that the joints and pieces of wood take over and you compromise the line of the original.

Re: Joinery Question

#7

Re: Joinery Question

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

I made this one a while back with 1/2" MDF and biscuits.


Re: Joinery Question

#8

Re: Joinery Question

William Duffield

If you are doing it in solid wood, I don't see any reason to have to deal with any cross grain joints. All the grain on the vertical panels on the left wall runs vertically. All the grain on the vertical panels on the right wall runs horizontally. All the grain on the horizontal panels runs parallel to the right wall. All the joints on the left wall are dovetails. All the joints on the right wall are glued long grain butt joints. The mirror image would work just as well. If you lay out, cut, fit assemble and glue all your dovetailed subassemblies first, the rest of the assembly is simply glued and clamped.

Re: Joinery Question

#9

Re: Joinery Question

TomD

That is what I suggested, but your explanation is admirably more easy to follow.

However, this approach does not eliminate all wood movement issue, or strength issues. While using panel products would.

Re: Joinery Question

#10

Re: Joinery Question

William Duffield

I thought that's what you were describing.

I was thinking that the strength and wood movement issues could be at least partially ameliorated by the fastening method to the walls. The walls themselves, like with built-in cabinet construction, would add a lot of strength. I thought that judicious use of French cleats and keyhole fasteners should do the job, However, t.he more I think about it, the more difficulties I see with any fastening method, since the whole structure would want to expand and shrink vertically, and additively where it is attached to the right wall.

I think you are right. The only reasonable way to build it is with composite materials. I think I would used baltic birch plywood, and hot glue edge banding, and make all the joints with Festool Dominos. Then, it could be attached to the walls with extruded aluminum French cleats, like these:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Hardware/page.aspx?p=60936&cat=3,40914,50630&ap=1

Right about now, a rant would be well deserved about "designers" who "design" junk because it looks cute, with utter disregard (or ignorance) of material and structural constraints. However, I will restrain myself, because they wouldn't be reading this forum anyhow.

Re: Joinery Question

#11

Re: Joinery Question // Thanks ...

AZ in Colorado Springs

... to everyone for the many ideas.

I think it'll look much better (proper?) with the grain on the vertical panels running vertically -- hence my assumption about wood movement problems.

The idea of building it in sections and mounting the sections to the adjacent walls -- we'll I'm building this in CO and then shipping it to MI, so it needs to be as simple an installation as possible.

The idea of using diagonal joints as would be demonstrated at a wood working shows booth ... um, no!

I think it'll be baltic birch plywood and some edge banding. Thanks for confirming that I wasn't overlooking some magic solution.

(and no one mentioned 3D printing)

Re: Joinery Question

#12

Re: Joinery Question

Matt Robinette

It would be a great exercise to make it with some type of dovetail joinery but if it is to be shipped it may be better to use Kreg pocket screws and do all the pre fab for unit wrap all the edges with veneer tape ,disassemble it numbering each piece for proper reassembly. Flat pack the pieces into boxes and ship it. Don't forget to include the screws and driver bit.The way it hangs the pocket holes would not be seen and are plenty strong for the size shelf shown. Looks like a fast fun good looking project.