Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Deck collapse......

Posts

Deck collapse......

#1

Deck collapse......

Barry Irby

Recently a balcony collapsed at Emerald Isle, NC. The news reported there were 14 people on it and several were seriously injured. A friend who lives near by tells me they have now concluded there were more like 24 people on it. Three families had rented nearby houses and gathered for a group photo. The balcony was 30 years old and the nails failed.

There is a discussion below about bunk beds and even a set of steps. There is a lesson in this balcony collapse for all of us. As a Home Inspector I hear of decks collapsing all the time. The local county recently changed their requirements for steps partially because I pointed out about six sets that had failed under the old rules. Decks are in the weather and have very active loading. So do bunk beds. Lets build them well. It's often easy to see why they fell down. Lets do it better up front.

Re: Deck collapse......

#3

6 dead in Berkeley CA

Neal in San Jose

a month or so ago. 5 were exchange students from Ireland. Very sad. 7 others were injured, but I don't know their present condition. The cause apparently was dry rot due to improper water proofing. It does rain in CA enough to cause problems.

Re: Deck collapse......

#4

why it doesn't happen more?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My daughter bought a house with a second story porch. It was held up by 3- 4 x6 western cedar posts, partially decayed at the bottom. I didn't feel safe with 4 people in it and replaced the posts with 6 x 6 yellow pine.

Re: Deck collapse......

#5

Re: Deck collapse......

roger lance

I do not intend to trivialize this situation; but, the deck lasted 30 years and there were maybe 24 people on it moving about partying.....

More failed here than the nails.....

My guess is that that deck was fairly well built to have lasted 30 years. Perhaps, decks should be rated to a load limit and people should take some responsibility for overloading a structure......but that type of thinking isn't very PC.

Re: Deck collapse......

#6

I suspect you are correct.....

Barry Irby

My friend and I were talking about it and we bet the local landlords and rental agents are reviewing and rewriting their contracts as fast as they can go. It would be interesting to know if the contract these people signed had any restrictions about using the deck/balcony. Its common for people to Pack these rental units with more people than were in the lease, but I doubt any of the Landlords/Rental Agents assumed they would have everybody from three units gather on one deck.

Nothing lasts forever. Maybe this will lead to some sort of maintenance inspections to prevent this type of failure.

Re: Deck collapse......

#7

But how often should a deck be rebuilt?

BrianMonumentCO

After 30 years, I would expect that any deck would need a new finish, new boards, and perhaps even new screws. I doubt the subject decks got either.

Realistically most deck that are not maintained properly would appear to headed to a total rebuild well before 30 years.

Re: Deck collapse......

#8

Re: Deck collapse......

walta

When I read “the nails failed” That make me think the real problem was one side of the deck was supported by the house and the only thing connecting the deck to the house were a few nails.

Today in most places it is very difficult to get a permit for a deck that is sported by the house stamped engineering drawing and special bracket attaching the deck to the floor joists, making self supporting decks less costly.

Walta

Re: Deck collapse......

#9

Re: Deck collapse......

Barry Irby

Again, I only know what the press has put out in this case and rumors heard by a friend.

I suspect that both Brian and Walta are correct. The deck was not built tot he standards we use today and was probably not well maintained if any maintenance was done.

I have watched the evolution of decks over the almost 30 years I have been doing Home Inspections. Walta is right. Back in the day they were nailed to the house. The deck was treated wood, but the house (band) was not. The band rotted. If the nails were steel, the water followed them in and the wood rotted around them and they turned loose in five years or less. If they were galvanized, the water soaked some of the zinc into the wood, preserving it and it took longer for the band to rot. Then they required bolts. Just took a few years longer for the bolts to rot out. Then they went to a treated band. ACQ treated wood came along and dissolved the nails and bolts. Now they practically require the deck to be an independent structure. Then they realized the deck had to have sway bracing. On and On. For most of this time the word DECK was not in the building code. You had to pick trough the code to find any sections that might apply. Recently I applied for a permit to build a deck. As an afterthought I asked if they had any guide lines. They printed out a 29 page document. Enormous detail and excellent except that some of it was already out of date.

My point to this is that decks are dangerous and harder to build (and maintain) properly than most of us think. And we should think.

We used to call them "The wedding Party Deck". Everything is fine until somebody gets married and fifty of your closest friends walk out on the deck and start to party. Google deck collapse. There are thousands of them. Most are precipitated by some group event. Lets be careful out there.

Re: Deck collapse......

#10

Re: But how often should a deck be rebuilt?

Bill Howatt

It's fairly easy to see when rotted deck boards need replacing or refinishing but in many cases it isn't so easy to determine how well the fasteners and supporting structures are. Part of the "isn't so easy" is because nobody thinks of it or even appreciates that it needs to be done because they don't see it.

Adding people to decks is similar to the straw that broke the camel's back story. If you asked the owner if it was OK to place a car on the deck there would likely be some thinking done. 24 people on a deck would weigh about the same as many cars and what's worse the people are moving around or perhaps even jumping around dancing.

I don't know if there is any easy answer to this problem but a first step might be a public awareness campaign of the problem - more than just an article in the media about a specific collapse. Rating a deck for maximum occupancy is difficult considering the lifetime and weather conditions and would likely get ignored anyway without proper education.

Bill

Re: Deck collapse......

#11

Re: Deck collapse......

E Snow

Have to wonder if there is a an inverse relationship between the rates of deck failure and the ever dropping price of a chop saw.

Speaking on behalf of the atrocity attached to my neighbors and my house clearly built by the same individual. No flashing, no drip edge at the bottom of the ledger,joists with stub ends scabbed on to get out the the correct length, composite decking on the bias on top of joists 16" on center. Their only savior is that neither have any cantilevered areas.

In my defense I was not ignorant going in, I bought the house for the detached 5 car garage-mahal/shop. Did have them re-sheath and reside below the deck on the contract as a time-buyer before I can strip it off and rebuild it. Neighbor is 80% done with his rebuild of his sketchfest.

Re: Deck collapse......

#12

Deck capacity.

BrianMonumentCO

Aside from the maintenance and condition of the deck.

The original construction of the deck should/could indicate a capacity limit.

In virtually all deck collapses, I would bet heavily on such a capacity limit being well and truly exceeded.

When I go into public buildings I see some sort of capacity stated IIRC by the fire marshal.

I wonder if those capacities are structural as well as 'how many humans can be here that can evacuate safely if a fire starts type question?'.

I would assume that each construction technique for a floor would also have some sort of floor loading/capacity type limitation that would be known.

Re: Deck collapse......

#13

Re: Deck capacity.

Barry Irby

You are correct. The building code specifies floor loads and then translates that into a design. "Public" areas in your house might be 40 LBS/sq ft and Private area such as bedrooms might be 30. Each one has a dead load also of maybe 10 lbs/sf in addition to the live load. So if you chose the heavier loading for a deck and the deck were 10' by 20' (200 SF) That would allow for 8,000 lbs of people and things like furniture and booze. If the deck I started talking about really did have 24 people on it @ 200 lbs each, that's 4800 lbs. It would not have been overloaded unless it was degraded by time and weather. Of course, that assumes it was built well to start with. I also don't know if the deck that collapsed was actually 200 SF.

I rebuilt my deck after about thirty years. One of the bolts rusted away to the point it was about 1/8" in diameter, down from 3/8".

Re: Deck collapse......

#14

Re: Deck capacity.

BrianMonumentCO

I am not sure how 40 Pounds/square foot would actually be useful.

For example, I weigh 240# fully clothed. If I stand with both my feet together in attention format, I would be 240# in just that one square foot.

For a building to actually stand it must be able to handle much more than 40 #/square foot.

Yes I am on a diet.......

Re: Deck collapse......

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Deck capacity.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

40#/s.f. is an average design load for the whole floor, not a concentrated load. I can't say I've ever come across a discussion about concentrated loads in residences, but they're probably out there.

Anyway, even if you're 240#, standing in one square foot, you're not likely to have anything or anyone within the 6 s.f. around you--a radius of about 1.4', so that averages out to 40#/s.f.

Jason

Re: Deck collapse......

#16

Re: Deck capacity.

Barry Irby

Jason Got the logic correct. while you stand on about 1sf you "occupy" more like six or even ten SF.

This gets thrown off when people jamb into crowded spaces like for a giant family photo or a reception or a dance.

Most water beds over load the floor. So do most refrigerators and freezers. My neighbor took the drip pan out from under his fridge and never put it back. Had carpet for a kitchen floor. Several years later the fridge plunge through the floor. It had rotted. His insurance paid for the repair. He was furious he had to pay the $100 deductible. I just laughed at him. Out of earshot, the agent told me "If we didn't pay for stupid we wouldn't pay for anything at all."

Part of the floor design is that the subfloor has to be rigid enough to distribute the load over enough area to even it out.

Re: Deck collapse......

#17

Re: Deck capacity.

BrianMonumentCO

"Part of the floor design is that the subfloor has to be rigid enough to distribute the load over enough area to even it out. "

So the 40 # per square foot spec is ONLY A PART of the spec for the floor.

If not, I suppose that I could foolishly build it with 1/4 inch ply on 16 inch centers of 2x10s and meet the 40# but no person could stand on the floor without breaking it. Most construction I have seen is 3/4inch ply sometimes flakeboard on 16 inch centers.

I find it ridiculous to have a solitary spec of 40#/sq ft as a spec for any floor.....

I would suspect if only a sq ft rating were used that a more realistic number would have to be closer to 200#/sq ft to be truly workable.

Re: Deck collapse......

#18

Re: Deck capacity.

Barry Irby

Brian, You are right. There is more to it than 40 Lbs/SF. I have not looked lately, but IIRC there is a requirement for 10 Lbs/SF for the "dead Load" of the structure. If the joist are more than 6 times as deep and they are thick there must be bridging between the joists. That is, 2 x 12 joists require bridging but 2 x 10's do not. Bridging is the X bracing between the joists. If one joist deflects, it transfers part of it load tot he adjacent joists. Thicker subflooring helps do the same thing.

The Codes take the grade of the lumber into account. No. 1 lumber may be allowed to span further than No. 2. The grading is very important. Either no knots in the edges or very limited.

Gluing the subfloor to the joists stiffens the floor significantly.

It goes on and on. Not nearly as simple as it looks. This is the danger of "doing it yourself" if you don't thoroughly understand what you are doing. Some of the workmanship I see on inspections is stunningly bad and dangerous and the "builder" is really proud.

Another thing many people don't know and understand is that floors are mot nearly as solid as they think or want. The code allows for "deflection". Designated as L/240 or L/360 Or Length/240 or 360. So if your floor joist was 15' long or 180" the allowable deflection would be either 3/4" or 1/2". Often the lesser standard is applied to bedrooms and the stiffer one to living areas.

Re: Deck collapse......

#19

Re: Deck capacity.

John in NM

Yes, there is a lot more to it than #/sq ft load ratings. If you go find the current IRC book, in addition to span tables for various deflections there will also be a table for sheathing thicknesses and joist spacings if I remember right. Therein lies distinctions between butted plywood sheathing and the thick tongue and groove stuff.

Every time I see one of these deck collapse stories, I think of the condition of decks and fences I've taken down. Even out here in the arid desert stuff just doesn't last outside. I can only marvel that a deck could last as long as 15 years on the beach!

Re: Deck collapse......

#20

Re: Deck collapse......

John K Jordan

I just shook my head when I read of these collapses. I've seen so many crappy decks, evidently engineered and built by someone with a third grade education and a hangover, built the same way regardless of size and height off the ground. A couple wobbled significantly when it was just me walking, undersized lumber, loose joints, wobbly railings.

I think the deck should be as strong as the house, overbuilt even since it is in the weather. For me, a 2nd story deck means lots of concrete with rebar in the ground, double 2x10 or 2x12 beams for wide spans, 4x6 PT SYP minimum posts, and properly sized joists. I like 2x12 outside band with 4x6 horizintal inside spaced to support the ends of the joists, the pair bolted with 3/8" carriage bolts through the posts. I like to use 2x6 for decking. Not one nail. This will probably support a car. When I built a 1000 sq ft multi-level this way about 30 years ago the building inspector said he wanted to send some contractors over to learn how to build a deck.

Sure, this costs more, but good grief, so do good tires and brakes for the family car.

JKJ