Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Which would you choose? *LINK*

Posts

Which would you choose? *LINK*

#1

Which would you choose? *LINK*

Keith Newton

I'm currently working on building the cabinets for a new house, under construction, for which the owner and builder have ask me to design the kitchen island. I of course tended to lean toward my own style, which I call my Arborescent series, mostly tables, which have the legs grouped together somewhat like a tree trunk.

Sometimes, when I'm dealing with clients, that I suspect have a hard time visualizing in 3D as they are looking at plans, I like to make a maquette. They can then hold it in their hands, and rotate it viewing from all angles, seeing how the light and shadows plays off the details.

The first one was what I first conceived, but then while make it, the other idea crept in, so I went ahead and knocked it out.

I'm not sure of the wood species yet. It may need to be light, I think all the wall cabinets will be painted white, so it will get to stand out.

There are lots of arches around the house, so I wanted to bow the front out, in keeping with that, but also, when people are cozying up to the pleasure side visiting with the cook, they would all have a view of each other, better than all lined up in a row.

Both of these were made by sawing the core out of a 4" thick poplar beam, then cutting the other parts out of mdf, which is hot-glued on. I started out by cutting the pattern for the top, then tried getting everything to fit under that, but I found in the end, the I want a little more overhang, so I probably will back things in a little, or just make the top larger.

The top will be ~ 12' long marble. I think the standard thickness for that is 1 3/8" and the tops here are made from 1/4" mdf, which would be 3" to scale, so that is about twice as thick as the real top will be. However, I will likely have another layer of plywood between the stone and base, which will add another layer of detail underneath, stepping out all around the architectural details, and I'm hoping will keep the upper part visible longer as you get closer.

Here is a link to some pics. I'd like to hear your thoughts.


https://www.flickr.com/photos/7391658@N03/sets/72157655710651965/

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#2

Re: Which would you choose?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1,3,4 look visually confusing to me. I have an artist friend and I have heard her to say about a piece of furniture, "I don't get it". I think she is commenting on how all the elements relate to one another. When looking at 1,3,4 her phrase crept into my thoughts.

"Elegant" was the thought that came to mind when looking at the other views. It is probably not surprising that I am drawn to the more conventional.

From the drawer side, the rectangular drawers seem out of place among graceful curves. I am not creative enough to come up with a modification to the ranks of drawers that would blend with the rest.

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#3

Re: Which would you choose?

Larry Barrett

I think 1, 3, and 4 (different views of the same thing, I think) look like tree trunks in a forest, with the top being the lower branches of the trees. I like it.

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#4

Depends

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

on the rest of the space. It's one thing to create a visual anchor; quite another to take over the entire area with an overpowering piece. Both designs/pieces are very heavy and complex objects. I have a sense that the "leg" elements are unnecessarily large. Your idea of tree trunk is there, but there's more of the flavor of "stump" rather than the visual "movement" of a grove of trees.

On the practical side, in a kitchen context, whoever gets the job of floor cleaning may be cussing you before too long while trying to get all those inside corners clean when the milk or cool-aid gets spilled.

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#5

Re: Which would you choose?

David Yoho

Keith, while I like both concepts, I keep going back to the first one. It grabbed my attention at first sight and held it. The other didn't command my attention near as much and I found it boring too soon. That's not to say it wasn't good but given the choice I think your first design is much better to my eye. I especially like the depth it has on the front.

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#6

The 1st one...

Pat Evans

... minus the intermediate legs.

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#7

Re: Which would you choose?

William Duffield

I couldn't have said it better, David. I agree completely with your analysis.

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#8

Re: Which would you choose?

mdclor

The design immediately reminded me of a banyan tree and I think the first one is truer to that concept than the second one.


Therefore, I vote for the first one. However, I agree that it is too heavy looking and would like to see the "trunks" reduced by perhaps 1/3 or so. Finally, I'm really happy that I don't have to carry the finished piece to its final home. :D

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#9

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

Keith Newton

Thanks, The first is my first choice also. I surely wish I had some help on this project. Ben, my last assistant / apprentice came to me by way of a timber-framer friend. He would have a good time with this project, as well as some other stuff that I have going on over the coming weekends.

I mentioned the property lines about a week ago, but didn't mention what wonderful habitat is included within it. I have a file over on the flickr site called "Some of my favorite trees". Most of the Cypress in that album are over in that lease. We inherited some hunting stands, which are usable, but I'll be replacing before long. But I'm pretty sure I'll be spending enough time over there, that I'll want to make one pretty special one that I will really be comfortable in, especially if I need to take shelter.

But besides that I'm thinking of doing several that may be borderline works of art. These woods are just too beautiful to be cluttering with the kind of crap that most people consider hunting blinds. And actually I could see that becoming a little sideline business.

If any of you know of a young craftsman which is showing some talent, wanting a good experience, this may be a good time for me to take someone on.


https://www.flickr.com/photos/7391658@N03/sets/72157644966697167

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#10

Location

Gary Smyth

My choice would be the latter. That said, (depending on the remainder of the home) the massiveness of both seem to be too much for its size and the function. Not clunky by any stretch, but maybe, overpowering. Pictures 1,3, & 4 do not indicate anything to me and to my eye at the size, not a tree. In addition, me being a klutz the forward foot in the former would have me tripping many times in passing. At minimum it would be a footrest. I'm thinking that the drawers (#4) might help to carry out the theme with rounded faces, examples of which are the farm sink front and a photo grabbed from a modern southwestern chimney cabinet. Just one I hope of many responses. .

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#11

Well, Thanks ALL,

Keith Newton

The Contractor just left here with sample #1, and a figured Bubinga veneer sample for the flat surfaces, to take to the customer.

I had already sent her the link to the photos of both, but I think we both have sway enough to convince her to go along with our choice.

Plus, I am working on ideas of how to tie in the details into other parts of the trim package. I'd love to get to design and build it all, but my pace is too slow for the rest of the construction. This is going in a large Great Room, about 20.5' x 48.5', with 10' ceiling height.

Once again, I need some help, whether it is an apprentice, or someone with plenty of experience. I've got more than I can handle alone right now.

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#12

Re: Which would you choose?

BobS

Keith, are you hunting gators in the swamp or something waterborne? Interesting trees for sure.

Bob

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#13

Re: Which would you choose?

Keith Newton

No, just deer, and I mainly use that as an excuse to get up and out there early, and stay late with my camera. With it, I shoot anything that moves, but can't outrun me. There are gators out there, but no season in our area yet. I'm not afraid of them for my own safety, but for Sassafras my GoldenRetriever, I have great concern.

Re: Which would you choose? *LINK*

#14

Re: Which would you choose?

Matt Robinette

I like both the only thing would be is ceiling height to me the first island is is like a live oak living in the forest with a low canopy. The second with it's up rights is more to a tall tree like a redwood. But I am sure both would be great.