The shop is in my barn. We were away for a while and we got back I found to roof had leaked causing rust on the table saw top. The town rest wiped off but there remains black spots that I cannot remove. Any suggestions? Thanks!
Go through the grits just like you would for wood, then WD40, the. Rub in some Johnsons paste wax. It may still be dark, but what is wrong with that, it will work as good as new.
You need to have a good reason to remove them. I suspect sanding them out will leave a depression. I have lots of black spots on my saw and they don't bother me a bit.
It would be an interesting chemistry experiment to see if they can be turned colorless with out dissolving the iron compound that made them which would leave a rough area or pitted area (just guessing). . I might try citric acid, but the risk is pitting. Actually if I was going to do chemistry experiments I would turn some test piece of cast iron black and mess with the test piece. But really it a problem that doesn't need to be fretted about.
Take a piece of heavy duty aluminum foil, folded w/ dull side out.
Put a drop or two (or three) of water on the saw.
Scrub hard w/ the aluminum foil.
Wipe it off w/ a paper towel.
The aluminum oxide on the dull side (and the shiny side) acts as a very fine abrasive. The water acts as a lubricant. There may be a chemical interaction taking place, but I don't know. It isn't as rough as sandpaper.
Bar Keeper’s Friend will remove the stain you'll find it in the cleanser & soap aisle at the grocery store. Also does a great job in the kitchen on your stainlesss steel sink and pan.
Hopefully, Robb's suggestion works.....that would be perfect.
But, if not, and you can't resist the urge to sand as Bill argues......then remember to always start and stop the sander while it is sitting flat on the saw.....don't lift it off and put it back down on cast iron while running......you can put some annoying swirl marks on your saw that are also difficult to remove.
The black "stain" is probably Fe3O4. I was trying to think of something that would reduce it to all ferrous or Fe(0). The Al might do it. Rubbing is going to abrade through the aluminum oxide layer and expose bare aluminum, which may just reduce the iron oxide.
I have a 6" circular pad of grey scotchbrite, or the Norton equivalent. I squirt some WD-40 on it and set it under a 6" ROS and turn it on. If there are deep pits, I just scrape the rust out of them with a carving knife, so the pit won't accumulate more stuff that encourages more rust. I wipe the top off with a paper towel, and apply a coat of T-9 Boeshield or Johnson's paste wax.
But then more than half my machines are older than I am and already had such stains and cosmetic flaws when I got them.
Do you think one of those chelating agents would work? I understand it removes bluing from steel as well as rust, so seems like it might do the same on cast iron.
After several weeks of all kinds of stuff going on in my shop, the most recent - cutting pressure treated deck lumber, my saw top was looking nasty and neglected. I had several spots of surface rust and a few black spots from all this. I put some WD40 on it and scrubbed with a Scotch Brite pad. Wiped it away and rubbed on some Johnson's paste wax and buffed it. The light surface rust came right off. The black spots got lighter but not totally gone. The top looks good again and is ready to go. Did my jointer tables too.
Once rust gets started on a iron surface it forms tiny pits (especially in "porous" cast iron), and will tend to continue the chemical process even if the surface oxide in removed. The other advice given is sound, however you can increase your success by first scrubbing the surface with phosphoric acid. You can find it in most any paint store or borg paint dept. under various brands like "Must-For-Rust" etc. (read labels). When applied, the acid reacts with the red iron oxide to create iron phosphate, a gray crystalline substance. This does two things. First it halts further oxidation in the tiny pits. Second, the crystals bond with the iron to form a kind of coating that resists moisture to help prevent further rusting in the pits. When you abrade the top you will remove most of the crystals, but the rest will stay in the tiny pits as additional protection along with the wax etc. that you apply.
>> Once rust gets started on a iron surface it forms
>> (especially in "porous" cast iron)
The European tool company Robland includes instructions with their sliding table to protect cast iron: rub talcum powder into the metal with a blackboard eraser once a week. They say this fills the pores and keeps out moisture. I've been doing this and it seems to work well.
The hard thing was finding pure talc without perfumes and additives so the table won't smell like a baby's room. I located some on Amazon marketed to billiards players.
Bar Keeper's Friend is primarily oxalic acid. It's a bleach. I've never tried it a rust mark remover. It's a relatively mild abrasive so I expect using it is the same as using any other kitchen abrasive.
Remember, when an item rusts, it actually loses metal. The resulting discoloration is the result of this metal loss.